The v2 Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

+10
ScarletSpiderman
munkian
Welshmushroom
red_stag
BoyneRFC
Dubbelyew L Overate
gowales
Feckless Rogue
JayMaster3000
Portnoy
14 posters

Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Portnoy Mon 21 May - 23:59

What do Dragons' fans think?

Will it be a re-hash of the Aironi side?
Portnoy
Portnoy

Posts : 4396
Join date : 2011-06-06
Age : 74
Location : Felixstowe, Tigers, England

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by JayMaster3000 Tue 22 May - 0:45

Link?

JayMaster3000

Posts : 214
Join date : 2011-06-07

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Feckless Rogue Tue 22 May - 0:54

I think the Italian Union has two Heineken Cup spots and they can enter any team they wish. I don't think Dragons fans are that bothered. At least I've never heard them complain. I know the English and French clubs are bothered. But Italian exposure to top level European rugby is more important than the ego's of English and French clubs in the grand scheme of things.

The Heineken Cup is the best thing about European rugby. I'd prefer it to be expanded to allow more French and English in to make qualification easier for them, than to see it reduced in size to allow the French to add two teams to the top 14. I'd rather see more cross border rugby competition for everyone than a super rich French juggernaught gobbling up everyone else's talent and sticking the knife into the smaller nations.

It's a shame Aironi failed. I have no idea what the new team will be. But pro rugby in some nations is in a fragile state. If we have ambitions to grow rugby's popularity I think it's right for the erc to guarantee all the 6 nations representation in the HC. And plan to add more nations in the future. If we have ambitions to kill pro rugby in Italy and possibly Scotland then we should follow the self serving French clubs proposals.
Feckless Rogue
Feckless Rogue

Posts : 3230
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : The Mighty Kingdom Of Leinster

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by gowales Tue 22 May - 5:26

I think it'd be better for this new Italian side to play in the Amlin cup next year so they can build themselves up, no point in playing against Clermont against and getting destroyed 83-0. Just to clarify this is not Welsh bias, i am in no way a Dragons supporter, i just think it makes the most sense for Aironi.

gowales

Posts : 2942
Join date : 2011-06-17

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Dubbelyew L Overate Tue 22 May - 10:07

Why pollute the potential excellence of HC with sub-standard teams, when there is the Amlin, which already provides a more diverse, development competition.

ERC is a commercial operation - the Italians will get their share of the collective income regardless of whether their teams are in HC or Amlin.

A couple of seasons ago, Italian clubs played amongst themselves, and two had 6 HC pool games, and four had 6 Amlin pool games.
Now, two have 22 Pro12 games and 6 HC pool games, and four have the same Amlin slots. Those 22 Pro12 games should be plenty enough to fuel the development of top level Italian rugby.

Why are there 4 tier 2 Italian teams in the Amlin, when there are none from Scotland or Welsh Prem - all 4 Italians finished botton of their pools with an average match score of about 8 - 43, often playing against reserve teams. How is that helping Italian rugby? How is it helping European rugby?

Should they give up their Amlin places to Georgians, Russians, Portuguese, Germans, etc?


Demote all teams finishing bottom of their HC pools, regardless of domestic league qualification or national entitlement, and promote all Amlin pool winners.

Dubbelyew L Overate

Posts : 1043
Join date : 2011-06-22

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by BoyneRFC Tue 22 May - 10:12

Why pollute the potential excellence of HC with sub-standard teams

Like Newport and Cardiff?

BoyneRFC

Posts : 493
Join date : 2012-04-03

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Dubbelyew L Overate Tue 22 May - 10:17

BoyneRFC wrote:
Why pollute the potential excellence of HC with sub-standard teams

Like Newport and Cardiff?

Newport and Cardiff play in the B&I Cup, if I'm not mistaken.

Dubbelyew L Overate

Posts : 1043
Join date : 2011-06-22

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by red_stag Tue 22 May - 10:18

They are not being rewarded with anything. Italy are entitled to 2 Heineken Cup places. That is currently Treviso and AN Other.

It is nothing to do with Dragons. Or Connacht. Or any other team outside Italy.
red_stag
red_stag

Posts : 15653
Join date : 2011-05-19
Age : 36
Location : Limerick, Ireland

http://www.redstagrugby.blogspot.com

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Dubbelyew L Overate Tue 22 May - 10:28

Italy are entitled to 2 HC spots, but why? Because they own a proportion of ERC, a purely commercial reason, entirely divorced from sporting reasons.

Is that what we want from the premier club rugby competition in Europe in the future, participation solely on commercial criteria?

Pragmatically, in this professional rugby world, commercialism cannot be ignored, but neither should sporting excellence.

Dubbelyew L Overate

Posts : 1043
Join date : 2011-06-22

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Welshmushroom Tue 22 May - 10:52

Dubbelyew L Overate wrote:Why pollute the potential excellence of HC with sub-standard teams, when there is the Amlin, which already provides a more diverse, development competition.

ERC is a commercial operation - the Italians will get their share of the collective income regardless of whether their teams are in HC or Amlin.

A couple of seasons ago, Italian clubs played amongst themselves, and two had 6 HC pool games, and four had 6 Amlin pool games.
Now, two have 22 Pro12 games and 6 HC pool games, and four have the same Amlin slots. Those 22 Pro12 games should be plenty enough to fuel the development of top level Italian rugby.

Why are there 4 tier 2 Italian teams in the Amlin, when there are none from Scotland or Welsh Prem - all 4 Italians finished botton of their pools with an average match score of about 8 - 43, often playing against reserve teams. How is that helping Italian rugby? How is it helping European rugby?

Should they give up their Amlin places to Georgians, Russians, Portuguese, Germans, etc?


Demote all teams finishing bottom of their HC pools, regardless of domestic league qualification or national entitlement, and promote all Amlin pool winners.

Is it not the whole point of a European Cup to have the best of the domestic leagues play against each other? Sure the teams mentioned above dont stand much of a chance but if they top their amateur leagues they should have the right to test themselves if its a true european cup. They certanly have more rights to representation than a team who finishes 6th in their League and has won no cup and not really done anything of note to warrant HC inclusion.


Welshmushroom

Posts : 2622
Join date : 2011-08-09

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by munkian Tue 22 May - 11:20

Its a European cup, not Champions league.

And Newport and Cardiff are Welsh premiership sides ? Erm
munkian
munkian

Posts : 8456
Join date : 2011-04-01
Age : 43
Location : Bristol/The Port

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by ScarletSpiderman Tue 22 May - 12:02

To be fair I would rather see a rebranded Aironi than see an Overmach Parma that have been stripped of their better players (to Treviso and the re-branded Aironi) seeing as those are the realistic choices.

That said thinking about it do the Blues, Scarlets, Ospreys Connacht, Edinburgh, or Treviso really deserve a place in the HEC. I have an idea lets ditch them all and just have Leinster, Ulster (only because they were defeated finalists), Munster, and make the rest up of Jeff and Top 14 sides. Much fairer and makes much more sense.
ScarletSpiderman
ScarletSpiderman

Posts : 9944
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 40
Location : Pembs

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by whocares Tue 22 May - 12:03

Welshmushroom wrote:
Is it not the whole point of a European Cup to have the best of the domestic leagues play against each other?

I remember debating that here with other posters and it's clear that we dont all agree on what the HC should be all about. Some like me would want less teams but better ones (note that I am not implying less pro12/irish teams here) with other teams going into the real development cup i.e. the AC. while other people seem to think that the HC should also be a developing league with all countries represented.

whocares

Posts : 4270
Join date : 2011-04-14
Age : 47
Location : France - paris area

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by formerly known as Sam Tue 22 May - 12:47

while other people seem to think that the HC should also be a developing league with all countries represented.

The French/English proposed a third tier competition which would cater much better for a lot of the smaller countries teams than the HEC. The Amlin would be a good stepping stone between the top and bottom tier and the teams from developing countries should be offered progression between the tiers.

I fail to see how shoving more teams from developing countries into the top tier event helps anybody. The crowds and tv coverage is smaller for the bigger teams and for the smaller teams there is the great excitement of taking a massive kicking in every game.

formerly known as Sam

Posts : 21333
Join date : 2011-07-13
Age : 38
Location : Leicestershire

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Shifty Tue 22 May - 18:59

I dont think there should be more than 1 country represented in any pool, if we have 5 pools have 5 french and english clubs, if we have 6 pools have 6 teams from those countries.

I think it's silly that a european cup can have 2 french or english teams in a single pool.

the way its going id rather europe scraped and the rabo expanded.
Shifty
Shifty

Posts : 7393
Join date : 2011-04-26
Age : 45
Location : Kenfig Hill, Bridgend

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Peter Seabiscuit Wheeler Wed 23 May - 8:35

Feckless Rogue wrote:I think the Italian Union has two Heineken Cup spots and they can enter any team they wish. I don't think Dragons fans are that bothered. At least I've never heard them complain. I know the English and French clubs are bothered. But Italian exposure to top level European rugby is more important than the ego's of English and French clubs in the grand scheme of things.

The Heineken Cup is the best thing about European rugby. I'd prefer it to be expanded to allow more French and English in to make qualification easier for them, than to see it reduced in size to allow the French to add two teams to the top 14. I'd rather see more cross border rugby competition for everyone than a super rich French juggernaught gobbling up everyone else's talent and sticking the knife into the smaller nations.

It's a shame Aironi failed. I have no idea what the new team will be. But pro rugby in some nations is in a fragile state. If we have ambitions to grow rugby's popularity I think it's right for the erc to guarantee all the 6 nations representation in the HC. And plan to add more nations in the future. If we have ambitions to kill pro rugby in Italy and possibly Scotland then we should follow the self serving French clubs proposals.

Quite right. Just like the rabo it has to allow in a load of no hopers just so people dont feel left out.

Joking aside there has to be a balance. If the inclusion of certain unions clubs is creating excessively one sided games ( as in the ECC) and doing little to add to the income generated, even potentially costing clubs, it doesnt help anyone.
As you say the finances of most clubs across all unions are in a pretty perilous state, lets be careful not to kill off the few that have some level off success trying to help out dead ducks or those not even born yet.

In this case i cant see how anyone can really argue against Italy getting a second nomination, its long been established they have the right to one. Going forward though if they cant get a second viable Rabo franchise going then that place should be reviewed to avoid an anomaly.

Peter Seabiscuit Wheeler

Posts : 10344
Join date : 2011-06-02
Location : Englandshire

Back to top Go down

A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games. Empty Re: A Phoenix Italian side must be rewarded with an HEC place after ~ 8 games.

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum