Best Ever team - so far!

Dan Carter - Fly Half https://www.606v2.com/t3418-who-is-the-best-fly-half-of-all-time?vote=viewresult
Keith Wood - Hooker https://www.606v2.com/t4169-greatest-hooker-of-all-time
Jonah Lumo - Winger https://www.606v2.com/t2796-who-is-the-best-winger-of-all-time
Shane Williams - Winger https://www.606v2.com/t2796-who-is-the-best-winger-of-all-time
Gareth Edwards - Scrum Half https://www.606v2.com/t3128-top-five-scrum-halves
JPR Williams - Full Back https://www.606v2.com/t3276-who-is-the-greatest-full-back-of-all-time
Zinzan Brooke - No 8 https://www.606v2.com/t3356-who-is-the-best-no8-in-rugby-union-of-all-time
Richie McCaw - Flanker https://www.606v2.com/t3251-top-flanker-of-all-time
Graham Price - Prop https://www.606v2.com/t4008-greatest-prop-of-all-time

So this is the team picked so far. Is this looking like the best team ever, at the halfway mark?

Still time to vote on these if you havent already but would love to hear your thoughts.

Next up are the second row - poll to follow!

Only one prop and one flanker? The referee will quickly be blowing up for a wheeling scrum

I was going to redo the prop polls to include tight head and loose head...smart bum!

Will they be playing at their current age, or will a time machine be required to bring them back to their prime? If not they might run out of puff after the first half...

Not picked by the polls,but my opinion.Kevin Skinner Prop.Ken Gray Prop.
Ron Hemi Hooker,Colin Meads,Pole Whiting Locks,McCaw,Michael Jones Flank
Kel Tremain Number 8.Des Connor Scrum half,Dan Carter Fly half.Wings David Campese,Jonah Lomu,Centres Mannie Roux,Bledynn Williams,Full Back Bob Scott or Don Clarke. I at least have seen all the above play.

That's the problem with so much of the debate about best players. I have only watched rugby for about 30 years so when someone like emack2 comes along and talks about having watched Colin Meads and Kel Tremain play I realise my opinion is as informed as my sister's "DC is the best because .... just look at his chest".

I bow to the wisdom of those who have witnessed our great game for decades beyond counting

Still better than being an English supporter who started in 2003

If Neil Jenkins get's on the list for best Fly Half ever I'll hand in my membership of the Welsh nation in disgust. We are the Nation that produced Cliff Morgan, Barry John, Phill Bennett & Johnathan Davies. Neil Jenkins produced some of the most turgid, slow and uninspired rugby I've EVER seen. He may have scored 1000+ points but that bloke cost us about 3000+ point in his career for being the greatest bottleneck in a team since the M4 got closed to all but mobility scooters! Awful, awful fly half. Would have done well playing for england in the 10 man rugby days and that says it all.

Greatest fly half I ever saw was indeed Jiffy. Was so sorry to see him jeered off the pitch in his last game for the scarlets.