A question for front rowers
+6
George Carlin
mckay1402
wasps
Looseheaded
TJ1
InjuredYetAgain
10 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 1 of 1
A question for front rowers
Here is something that I have wondered about for a while but wonder what the donkeys front row union think.
Every time Scotland (and Edinburgh for that matter) pack down for a scrum, we always "crouch" a second or two after the opposition which to me sends out the message that we aren't really lookimg forwrad to the next few seconds. To front-rowers out there, would you interpret this body language as an indication of a nervousness to scrum or am I just imagining it. I know that Ross Ford is a converted flanker but he in particular never seems to look particularly comfortable at scrum-time.
I must confess to knowing very little about front row play apart from knowing that every time our prop appeared half way down my back, we were likely to be in quick retreat and unlikely to be winning our own ball.
If I have used too many long words for any props out there, let me know and I will see if I can translate using smaller words.
Every time Scotland (and Edinburgh for that matter) pack down for a scrum, we always "crouch" a second or two after the opposition which to me sends out the message that we aren't really lookimg forwrad to the next few seconds. To front-rowers out there, would you interpret this body language as an indication of a nervousness to scrum or am I just imagining it. I know that Ross Ford is a converted flanker but he in particular never seems to look particularly comfortable at scrum-time.
I must confess to knowing very little about front row play apart from knowing that every time our prop appeared half way down my back, we were likely to be in quick retreat and unlikely to be winning our own ball.
If I have used too many long words for any props out there, let me know and I will see if I can translate using smaller words.
InjuredYetAgain- Posts : 1317
Join date : 2011-06-02
Age : 58
Location : Edinburgh
Re: A question for front rowers
Hmmmmmmm
Not a prop but I see it the other way - stamping authority by making the other team wait in "crouch"
Not a prop but I see it the other way - stamping authority by making the other team wait in "crouch"
TJ1- Posts : 2666
Join date : 2011-08-06
Re: A question for front rowers
I personally wouldn't consider that as a sign of fear or a lack of confidence going into the scrum. It'd lead me to believe that they have less comfort with each other, as they are struggling to set up quickly, and suggests they are possibly inexperienced in scrummaging together.
Either that or the hooker's a fussy Bar Steward.
Either that or the hooker's a fussy Bar Steward.
Looseheaded- Posts : 1030
Join date : 2011-05-10
Re: A question for front rowers
We used to have a prepared move at scrum time where we would purposely wait a couple of seconds before crouching.
Mainly, we were waiting for the opposition to start looking up at us to see what we were doing.
Once they had done that, they had often moved themselves out of position slightly and were no longer as solid as they were before.
Obviously, if you do it all the time, it loses something.
On the whole, I usually wanted to be set and settled before we hit so I was quite happy to be down and crouched before the opposition
Mainly, we were waiting for the opposition to start looking up at us to see what we were doing.
Once they had done that, they had often moved themselves out of position slightly and were no longer as solid as they were before.
Obviously, if you do it all the time, it loses something.
On the whole, I usually wanted to be set and settled before we hit so I was quite happy to be down and crouched before the opposition
wasps- Posts : 145
Join date : 2011-09-13
Re: A question for front rowers
I played hooker and I would think it's a psychological ploy. Like your man says above, is to get the opposition to wear their legs out a bit. It's not easy staying in that crouch position with all the Wright of the pack coming through you and the less time you have to do it the better. I certainly wouldn't judge them on that. I'd judge them on the next few seconds. How the hit goes and where they end up.
mckay1402- Posts : 2512
Join date : 2011-04-27
Age : 47
Location : Market Harborough
Re: A question for front rowers
If you watch Owen and Ben Franks, they're always down and waiting before anyone else.
George Carlin- Admin
- Posts : 15802
Join date : 2011-06-23
Location : KSA
Re: A question for front rowers
I moved to hooker after the first time I broke my neck (interesting choice ).
As others have suggested getting ready second is just a ploy to try and eke out an advantage. I also liked to wait for the opposition to crouch then go lower and drive up at them.
All games really - Scottish front rows always look up for the fight to me.
As others have suggested getting ready second is just a ploy to try and eke out an advantage. I also liked to wait for the opposition to crouch then go lower and drive up at them.
All games really - Scottish front rows always look up for the fight to me.
LondonTiger- Moderator
- Posts : 23485
Join date : 2011-02-10
Re: A question for front rowers
oh don't be mistaken. In no way are the Edinburgh or Scotland front rows scared of scrumtime.
Look at Euan Murray, he is amost drooling at the propest of hitting someone when he is getting ready for a scrum.
If you watch/listen closely you will hear the ref shouting crouch, then a second later you will see/hear Ross Ford say crouch. When Ford is in the scrum he takes charge as to what his scrum will do. He will only tell his front row to crouch when he belives his whole scrum is ready for the off. This is something they will do in every game and something they will do in training. Mostly it is making sure that your scrum is ready, part of it is gamemanship to try and put off your opponents!
Look at Euan Murray, he is amost drooling at the propest of hitting someone when he is getting ready for a scrum.
If you watch/listen closely you will hear the ref shouting crouch, then a second later you will see/hear Ross Ford say crouch. When Ford is in the scrum he takes charge as to what his scrum will do. He will only tell his front row to crouch when he belives his whole scrum is ready for the off. This is something they will do in every game and something they will do in training. Mostly it is making sure that your scrum is ready, part of it is gamemanship to try and put off your opponents!
tigertattie- Posts : 9580
Join date : 2011-07-11
Location : On the naughty step
Re: A question for front rowers
If you look at the leinster front rows, they form up in the crouch position. I think it's to do with not having to readjust when going from the standing to the crouch position .Always happens when you have a front row made up of guys of varying heights. The hooker is usually quite a bit shorter than the TH these days.
Submachine- Posts : 1092
Join date : 2011-06-21
Re: A question for front rowers
I have always played tighthead, and to be honest I have never paid much attention to pause before crouching as its more about feeling stable and ready, I don't think it's a telling sign of nerves etc. you can tell more by the enthusiasm they exhibit when they bind, their body language when packing down, the speed at which they come accross to pack down in the scrummage.
I don't think the front rows of Scotland or Edinburgh are nervous in the scrummage. Any front row worth his salt will live for the battle of the scrumage. That's how they earn their reputations. If you weren't a particulary good scrummager, then you would go into each scrum to prove a point.
I don't think the front rows of Scotland or Edinburgh are nervous in the scrummage. Any front row worth his salt will live for the battle of the scrumage. That's how they earn their reputations. If you weren't a particulary good scrummager, then you would go into each scrum to prove a point.
Similar topics
» All Welsh lions front row?
» Scotland - front row crisis for AIs
» An Article for all Aspiring Back Rowers from Richard Hill
» Back row,what about the front row?
» Front Row Replacements
» Scotland - front row crisis for AIs
» An Article for all Aspiring Back Rowers from Richard Hill
» Back row,what about the front row?
» Front Row Replacements
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum