Scottish crowds
+16
RuggerRadge2611
thebandwagonsociety
Kingshu
overlordofthewest
geoff998rugby
George Carlin
IanBru
RDW
greybeard
TJ1
Smirnoffpriest
Golden
nickj
Glas a du
AsLongAsBut100ofUs
GLove39
20 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Scottish crowds
For a while the size of crowds at Edinburgh & Glasgow games has rightly been a great concern to many, and since it's a slow day at the 'office' I thought I might as well have a look at the attendances so far in the pro 12 as compared to last season.
Both Edinburgh and Glasgow have played 5 home games each so far this season. And the good news is that for both teams, the average attendance (after 5 games) has improved on last season.
Edinburgh getting an average 621 more fans per game, and Glasgow managing to coax 373 extra fans to Firhill. Admittedly these figures aren't as impressive as I hoped, they do show a positive trend. And if Glasgow can continue their unbeaten run of 6 games in the rabo, and Tim Visser continues to delight hopefully we'll see these figures improve further.
Hopefully lots of people will take advantage of the SRU's buy a ticket for Scotland V France and claim the free ticket to the 1872 cup bash.
Last year from the two legs a combined crowd of 16,354 watched Glasgow battle it out. Hopefully they can try and break the 20K barrier?
2011 / 2012
Edinburgh v Blues - 2,431
Edinburgh V Connacht 2,354
Edinburgh V Munster 3,467
Edinburgh V Leinster 3,580
Edinburgh V Aironi 4,403
Average 3,247
2010/ 2011
Edinburgh V Munster 2,879
Edinburgh V Leinster 2,923
Edinburgh V Ulster 3,195
Edinburgh V Treviso 2,422
Edinburgh V Connacht 1,707
Average 2,626
2011 / 2012
Glasgow V Munster 2,914
Glasgow V Treviso 2,864
Glasgow V Dragons 2,705
Glasgow V Ospreys 3,443
Glasgow V Ulster 3,940
Average 3,173
2010/2011
Glasgow V Leinster 2,879
Glasgow V Connacht 3,049
Glasgow V Munster 3,432
Glasgow V Ospreys 2,554
Glasgow V Aironi 2,087
Average 2,800
Both Edinburgh and Glasgow have played 5 home games each so far this season. And the good news is that for both teams, the average attendance (after 5 games) has improved on last season.
Edinburgh getting an average 621 more fans per game, and Glasgow managing to coax 373 extra fans to Firhill. Admittedly these figures aren't as impressive as I hoped, they do show a positive trend. And if Glasgow can continue their unbeaten run of 6 games in the rabo, and Tim Visser continues to delight hopefully we'll see these figures improve further.
Hopefully lots of people will take advantage of the SRU's buy a ticket for Scotland V France and claim the free ticket to the 1872 cup bash.
Last year from the two legs a combined crowd of 16,354 watched Glasgow battle it out. Hopefully they can try and break the 20K barrier?
2011 / 2012
Edinburgh v Blues - 2,431
Edinburgh V Connacht 2,354
Edinburgh V Munster 3,467
Edinburgh V Leinster 3,580
Edinburgh V Aironi 4,403
Average 3,247
2010/ 2011
Edinburgh V Munster 2,879
Edinburgh V Leinster 2,923
Edinburgh V Ulster 3,195
Edinburgh V Treviso 2,422
Edinburgh V Connacht 1,707
Average 2,626
2011 / 2012
Glasgow V Munster 2,914
Glasgow V Treviso 2,864
Glasgow V Dragons 2,705
Glasgow V Ospreys 3,443
Glasgow V Ulster 3,940
Average 3,173
2010/2011
Glasgow V Leinster 2,879
Glasgow V Connacht 3,049
Glasgow V Munster 3,432
Glasgow V Ospreys 2,554
Glasgow V Aironi 2,087
Average 2,800
Re: Scottish crowds
Nice work, GLove, let's hope the trend continues and the success on the pitch that is driving it too
AsLongAsBut100ofUs- Posts : 14129
Join date : 2011-03-26
Age : 112
Location : Devon/London
Re: Scottish crowds
And then in ten years time you can average as much as the Welsh regions, who are roundly condemned for failing to bring the punters in.
Can anybody give a sensible reason for Edinburgh playing in Murrayfield?
Can anybody give a sensible reason for Edinburgh playing in Murrayfield?
Glas a du- Posts : 15843
Join date : 2011-04-28
Age : 48
Location : Ammanford
Re: Scottish crowds
Lack of alternatives - SEEMPLES
AsLongAsBut100ofUs- Posts : 14129
Join date : 2011-03-26
Age : 112
Location : Devon/London
Re: Scottish crowds
What, not even a decent soccer pitch holding up to 10k?
Glas a du- Posts : 15843
Join date : 2011-04-28
Age : 48
Location : Ammanford
Re: Scottish crowds
GLove, nice post. Glad to see the positive noises around Scottish rugby is having an impact on gates. Its great to see.
As is the positive press coverage. Someone mentioned the gate for the Edinburgh game was bigger than the Gloucester vs Newcastle game.
As is the positive press coverage. Someone mentioned the gate for the Edinburgh game was bigger than the Gloucester vs Newcastle game.
nickj- Posts : 1063
Join date : 2011-03-04
Re: Scottish crowds
The way edinburgh are playing at the moment should get some punters in. What do you think of Bradley as a Coach???
What are the attendences like when they meet each other?
What are the attendences like when they meet each other?
Golden- Posts : 3368
Join date : 2011-09-06
Re: Scottish crowds
I mis-read that for a minute and thought you said it was good that Edinburgh had managed to coax 621 fans to their games on average - and I thought jesus Scottish rugby is in trouble!
Smirnoffpriest- Posts : 5321
Join date : 2011-06-03
Age : 41
Location : Cardiff (born in Llanelli)
Re: Scottish crowds
Tehre desparatly needs to be some promotion. Myselfadn my friends are the sort of people that should be being targeted but we always forget to get organised as there is no mention of the games in the general press / advertised anywhere
A few years ago there were loads of deals on offer and the games were advertised. Now they are not. e used to go now we don't simply because we forget to check
I would prefer somewhere other than murrayfeld but there really dosn' t seem to be an alternative
A few years ago there were loads of deals on offer and the games were advertised. Now they are not. e used to go now we don't simply because we forget to check
I would prefer somewhere other than murrayfeld but there really dosn' t seem to be an alternative
TJ1- Posts : 2666
Join date : 2011-08-06
Re: Scottish crowds
Wouldn't it be better to compare the 5 games already played this season with the attendances at the same matches in previous years? The first five games in any given season won't have the same pulling power as another season.
greybeard- Posts : 2078
Join date : 2011-03-19
Re: Scottish crowds
Glas a du wrote:What, not even a decent soccer pitch holding up to 10k?
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! How many times does someone bring this up on a post regarding the Scottish club sides!!!!!! Drives me mental!! Not a dig at you Glas a du, you're just the unfortunate person to ask it the one extra time it needed before I snapped!
So, as you may have gathered, this topic has been discussed to death both on V2 and the old 606. I can remember at least 4 topics that have brought this up since I joined V2 and I even made an article of my own all about it, to try and stop its current recurrence!
So, here is why Edinburgh play at Murrayfield:
Point 1 - nae cash. This is the be all and end all that feeds in to every option available.
Option 1 - football stadiums
Hearts and Hibs are around 18k seaters but the pitches are tiny - smaller than Firhill. Also the SRU don't want a power struggle with football, as well as paying football money when Murrayfield is empty (see point 1)
Option 2 - Meadowbank
Better option than Hibs or Hearts stadiums but is literally falling apart and would need substantial investment (see point 1)
Option 3 - build a new stadium
See point 1
Option 4 - temporary stands on the back pitches
This is the overwhelming favourite option for all fans. However - see point 1.
That only leaves 1 thing - stay at Murrayfield until there is more cash in the SRU!
And how to get that is another topic altogether....
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Back to the topic - is good to see an increase but tbh I think we need to wait 'til the end of season figures to know if there is a real improvement.
I know it is obvious but that clearly proves what can happen if the teams are winning. 4400 vs Airioni?? Would never have happened if the team weren't playing attractive rugby and winning.
I agree regarding the 1872 cup - there's really no reason why we shouldn't be aiming at 20 000 at Murrayfield and over 10 000 in Glasgow in the coming years. I don't care if half the tickets are given away free - we need people coming through the turnstiles in the first place if we ever want them to come back regularly!
I know it is obvious but that clearly proves what can happen if the teams are winning. 4400 vs Airioni?? Would never have happened if the team weren't playing attractive rugby and winning.
I agree regarding the 1872 cup - there's really no reason why we shouldn't be aiming at 20 000 at Murrayfield and over 10 000 in Glasgow in the coming years. I don't care if half the tickets are given away free - we need people coming through the turnstiles in the first place if we ever want them to come back regularly!
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Thats what it needs, children free, adults a fiver, by two get a third free and advertise the games. get the crowds there
TJ1- Posts : 2666
Join date : 2011-08-06
Re: Scottish crowds
RDW, it's a team for the eastern half of Scotland! Surely there's a stadium within an hour North or South?
Glas a du- Posts : 15843
Join date : 2011-04-28
Age : 48
Location : Ammanford
Re: Scottish crowds
Yes but I'd say 90% of the fans come from central Edinburgh, and wouldn't go if it was anywhere else. Also - see point 1!
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Have you approached the SNP?
Glas a du- Posts : 15843
Join date : 2011-04-28
Age : 48
Location : Ammanford
Re: Scottish crowds
Me personally?
Only reason I'd approach Salmond is to kick him in the nuts!
Only reason I'd approach Salmond is to kick him in the nuts!
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Ask him to build a rugger stadium. If it has a duel use, like a state opening of the SP or Burnes suppers for the toffs or something he might go for it.
What about Ingliston, the RDS worked for Leinster. Plenty of parking, convenient for the airport, cracking setting. You could use the food hall as an indoor training facility.
What about Ingliston, the RDS worked for Leinster. Plenty of parking, convenient for the airport, cracking setting. You could use the food hall as an indoor training facility.
Glas a du- Posts : 15843
Join date : 2011-04-28
Age : 48
Location : Ammanford
Re: Scottish crowds
OK, crazy idea, but with the Commonwealth Games coming up in Glasgow, there was an opportunity (now probably missed) to create a multi-sport venue in central Edinburgh.
