[solved]Mafia- The return of Bullsack Holmes

Nando

Yeah I'm playing

Gonna make it hard baby.

3 townies
1 doctor
1 cop
1 mafia roleblocker

PMs should have been sent.

Let's do this.

take the doctor out

Right let's think about this before we all rush in a take one of our own out

I don't think Viva has thought that vote through.

Doctor makes it too easy

GSC wrote:take the doctor out

Thought about it but 2 role players and 4 townies isn't much fun. The watcher's a role for 7 player games IMO. I put in the roleblocker.

Doctor makes it pretty formulaic though

cherriesfna wrote:vote afro

That's all you did last game when you were mafia. You're now suspicious looking.

What's the most logical thing to do?

GSC - does the fact that the mafia is also a role blocker have any impact on how we should vote? I'm thinking it doesn't but the fact that he will get to kill and block at night time has some impact.

Why haven't I?

Afro it's pure guessing at this time, I'd take the chance now because we're definitely going to lose someone at night.

GSC wrote:Doctor makes it pretty formulaic though

Let's do this game and worry about changing it next time around.

He would prevent the cop from investigating anyone, so the cop shouldn't out unless he finds the mafia.

We are people, we fear, let's kill sle one, I'm a townie so obvious they wouldn't trust me with big boy role again yo

VivaPaulScholes wrote:Why haven't I?

Afro it's pure guessing at this time, I'd take the chance now because we're definitely going to lose someone at night.

Azzy isn't playing, dude.

Azzy isn't playing Viva.

With 6 players no lynch still makes mathematical sense.

Vote cherries

Too suspicious.

VivaPaulScholes wrote:Why haven't I?

Afro it's pure guessing at this time, I'd take the chance now because we're definitely going to lose someone at night.

It is pure guessing, but in normal 6 player games. no lynching works first time because it gives the cop and doc a chance overnight, with only risking losing one player. Because they can be blocked makes a difference, but I can't quite work out how much

U killme u kill an innocent homie

GSC wrote:Azzy isn't playing Viva.

With 6 players no lynch still makes mathematical sense.

But the chance of him killing or blocking the cop/doc at night time just doubled

Changes nothing atm.

Afro wrote:

VivaPaulScholes wrote:Why haven't I?

Afro it's pure guessing at this time, I'd take the chance now because we're definitely going to lose someone at night.

It is pure guessing, but in normal 6 player games. no lynching works first time because it gives the cop and doc a chance overnight, with only risking losing one player. Because they can be blocked makes a difference, but I can't quite work out how much

Well if we kill both then the chance of having our only role player blocked is heightened greatly.

If we take two into the night only one could be blocked.

Vote Cherries

No lynching is still the smart option

U really kill me, I'm so innocent yo,

It's almost 90% that one of the cop or doc get blocked or killed

I'd vote no lynch but I just want to lynch cherries.

Afro (1) - cherries
cherries (1) - Viva

But for the good of #TeamTownie

I'm going

Vote No Lynch

Vote: Viva

PS. Im having technical issues here but i wouldn't kill me off i was you, You need me like Viva needs his United onesie at night to get to sleep.

Vote cherries

No other reason than it is the popular vote atm

Afro (1) - cherries
cherries (2) - Viva, Afro
No lynch (2) - sodhat, GSC
Viva(1) - nando

or was the popular vote...

Logic does say no lynching I think..

Vote no lynching

No lynching it is. Nighty time please (by that I mean get your nighties on!!)

I won't tell role players that they've been blocked.

The Special Juan wrote:No lynching it is.  Nighty time please (by that I mean get your nighties on!!)

I haven't gotten out of my nightie.

Presumably you'd have to tell the cop if he was blocked as you'd not be telling him the outcome of his investigation

Afro wrote:Presumably you'd have to tell the cop if he was blocked as you'd not be telling him the outcome of his investigation

Yeah that dawned on me as soon as I hit post

It'd be obvious anyway though.

Dawn breaks to find GSC in the local river wearing a pair of concrete boots and a Colombian necktie.

Go!

What was he, townie, doc, cop?

sodhat wrote:

The Special Juan wrote:No lynching it is.  Nighty time please (by that I mean get your nighties on!!)

I haven't gotten out of my nightie.

 
 
 

Spoiler: