Worst value club players of all time

Ok to we all know some players have a terrible match record for clubs they sign for. But who historically to date including only club history are the worst value players of all time.

I'll kick this one off to start with Manu Tuilagi. 139 club matches since 2009. That gives him around a average of 10.6 Games per season. Granted his early career he wasn't on big money but by 22 he was banking in excess of 400K per year. That means he essentially was being paid 37.7K per match since 22 at club level. That is a higher per match fee than England pay for international matches. Reckon he must rank in the worst value top 10 players since the game went professional.

Feel free to add similar nominations but keep in mind we are looking at players entire club career to date so will be looking at their entire club history not just based at one club.

Likely RG Snyman, has been at Munster for a couple of seasons and had been on the injury list for the most part of it.

Welshmushroom wrote:Ok to we all know some players have a terrible match record for clubs they sign for.  But who historically to date including only club history are the worst value players of all time.

I'll kick this one off to start with Manu Tuilagi.  139 club matches since 2009.  That gives him around a average of 10.6 Games per season.  Granted his early career he wasn't on big money but by 22 he was banking in excess of 400K per year.  That means he essentially was being paid 37.7K per match since 22 at club level.  That is a higher per match fee than England pay for international matches.  Reckon he must rank in the worst value top 10 players since the game went professional.

Feel free to add similar nominations but keep in mind we are looking at players entire club career to date so will be looking at their entire club history not just based at one club.

Christ I would love it if the Scarlets Welsh internationals played over 10 games a season for us!!

Liam Williams's second stint at the Scarlets has been very disappointing.

Surely Frano Botica wins this game hands down?