As it stands, the field hockey will be played in a temporary venue in Glasgow Green. If the organisers had been willing to accept that some sports would be played outside of Glasgow (as London 2012 have done), you could build a combined hockey/shinty/rugby venue in one of the many green spaces in central Edinburgh. Raeburn Place or the playing fields of Heriot's RFC are just a couple of ideas.
The one thing that's clear is that the process of building a new purpose-built stadium will have to start as soon as possible. Temporary stands at the Murrayfield back pitches is fine, but this can't be a permanent solution. I've been quite encouraged by Mark Dodson's stated intention to bite the bullet by picking one of the many options and actually forging ahead with it.
As it stands, the field hockey will be played in a temporary venue in Glasgow Green. If the organisers had been willing to accept that some sports would be played outside of Glasgow (as London 2012 have done), you could build a combined hockey/shinty/rugby venue in one of the many green spaces in central Edinburgh. Raeburn Place or the playing fields of Heriot's RFC are just a couple of ideas.
The one thing that's clear is that the process of building a new purpose-built stadium will have to start as soon as possible. Temporary stands at the Murrayfield back pitches is fine, but this can't be a permanent solution. I've been quite encouraged by Mark Dodson's stated intention to bite the bullet by picking one of the many options and actually forging ahead with it.
IanBru- Posts : 2909
Join date : 2011-04-30
Age : 36
Location : Newcastle
Re: Scottish crowds
RDW_Scotland wrote:Glas a du wrote:What, not even a decent soccer pitch holding up to 10k?
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! How many times does someone bring this up on a post regarding the Scottish club sides!!!!!! Drives me mental!! Not a dig at you Glas a du, you're just the unfortunate person to ask it the one extra time it needed before I snapped!
So, as you may have gathered, this topic has been discussed to death both on V2 and the old 606. I can remember at least 4 topics that have brought this up since I joined V2 and I even made an article of my own all about it, to try and stop its current recurrence!
So, here is why Edinburgh play at Murrayfield:
Point 1 - nae cash. This is the be all and end all that feeds in to every option available.
Option 1 - football stadiums
Hearts and Hibs are around 18k seaters but the pitches are tiny - smaller than Firhill. Also the SRU don't want a power struggle with football, as well as paying football money when Murrayfield is empty (see point 1)
Option 2 - Meadowbank
Better option than Hibs or Hearts stadiums but is literally falling apart and would need substantial investment (see point 1)
Option 3 - build a new stadium
See point 1
Option 4 - temporary stands on the back pitches
This is the overwhelming favourite option for all fans. However - see point 1.
That only leaves 1 thing - stay at Murrayfield until there is more cash in the SRU!
And how to get that is another topic altogether....
Glas - yes, you accidentally hit on the biggest single thing annoying Edinburgh supporters. Apart from possibly a tram which has apparently caused a bit of disruption in town.
George Carlin- Admin
- Posts : 15802
Join date : 2011-06-23
Location : KSA
Re: Scottish crowds
George Carlin wrote:
Glas - yes, you accidentally hit on the biggest single thing annoying Edinburgh supporters. Apart from possibly a tram which has apparently caused a bit of disruption in town.
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Glas a du wrote:Ask him to build a rugger stadium. If it has a duel use, like a state opening of the SP or Burnes suppers for the toffs or something he might go for it.
What about Ingliston, the RDS worked for Leinster. Plenty of parking, convenient for the airport, cracking setting. You could use the food hall as an indoor training facility.
He's far too interested in ruining Scotland than building sports stadiums!
There was talk relatively recently of David Murray funding a sports stadium out in Ingliston that the SRU could join in on. I, however, really don't like the idea of Edinburgh playing out at Ingliston. It is in the arse end of no-where (next to the airport) with no bars, food places are anything like that near by. It is literally a big outdoor venue with big sheds and no one there unless an event is on. Murrayfield has 4 pubs in the direct vicinity as well as food joints and shops. It is 10 mins from Haymarket train station and 15 minutes from Princes street and the centre of town.
To get to Ingliston you would have to drive or get a bus taking 20 minutes (from Murrayfield, 30 from town) and once you get there it will be a big empty barren wilderness other than the stadium!
There's more to a sports ground than just the stands and I think moving Edinburgh to Ingliston will lose a lot of the support.
No thanks.
Unfortunately there aren't many other locations for a new venue, should the SRU ever be able to afford it!
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Glas a du wrote:What about Ingliston, the RDS worked for Leinster.
Actually it doesn't they are planning on moving
geoff998rugby- Posts : 5249
Join date : 2011-06-09
Age : 70
Location : Belfast/Ardglass
Re: Scottish crowds
Out of curiosity, how much is a ticket to watch Edinburgh or Glasgow?
Are they doing the same as the Welsh regions to attract the younger generation eg free kids tickets cheaper student tickets etc.
It's good to see that sales are improving and the clubs need to take advantage. As mentioned above - buy two tickets get a third free etc. Get some of the players into town and the uni to promote offers etc. As long as season ticket holders don't get forgotten about - I say this as I met a few Blues fans who were regular season ticket holders, decide not to renew a couple of years ago as with all the free tickets being thrown around and offers available for single games, it worked out cheaper - Maybe offer international tickets with a season ticket bundle sort if thing, you'd have more through the door watching Scotland too that way.
Are they doing the same as the Welsh regions to attract the younger generation eg free kids tickets cheaper student tickets etc.
It's good to see that sales are improving and the clubs need to take advantage. As mentioned above - buy two tickets get a third free etc. Get some of the players into town and the uni to promote offers etc. As long as season ticket holders don't get forgotten about - I say this as I met a few Blues fans who were regular season ticket holders, decide not to renew a couple of years ago as with all the free tickets being thrown around and offers available for single games, it worked out cheaper - Maybe offer international tickets with a season ticket bundle sort if thing, you'd have more through the door watching Scotland too that way.
overlordofthewest- Posts : 331
Join date : 2011-02-21
Age : 51
Location : Brynmawr
Re: Scottish crowds
Tickets are 20 quid and 10 quid for adults and students respectively if you buy at the stadium. They are 5 quid cheaper if you get them before 5pm on match day. Think kids tickets are a fiver but more often than not there are free ticket offers.
I have to say the marketing this year has been the best it has ever been - I even got a text from "Tim Visser" asking me if I was coming to the Airioni game!
The players spend a lot of time visiting schools and taking kids coaching sessions etc which is great. From an Edinburgh perspective we seem to really be focussing on the kids with these visits to schools and buy 1 adult ticket, get 10 kids free kind of things.
The difficult market however, and the one that you need to make money, is the full price adult tickets. The market I think they need to try and get in to is the people actually involved with rugby clubs in Edinburgh, be it playing, coaching, running or watching. If the game is on a Saturday this is a non-starter as they will be playing themselves. However, if it is on a Friday night then there is no excuse.
Something like half price tickets if booked through your club or something, maybe even give the clubs a commission for ticket sales. There are probably around 4000 registered rugby players in Edinburgh (depressing eh?) and that number can easily be doubled when you consider the coaches and those who run the clubs themselves, as well as the supporters of each club.
I think it would be great if 15-20 of us from my club came to watch Edinburgh on Friday night, have a couple of pints and talk about our coming game the next day. Get another 50-100 clubs doing the same and you start building up your crowd!
There is a great offer just now where if you buy a ticket for the France 6N game you get a free ticket for the Edinburgh V Glasgow derby.
I have to say the marketing this year has been the best it has ever been - I even got a text from "Tim Visser" asking me if I was coming to the Airioni game!
The players spend a lot of time visiting schools and taking kids coaching sessions etc which is great. From an Edinburgh perspective we seem to really be focussing on the kids with these visits to schools and buy 1 adult ticket, get 10 kids free kind of things.
The difficult market however, and the one that you need to make money, is the full price adult tickets. The market I think they need to try and get in to is the people actually involved with rugby clubs in Edinburgh, be it playing, coaching, running or watching. If the game is on a Saturday this is a non-starter as they will be playing themselves. However, if it is on a Friday night then there is no excuse.
Something like half price tickets if booked through your club or something, maybe even give the clubs a commission for ticket sales. There are probably around 4000 registered rugby players in Edinburgh (depressing eh?) and that number can easily be doubled when you consider the coaches and those who run the clubs themselves, as well as the supporters of each club.
I think it would be great if 15-20 of us from my club came to watch Edinburgh on Friday night, have a couple of pints and talk about our coming game the next day. Get another 50-100 clubs doing the same and you start building up your crowd!
There is a great offer just now where if you buy a ticket for the France 6N game you get a free ticket for the Edinburgh V Glasgow derby.
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Where are Leinster moving to Geoff?
I heard they pay the highest rent in the league (more than the football stadiums charge), Donnybrook is to small, and New Lansdowne Road is too big. Also I thought the RDS will be Leinster's home until 2027, as a 20 year lease was signed in 2007?
I heard they pay the highest rent in the league (more than the football stadiums charge), Donnybrook is to small, and New Lansdowne Road is too big. Also I thought the RDS will be Leinster's home until 2027, as a 20 year lease was signed in 2007?
Kingshu- Posts : 4127
Join date : 2011-05-30
Re: Scottish crowds
I actually don't know but they do have some building planned and I know it is not at RDS. The high rent is a major factor. As a guess they probably have a buy out clause after a number of years (6/7 ?) - only a guess though
geoff998rugby- Posts : 5249
Join date : 2011-06-09
Age : 70
Location : Belfast/Ardglass
Re: Scottish crowds
RDW - It looks like Edinburgh are doing all the right things and hopefully things will continue to improve.
The point you make about other clubs playing at the same time is the same for us. A fair size group of us (25 ish) watched the Scarlets play at home at couple of weeks ago as it was on a Friday night. There are only 9 of us going to watch the game this week as the others are playing for their club (I don't play - too old!) and the tickets started at £11 each - that's to watch the Scarlets play Munster in the HEC. I know that there's only a difference of 16 or so and that's not going to make any huge improvements to ticket sales. However, something that was banded about was the local clubs playing early on a Saturday and running a bus to the region later. If that was adopted by all the regions and an agreement reached with the smaller clubs (maybe pay for the transport) then the numbers could significantly increase. I don't see why this couldn't work in Scotland too, Im sure there are problems with it but it sounds like a good idea to me.
The point you make about other clubs playing at the same time is the same for us. A fair size group of us (25 ish) watched the Scarlets play at home at couple of weeks ago as it was on a Friday night. There are only 9 of us going to watch the game this week as the others are playing for their club (I don't play - too old!) and the tickets started at £11 each - that's to watch the Scarlets play Munster in the HEC. I know that there's only a difference of 16 or so and that's not going to make any huge improvements to ticket sales. However, something that was banded about was the local clubs playing early on a Saturday and running a bus to the region later. If that was adopted by all the regions and an agreement reached with the smaller clubs (maybe pay for the transport) then the numbers could significantly increase. I don't see why this couldn't work in Scotland too, Im sure there are problems with it but it sounds like a good idea to me.
overlordofthewest- Posts : 331
Join date : 2011-02-21
Age : 51
Location : Brynmawr
Re: Scottish crowds
When looking at it Geoff, I found
http://www.universityobserver.ie/2011/11/15/leinster-rugby-to-move-to-ucd-campus/
But its a training ground move, maybe this is what you picked up on, or maybe they plan to build and move to UCD? Expand the UCD Bowl?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UCD_Bowl
http://www.universityobserver.ie/2011/11/15/leinster-rugby-to-move-to-ucd-campus/
But its a training ground move, maybe this is what you picked up on, or maybe they plan to build and move to UCD? Expand the UCD Bowl?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UCD_Bowl
Kingshu- Posts : 4127
Join date : 2011-05-30
Re: Scottish crowds
I'd love to see the clubs mroe involved with Edinburgh games but, tbh, there's almost a "them and us" relationship between the pro teams with the SRU and the club game in Scotland. Clubs are trying hard just to stay afloat just now and they aren't overly interested in losing some of their punters to go to an Edinburgh game.
As we've been saying though - if you can do it on a Friday night when the clubs aren't playing then great.
I don't see clubs being happy having an early kick off to allow people to go to the pro game as they would lose bar takings from people hanging around after the game.
I really would like to see more clubs coming along though - a bunch of loud rugby players would make a much better atmoshpere than the prawn sandwich brigade and the elderly that you often get at Edinburgh games!
As we've been saying though - if you can do it on a Friday night when the clubs aren't playing then great.
I don't see clubs being happy having an early kick off to allow people to go to the pro game as they would lose bar takings from people hanging around after the game.
I really would like to see more clubs coming along though - a bunch of loud rugby players would make a much better atmoshpere than the prawn sandwich brigade and the elderly that you often get at Edinburgh games!
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Kingshu wrote:Where are Leinster moving to Geoff?
I heard they pay the highest rent in the league (more than the football stadiums charge), Donnybrook is to small, and New Lansdowne Road is too big. Also I thought the RDS will be Leinster's home until 2027, as a 20 year lease was signed in 2007?
Wouldn't be surprised if there was a 10 year break in that, so 2017. 2 years to build somewhere gets back to 2015, 2 years in planning phase 2013. So plenty of time yet.
The RDS is a nice venue but at the end of it all, they are playing on an equestrian venue. It will be tricky for them to move somewhere, RDS is so central (from a Dublin point of view) its great to catch a game and head into town afterwards. But for people coming up to the big smoke it is buried a long way from the bypass. Maybe if the incinerator is finally scuttled in ringsend, Munster could lend the engineering plans to TP (save the IRFU some money) and TP2 could be constructed there (with 10 extra seats for one-up-man-ship).
Interesting point earlier on not hearing about the game. I don't know the details for it but there are 2 radio stations 'sponsoring' Leinster FM104 and Newtalk. But because of that you will always hear on both stations a nice bit of evening and morning sport talk mentioning Leinster games. Scottish teams could do a payment in kind deal. Bring in a station as a sponsor for a notional amount and then the station provide a certain amount of airtime building up the the Glasgow/Edinburgh game discussing it, etc.
thebandwagonsociety- Posts : 2901
Join date : 2011-06-02
Re: Scottish crowds
I think the Kick off times are an important factor, as the Regions/Provinces/City sides, are set up to provide a higher level of rugby than club rubgy and should complimnet it not compete with it.
This is why I'm happy with Friday night games, alot of people on these boards say Kick off should be at the tradition time, but I think that tradition KO's time should be the Clubs time and the Regions/Provinces/City sides, try not to compete.
Saturday is a hard sell anyway with Football kicking off at the same time, theres a gap for Friday night games, and thats what we should be going for.
Ulster for me is great on a Friday, just the 7.05 Ko is a bit early, 7.30 would be ok and 7.45 better.
Citys like Edinburgh and Glasgow can support Friday night games better that most, I can see why Connacht, Dragons and Scarlets dislike them, but every other team is based in an area with a high population density and should be able to hold friday night games.
This is why I'm happy with Friday night games, alot of people on these boards say Kick off should be at the tradition time, but I think that tradition KO's time should be the Clubs time and the Regions/Provinces/City sides, try not to compete.
Saturday is a hard sell anyway with Football kicking off at the same time, theres a gap for Friday night games, and thats what we should be going for.
Ulster for me is great on a Friday, just the 7.05 Ko is a bit early, 7.30 would be ok and 7.45 better.
Citys like Edinburgh and Glasgow can support Friday night games better that most, I can see why Connacht, Dragons and Scarlets dislike them, but every other team is based in an area with a high population density and should be able to hold friday night games.
Kingshu- Posts : 4127
Join date : 2011-05-30
Re: Scottish crowds
RDW_Scotland
The people they should be aiming at are people like me and my friends - interested in rugby but not club members. A few years ago there were adverts on the buses, telly and radio - that got the notice of a wider audience. We also used to be able to get free tickets a lot of the time.
The crowds should not be treated as a device to make money - its an small sum in comparison to the total outlays. Instead it should be used to expand the audience for he games by widely promoting he games and making it very cheap / free to get in to build audience.
Better to have ten thousand at £5 a go that threethousand at £10
The people they should be aiming at are people like me and my friends - interested in rugby but not club members. A few years ago there were adverts on the buses, telly and radio - that got the notice of a wider audience. We also used to be able to get free tickets a lot of the time.
The crowds should not be treated as a device to make money - its an small sum in comparison to the total outlays. Instead it should be used to expand the audience for he games by widely promoting he games and making it very cheap / free to get in to build audience.
Better to have ten thousand at £5 a go that threethousand at £10
TJ1- Posts : 2666
Join date : 2011-08-06
Re: Scottish crowds
I understand your arguments but the proximity to the airport makes it ideal for travelling fans. Is driving 20 minutes really going to kill you? It may be the arse end of nowhere, but I guarantee you that if the council allow an out of town development close by that can change.
Glas a du- Posts : 15843
Join date : 2011-04-28
Age : 48
Location : Ammanford
Re: Scottish crowds
Ingleston - would reduce crowds significantly IMO - I certainly would never go as I don't drive
TJ1- Posts : 2666
Join date : 2011-08-06
Re: Scottish crowds
A few points being raised here which I'll adress in turn.
Stadia :
Untill Meadowbank is either saved/renovated in the same way as Scotstoun in Glasgow, Edinburgh will (and rightly so) play their matches at Murrayfield. There are a number of reasons for this. Pitch size and price being the most important factors.
Tynecastle and Easter Road are too small for Rugby pitches. With the Jambos in dire straits financially I can't really see Tynecastle being there in 10 years time anyway.
Meadowbank would be perfect however as I said in another thread it's a product of a few decades ago. It was acceptable in the 80s.... a bit like Calvin Harris. Unless it gets a huge revamp in partnership with the SRU and Scottish Athletics and any other potential tennants it's not a viable solution.
Ergo we must stay at Murrayfield. In truth with some of the new additions like standing pitchside and the increace in numbers coming along (when have you ever seen 4000+ at an Aironi game) Murrayfield is in a strange way developing an atmosphere.
Ticket pricing :
15 quid is a lot of money, especially if like me and other supporters who don't live in Edinburgh. It costs me an additional £13 for a return train ticket to Haymarket and a few beers on top of that at Edinburgh prices and you are talking £50 a week. It's a lot. Dropping ticket prices to a fiver I think will get more through the gates and balence out the price differance.
Signs of improvement though which can only be linked to some good PR and results on the pitch. Edinburgh seem to be cashing in on Visser's phenomenal strike rate... good on them!
Stadia :
Untill Meadowbank is either saved/renovated in the same way as Scotstoun in Glasgow, Edinburgh will (and rightly so) play their matches at Murrayfield. There are a number of reasons for this. Pitch size and price being the most important factors.
Tynecastle and Easter Road are too small for Rugby pitches. With the Jambos in dire straits financially I can't really see Tynecastle being there in 10 years time anyway.
Meadowbank would be perfect however as I said in another thread it's a product of a few decades ago. It was acceptable in the 80s.... a bit like Calvin Harris. Unless it gets a huge revamp in partnership with the SRU and Scottish Athletics and any other potential tennants it's not a viable solution.
Ergo we must stay at Murrayfield. In truth with some of the new additions like standing pitchside and the increace in numbers coming along (when have you ever seen 4000+ at an Aironi game) Murrayfield is in a strange way developing an atmosphere.
Ticket pricing :
15 quid is a lot of money, especially if like me and other supporters who don't live in Edinburgh. It costs me an additional £13 for a return train ticket to Haymarket and a few beers on top of that at Edinburgh prices and you are talking £50 a week. It's a lot. Dropping ticket prices to a fiver I think will get more through the gates and balence out the price differance.
Signs of improvement though which can only be linked to some good PR and results on the pitch. Edinburgh seem to be cashing in on Visser's phenomenal strike rate... good on them!
Last edited by RuggerRadge2611 on Tue 06 Dec 2011, 11:37 am; edited 1 time in total
RuggerRadge2611- Posts : 7194
Join date : 2011-03-04
Age : 39
Location : The North, The REAL North (Beyond the Wall)
Re: Scottish crowds
I'm picking up a theme. You don't get many fans and those you have are inflexible. If those you don't have are just as inflexible then this thread seems to be a waste of time. However I don't believe that for a minute. If it were possible to play in a smaller stadium AND the team did well on the pitch, the crowds would miraculously grow of their own accord.
I know see point 1 above!
I know see point 1 above!
Glas a du- Posts : 15843
Join date : 2011-04-28
Age : 48
Location : Ammanford
Re: Scottish crowds
Radge, in truth, when has Calvin Harris ever been acceptable?
AsLongAsBut100ofUs- Posts : 14129
Join date : 2011-03-26
Age : 112
Location : Devon/London
Re: Scottish crowds
AsLongAsBut100ofUs wrote:Radge, in truth, when has Calvin Harris ever been acceptable?
I have heard worse! Have you been watching Xfactor?
That thimbs down is the same kind of thumbs down Emperor Nero would do. Sadly it would not be deemed politcally correct to feed the Xfactor rejects to lions.....
RuggerRadge2611- Posts : 7194
Join date : 2011-03-04
Age : 39
Location : The North, The REAL North (Beyond the Wall)
Re: Scottish crowds
It's a matter of time in the ratings war.
Glas a du- Posts : 15843
Join date : 2011-04-28
Age : 48
Location : Ammanford
Re: Scottish crowds
Real feeding of dross to the lions? - I might watch it then!
AsLongAsBut100ofUs- Posts : 14129
Join date : 2011-03-26
Age : 112
Location : Devon/London
Re: Scottish crowds
It might help society out as well if we just fed all the Big Brother and X Factor rejects to the lions - might also increase numbers of a few endangered species while we're at it - and even at it's worst it would still be more entertaining than the current programmes!
(you could even charge people for the pleasure of feeding Simon Cowell and Ant & Dec to the lions bit by bit - and the proceeds could pay for a new Edinburgh stadium) WIN WIN WIN!
(you could even charge people for the pleasure of feeding Simon Cowell and Ant & Dec to the lions bit by bit - and the proceeds could pay for a new Edinburgh stadium) WIN WIN WIN!
Smirnoffpriest- Posts : 5321
Join date : 2011-06-03
Age : 41
Location : Cardiff (born in Llanelli)
Re: Scottish crowds
Lads - I'm involved down here as my clubs 'Regional Ticketing' rep. We can buy tickets to any Cardiff Blues game, including Heineken Cup group games, at £10 per ticket (minimum purchase 10) as opposed to the face value price of £22 . Then the clubs can sell them to players, supporters ...etc at any price up to £22, thus getting bums on seats for the Blues and maybe genetrating a wee bit of cash for the club. Generally we knock out the tickets at £15 each , so the lads save £7
Do either Glasgow or Edinburgh do similar ? ( I've I've missed something above, on my lunch break, so 'speed reading"
As it goes I definitely have 2, possibly 4, spare for Fridays game at £15 each. If there are any Edinburgh fans making the trip down and want to save some money just drop us a PM and no, I'm not stereotyping
Do either Glasgow or Edinburgh do similar ? ( I've I've missed something above, on my lunch break, so 'speed reading"
As it goes I definitely have 2, possibly 4, spare for Fridays game at £15 each. If there are any Edinburgh fans making the trip down and want to save some money just drop us a PM and no, I'm not stereotyping
PenfroPete- Posts : 3415
Join date : 2011-05-13
Age : 63
Location : Pentre'r Eglwys, Cymru
Re: Scottish crowds
Kingshu wrote:When looking at it Geoff, I found
http://www.universityobserver.ie/2011/11/15/leinster-rugby-to-move-to-ucd-campus/
But its a training ground move, maybe this is what you picked up on, or maybe they plan to build and move to UCD? Expand the UCD Bowl?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UCD_Bowl
Leinster are moving their offices (from a cramped 1st floor opposite the stadium in Donnybrook) and their training setup. (from Riverview gym)
to UCD, or more correctly the old Philips (Dutch Electronics giant) building which is now owned by, and adjacent to UCD.
It makes sense. I have lived in the area for many years. RDS, Donnybrook, Philips Building are all within a mile (ish) of each other.
No plans to leave the RDS. I'd say the rent may be re negotiated at the break in the contract.
It works for us. Playing 12 games per year is the contract. We move at least 2 big games (Munster and a HC game) each year to Lansdowne rd. With the Italian teams in the pro12, the B&I cup (currently played in D'brook) and the Schools cup final. We have flexibility to get even more games in LR. (We played 4 there last year)
So the RDS is perfect for games too big for Donnybrook (Capacity 6 to 8000) and too small for LR.
We have over 13500 season ticket holders so D'brook will never be an option for even Aironi in the pro12.
There is a plan to redevelop the Anglesea stand in the RDS to give more space/better facilities.
PS. Sorry for hijacking a Scottish thread.
Jenifer McLadyboy- Posts : 4764
Join date : 2011-06-30
Re: Scottish crowds
PenfroPete wrote:Lads - I'm involved down here as my clubs 'Regional Ticketing' rep. We can buy tickets to any Cardiff Blues game, including Heineken Cup group games, at £10 per ticket (minimum purchase 10) as opposed to the face value price of £22 . Then the clubs can sell them to players, supporters ...etc at any price up to £22, thus getting bums on seats for the Blues and maybe genetrating a wee bit of cash for the club. Generally we knock out the tickets at £15 each , so the lads save £7
Do either Glasgow or Edinburgh do similar ? ( I've I've missed something above, on my lunch break, so 'speed reading"
As it goes I definitely have 2, possibly 4, spare for Fridays game at £15 each. If there are any Edinburgh fans making the trip down and want to save some money just drop us a PM and no, I'm not stereotyping
That's a really good idea and along the lines of what I've mentioned above!
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Glas a du wrote:I'm picking up a theme. You don't get many fans and those you have are inflexible. If those you don't have are just as inflexible then this thread seems to be a waste of time. However I don't believe that for a minute. If it were possible to play in a smaller stadium AND the team did well on the pitch, the crowds would miraculously grow of their own accord.
I know see point 1 above!
I wouldn't say inflexible really describes it. Basically, rugby in Scotland is a minority sport compared to football. It gets next to no coverage in the "sports" news on BBC Scotland (they talked about the following days 1st division football fixtures instead of Edinburgh humping Airioni) and the media in general. Therefore most of the supporters are fair weather, need incentives, kind of supporters. I'd say there is a core of maybe 2000 who would come most weeks, and would probably come to whatever venue. However it is the additional 2-3k which are the difficult ones as it would not take much to sway them either way - pishin doon with rain? Not going. 2 for 1 on tickets and the wife is out for the evening? Yeah I'll go to that.
If we moved somewhere unattractive like ingliston then that 2-3k extra will be pushed towards the "no thank you" end.
And you talk about it being close to the airport so is good for travelling fans:
1 - why would we base our decision where to play on the needs of the away fans?
2 - that is all fair and well if you are coming straight off the plane and on to straight Ingliston. How many people would want to do that instead of heading in to the City centre to see the sights? Then they would have to go all the way out to Ingliston again, followed by all the way back into town for their hotel, followed by...
RDW- Founder
- Posts : 33185
Join date : 2011-06-01
Location : Sydney
Re: Scottish crowds
Jen, Not at all, it's really good to learn more about other clubs' experiencesJenifer McLadyboy wrote:Kingshu wrote:When looking at it Geoff, I found
http://www.universityobserver.ie/2011/11/15/leinster-rugby-to-move-to-ucd-campus/
But its a training ground move, maybe this is what you picked up on, or maybe they plan to build and move to UCD? Expand the UCD Bowl?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UCD_Bowl
Leinster are moving their offices (from a cramped 1st floor opposite the stadium in Donnybrook) and their training setup. (from Riverview gym)
to UCD, or more correctly the old Philips (Dutch Electronics giant) building which is now owned by, and adjacent to UCD.
It makes sense. I have lived in the area for many years. RDS, Donnybrook, Philips Building are all within a mile (ish) of each other.
No plans to leave the RDS. I'd say the rent may be re negotiated at the break in the contract.
It works for us. Playing 12 games per year is the contract. We move at least 2 big games (Munster and a HC game) each year to Lansdowne rd. With the Italian teams in the pro12, the B&I cup (currently played in D'brook) and the Schools cup final. We have flexibility to get even more games in LR. (We played 4 there last year)
So the RDS is perfect for games too big for Donnybrook (Capacity 6 to 8000) and too small for LR.
We have over 13500 season ticket holders so D'brook will never be an option for even Aironi in the pro12.
There is a plan to redevelop the Anglesea stand in the RDS to give more space/better facilities.
PS. Sorry for hijacking a Scottish thread.
AsLongAsBut100ofUs- Posts : 14129
Join date : 2011-03-26
Age : 112
Location : Devon/London
Re: Scottish crowds
PenfroPete wrote:Lads - I'm involved down here as my clubs 'Regional Ticketing' rep. We can buy tickets to any Cardiff Blues game, including Heineken Cup group games, at £10 per ticket (minimum purchase 10) as opposed to the face value price of £22 . Then the clubs can sell them to players, supporters ...etc at any price up to £22, thus getting bums on seats for the Blues and maybe genetrating a wee bit of cash for the club. Generally we knock out the tickets at £15 each , so the lads save £7
Do either Glasgow or Edinburgh do similar ? ( I've I've missed something above, on my lunch break, so 'speed reading"
As it goes I definitely have 2, possibly 4, spare for Fridays game at £15 each. If there are any Edinburgh fans making the trip down and want to save some money just drop us a PM and no, I'm not stereotyping
That sounds a good deal Penfro - I do sometimes go down to see the Blues (for my sins) when I can't get down to the Scarlets - I maybe in touch in the future about getting a ticket if thats ok...
Smirnoffpriest- Posts : 5321
Join date : 2011-06-03
Age : 41
Location : Cardiff (born in Llanelli)
Re: Scottish crowds
When we move to Scotstoun next season where will we get a pint ? Us Warriors are a thirsty lot !
21st Century Schizoid Man- Posts : 3564
Join date : 2011-05-31
Location : Glasgow
Re: Scottish crowds
No probs Smirnoff (although you really should try NEARER HOME for your tipple Only issue would be whether we would get the demand, although I wouldn't think there'd be a problem for the Dragons (Fri 23/12) Scarlets (Sat 24/03) Ospreys (13/14/15/04) and maybe the Heineken against Racing, if the Blues are still in with a shoutSmirnoffpriest wrote: That sounds a good deal Penfro - I do sometimes go down to see the Blues (for my sins) when I can't get down to the Scarlets - I maybe in touch in the future about getting a ticket if thats ok...
PenfroPete- Posts : 3415
Join date : 2011-05-13
Age : 63
Location : Pentre'r Eglwys, Cymru
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» Scottish Rugby Crowds?
» Bumper Crowds for the Holiday Season
» The Decline In Crowds At Munster Matches Was Wholly Predictable
» Rugby crowds
» Regional attendances so far this season
» Bumper Crowds for the Holiday Season
» The Decline In Crowds At Munster Matches Was Wholly Predictable
» Rugby crowds
» Regional attendances so far this season
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum