Goal Line Technology
+5
SPORT FANTASTIC
asdral225
Legend
Solerina
RocketAce
9 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Football
Page 1 of 1
Should we have it?
Goal Line Technology
Hot topic at the moment ahead of FIFA's meeting next month with several options on the table.
Are you in favour of it, or will it slow the game?
What type of technology would work, and what are the boundaries, just for goals, or including dodgy penalty decisions as well?
Are you in favour of it, or will it slow the game?
What type of technology would work, and what are the boundaries, just for goals, or including dodgy penalty decisions as well?
Guest- Guest
Re: Goal Line Technology
I've voted yes.
I didn't realise they didn't have goal line technology until the disgraceful incident of Frank Lampard's disallowed goal in the World Cup.
It was clear for all to see that the ball went in........why wasn't it looked at by the officials on a replay, at half-time. and the decision reversed.
It seems absolutely ludicrous that in this day and age and with all the technology available that there isn't anything in place to prevent this happening in football.....and at the World Cup too!!!!
We have a photo finish in horse racing.......tennis has Hawk-Eye.......why nothing for football?
That was a good old rant seeing as I couldn't care less about football lol
I was having a general browse of our lovely forum and happened upon this thread ( that sounds rather 'Jane Austen' lol)
Solerina
I didn't realise they didn't have goal line technology until the disgraceful incident of Frank Lampard's disallowed goal in the World Cup.
It was clear for all to see that the ball went in........why wasn't it looked at by the officials on a replay, at half-time. and the decision reversed.
It seems absolutely ludicrous that in this day and age and with all the technology available that there isn't anything in place to prevent this happening in football.....and at the World Cup too!!!!
We have a photo finish in horse racing.......tennis has Hawk-Eye.......why nothing for football?
That was a good old rant seeing as I couldn't care less about football lol
I was having a general browse of our lovely forum and happened upon this thread ( that sounds rather 'Jane Austen' lol)
Solerina
Last edited by Solerina on Tue 01 Mar 2011, 4:45 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : poor spelling!)
Solerina- Posts : 2250
Join date : 2011-01-28
Location : Button Moon
Re: Goal Line Technology
There's no good reasons why not!
Legend- Posts : 3872
Join date : 2011-02-13
Location : No longer behind you
Re: Goal Line Technology
How long would it take to review a incident like the Lampard one, not very long.
An official sitting in the stands looking at incidents like these and just stopping the game through the referee, this fifth official of course must be quick off the mark, the time delay after the incident must be kept to a minimum but look at rugby union how long will a referee play an advantage for.
An official sitting in the stands looking at incidents like these and just stopping the game through the referee, this fifth official of course must be quick off the mark, the time delay after the incident must be kept to a minimum but look at rugby union how long will a referee play an advantage for.
asdral225- Posts : 1281
Join date : 2011-01-26
Age : 64
Location : Hampshire
Re: Goal Line Technology
Definetly. It wouldn't take long to tell whether or not something was over the line; the amount of goals that would/wouldn't have counted if this was already in place is probably huge.
Although if you bring it in for the goal line, do you bring it in for other situations in the 18 yard box e.g. Thierry Henry against Ireland.
Although if you bring it in for the goal line, do you bring it in for other situations in the 18 yard box e.g. Thierry Henry against Ireland.
Guest- Guest
Re: Goal Line Technology
On stopping the game - As the ball will almost certainly stay in play I would not stop play. Can you imagine the furore if the ball bounces back, ref stops play and in the process its kicked into the net then its decided the ball didn't cross the line, managers will complain about anything? As they say football is not a stop start sport like rugby.
The decision has to be decided whlst play continues and relayed to the ref.
I take it these moments will not be allowed to be played on the screen inside the ground, only worded messages, so anyone watching may be kept 'in the dark'.
This may not take as quickly as you think, anyone who watches cricket knows how long it can take for run outs, again deciding whether something crossed the line or not.
The decision has to be decided whlst play continues and relayed to the ref.
I take it these moments will not be allowed to be played on the screen inside the ground, only worded messages, so anyone watching may be kept 'in the dark'.
This may not take as quickly as you think, anyone who watches cricket knows how long it can take for run outs, again deciding whether something crossed the line or not.
SPORT FANTASTIC- Posts : 8
Join date : 2011-02-09
Age : 58
Re: Goal Line Technology
I'd bring it in but limit it to goal-line technology only, no other replays for dodgy incidents like the Henry handball or tackles in the penalty area.
theundisputedY2D2- Posts : 4205
Join date : 2011-01-25
Age : 42
Location : Down By The Clyde, Near The SECC - You Can't Miss It!
Re: Goal Line Technology
Fifa president Sepp Blatter says goal-line technology will be used at the 2014 World Cup in Brazil if a suitable system is approved in time.
Tests of various systems will continue for another year at the insistence of the game's lawmakers, the International Football Association Board (Ifab).
Blatter, speaking after Ifab's annual meeting in Wales said: "If it works there should be no problem for 2014.
"But the tests we have had so far are not conclusive."
10 goal-line systems were judged inadequate after coming under Fifa scrutiny last month and Ifab said further tests would now take place during games.
"We will go on with the technical experiments and then bring back this item to the Ifab meeting next year in London and then a final decision will be taken," concluded Blatter who indicated that three of the systems, which worked using a magnetic field, had a good chance of passing the tests.
Source: BBC Sport Click Here
Tests of various systems will continue for another year at the insistence of the game's lawmakers, the International Football Association Board (Ifab).
Blatter, speaking after Ifab's annual meeting in Wales said: "If it works there should be no problem for 2014.
"But the tests we have had so far are not conclusive."
10 goal-line systems were judged inadequate after coming under Fifa scrutiny last month and Ifab said further tests would now take place during games.
"We will go on with the technical experiments and then bring back this item to the Ifab meeting next year in London and then a final decision will be taken," concluded Blatter who indicated that three of the systems, which worked using a magnetic field, had a good chance of passing the tests.
Source: BBC Sport Click Here
Guest- Guest
Re: Goal Line Technology
Technology to help football officials decide if a goal has gone over the line could be introduced in just 12 months' time following years of resistance.
Continue reading...
Article taken from Sky News iPhone App
Continue reading...
- Spoiler:
- The sport's bosses have decided testing of the gadgetry should be extend for a year after 10 systems failed to meet governing body Fifa's requirements last month.
The International Football Association Board (Ifab) has also banned players from wearing neck-warming snoods from this July.
The announcements were made following an annual meeting of Ifab in Newport, Wales.
It has also approved the use of two additional referees' assistants during games at the 2012 European Championships in Poland and Ukraine.
This follows successful testing with Uefa president Michel Platini's five-official system in the Europa League.
Ifab is a 125-year-old body comprising officials from England, Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales, plus Fifa representing the other 204 football nations and referees, coaches and players worldwide.
Each British member has one vote, Fifa has four and a proposed new rule needs six votes to be passed.
The search is still on for a system that meets Fifa's exacting requirements over goal-line technology.
Last year, Ifab - which makes the rules that govern the game - voted 6-2 against introducing technology that would show if the ball had crossed the goal-line.
But the Frank Lampard goal that a referee missed during England's defeat by Germany in last summer's World Cup has focused minds.
Fifa president Sepp Blatter admitted Lampard's "goal that never was" prompted football's lawmakers to test goal-line gadgetry.
He said after what he called the "immense error" in South Africa it was "time to re-open the discussion on the technology".
Mr Blatter said if any system can meet their strict requirements, it could be introduced in time for the 2014 World Cup in Brazil.
Before the meeting, he told Sky News: "I've never been resistant to anything.
"But it must be done the right way. And that's why we activated again this discussion in the international board.
"And then we will have a look at how it works."
Several of Mr Blatter's colleagues on Fifa's Executive Committee (Exco) - including UK member Geoff Thompson and Asia's representative Mohamed bin Hammam - are in favour of goal-line technology, if it is reliable and relayed swiftly to the referee.
However, tests on 10 systems at Fifa headquarters last month did not identify one that could live up to its requirements.
But news that football chiefs have not dismissed the technology may encourage potential suppliers to redouble their efforts to find a solution.
US Fifa Exco member Chuck Blazer told Sky News: "It's (Fifa's) intention is to go to something that works. So as soon as there's something that works, I think they're happy to talk about trying it."
But Uefa president Michel Platini remains staunchly opposed to its introduction, preferring an extension of the experiment with goalmouth referees.
Goal-line controversies have raged down the years, whether it is England's third goal of the 1966 World Cup final or Roy Carroll dropping a Pedro Mendes shot over the line and getting away with it in 2005 - or Lampard's recent goal-that-was-not-given, which may now lead to the introduction of technology.
Article taken from Sky News iPhone App
Legend- Posts : 3872
Join date : 2011-02-13
Location : No longer behind you
Re: Goal Line Technology
Rather than goal line technology i'd much rather have 4 lines people so they had a view of an incident from both sides of the pitch plus two sets of an eyes on a offside decision. Ok, there could be confrontation if they were to make a different decision but goal line technology is only needed every so often so is pretty pointless IMO
Anyway, Lampard's shot was never over the line :run1:
Anyway, Lampard's shot was never over the line :run1:
AberdeenSteve- Posts : 6520
Join date : 2011-01-24
Age : 33
Location : Guess?
Re: Goal Line Technology
Is this not the reason that they had another 1 or 2 officials stood by both goals in the UEFA Cup? Did they not work or ?
Jammy31- Posts : 867
Join date : 2011-01-30
Age : 32
Re: Goal Line Technology
Hit the nail on the head with that Jammy.
Surely that is the answer. Its tried & tested in the Europa League, so why not bring it into league matches as well. How hard can it be?
Surely that is the answer. Its tried & tested in the Europa League, so why not bring it into league matches as well. How hard can it be?
Guest- Guest
Re: Goal Line Technology
So long as none of the officials are female
Jammy31- Posts : 867
Join date : 2011-01-30
Age : 32
Re: Goal Line Technology
Not a fan of goal line technology where does it stop? If a goal was scored and technology was used to show the ball had crossed the line what if their was a foul or an offside in the build up to the goal? It would never end next thing we will have video refs for throw ins.
SugarRayRussell (PBK)- Posts : 6716
Join date : 2011-03-19
Age : 39
Similar topics
» Goal line technology
» Goal line technology (again)
» Goal line technology
» Goal Line Technology - A Scenario
» Goal-Line Technology to be used at 2014 World Cup
» Goal line technology (again)
» Goal line technology
» Goal Line Technology - A Scenario
» Goal-Line Technology to be used at 2014 World Cup
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Football
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum