Will or Should Sentiment Come Into It?
2 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 1 of 1
Will or Should Sentiment Come Into It?
I am on about our game against Australia at the MS in December.
Shane has said it would be nice to bow out in front of a home ground with family around him etc, and I can full undertsand that as he has been great servant for us.
It will also be Nuggetts last chance in front of his home crowd and possibly Stephen Jones both again have been great servants to us.
BUT should they be picked out of sentiment?
For me the answer is no, if they are still playing and in form then fine but not just out of sympathy. Not sure how long Stoddart is out for so if Shane carries on playing for O's then that would be a fair call but I doubt if Jones or M Williams will get muchgametime and their Regions.
IMO I would much rather see Gatland name his strongest side BUT let the 3 players named above do a lap of honour etc before/after the game and take the well deserved appluads from the crowd.
Shane has said it would be nice to bow out in front of a home ground with family around him etc, and I can full undertsand that as he has been great servant for us.
It will also be Nuggetts last chance in front of his home crowd and possibly Stephen Jones both again have been great servants to us.
BUT should they be picked out of sentiment?
For me the answer is no, if they are still playing and in form then fine but not just out of sympathy. Not sure how long Stoddart is out for so if Shane carries on playing for O's then that would be a fair call but I doubt if Jones or M Williams will get muchgametime and their Regions.
IMO I would much rather see Gatland name his strongest side BUT let the 3 players named above do a lap of honour etc before/after the game and take the well deserved appluads from the crowd.
bedfordwelsh- Moderator
- Posts : 9962
Join date : 2011-05-11
Age : 56
Re: Will or Should Sentiment Come Into It?
Had we won RWC - yep, bring on the sentiment and play Nuggett
If we lose Friday - no room for it put out vest side
if we win Friday - toughie, we will want to win again and start a series of victories against Aus inthe next 12 months. Shane yes if ft and on form and likewise nuggett off the bench
If we lose Friday - no room for it put out vest side
if we win Friday - toughie, we will want to win again and start a series of victories against Aus inthe next 12 months. Shane yes if ft and on form and likewise nuggett off the bench
Gatts- Posts : 2212
Join date : 2011-08-18
Similar topics
» Anti-English Sentiment In Lions 15's
» Former Writer Says HHH Jealousy Behind Anti-Rock Sentiment?
» Yuvraj Singh's comeback - sentiment over common sense?
» Former Writer Says HHH Jealousy Behind Anti-Rock Sentiment?
» Yuvraj Singh's comeback - sentiment over common sense?
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum