Top 5 every division
+6
HumanWindmill
Colonial Lion
skidd1
88Chris05
azania
Imperial Ghosty
10 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Boxing
Page 2 of 2
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Top 5 every division
First topic message reminder :
Now this may take a lot of effort for anyone who wishes to partake
In short there are now 17 recognized weight divisions with differing levels of history and some are considered more prestigious than others with the so called original 8 being the most obvious case of this. For many their knowledge of each division varies markably with Captain being well know for his knowledge of the Light Heavyweight division. In short I want to see what peoples top 5 rankings are of all 17 divisions with a little twist at the end, who are the greatest 5 who don't feature in the top 5 of any division.
I'll Give a few of mine just to kick things off
Heavyweight
1. Ali
2. Louis
3. Holmes
4. Dempsey
5. Lewis
Light Heavyweight
1. Charles
2. Tunney
3. Moore
4. Spinks
5. Foster
Middleweight
1. Monzon
2. Hagler
3. Greb
4. Robinson
5. Ketchel
Light Middleweight
1. McCallum
2. Hearns
3. Wright
4. Norris
5. Jackson
Welterweight
1. Robinson
2. Leonard
3. Armstrong
4. Ross
5. Gavilan
Light Welterweight
1. Pryor
2. Locche
3. Cervantez
4. Canzoneri
5. Berg
Lightweight
1. Duran
2. Leonard
3. Gans
4. Whitaker
5. Williams
Featherweight
1. Pep
2. Saddler
3. Arguello
4. Attell
5. Sanchez
My Top 5 not included
1. Fitzsimmons
2. Langford
3. Pacquiao
4. Burley
5. Griffith
Now this may take a lot of effort for anyone who wishes to partake
In short there are now 17 recognized weight divisions with differing levels of history and some are considered more prestigious than others with the so called original 8 being the most obvious case of this. For many their knowledge of each division varies markably with Captain being well know for his knowledge of the Light Heavyweight division. In short I want to see what peoples top 5 rankings are of all 17 divisions with a little twist at the end, who are the greatest 5 who don't feature in the top 5 of any division.
I'll Give a few of mine just to kick things off
Heavyweight
1. Ali
2. Louis
3. Holmes
4. Dempsey
5. Lewis
Light Heavyweight
1. Charles
2. Tunney
3. Moore
4. Spinks
5. Foster
Middleweight
1. Monzon
2. Hagler
3. Greb
4. Robinson
5. Ketchel
Light Middleweight
1. McCallum
2. Hearns
3. Wright
4. Norris
5. Jackson
Welterweight
1. Robinson
2. Leonard
3. Armstrong
4. Ross
5. Gavilan
Light Welterweight
1. Pryor
2. Locche
3. Cervantez
4. Canzoneri
5. Berg
Lightweight
1. Duran
2. Leonard
3. Gans
4. Whitaker
5. Williams
Featherweight
1. Pep
2. Saddler
3. Arguello
4. Attell
5. Sanchez
My Top 5 not included
1. Fitzsimmons
2. Langford
3. Pacquiao
4. Burley
5. Griffith
Imperial Ghosty- Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15
Re: Top 5 every division
Out of interest Jimmy, who are considering to be Foremans best wins because other than Frazier I can't think of another
Imperial Ghosty- Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15
Re: Top 5 every division
Norton. Then probably Moorer, Cooney, Lyle in that order.imperialghosty wrote:Out of interest Jimmy, who are considering to be Foremans best wins because other than Frazier I can't think of another
Scottrf- Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Top 5 every division
Think I worded that wrong, I don't consider any of Foremans wins to be among the greatest in the division
Imperial Ghosty- Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15
Re: Top 5 every division
Scottrf wrote:Norton. Then probably Moorer, Cooney, Lyle in that order.imperialghosty wrote:Out of interest Jimmy, who are considering to be Foremans best wins because other than Frazier I can't think of another
Pretty much what Scott said Imperial, I may be inclined to say reclaiming the lineal HW title twenty years later in his forties is one of the top 10 great heavyweight wins, regardless what many will say about the opposition..
Jimmy Stuart- Posts : 153
Join date : 2011-02-17
Re: Top 5 every division
It's a great achievement no dount but a great win i'm not too sure
Imperial Ghosty- Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15
Re: Top 5 every division
Ah sorry, I think he was referring to the achiements rather than opponents. Blasting out a red hot Frazier and regaining the Heavyweight title at such an age.
EDIT: Clearly that was what he meant, but I'll still post this anyway...
EDIT: Clearly that was what he meant, but I'll still post this anyway...
Scottrf- Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Top 5 every division
See your point Imperial
Foreman has the more shocking names on his resume with Frazier and Moorer (if only because he was 45), but during both reigns as champions, he took soft touches, was very inactive, and didn't hold the belts for very long.
I say Lewis and Foreman are pretty interchangeable but neither strong enough to be apart of the elite 5 IMO.
Foreman has the more shocking names on his resume with Frazier and Moorer (if only because he was 45), but during both reigns as champions, he took soft touches, was very inactive, and didn't hold the belts for very long.
I say Lewis and Foreman are pretty interchangeable but neither strong enough to be apart of the elite 5 IMO.
Jimmy Stuart- Posts : 153
Join date : 2011-02-17
Re: Top 5 every division
Other than Ali and Louis there are no real stand outs in the divsion so in that sense spots 3-5 are up for grabs
Imperial Ghosty- Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15
Re: Top 5 every division
I have to say I agree with Colonial Lion on Lewis. I think if you are basing him being a top 5 heavyweight by virtue of him dominating his era or beating all his rivals then Colonial Lion has pretty much summed up perfectly why that isnt the case. Lewis outlasted his main rivals as much as anything.
However as Chris says, if you apply similar levels of scrutiny to the other heavyweight contenders for the spot then you can just as easily find various reasons to discount them also. Dempsey for instance I have long held as being an overrated champion in this context.
Like most others I have Ali and Louis a clear stretch ahead but after that I think the margins become fine. Largely for the same reasons as Colonial Lion I have Lewis missing out on a top 5 spot but being in the top 10 when all things are considered.
Like perhaps no other division, I think the "head to head" vs "list rankings" in the heavyweight division is at odds as there are many cases of 1 heavyweight being ranked higher than an other who I think would actually beat them head to head.
However as Chris says, if you apply similar levels of scrutiny to the other heavyweight contenders for the spot then you can just as easily find various reasons to discount them also. Dempsey for instance I have long held as being an overrated champion in this context.
Like most others I have Ali and Louis a clear stretch ahead but after that I think the margins become fine. Largely for the same reasons as Colonial Lion I have Lewis missing out on a top 5 spot but being in the top 10 when all things are considered.
Like perhaps no other division, I think the "head to head" vs "list rankings" in the heavyweight division is at odds as there are many cases of 1 heavyweight being ranked higher than an other who I think would actually beat them head to head.
manos de piedra- Posts : 5274
Join date : 2011-02-21
Re: Top 5 every division
It's always tight at the top.
I could make a perfectly respectable argument for Jeffries to claim a top five spot, ( and several respected historians do just that, ) but nowadays he's even overlooked in the top tens of many.
These things are seldom clear cut, and never easy.
I could make a perfectly respectable argument for Jeffries to claim a top five spot, ( and several respected historians do just that, ) but nowadays he's even overlooked in the top tens of many.
These things are seldom clear cut, and never easy.
HumanWindmill- VIP
- Posts : 10945
Join date : 2011-02-18
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» Most exciting division?
» The tag division in WWE and TNA
» 2nd division
» Anybody else not want one champion per division ???
» WWE tag team division
» The tag division in WWE and TNA
» 2nd division
» Anybody else not want one champion per division ???
» WWE tag team division
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Boxing
Page 2 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum