Different Week, same old story
+34
englandglory4ever
HERSH
sad_gimp
Rob B
blackcanelion
littlejohn
trebellbobaggins
Knackeredknees
Peter Seabiscuit Wheeler
Taylorman
Rangiora
Breadvan
InjuredYetAgain
Mick(TEFC)
Thomond
captainrapido
Sgt_Pooly
funnyExiledScot
mckay1402
Biltong
Hood83
Draigoch
asoreleftshoulder
mpc28
Shifty
aucklandlaurie
nottins
Full Credit
mr-bryns-attitude
eirebilly
Pal Joey
Artful_Dodger
Gatts
TheGreyGhost
38 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 3 of 4
Page 3 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Different Week, same old story
First topic message reminder :
For the second week in a row, the All Blacks were robbed by an appalling decision by a local TMO.
After the shocking debacle in Port Elizabeth a week ago, toothless Paddy O'Brien's IRB refereeing so-called Elite panel have come in for more criticism after a shambles in the Tri-nations decider between New Zealand and Australia.
This time the villain was parochial Australian Matt Goddard. Faced with with video evidence clearly indicating a 22 meter restart after excellent work by All Black Veteran Muliaina, the local notorious Australian indicated to controversial Englishman Wayne Barnes that he believed a 5 meter scrum to his home team Australia was warranted.
With 3 key backrowers temporarily injured, Australia worked a move close to the scrum and scored what turned out to be the games clinching try.
Barnes, who himself this time took a more active role than usual in the All Blacks down fall after impeding Adam Thompson as he attempt to put a tackle of Samo, creating an unimpeded run to the try line for the Australia 8, was this time additionally rather let down by his assistants. Firstly Goddard, and secondly by another South African who was fooled by some Hollywood theatrics by Adam Ashley-Cooper who ran into the back of Kevin Mealamu and then threw himself to the ground in the style more befitting the closing act of Hamlet. This was enough for the South African to disrupt All Black momentum and award a penalty shot to Cooper.
IRB head referee Paddy O'Brien has presided over an era of controversy as chief referee. Many experts have levelled blame for the fall of the games professional adjudication into chaos as he has failing to address the inadequate level of the so-called top level referees. O'Brien was responsible for appointing inexperienced Wayne Barnes to referee the All Blacks when the were thrown out of the 2007 world cup in one of the worst refereeing displays in the professional era where he failed to penalise France for any one of 27 indiscretions in the last 60 minutes and missed a blatantly forward pass.
O'Brien was also responsible for the debacle which saw the two hemispheres play under different rules for 2 years throwing the global game into chaos.
Unsurprisingly Cooper missed the kick, but the controversial Australian already looks set to miss the world cup after being cited for a cynical off the ball knee to the head of All Black legend Richie McCaw. Many industry pundits have suggested that despite the obvious cynicism that Cooper may escape sanction if O'brien continues his trend of inadequate accountability in the global game.
"Unless Paddy gets off his chuff and does something about the state of the game, this kind of unacceptable travesty will continue to roll off the international rugby conveyor belt." our correspondent said.
For the second week in a row, the All Blacks were robbed by an appalling decision by a local TMO.
After the shocking debacle in Port Elizabeth a week ago, toothless Paddy O'Brien's IRB refereeing so-called Elite panel have come in for more criticism after a shambles in the Tri-nations decider between New Zealand and Australia.
This time the villain was parochial Australian Matt Goddard. Faced with with video evidence clearly indicating a 22 meter restart after excellent work by All Black Veteran Muliaina, the local notorious Australian indicated to controversial Englishman Wayne Barnes that he believed a 5 meter scrum to his home team Australia was warranted.
With 3 key backrowers temporarily injured, Australia worked a move close to the scrum and scored what turned out to be the games clinching try.
Barnes, who himself this time took a more active role than usual in the All Blacks down fall after impeding Adam Thompson as he attempt to put a tackle of Samo, creating an unimpeded run to the try line for the Australia 8, was this time additionally rather let down by his assistants. Firstly Goddard, and secondly by another South African who was fooled by some Hollywood theatrics by Adam Ashley-Cooper who ran into the back of Kevin Mealamu and then threw himself to the ground in the style more befitting the closing act of Hamlet. This was enough for the South African to disrupt All Black momentum and award a penalty shot to Cooper.
IRB head referee Paddy O'Brien has presided over an era of controversy as chief referee. Many experts have levelled blame for the fall of the games professional adjudication into chaos as he has failing to address the inadequate level of the so-called top level referees. O'Brien was responsible for appointing inexperienced Wayne Barnes to referee the All Blacks when the were thrown out of the 2007 world cup in one of the worst refereeing displays in the professional era where he failed to penalise France for any one of 27 indiscretions in the last 60 minutes and missed a blatantly forward pass.
O'Brien was also responsible for the debacle which saw the two hemispheres play under different rules for 2 years throwing the global game into chaos.
Unsurprisingly Cooper missed the kick, but the controversial Australian already looks set to miss the world cup after being cited for a cynical off the ball knee to the head of All Black legend Richie McCaw. Many industry pundits have suggested that despite the obvious cynicism that Cooper may escape sanction if O'brien continues his trend of inadequate accountability in the global game.
"Unless Paddy gets off his chuff and does something about the state of the game, this kind of unacceptable travesty will continue to roll off the international rugby conveyor belt." our correspondent said.
Last edited by TheGreyGhost on Sat 27 Aug 2011, 1:24 pm; edited 4 times in total
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
Anyway as it turned out I was correct about the toothless SANZAR judiciary who have let Cooper walk for the cynical and cowardly knee to the back of McCaw's head.
So I assume all the posters who are normally on here complaining about McCaw's cheating will now be lining up to condemn Cooper for his cowardice and SANZAR judiciary for letting him off based on some half-baked excuse about "not remembering it" and "it must have been accidental".
So I assume all the posters who are normally on here complaining about McCaw's cheating will now be lining up to condemn Cooper for his cowardice and SANZAR judiciary for letting him off based on some half-baked excuse about "not remembering it" and "it must have been accidental".
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:Anyway as it turned out I was correct about the toothless SANZAR judiciary who have let Cooper walk for the cynical and cowardly knee to the back of McCaw's head.
So I assume all the posters who are normally on here complaining about McCaw's cheating will now be lining up to condemn Cooper for his cowardice and SANZAR judiciary for letting him off based on some half-baked excuse about "not remembering it" and "it must have been accidental".
Perhaps, though i'm still seething at the Mealamu flying head butt and its pitifully lenient punishment. Oh no i'm not, i'm over it.
I think most people would make a distinction between cheating and thuggery. I've always thought McCaw's 'i can't roll away, honest' type of cheating is infuriating, but i've never seen him as a particularly dirty player. Plus i think the McCaw brand of 'cheating' is as much a fault of the ref's. Cooper's brand of cheating is more sinister and needs to be squeezed out of the game through citation, i agree on that much.
Hood83- Posts : 2751
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:Anyway as it turned out I was correct about the toothless SANZAR judiciary who have let Cooper walk for the cynical and cowardly knee to the back of McCaw's head.
So I assume all the posters who are normally on here complaining about McCaw's cheating will now be lining up to condemn Cooper for his cowardice and SANZAR judiciary for letting him off based on some half-baked excuse about "not remembering it" and "it must have been accidental".
GreyGhost
Have you ever been at the bottom of a ruck trying to get up quick??? hands, elbows heads knees are hitting you and your doing the same to others, teammates and opposition alike.
When i saw it, it looked just like an acident McCaw did'nt seem to make much of a fuss about it. thats why he was cleared as it was nothing, what to you want?no body contact in a ruck??
if you want to be condeming the SANZAR judiciary, how about the trip?????
You really need to get over this you sound like my 5yr old when she doesn't get her own way, time to grow up!!
Knackeredknees- Posts : 850
Join date : 2011-07-22
Age : 50
Location : Swanage
Re: Different Week, same old story
LB
Isn't this a tad paternalistic? We are all big boys on here.
Isn't this a tad paternalistic? We are all big boys on here.
Gatts- Posts : 2212
Join date : 2011-08-18
Re: Different Week, same old story
eirebilly wrote:Even though the AB's lost today, i still cant see them being beaten at the RWC. They lost to an Australian team that were better on the day but i still feel as if the AB's are the better team.
Agreed. I am sure they will do it at home.
trebellbobaggins- Posts : 4943
Join date : 2011-06-03
Re: Different Week, same old story
Knackeredknees wrote:TheGreyGhost wrote:Anyway as it turned out I was correct about the toothless SANZAR judiciary who have let Cooper walk for the cynical and cowardly knee to the back of McCaw's head.
So I assume all the posters who are normally on here complaining about McCaw's cheating will now be lining up to condemn Cooper for his cowardice and SANZAR judiciary for letting him off based on some half-baked excuse about "not remembering it" and "it must have been accidental".
GreyGhost
Have you ever been at the bottom of a ruck trying to get up quick??? hands, elbows heads knees are hitting you and your doing the same to others, teammates and opposition alike.
When i saw it, it looked just like an acident McCaw did'nt seem to make much of a fuss about it. thats why he was cleared as it was nothing, what to you want?no body contact in a ruck??
if you want to be condeming the SANZAR judiciary, how about the trip?????
You really need to get over this you sound like my 5yr old when she doesn't get her own way, time to grow up!!
Come on dude. Quade Cooper? In a ruck? I don't think so. Have you seen the incident? The ball is gone and Cooper wanders over, checks both ways then knees McCaw in the head. It's no accident. And it's obvious.
Copping a knee or a boot in a ruck is very different from someone deliberately attacking you from the blindside when they think they can get away with it.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
Overall Wallabies deserved the win here - Greater hunger, desire and sharpness had it for me. If they hadn't scored there they still had momentum and ABs were on the back foot.
Blaming it on refs/TMOs is sour grapes - can't blame ya for trying though! I know I was a 'wee' bit upset when Phillips scored an illegal try for Wales against Ireland this year...
Blaming it on refs/TMOs is sour grapes - can't blame ya for trying though! I know I was a 'wee' bit upset when Phillips scored an illegal try for Wales against Ireland this year...
littlejohn- Posts : 279
Join date : 2011-06-09
Re: Different Week, same old story
Australia were on top for the first 40 - no doubt. AB's kept putting themselves under pressure.
But NZ came back in the 40-60 minute mark.
The difference in these kind of games are small margins. To cop two ridiculous TMO decisions in two weeks is tough to stomach. Especially both from local men. I don't buy the argument that the Wallabies would have scored sooner or later. Fact is they scored due to consistent pressure - pressure which the ABs didn't deserve to be under due to a clearly wrong call.
Add that the SANZAR decision to take no action over Cooper's knee to the head despite clear video evidence, and it makes me despair that the thing that separates the top 3 or 4 teams in the world is poor refereeing decisions.
It's not a great state of affairs for the game.
But NZ came back in the 40-60 minute mark.
The difference in these kind of games are small margins. To cop two ridiculous TMO decisions in two weeks is tough to stomach. Especially both from local men. I don't buy the argument that the Wallabies would have scored sooner or later. Fact is they scored due to consistent pressure - pressure which the ABs didn't deserve to be under due to a clearly wrong call.
Add that the SANZAR decision to take no action over Cooper's knee to the head despite clear video evidence, and it makes me despair that the thing that separates the top 3 or 4 teams in the world is poor refereeing decisions.
It's not a great state of affairs for the game.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
Cooper wanders over ? That implies he was on his feet, he was getting to his feet when McCaw assaulted his knee with his chin.
25th June 2005.
The ball is gone and Mealamu and Nonu wander over, check both ways then lift O'Driscoll in the air and drive him into the floor. It's no accident. And it's obvious.
Copping a knee or a boot in a ruck is very different from someone deliberately attacking you from the blindside when they think they can get away with it.
25th June 2005.
The ball is gone and Mealamu and Nonu wander over, check both ways then lift O'Driscoll in the air and drive him into the floor. It's no accident. And it's obvious.
Copping a knee or a boot in a ruck is very different from someone deliberately attacking you from the blindside when they think they can get away with it.
nottins- Posts : 1413
Join date : 2011-05-12
Age : 58
Location : Wakefield
Re: Different Week, same old story
Why try to bring up something from 6 years ago Nottins? Let it go man, that one has been done to death.
We're in a new era now. I'm talking about Cooper's knee to the head. Either blindman Barnes, or the SANZAR judiciary should have punished him for that. The truth is a lot of these officials only make a ruling if the crowd makes a bit of a noise.
No surprise that your man Barnes was involved again.
We're in a new era now. I'm talking about Cooper's knee to the head. Either blindman Barnes, or the SANZAR judiciary should have punished him for that. The truth is a lot of these officials only make a ruling if the crowd makes a bit of a noise.
No surprise that your man Barnes was involved again.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
Australia deserved the win and were awesome in the first half. Reality Barnes is a difficult ref for the AB's to deal with. he penalises us more the opposition and he tends to be inconsistent. That's life, I'm more interested in how they adjust to his rulings. I think they could have negated a lot of the issues by being more intense at the breakdown. barnes was pretty lax. Assuming he would treat both sides the same, they should have thrown themselves into the breakdown as early and hard as the could. Another option they should have taken was for the second tackler to jackle for the ball (i.e. stay on his feet, and go for the turnover without releasing). It would have slowed the ball down and possibly got some turnover ball. Most northern refs gon't ping it and they probably would have gotten away with it (a la Australia and SA).
In terms of running interference. It happened a bit this game from both sides.
The IRN really has to look at the TMO's. 2 substandard decisions by hometown TMO's for hometown teams in 2 weeks.
In terms of running interference. It happened a bit this game from both sides.
The IRN really has to look at the TMO's. 2 substandard decisions by hometown TMO's for hometown teams in 2 weeks.
blackcanelion- Posts : 1989
Join date : 2011-06-20
Location : Wellington
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:Why try to bring up something from 6 years ago Nottins? Let it go man, that one has been done to death.
We're in a new era now. I'm talking about Cooper's knee to the head. Either blindman Barnes, or the SANZAR judiciary should have punished him for that. The truth is a lot of these officials only make a ruling if the crowd makes a bit of a noise.
No surprise that your man Barnes was involved again.
Being you must be a nightmare
Gatts- Posts : 2212
Join date : 2011-08-18
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:Why try to bring up something from 6 years ago Nottins? Let it go man, that one has been done to death.
We're in a new era now. I'm talking about Cooper's knee to the head. Either blindman Barnes, or the SANZAR judiciary should have punished him for that. The truth is a lot of these officials only make a ruling if the crowd makes a bit of a noise.
No surprise that your man Barnes was involved again.
The same reason you keep mentioning a certain 1/4 final in 2007. Let it go, that one has been done to death.
Australia were the better side and clearly deserved to win.
nottins- Posts : 1413
Join date : 2011-05-12
Age : 58
Location : Wakefield
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:Knackeredknees wrote:TheGreyGhost wrote:Anyway as it turned out I was correct about the toothless SANZAR judiciary who have let Cooper walk for the cynical and cowardly knee to the back of McCaw's head.
So I assume all the posters who are normally on here complaining about McCaw's cheating will now be lining up to condemn Cooper for his cowardice and SANZAR judiciary for letting him off based on some half-baked excuse about "not remembering it" and "it must have been accidental".
GreyGhost
Have you ever been at the bottom of a ruck trying to get up quick??? hands, elbows heads knees are hitting you and your doing the same to others, teammates and opposition alike.
When i saw it, it looked just like an acident McCaw did'nt seem to make much of a fuss about it. thats why he was cleared as it was nothing, what to you want?no body contact in a ruck??
if you want to be condeming the SANZAR judiciary, how about the trip?????
You really need to get over this you sound like my 5yr old when she doesn't get her own way, time to grow up!!
Come on dude. Quade Cooper? In a ruck? I don't think so. Have you seen the incident? The ball is gone and Cooper wanders over, checks both ways then knees McCaw in the head. It's no accident. And it's obvious.
Copping a knee or a boot in a ruck is very different from someone deliberately attacking you from the blindside when they think they can get away with it.
Heres a link GG yep that is Quade Cooper in the ruck, No Thats not the back of Richie McCaw's head as you stated, oh and why was Brad Thorne not Yellow carded for retaliation with his follow-up?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9RYZStDdDI
Also you have not really mentioned a bit of blatent cheating/foulplay that went unpunished the trip?
Knackeredknees- Posts : 850
Join date : 2011-07-22
Age : 50
Location : Swanage
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:For the second week in a row, the All Blacks were robbed by an appalling decision by a local TMO.
After the shocking debacle in Port Elizabeth a week ago, toothless Paddy O'Brien's IRB refereeing so-called Elite panel have come in for more criticism after a shambles in the Tri-nations decider between New Zealand and Australia.
This time the villain was parochial Australian Matt Goddard. Faced with with video evidence clearly indicating a 22 meter restart after excellent work by All Black Veteran Muliaina, the local notorious Australian indicated to controversial Englishman Wayne Barnes that he believed a 5 meter scrum to his home team Australia was warranted.
With 3 key backrowers temporarily injured, Australia worked a move close to the scrum and scored what turned out to be the games clinching try.
Barnes, who himself this time took a more active role than usual in the All Blacks down fall after impeding Adam Thompson as he attempt to put a tackle of Samo, creating an unimpeded run to the try line for the Australia 8, was this time additionally rather let down by his assistants. Firstly Goddard, and secondly by another South African who was fooled by some Hollywood theatrics by Adam Ashley-Cooper who ran into the back of Kevin Mealamu and then threw himself to the ground in the style more befitting the closing act of Hamlet. This was enough for the South African to disrupt All Black momentum and award a penalty shot to Cooper.
IRB head referee Paddy O'Brien has presided over an era of controversy as chief referee. Many experts have levelled blame for the fall of the games professional adjudication into chaos as he has failing to address the inadequate level of the so-called top level referees. O'Brien was responsible for appointing inexperienced Wayne Barnes to referee the All Blacks when the were thrown out of the 2007 world cup in one of the worst refereeing displays in the professional era where he failed to penalise France for any one of 27 indiscretions in the last 60 minutes and missed a blatantly forward pass.
O'Brien was also responsible for the debacle which saw the two hemispheres play under different rules for 2 years throwing the global game into chaos.
Unsurprisingly Cooper missed the kick, but the controversial Australian already looks set to miss the world cup after being cited for a cynical off the ball knee to the head of All Black legend Richie McCaw. Many industry pundits have suggested that despite the obvious cynicism that Cooper may escape sanction if O'brien continues his trend of inadequate accountability in the global game.
"Unless Paddy gets off his chuff and does something about the state of the game, this kind of unacceptable travesty will continue to roll off the international rugby conveyor belt." our correspondent said.
You never seem to whinge when the rub of the green goes with the ABs. Why would that be do you think? Didn't hear much out of you over Read's knock on at Eden Park providing ABs with 7 points on a plate. What did you have to say about McCaws illegal detaching from a scrum creating an illgeal overlap and try against W last year when ABs won 23-22? AAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH I get it - ABs won those games. Right.
Rob B- Posts : 466
Join date : 2011-06-27
Re: Different Week, same old story
I didn't need to mate, all the Ozzie posters were on here having a whinge about it already.
It's only "whinging" when I make a valid statement about the referees being incorrect, apparently.
For example when the English complain about the law that means if Cueto's foot is in touch then it's not a try they all rally together into a giant ball of anxiety and justify each other's position.
Just because I'm a lone voice in the wilderness calling for fair standards of refereeing to be applied to NZ, doesn't mean I'm wrong. It probably just means you don't like hearing it because you know I'm right.
It's only "whinging" when I make a valid statement about the referees being incorrect, apparently.
For example when the English complain about the law that means if Cueto's foot is in touch then it's not a try they all rally together into a giant ball of anxiety and justify each other's position.
Just because I'm a lone voice in the wilderness calling for fair standards of refereeing to be applied to NZ, doesn't mean I'm wrong. It probably just means you don't like hearing it because you know I'm right.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
Ghost you don't honestly believe there is a conspiracy against NZ do you?
Biltong- Moderator
- Posts : 26945
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Twilight zone
Re: Different Week, same old story
So you think they should be penalised more too then?TheGreyGhost wrote:Just because I'm a lone voice in the wilderness calling for fair standards of refereeing to be applied to NZ
Full Credit- Posts : 721
Join date : 2011-06-08
Re: Different Week, same old story
Full Credit wrote:So you think they should be penalised more too then?TheGreyGhost wrote:Just because I'm a lone voice in the wilderness calling for fair standards of refereeing to be applied to NZ
You made a funny!
Biltong- Moderator
- Posts : 26945
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Twilight zone
Re: Different Week, same old story
Of course not. But the argument that poor refereeing decisions against NZ are acceptable because they should be good enough to win anyway is illogical nonsense and I'm sick of hearing it.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
Ghost, i don't think anyone disagrees with you that the correct procedures should be applicable, but then you have to concede even thoiugh the TMO got it wrong against SA, it was a forward pass.
THe situation against the Wallabies this weekend, once again, the TMO ruled that as held up, thus the 5 meter scrum.
THe situation against the Wallabies this weekend, once again, the TMO ruled that as held up, thus the 5 meter scrum.
Biltong- Moderator
- Posts : 26945
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Twilight zone
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:Of course not. But the argument that poor refereeing decisions against NZ are acceptable because they should be good enough to win anyway is illogical nonsense and I'm sick of hearing it.
No-one is saying that, you are wilfully misconstruing people's comments. When people talk about 2007 the point they are making is that Barnes' performance is not the only reason the ABs lost, and that IF they had been good/smart enough in certain aspects as their play, they would have won anyway as they had opportunities. No-one thought Barnes's performance was acceptable, they just don't see it as the only reason the ABs lost.
As for your comments on the English response to Cueto's non-try...this is utter garbage, this resides entirely and solely in your mind. The vast majority of England supporters, once they'd seen the replay, accepted his foot was out. A tiny minority refused to.
I, like most people, want to see games reffed consistently and fairly. You are a terrible loser GG, i have an 8yr old cousin with better grace in defeat. It's embarrassing. Please please please revert to your more sensible postings.
Hood83- Posts : 2751
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Different Week, same old story
Nope, you see what you said? exactly what I just said you were saying.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:I didn't need to mate, all the Ozzie posters were on here having a whinge about it already.
It's only "whinging" when I make a valid statement about the referees being incorrect, apparently.
For example when the English complain about the law that means if Cueto's foot is in touch then it's not a try they all rally together into a giant ball of anxiety and justify each other's position.
Just because I'm a lone voice in the wilderness calling for fair standards of refereeing to be applied to NZ, doesn't mean I'm wrong. It probably just means you don't like hearing it because you know I'm right.
Being the lone voice may not make you wrong per se, but it doesn't make you right either. I am not an advocate for a system that rewards tries when they are not tries - such as from forward passes. What a farce. Yes NZ should have been awarded a try in SA off a blatant forward pass.
Rob B- Posts : 466
Join date : 2011-06-27
Re: Different Week, same old story
Hood83 wrote:
As for your comments on the English response to Cueto's non-try...this is utter garbage, this resides entirely and solely in your mind. The vast majority of England supporters, once they'd seen the replay, accepted his foot was out. A tiny minority refused to.
I, like most people, want to see games reffed consistently and fairly. You are a terrible loser GG, i have an 8yr old cousin with better grace in defeat. It's embarrassing. Please please please revert to your more sensible postings.
This. I don't know anyone that thinks Cueto wasn't in touch. Does anyone on here think he wasn't? No, it's just the lone voice whinging about referees constantly. Decisions go both ways for all teams, on the whole they balance out.
I am still amazed that the AB 'superman bellyflop' approach to the breakdown doesn't get them binned more often, but hey ho.
sad_gimp- Posts : 518
Join date : 2011-05-20
Location : Germany
Re: Different Week, same old story
The superman bellyflop approach that Australia were using on the weekend you mean? The same one that England were using against Ireland?
In both instances it was northern hemisphere referees who were failing to ping this uncontrolled clean out/ruck entry off the feet.
I'd say the teams just play to the referees interpretation.
I've been banging on about how Barnes and Owens in particularly are not very good referees for a long time.
In both instances it was northern hemisphere referees who were failing to ping this uncontrolled clean out/ruck entry off the feet.
I'd say the teams just play to the referees interpretation.
I've been banging on about how Barnes and Owens in particularly are not very good referees for a long time.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
New site (to me anyway) and the same old story coming from theGreyGhost
just take it on the chin my friend, you lost
just take it on the chin my friend, you lost
HERSH- Posts : 4207
Join date : 2011-08-26
Location : Arundel/Bath
Re: Different Week, same old story
Hersh, just pointing out that many teams do the same thing. It's about the referees encouraging it by not penalising; rather than certain teams relying on the technique.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
The GG crying in his milk again I see. As for the Thompson weak tackling on Samo its absolutely clear what happened. ie,
Thompson ran in to the ref but still had time to brush him aside and get to Samo. Samo handed him off very easily as Thompson went in upright. It was a great and absolutely legitimate try. Get over it GG the aussies gave you a good spanking.
BTW if you ever get to speak to Ali Williams you could ask him to stop deliberately tripping players up.
Thompson ran in to the ref but still had time to brush him aside and get to Samo. Samo handed him off very easily as Thompson went in upright. It was a great and absolutely legitimate try. Get over it GG the aussies gave you a good spanking.
BTW if you ever get to speak to Ali Williams you could ask him to stop deliberately tripping players up.
englandglory4ever- Posts : 1635
Join date : 2011-08-04
Location : Brighton, Sussex
Re: Different Week, same old story
We all know that Thompson was injured. My point is that had Barnes not been standing in his way, he would have had time to get into better position to make a tackle. Samo was attacking a gap created by Barnes, which gave him an advantage.
As for foul play, I nobody fell over, so I don't see how Ali Williams could have tripped anyone. Or perhaps you were just parroting what the one-eyed Aussie commentators said...oh yeah, that's it.
Interesting you didn't comment on Quade Coopers knee to the back of McCaw's head? I've seen players (Irish ones) red carded for that.
But I guess that game was in NZ, and Barnes has a habbit of fawning all over a local crowd. I guess it makes him feel wanted and accepted, briefly.
As for foul play, I nobody fell over, so I don't see how Ali Williams could have tripped anyone. Or perhaps you were just parroting what the one-eyed Aussie commentators said...oh yeah, that's it.
Interesting you didn't comment on Quade Coopers knee to the back of McCaw's head? I've seen players (Irish ones) red carded for that.
But I guess that game was in NZ, and Barnes has a habbit of fawning all over a local crowd. I guess it makes him feel wanted and accepted, briefly.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
Barnes was definitely not 'standing in his way'. Thompson ran in to an almost stationary Barnes. The ref has to stand somewhere and at any given point he could be 'standing in the way' of 10 or 12 players as they are all at different points on the pitch.. Thompson was simply blitzed by Samo.
englandglory4ever- Posts : 1635
Join date : 2011-08-04
Location : Brighton, Sussex
Re: Different Week, same old story
He ran into an almost stationary Barnes who was standing in the ABs defensive line. That's my point.
He does have to stand somewhere. Does it have to be in the ABs defensive line?
He does have to stand somewhere. Does it have to be in the ABs defensive line?
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
It was a poor effort from Thomson, pure and simple.
Even with the minor obstruction from Barnes (which clearly wasn't deliberate), Thomson got sufficient hold of Samo to bring him down. It was an easy hand-off from Samo considering Thomson is supposed to be a hard man.
Thomson has played poorly two games in a row now. If he really was so badly injured that he couldn't even make a tackle, then he should never have been on the pitch.
Barnes didn't have a good game, both sides had poor decisions from him in my view, but I don't think the result would have been any different had another ref been in charge. The ABs had the players and the game plan available to win that game, but the Aussies were focused, strong enough in defense and crucially able to dictate for the majority of the game the way in which the game would be played.
I know it's frustrating when a couple of decisions don't go your way, believe me, last time we lost to Argentina Alan Lewis may have well have just declared that the offside rule didn't apply to Albacete, but sometimes even with rough decisions you are second best. The ABs were second best on Saturday.
Even with the minor obstruction from Barnes (which clearly wasn't deliberate), Thomson got sufficient hold of Samo to bring him down. It was an easy hand-off from Samo considering Thomson is supposed to be a hard man.
Thomson has played poorly two games in a row now. If he really was so badly injured that he couldn't even make a tackle, then he should never have been on the pitch.
Barnes didn't have a good game, both sides had poor decisions from him in my view, but I don't think the result would have been any different had another ref been in charge. The ABs had the players and the game plan available to win that game, but the Aussies were focused, strong enough in defense and crucially able to dictate for the majority of the game the way in which the game would be played.
I know it's frustrating when a couple of decisions don't go your way, believe me, last time we lost to Argentina Alan Lewis may have well have just declared that the offside rule didn't apply to Albacete, but sometimes even with rough decisions you are second best. The ABs were second best on Saturday.
funnyExiledScot- Posts : 17072
Join date : 2011-05-31
Age : 43
Location : Edinburgh
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:
Interesting you didn't comment on Quade Coopers knee to the back of McCaw's head?
How did he manage to knee him in the back off his head when McCaw was laid on his back ? Have you actually seen it or you just posting your usual one-eyed view ?
nottins- Posts : 1413
Join date : 2011-05-12
Age : 58
Location : Wakefield
Re: Different Week, same old story
I think any rational person who's seen it, agrees Cooper did it accidentally-on-purpose.
Have you seen it? or are you just posting your usual one-eyed view?
Have you seen it? or are you just posting your usual one-eyed view?
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
A few points.
Williams did have a trailing leg that tripped a Wallaby, can't remember who it was.
Thompson didn't make that tackle becuase he was injured and should have left the pitch.
Cooper looked at McCaw just before he got up, McCaw looked back at him and got the knee sort of under the chin.
I saw it all, so no contest.
Williams did have a trailing leg that tripped a Wallaby, can't remember who it was.
Thompson didn't make that tackle becuase he was injured and should have left the pitch.
Cooper looked at McCaw just before he got up, McCaw looked back at him and got the knee sort of under the chin.
I saw it all, so no contest.
Biltong- Moderator
- Posts : 26945
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Twilight zone
Re: Different Week, same old story
On the other side of the ledger, AAC deliberately ran into KM and then threw himself to the ground like a Shakespearian hack acting out the closing sequence of Hamlet, and milking a penalty from the same touch judge who missed the Cooper knee 2 meters in front of him.
Barnes took the linesman's word for it, having "failed to see" either incident.
Barnes took the linesman's word for it, having "failed to see" either incident.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:I think any rational person who's seen it, agrees Cooper did it accidentally-on-purpose.
Have you seen it? or are you just posting your usual one-eyed view?
I have seen it, he does not knee him in the back of the head. It's quite clear you haven't seen it.
nottins- Posts : 1413
Join date : 2011-05-12
Age : 58
Location : Wakefield
Re: Different Week, same old story
Nottins. Most people on this site aren't in denial like you.
Most people will just accept that not everything that happens to NZ is something to have a little self satisfied giggle about.
Clearly Cooper is doing something which is plainly aware of, and that constitutes foul play.
Most people will just accept that not everything that happens to NZ is something to have a little self satisfied giggle about.
Clearly Cooper is doing something which is plainly aware of, and that constitutes foul play.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
No foul play there. Time to move on .
nottins- Posts : 1413
Join date : 2011-05-12
Age : 58
Location : Wakefield
Re: Different Week, same old story
I see that blindness to foul play against NZ isn't just a feature of Wayne Barnes's eyesight. It seems to be an English eye disease.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
nottins wrote:25th June 2005.
The ball is gone and Mealamu and Nonu wander over, check both ways then lift O'Driscoll in the air and drive him into the floor. It's no accident. And it's obvious.
It was actually Mealamu and Umaga. Nonu didn't make the squad until the 2nd test. Wrong as per usual!
nottins_jones- Posts : 684
Join date : 2011-06-27
Age : 35
Location : Casnewydd
Re: Different Week, same old story
Yeah, get it right Nottins.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
nottins_jones- Posts : 684
Join date : 2011-06-27
Age : 35
Location : Casnewydd
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:Nope, you see what you said? exactly what I just said you were saying.
Nope. You implied people think the ABs should win all the time and don't deserve a fair cop from the ref. This is bunkum. Most people thought Barnes performance was poor, disadvantaged the ABs, but not enough to affect the game In other words, they COULD have won but didn't due to other reasons i.e. not making the right decisions.
It's not difficult.
Trust me, we all wish Barnes had reffed it better and spared us the last few years of bleating.
Oh and everyone saw the Cooper knee, nottins point was everyone who saw it knows it was on his chin, not the back of his head as you said. A legitimate question therefore is what part of the back of your head features a chin GG? You really can't even admit to a simple, innocent slip of the tongue mistake can you?!
I do agree though, amazed it was cited and not met with any punishment, looked very deliberate to me.
Hood83- Posts : 2751
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:On the other side of the ledger, AAC deliberately ran into KM and then threw himself to the ground like a Shakespearian hack acting out the closing sequence of Hamlet, and milking a penalty from the same touch judge who missed the Cooper knee 2 meters in front of him.
Barnes took the linesman's word for it, having "failed to see" either incident.
Have you aver seen a bullet deflect of a tiny little branch?
It doesn't take much to deflect an object's momentum when it hits the tiniest stationary particle.
He BOUNCED.
Biltong- Moderator
- Posts : 26945
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Twilight zone
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:On the other side of the ledger, AAC deliberately ran into KM and then threw himself to the ground like a Shakespearian hack acting out the closing sequence of Hamlet, and milking a penalty from the same touch judge who missed the Cooper knee 2 meters in front of him.
Barnes took the linesman's word for it, having "failed to see" either incident.
A Shakesperian journalist? Que?
Hood83- Posts : 2751
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Different Week, same old story
Hood83 wrote:TheGreyGhost wrote:Nope, you see what you said? exactly what I just said you were saying.
Nope. You implied people think the ABs should win all the time and don't deserve a fair cop from the ref. This is bunkum. Most people thought Barnes performance was poor, disadvantaged the ABs, but not enough to affect the game In other words, they COULD have won but didn't due to other reasons i.e. not making the right decisions.
That's just apologetic nonsense though. Fact is a single wrong call can influence the game. The ABs lost by what? 1 point? Just one of those 26 missed calls would have changed the outcome of the game. I'm not sure how anyone could arrive at the conclusion that it didn't affect the outcome. It's just ludicrous.
TheGreyGhost- Posts : 2531
Join date : 2011-06-06
Re: Different Week, same old story
TheGreyGhost wrote:On the other side of the ledger, AAC deliberately ran into KM and then threw himself to the ground like a Shakespearian hack acting out the closing sequence of Hamlet, and milking a penalty from the same touch judge who missed the Cooper knee 2 meters in front of him.
Barnes took the linesman's word for it, having "failed to see" either incident.
If you were to watch it agin you would see that AAC DIDN'T deliberately run into KM He was blocked by another NZ player(cant remember which), and then fell in to KM, thats why the other NZ player was pinged for it not the saintly and blessed KM.
If you that "one eyed" we may hve to start calling you "Leela"
Knackeredknees- Posts : 850
Join date : 2011-07-22
Age : 50
Location : Swanage
Re: Different Week, same old story
Newsflash : referees sometimes make bad decisions. Always have, always will, in any sport.
Most people over the age of ten understand this, and accept it. There's just a tiny minority with a persecution complex that spend their time bleating and stamping their feet.
A friend of mine suffers from this affliction and frequently has to be reminded to STFU during and after games before his whinging drives everyone insane. Tedious.
Most people over the age of ten understand this, and accept it. There's just a tiny minority with a persecution complex that spend their time bleating and stamping their feet.
A friend of mine suffers from this affliction and frequently has to be reminded to STFU during and after games before his whinging drives everyone insane. Tedious.
sad_gimp- Posts : 518
Join date : 2011-05-20
Location : Germany
Page 3 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Similar topics
» Such a sad story
» NFL prediction survivor league - Week 2 results (NYJ wins) and Week 3 picks
» THE OMPL SEASON 5: Week 5 Results Updated!! Week 6 Deadline Saturday 12th October
» NFL Competition - Week 16 (Thursday and Saturday (most games) this week)
» OWGR Week 36 Week of Tour Championship
» NFL prediction survivor league - Week 2 results (NYJ wins) and Week 3 picks
» THE OMPL SEASON 5: Week 5 Results Updated!! Week 6 Deadline Saturday 12th October
» NFL Competition - Week 16 (Thursday and Saturday (most games) this week)
» OWGR Week 36 Week of Tour Championship
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 3 of 4
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum