Should Andy Robinson go after this 6 nations? (6th Vote)

First topic message reminder :

Should Andy Robinson go after this 6 nations? (6th Vote)

Previous votes

Yes 25% 55% 42% 52% 39%
no 30% 20% 37% 32% 54%
Depends if Scotland finish higher that 2nd last 44% 24% 20% 14% 5%



So, after the fifth 6th straight loss, and Scotland dropping down the rankings, has the two one tries and good poor performance done enough to stave off the anti Andy voting, or is it too late soon for most supporters.

Please vote and let me know your thoughts

Eddie O'Sullivan would be a reasonable shout or John Kirwan, both deemed too inexperienced by England, but both with plenty of adequate experience for the Scotland job

How about that English chap, NIck Mallett?

Chick Chalmers would have been my choice to go to the Warriors, but the less said about that the better.

Mallet again would be a good choice but he has made some howlers in the past. Bergamassco at Scrum half anyone? I can Just see Strokosch taking to the field at 9.....

I think Redpath would actually be best. Mallett is undoubtedly a very good coach, but he's not the kind of coach Scotland needs right now. Redpath has made a few insightful but entirely relevent comments regarding Scotland's current weaknesses, namely the centres and half-backs. I think if anyone could unlock Scotlands backline and improve our win:loss/try:no try ratio it'd be him.

More insightful selections from Robbo today with Cuthbert and MURCHIE called up to the squad. Thankfully he's also included Grove as well.