WRU Central Contracts
+14
Luckless Pedestrian
Scrumdown
HammerofThunor
doctornickolas
Stone Motif
mikey_philVIII
Cardiff Dave
maestegmafia
formerly known as Sam
MonkeyOwain12
thebluesmancometh
doddieman
123456789
wales606
18 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
WRU Central Contracts
The WRU want to meet regarding central contracts. The have been 2 reasons that the regions have rejected central contracts in the past.
- The WRU didn't bring more money to the table, instead they wanted to use the £6 millions in top ups to contract the players.
- The regions have a objection to complete WRU control of regional players, deciding which region they play for and what games they play.
The only way I can see this working is if the contracts are 50/50 (or perhaps a 75/25 slip for top players and 25/75 for borderline players) and the WRU bring about £1million more to the negotiating table. The WRU uses £3 million to 50% centrally contract the top 30 players in Wales (£100,000 average per player from the WRU would provide a lot extra for players like Adam Jones)
This leaves £4 million still to be split between the regions (a £500,000 decrease), which would probably only disadvantage the Dragons, but would help them keep Faletau.
Large Contracts (around 150,000/50,000 split)
Cardiff Blues
Alex Cuthbert
Leigh Halfpenny
Gethin Jenkins
Sam Warburton
Ospreys
Adam Jones
Alun Wyn Jones
Ian Evans
Ryan Jones
Dan Biggar
Justin Tipuric
Scarlets
Jonathan Davies
George North
Ken Owens
Dragons
Dan Lydiate (?)
Toby Faletau
Total Players : 15
Total WRU cost : £2.25 million
Medium Contract (say around 75,000/75,000 split)
Blues
Scott Andrews
Bradley Davies
Lloyd Williams
Ospreys
Ashley Beck
Rhys Webb
Richard Hibbard
Ryan Bevington
Scarlets
Aaron Shingler
Liam Williams
Rhys Preistland
Total Players : 10
Total WRU cost : £0.75 million
Small/Development Contracts (say 25,000/50,000 split)
Blues
Josh Navidi
Rhys Patchell
Scarlets
Adam Warren
Gareth Davies
Dragons
Andrew Coombes
Total players : 5
WRU cost : £150,000
Total Cost WRU : £3.15 millions
Money to the Blues : £875,000
Money to the Ospreys : £1,200,000
Money to the Scarlets : £725,000
Money to the Dragons : £325,000
- The WRU didn't bring more money to the table, instead they wanted to use the £6 millions in top ups to contract the players.
- The regions have a objection to complete WRU control of regional players, deciding which region they play for and what games they play.
The only way I can see this working is if the contracts are 50/50 (or perhaps a 75/25 slip for top players and 25/75 for borderline players) and the WRU bring about £1million more to the negotiating table. The WRU uses £3 million to 50% centrally contract the top 30 players in Wales (£100,000 average per player from the WRU would provide a lot extra for players like Adam Jones)
This leaves £4 million still to be split between the regions (a £500,000 decrease), which would probably only disadvantage the Dragons, but would help them keep Faletau.
Large Contracts (around 150,000/50,000 split)
Cardiff Blues
Alex Cuthbert
Leigh Halfpenny
Gethin Jenkins
Sam Warburton
Ospreys
Adam Jones
Alun Wyn Jones
Ian Evans
Ryan Jones
Dan Biggar
Justin Tipuric
Scarlets
Jonathan Davies
George North
Ken Owens
Dragons
Dan Lydiate (?)
Toby Faletau
Total Players : 15
Total WRU cost : £2.25 million
Medium Contract (say around 75,000/75,000 split)
Blues
Scott Andrews
Bradley Davies
Lloyd Williams
Ospreys
Ashley Beck
Rhys Webb
Richard Hibbard
Ryan Bevington
Scarlets
Aaron Shingler
Liam Williams
Rhys Preistland
Total Players : 10
Total WRU cost : £0.75 million
Small/Development Contracts (say 25,000/50,000 split)
Blues
Josh Navidi
Rhys Patchell
Scarlets
Adam Warren
Gareth Davies
Dragons
Andrew Coombes
Total players : 5
WRU cost : £150,000
Total Cost WRU : £3.15 millions
Money to the Blues : £875,000
Money to the Ospreys : £1,200,000
Money to the Scarlets : £725,000
Money to the Dragons : £325,000
wales606- Posts : 10728
Join date : 2011-03-04
Re: WRU Central Contracts
The contracts would have to be worked out on an individual basing.
For example, Dan Biggar has only just broken onto the international scene, however, he is worth a lot to the Ospreys and is recognised throughout Europe as a quality club flyhalf - therefore, he will require a large contract, but the WRU might want the Ospreys to finance a larger part of it, while making it feasible to keep him in Wales
For example, Dan Biggar has only just broken onto the international scene, however, he is worth a lot to the Ospreys and is recognised throughout Europe as a quality club flyhalf - therefore, he will require a large contract, but the WRU might want the Ospreys to finance a larger part of it, while making it feasible to keep him in Wales
wales606- Posts : 10728
Join date : 2011-03-04
Re: WRU Central Contracts
I would suggest that they look at the maximum the region can pay compared to the French and make up the difference.
123456789- Posts : 1841
Join date : 2011-11-13
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Make academy players sign a 7 year contract when they turn 18 to stay in wales. Welsh academies have got them that far and are responsible for their development and ability to go on and negotiate a fat cat contract in france so they should repay the training and development put into them by the regions/wru with some years of servitude. I've no problem with players in the later years of their game going abroad and developing further but b4 25 I think they belong in wales.
doddieman- Posts : 93
Join date : 2013-01-27
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Youve hit the 2 big nails on the head Wales...
With regards to the financial arrangement, it was a feign by the WRU to restructure funding with the intention of signing the best players to the WRU. There is no incentive here for the regions to do so!!
Regarding player controll, I would have no problem with international players being placed where the governing body deems best, however I wouldn't trust the WRU as far as I could throw them, and the Scarlets and Dragons would be very wary if Lewis keeps eluding to reducing the regions to 2 or 3.
Central contracts are such an easy thing to impliment, and would do every aspect of Welsh rugby good IMHO, but the WRU find a way to botch even the easiest and most positive initiatives!!
With regards to the financial arrangement, it was a feign by the WRU to restructure funding with the intention of signing the best players to the WRU. There is no incentive here for the regions to do so!!
Regarding player controll, I would have no problem with international players being placed where the governing body deems best, however I wouldn't trust the WRU as far as I could throw them, and the Scarlets and Dragons would be very wary if Lewis keeps eluding to reducing the regions to 2 or 3.
Central contracts are such an easy thing to impliment, and would do every aspect of Welsh rugby good IMHO, but the WRU find a way to botch even the easiest and most positive initiatives!!
thebluesmancometh- Posts : 8358
Join date : 2011-05-04
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Doddieman, are you serious?!? How on earth can you "force"a player in to a 7year contract...talk about driving players away.
It's got to be about making it an attractive option to stay in Wales. Which will mean; a good wage (not the same as some of French contracts, nowhere near sustainable), good facilities to train in, good coaches, good players to play with, good competition and excellent medical support. Each Welsh player with a personalised pathway on how they could reach international level. On top of that the option of some benefits would be good.
I wonder if the WRU and regions have even asked the players and coaches what they want? What would they want to see changed in order to stay... Seems common sense to me to get their insight.
Some players will always go, for example, I don't see how anyone could begrudge Jamie Roberts a year or two in Paris. If I was offered a pay rise to live in Paris...I'd take it.
It's got to be about making it an attractive option to stay in Wales. Which will mean; a good wage (not the same as some of French contracts, nowhere near sustainable), good facilities to train in, good coaches, good players to play with, good competition and excellent medical support. Each Welsh player with a personalised pathway on how they could reach international level. On top of that the option of some benefits would be good.
I wonder if the WRU and regions have even asked the players and coaches what they want? What would they want to see changed in order to stay... Seems common sense to me to get their insight.
Some players will always go, for example, I don't see how anyone could begrudge Jamie Roberts a year or two in Paris. If I was offered a pay rise to live in Paris...I'd take it.
MonkeyOwain12- Posts : 162
Join date : 2011-04-29
Location : Sydney
Re: WRU Central Contracts
You'd need a payrise to live in Paris.
Wouldn't an EPS style arrangement work best where the WRU announce an elite player squad and then pay the clubs for additional access to these players. English players in the EPS are worth 100k of compensation. Would that suit both parties on top of the current funding streams?
Wouldn't an EPS style arrangement work best where the WRU announce an elite player squad and then pay the clubs for additional access to these players. English players in the EPS are worth 100k of compensation. Would that suit both parties on top of the current funding streams?
formerly known as Sam- Posts : 21241
Join date : 2011-07-13
Age : 37
Location : Leicestershire
Re: WRU Central Contracts
doddieman wrote:Make academy players sign a 7 year contract when they turn 18 to stay in wales. Welsh academies have got them that far and are responsible for their development and ability to go on and negotiate a fat cat contract in france so they should repay the training and development put into them by the regions/wru with some years of servitude. I've no problem with players in the later years of their game going abroad and developing further but b4 25 I think they belong in wales.
I agree
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
doddieman wrote:Make academy players sign a 7 year contract when they turn 18 to stay in wales. Welsh academies have got them that far and are responsible for their development and ability to go on and negotiate a fat cat contract in france so they should repay the training and development put into them by the regions/wru with some years of servitude. I've no problem with players in the later years of their game going abroad and developing further but b4 25 I think they belong in wales.
Crikey moses!
Cardiff Dave- Posts : 6596
Join date : 2011-11-29
Location : Cardiff reejun
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Only semi serious really but its a good theory. Aside from the odd George north, at 18 a semi developed player can choose to receive the training and facilities on offer from the academies and wru to become potentially elite rugby players in return for their services should they be required for a period of time say until 25 perhaps. Otherwise they can return home to play for their local club with best wishes for the future. Fair deal I think.
If you look at young player development as an investment its not unfair to expect the player to offer a return on that investment otherwise the player can simply take that investment and leave for greener hills and the region is left with nothing. Is that fair?
If you look at young player development as an investment its not unfair to expect the player to offer a return on that investment otherwise the player can simply take that investment and leave for greener hills and the region is left with nothing. Is that fair?
doddieman- Posts : 93
Join date : 2013-01-27
Re: WRU Central Contracts
doddieman wrote:Only semi serious really but its a good theory. Aside from the odd George north, at 18 a semi developed player can choose to receive the training and facilities on offer from the academies and wru to become potentially elite rugby players in return for their services should they be required for a period of time say until 25 perhaps. Otherwise they can return home to play for their local club with best wishes for the future. Fair deal I think.
If you look at young player development as an investment its not unfair to expect the player to offer a return on that investment otherwise the player can simply take that investment and leave for greener hills and the region is left with nothing. Is that fair?
Doddie I said something similar on one of the other threads meandering around this debate. I think players should agree an academy contract that lasts until the season they turn 25.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Obviously Wales606 you should take Roger Lewis' place. I can't see Hibbard being happy about that contract though, same with some others on and off your list. Hence more issues.
mikey_philVIII- Posts : 343
Join date : 2012-09-28
Location : Bristol.
Re: WRU Central Contracts
maestegmafia wrote:doddieman wrote:Only semi serious really but its a good theory. Aside from the odd George north, at 18 a semi developed player can choose to receive the training and facilities on offer from the academies and wru to become potentially elite rugby players in return for their services should they be required for a period of time say until 25 perhaps. Otherwise they can return home to play for their local club with best wishes for the future. Fair deal I think.
If you look at young player development as an investment its not unfair to expect the player to offer a return on that investment otherwise the player can simply take that investment and leave for greener hills and the region is left with nothing. Is that fair?
Doddie I said something similar on one of the other threads meandering around this debate. I think players should agree an academy contract that lasts until the season they turn 25.
Is 25 the magic number? For props and pretty backs?
Cardiff Dave- Posts : 6596
Join date : 2011-11-29
Location : Cardiff reejun
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Then if 2 of us agree it must be an awesome plan!
doddieman- Posts : 93
Join date : 2013-01-27
Re: WRU Central Contracts
You would have a pretty good idea whether a prop is going to become established or not by 25. I think Dan Cole is around that age.Cardiff Dave wrote:Is 25 the magic number? For props and pretty backs?
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
maestegmafia wrote:You would have a pretty good idea whether a prop is going to become established or not by 25. I think Dan Cole is around that age.Cardiff Dave wrote:Is 25 the magic number? For props and pretty backs?
Yep, but how many others would fail well before the age of 25 who happened to be on generous 7 year contracts?
Cardiff Dave- Posts : 6596
Join date : 2011-11-29
Location : Cardiff reejun
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Cardiff Dave wrote:maestegmafia wrote:You would have a pretty good idea whether a prop is going to become established or not by 25. I think Dan Cole is around that age.Cardiff Dave wrote:Is 25 the magic number? For props and pretty backs?
Yep, but how many others would fail well before the age of 25 who happened to be on generous 7 year contracts?
I guess a get out clause for both parties would be fair, the player may not want it, the Region may think the player doesn't have the right attitude. There are plenty of reasons I suppose. There are already contract cancelling agreements at regions over prolonged injury.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
The whole issue is irrelevant a. Because what was revealed of the PWC report stated that central contracts were pie in the sky Roger bullshite and b. It condemns the regions forever to the role of battery hens. Nonsense. This needs to be about giving the regions the space and freedom to grow not about restricting them further.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Stone Motif wrote:The whole issue is irrelevant a. Because what was revealed of the PWC report stated that central contracts were pie in the sky Roger bullshite and b. It condemns the regions forever to the role of battery hens. Nonsense. This needs to be about giving the regions the space and freedom to grow not about restricting them further.
They have had that for a decade and they cocked it up, got themselves into huge debt and now they are constantly not only begging for money but trying to bite the hand that feeds them.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Release Cardiff from this regional charade and let them go on their way.
Let them be Cardiff FFS and let's stop the pretending regional rubbish.
Let them be Cardiff FFS and let's stop the pretending regional rubbish.
Cardiff Dave- Posts : 6596
Join date : 2011-11-29
Location : Cardiff reejun
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Cardiff Dave wrote:Release Cardiff from this regional charade and let them go on their way.
Let them be Cardiff FFS and let's stop the pretending regional rubbish.
Would it make any difference.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
maestegmafia wrote:Cardiff Dave wrote:Release Cardiff from this regional charade and let them go on their way.
Let them be Cardiff FFS and let's stop the pretending regional rubbish.
Would it make any difference.
I reckon Yes and 10 years of pretend regionalism clearly haven't worked down our way.
Cardiff Dave- Posts : 6596
Join date : 2011-11-29
Location : Cardiff reejun
Re: WRU Central Contracts
laughable self delusion. Who negotiates the tv deals for starters, the one that gives blanket coverage of pro 12 rugby away for next to ffwc all to terrestrial tv, all the while claiming said pittance is some sort of gift to the pro teams that earn it? You take obtuse to a whole new level.maestegmafia wrote:Stone Motif wrote:The whole issue is irrelevant a. Because what was revealed of the PWC report stated that central contracts were pie in the sky Roger bullshite and b. It condemns the regions forever to the role of battery hens. Nonsense. This needs to be about giving the regions the space and freedom to grow not about restricting them further.
They have had that for a decade and they cocked it up, got themselves into huge debt and now they are constantly not only begging for money but trying to bite the hand that feeds them.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
So your saying that if the Regions are given more money, so they can but more players they'll win more?
It won't.
It will just mean that France and England will raise the bar and pay more off players and we will have lost more money.
The TV deal is a very tricky area. The WRU agreed not to sell off Rugby to the satalite/cable companies. that was the wish of the welsh public who wanted their sport to be accessible.
Now that other countries are talking about massive TV deals everyone's changed their minds.
It won't.
It will just mean that France and England will raise the bar and pay more off players and we will have lost more money.
The TV deal is a very tricky area. The WRU agreed not to sell off Rugby to the satalite/cable companies. that was the wish of the welsh public who wanted their sport to be accessible.
Now that other countries are talking about massive TV deals everyone's changed their minds.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
If the regions are handed more money they will just spend it on Italian scrum halves, fat Fijian props or useless SA rejects. I don't trust them at all.
Every time an agreement is signed for funding everyone is happy and then 5 minutes later the regions plead poverty because they have spent it all.
Usually on the regions side of the deal theya re supposed to reduce the numkber of foreign players but that never happens at all. By now we are supposed to be down to just a handful but they keep fudging the issue by signing average foreigners on 3 year deals who would "really love to qualify to play for Wales". It's nonsense, and then they let all our best players leave.
The regions are run by an amateur mindset, the same people who made a mess of club rugby through incompetence.
The Australians used to have a saying about NZ'ers. If you want to set a Kiwi up in a small business then set him up with a big one and just wait. The same applies to these idiots. They have had 10 years to get this right and all of them have failed.
Giving the regiosn more money is just throwing more good money after bad and I totally understand the WRU's reluctance to do so.
A new agreement is due in 2 years. I don't expect all the regiosn to still be around by then.
Every time an agreement is signed for funding everyone is happy and then 5 minutes later the regions plead poverty because they have spent it all.
Usually on the regions side of the deal theya re supposed to reduce the numkber of foreign players but that never happens at all. By now we are supposed to be down to just a handful but they keep fudging the issue by signing average foreigners on 3 year deals who would "really love to qualify to play for Wales". It's nonsense, and then they let all our best players leave.
The regions are run by an amateur mindset, the same people who made a mess of club rugby through incompetence.
The Australians used to have a saying about NZ'ers. If you want to set a Kiwi up in a small business then set him up with a big one and just wait. The same applies to these idiots. They have had 10 years to get this right and all of them have failed.
Giving the regiosn more money is just throwing more good money after bad and I totally understand the WRU's reluctance to do so.
A new agreement is due in 2 years. I don't expect all the regiosn to still be around by then.
doctornickolas- Posts : 813
Join date : 2011-05-31
Location : Penarth
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Stone Motif wrote:laughable self delusion. Who negotiates the tv deals for starters, the one that gives blanket coverage of pro 12 rugby away for next to ffwc all to terrestrial tv, all the while claiming said pittance is some sort of gift to the pro teams that earn it? You take obtuse to a whole new level.maestegmafia wrote:Stone Motif wrote:The whole issue is irrelevant a. Because what was revealed of the PWC report stated that central contracts were pie in the sky Roger bullshite and b. It condemns the regions forever to the role of battery hens. Nonsense. This needs to be about giving the regions the space and freedom to grow not about restricting them further.
They have had that for a decade and they cocked it up, got themselves into huge debt and now they are constantly not only begging for money but trying to bite the hand that feeds them.
BBC wales and S4C are the only ones interested in showing it so how much of a deal do you think you can negotiate with one bidder, with a restricted budget for a viewing audience that will be in the tens of thousands not millions? The money negotiated is actually very good given the situation.
doctornickolas- Posts : 813
Join date : 2011-05-31
Location : Penarth
Re: WRU Central Contracts
I'm not saying anything of the sort, but then I haven't got a willingness to swallow Chairman Wodge's lies like you have. The ones who are making this solely about player wages are the WRU. More money might allow the regions to operate sustainably as businesses by increasing the effectiveness of the academies the WRU currently grossly underfund and rely on private individuals to finance, for example. If you do want to paint it purely as competing with French wages, it would almost certainly have helped to keep George North and the like who refused to go to France.maestegmafia wrote:So your saying that if the Regions are given more money, so they can but more players they'll win more?
It won't.
It will just mean that France and England will raise the bar and pay more off players and we will have lost more money.
The TV deal is a very tricky area. The WRU agreed not to sell off Rugby to the satalite/cable companies. that was the wish of the welsh public who wanted their sport to be accessible.
Now that other countries are talking about massive TV deals everyone's changed their minds.
What non-point you're trying to make about the Welsh rugby public having the sport be accessible is anybody's guess. It's now so accessible people don't bother to go to games anymore, yay Rog.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Said fat Fijians are almost certainly less of a liability than a Welsh player though. Even apart from the fact most regions have an all-Welsh qualified team out for most fixtures, the WRU don't fund the academies properly, created an artificial value hike on WQ players via the participation agreement (which I fully agree the regions were daft to sign up to, but maybe just desperate), and if they're any good they ransom them for a pittance and run them into the ground playing pointless internationals.doctornickolas wrote:If the regions are handed more money they will just spend it on Italian scrum halves, fat Fijian props or useless SA rejects. I don't trust them at all.
Every time an agreement is signed for funding everyone is happy and then 5 minutes later the regions plead poverty because they have spent it all.
Usually on the regions side of the deal theya re supposed to reduce the numkber of foreign players but that never happens at all. By now we are supposed to be down to just a handful but they keep fudging the issue by signing average foreigners on 3 year deals who would "really love to qualify to play for Wales". It's nonsense, and then they let all our best players leave.
The regions are run by an amateur mindset, the same people who made a mess of club rugby through incompetence.
The Australians used to have a saying about NZ'ers. If you want to set a Kiwi up in a small business then set him up with a big one and just wait. The same applies to these idiots. They have had 10 years to get this right and all of them have failed.
Giving the regiosn more money is just throwing more good money after bad and I totally understand the WRU's reluctance to do so.
A new agreement is due in 2 years. I don't expect all the regiosn to still be around by then.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
How do you know no-one else would be interested? The point is the regions aren't able to try and negotiate a better deal, which is just one example among many of the regions not being allowed to grow as businesses. Admittedly the Poopie league doesn't help but it could be sold better. And regardless of what you think the product is worth, given that the WRU don't directly fund the regions a tuppence it is not enough and needs to increase just to put the pro teams on a level footing with their competitors. That's before we get into the effect of free wall to wall coverage free to potential customers free to watch at home, and the ridiculous kick-off times it helps generate.doctornickolas wrote:
BBC wales and S4C are the only ones interested in showing it so how much of a deal do you think you can negotiate with one bidder, with a restricted budget for a viewing audience that will be in the tens of thousands not millions? The money negotiated is actually very good given the situation.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Stone motif your posts are full of supposition and gossip and no hard fact.
Find some adequate proof of your claims
1). That although the WRU fund the regions they are also being funded to a greater extent by private investors...?
2). Provide any evidence that a TV deal from a wealthy sports provider has shown any interest in covering Wales Regions in RP12 comps.
Find some adequate proof of your claims
1). That although the WRU fund the regions they are also being funded to a greater extent by private investors...?
2). Provide any evidence that a TV deal from a wealthy sports provider has shown any interest in covering Wales Regions in RP12 comps.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Wasn't there an article on here that Sky were looking a picking up the PRO12?
7 year contracts would be pretty harsh. Even now some players (Cuthbert and supposedly Lydiate) are on very small salaries due to longish contracts. Either you have get out clauses for both sides (what's the point then?) or you have graded salaries over time, which is still a problem...right? If it wasn't a large increase it would make those French contracts all the more enticing for the reasonbly experienced 25 year olds flooding the market.
Having central contracts AND keeping the £6M for player release was wishful thinking from the Regions. If Central contracts are an objective the whole funding structure needs to be reviewed. I don't think it's very clear (I'm not much of one for finances) in the WRU annual report, how much they get from TV and sponsorship for the Pro12 and ERC and how much this makes up the £9M they give the Regions (not including the £6M for additional player release).
7 year contracts would be pretty harsh. Even now some players (Cuthbert and supposedly Lydiate) are on very small salaries due to longish contracts. Either you have get out clauses for both sides (what's the point then?) or you have graded salaries over time, which is still a problem...right? If it wasn't a large increase it would make those French contracts all the more enticing for the reasonbly experienced 25 year olds flooding the market.
Having central contracts AND keeping the £6M for player release was wishful thinking from the Regions. If Central contracts are an objective the whole funding structure needs to be reviewed. I don't think it's very clear (I'm not much of one for finances) in the WRU annual report, how much they get from TV and sponsorship for the Pro12 and ERC and how much this makes up the £9M they give the Regions (not including the £6M for additional player release).
HammerofThunor- Posts : 10471
Join date : 2011-01-29
Location : Hull, England - Originally Potteries
Re: WRU Central Contracts
maestegmafia wrote:Stone motif your posts are full of supposition and gossip and no hard fact.
Find some adequate proof of your claims
1). That although the WRU fund the regions they are also being funded to a greater extent by private investors...?
2). Provide any evidence that a TV deal from a wealthy sports provider has shown any interest in covering Wales Regions in RP12 omps.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
maestegmafia wrote:Stone motif your posts are full of supposition and gossip and no hard fact.
Find some adequate proof of your claims
1). That although the WRU fund the regions they are also being funded to a greater extent by private investors...?
2). Provide any evidence that a TV deal from a wealthy sports provider has shown any interest in covering Wales Regions in RP12 comps.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Your posts are little more than the usual pseudo-religious twaddle adhered to by Team Wales fetishists who refuse to countenance any criticism of the Church of Rog. 1. Documented in virtually every article on the subject, saliently the one's originating within your own region. The vast majority of the regional incomes are tv, benefactor and competition based, therefore generated directly from the investments of private individuals. 2. Spectacular missing of point which happens to be that they need the freedom to explore this given the WRU want to rip them off.maestegmafia wrote:Stone motif your posts are full of supposition and gossip and no hard fact.
Find some adequate proof of your claims
1). That although the WRU fund the regions they are also being funded to a greater extent by private investors...?
2). Provide any evidence that a TV deal from a wealthy sports provider has shown any interest in covering Wales Regions in RP12 comps.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Stone Motif wrote:Your posts are little more than the usual pseudo-religious twaddle adhered to by Team Wales fetishists who refuse to countenance any criticism of the Church of Rog. 1. Documented in virtually every article on the subject, saliently the one's originating within your own region. The vast majority of the regional incomes are tv, benefactor and competition based, therefore generated directly from the investments of private individuals. 2. Spectacular missing of point which happens to be that they need the freedom to explore this given the WRU want to rip them off.maestegmafia wrote:Stone motif your posts are full of supposition and gossip and no hard fact.
Find some adequate proof of your claims
1). That although the WRU fund the regions they are also being funded to a greater extent by private investors...?
2). Provide any evidence that a TV deal from a wealthy sports provider has shown any interest in covering Wales Regions in RP12 comps.
No links then?
Just insults
Patethic
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
MM
Stone makes valid points though, you seem to think the WRU's funding is from the WRU's back pocket, where as in reality a large chunk of it is TV and particiapation money re distributed to the regions in the disguise of funding!!
Oh and can you please change your name to Stones comment below please...
'pseudo-religious twaddle adhered to by Team Wales fetishists who refuse to countenance any criticism of the Church of Rog'
Stone makes valid points though, you seem to think the WRU's funding is from the WRU's back pocket, where as in reality a large chunk of it is TV and particiapation money re distributed to the regions in the disguise of funding!!
Oh and can you please change your name to Stones comment below please...
'pseudo-religious twaddle adhered to by Team Wales fetishists who refuse to countenance any criticism of the Church of Rog'
thebluesmancometh- Posts : 8358
Join date : 2011-05-04
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Regarding the £15million WRU re directs to Regions each year, this money would be available whomever owns the regions i.e. bbc does not pay for tv rights to screen regional rugby because Peter Thomas owns Cardiff Blues. That money would be available if WRU owned the regions too.
They key point is that the WRU needs to direct the £15million towards the regions who have proven that they have the ability to make good decisions and achieve results. In this way, a poorly performing region is forced to improve and change as if it doesn't change then it will continue to receive less funding and the owner will have no choice but to sell up or continue to incurr losses.
Current owners have it too easy. P Thomas and co are being given £15million per year to spend as they wish with no questions asked.
And some fans are pleading with Roger Lewis to give these individuals and the regions they own even more money despite the criticism their management received in the PWC report.
They key point is that the WRU needs to direct the £15million towards the regions who have proven that they have the ability to make good decisions and achieve results. In this way, a poorly performing region is forced to improve and change as if it doesn't change then it will continue to receive less funding and the owner will have no choice but to sell up or continue to incurr losses.
Current owners have it too easy. P Thomas and co are being given £15million per year to spend as they wish with no questions asked.
And some fans are pleading with Roger Lewis to give these individuals and the regions they own even more money despite the criticism their management received in the PWC report.
Scrumdown- Posts : 455
Join date : 2012-05-07
Re: WRU Central Contracts
thebluesmancometh wrote:MM
Stone makes valid points though, you seem to think the WRU's funding is from the WRU's back pocket, where as in reality a large chunk of it is TV and particiapation money re distributed to the regions in the disguise of funding!!
Not really.
The WRU give the regions what they are entitled to, on top of that is extra. The Regions are asking the WRU for more money because they don't have any, not for a larger share of an entitlement.
The regions aren't owed anything by the WRU.
What Stone wants is a mock version of the English system but it would be expensive to set up and will leave us in the same situation.
With the prospect of the English clubs becoming the wealthiest in the world by a country mile if this BT deal actually does pay out, France re-negotiating for more and a larger competition, none of us stand a chance, no matter what the WRU gives the Regions.
England's premiership and Frances Top 14 could well be the equivalent of the Spanish and English Soccer leagues in a year or two.
Consider the future a bit more. The WRU aren't the clowns you keep making out, the future could be bloody miserable for Wales if we don't make changes. The regions want to keep it how they have had it for the last ten years, spend spend spend and never be accountable.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
You don't know what I want because you can't take your Team Wales daffodil hat out the way of your eyes for five minutes to read a post. It is only about money as long as the WRU politburo frame it in those terms. Were the regions allowed to run themselves as businesses they may be able to generate the funds required themselves. They aren't because of the governing body's meddling, so yes absolutely the WRU are the ones who should step in, as this broken system is so heavily weighted towards their success and that of the national team, at the expense of the regions own success and sustainability.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Wrong. The key point is that the money the regions are able to earn - again for the hard of thinking the WRU hardly contribute anything - is insufficient to generate any meaningful progress, so any 'performance' (i.e. how much of a shafting they get from the union) remains linked to how much benefactors are willing to throw down the black hole of no reward. You seem to have the usual chippy Welsh trait of automatically assuming anyone with money got it by being more of a fool than you appear to be. Imaginary premises like the WRU running the regions are nonsense, they can't afford it and we'd end up with four Newport Gwent Dragons run on a shoestring.Scrumdown wrote:Regarding the £15million WRU re directs to Regions each year, this money would be available whomever owns the regions i.e. bbc does not pay for tv rights to screen regional rugby because Peter Thomas owns Cardiff Blues. That money would be available if WRU owned the regions too.
They key point is that the WRU needs to direct the £15million towards the regions who have proven that they have the ability to make good decisions and achieve results. In this way, a poorly performing region is forced to improve and change as if it doesn't change then it will continue to receive less funding and the owner will have no choice but to sell up or continue to incurr losses.
Current owners have it too easy. P Thomas and co are being given £15million per year to spend as they wish with no questions asked.
And some fans are pleading with Roger Lewis to give these individuals and the regions they own even more money despite the criticism their management received in the PWC report.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
http://www.walesonline.co.uk/rugbynation/rugby-news/2013/04/04/analysis-stats-show-central-contracts-could-be-way-forward-for-welsh-rugby-91466-33112439/
Interesting stats
What a surprise, the 3 players who have played for Wales more times than their region are all from the Blues. No wonder PT gets so annoyed on the issue.
The Ospreys are very good at getting the most out of their internationals
Interesting stats
What a surprise, the 3 players who have played for Wales more times than their region are all from the Blues. No wonder PT gets so annoyed on the issue.
The Ospreys are very good at getting the most out of their internationals
wales606- Posts : 10728
Join date : 2011-03-04
Re: WRU Central Contracts
"If they were on an annual salary of, say, £150,000 it would equate to Roberts being paid £20,000 per game, Halfpenny approximately £15,000 and Warburton about £13,000."
and i'm pretty sure Roberts is on more than £150k - no wonder no Blues supporter I have spoken to is disappointed he is leaving the region. 15 games in 2 years - and I remember him going off injured pretty early on in at least 3 of those games
and i'm pretty sure Roberts is on more than £150k - no wonder no Blues supporter I have spoken to is disappointed he is leaving the region. 15 games in 2 years - and I remember him going off injured pretty early on in at least 3 of those games
wales606- Posts : 10728
Join date : 2011-03-04
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Did you know when there is a big news story in Wales, Grandslam or controversial Regional matters the sales figures for the Western Mail can almost double. THey more than Double if we win a Grandslam/Six Nations championship, and can increase by a quarter when a controversial debate is happening within the regions.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Could WRU also sell naming rights to the millenium stadium in order to finance central contracts.
Could be worth at least £5million a year.
Could be worth at least £5million a year.
Scrumdown- Posts : 455
Join date : 2012-05-07
Re: WRU Central Contracts
'The Roger Lewis Megadrome.'
It has a ring to it.
It has a ring to it.
Luckless Pedestrian- Posts : 24898
Join date : 2011-02-01
Age : 45
Location : Newport
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Another Rogering;
http://www.southwalesargus.co.uk/sport/10331321.CHRIS_KIRWAN_SAYS__Schism_between_WRU_and_regions_increasing/
http://www.southwalesargus.co.uk/sport/10331321.CHRIS_KIRWAN_SAYS__Schism_between_WRU_and_regions_increasing/
Cardiff Dave- Posts : 6596
Join date : 2011-11-29
Location : Cardiff reejun
Re: WRU Central Contracts
I heard he likes 'The Rogia Sophia'Luckless Pedestrian wrote:'The Roger Lewis Megadrome.'
It has a ring to it.
Stone Motif- Posts : 3141
Join date : 2012-03-26
Location : Gwent Region
Re: WRU Central Contracts
So what do you guys think about the rumours suggesting that the WRU are looking to contact National Academy players and Regional Coaches...???
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Contacting them with a view to what?
Luckless Pedestrian- Posts : 24898
Join date : 2011-02-01
Age : 45
Location : Newport
Re: WRU Central Contracts
Contracting them to the WRU.Luckless Pedestrian wrote:Contacting them with a view to what?
I heard this earlier that apparently this is one of the proposals.
The WRU take all National Academy players and will contract some of the the Regional Coaches.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» PCA want new-look central contracts
» Irish Central Contracts
» Let's talk about Central Contracts
» What's the latest on WRU Central Contracts?
» A problem with central contracts...
» Irish Central Contracts
» Let's talk about Central Contracts
» What's the latest on WRU Central Contracts?
» A problem with central contracts...
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|