Nigel Owens and Ireland and the Ruck Monkey
+24
FitzStephen
BoyneRFC
Mickado
blackcanelion
nganboy
emack2
rodders
yappysnap
welshy6
sugarNspikes
The Great Aukster
Bullsbok
Biltong
Thomond
SecretFly
Sin é
Shifty
Standulstermen
logie28
glamorganalun
LeinsterFan4life
GunsGerms
funnyExiledScot
anotherworldofpain
28 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 3 of 3
Page 3 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
Nigel Owens and Ireland and the Ruck Monkey
First topic message reminder :
So with all the emotional from the air disappear I take another look to yesterdays games.
First up Ireland.
Now all week we read about in the papers how Ireland better NZ at the breakdown. And a lot of complaining from Ireland about the rules at the ruck not going there way.
So this weekend Nigel Owens seem to go out with the mind already that Ireland better and really let them away with a lot of things.
"Obstruction, Obstruction, Obstruction" must have been Irish game plan because from very start this is what they doing. Watch the game again. Always have the Irish back row, particular no.6 run horizontal in front of the Irish attacker. At the ruck Ireland have "pillars" out like it was 2004. On the kick off Ireland give up catch the ball and look to impeding advancing all blacks "second receiver" to take the tip. They just barge them off the way before the ball arrive.
Second Nigel Owens allow the Irish to enter the defensive ruck in "ruck monkey" position. They flop over the tackle area and take the weight to their hands then start to grapple at the ball. This is not allowed in the SH where attacking clearance is favour and defenders must attack only the isolated runner and stay to the feet always. No wonder Richie McCaw look so confused most of the game!
On the contrary Owens penalise the all blacks on the clear out who lose their feet try to clear away the Irish defenders. This is refereeing from a decade ago.
Add to that the knee-jerk yellow card for israel dagg who was already commit to a innocuous charge down and we see that Owens was clearly start the game on the north side of euqator and too influence by the Irish fans in the crowd and media run up to the game.
This tubby Welshman is the center of a lot of controversy. And is it time to give him the pension and move on with younger fitter referees who can keep up with the rules and the match?
So with all the emotional from the air disappear I take another look to yesterdays games.
First up Ireland.
Now all week we read about in the papers how Ireland better NZ at the breakdown. And a lot of complaining from Ireland about the rules at the ruck not going there way.
So this weekend Nigel Owens seem to go out with the mind already that Ireland better and really let them away with a lot of things.
"Obstruction, Obstruction, Obstruction" must have been Irish game plan because from very start this is what they doing. Watch the game again. Always have the Irish back row, particular no.6 run horizontal in front of the Irish attacker. At the ruck Ireland have "pillars" out like it was 2004. On the kick off Ireland give up catch the ball and look to impeding advancing all blacks "second receiver" to take the tip. They just barge them off the way before the ball arrive.
Second Nigel Owens allow the Irish to enter the defensive ruck in "ruck monkey" position. They flop over the tackle area and take the weight to their hands then start to grapple at the ball. This is not allowed in the SH where attacking clearance is favour and defenders must attack only the isolated runner and stay to the feet always. No wonder Richie McCaw look so confused most of the game!
On the contrary Owens penalise the all blacks on the clear out who lose their feet try to clear away the Irish defenders. This is refereeing from a decade ago.
Add to that the knee-jerk yellow card for israel dagg who was already commit to a innocuous charge down and we see that Owens was clearly start the game on the north side of euqator and too influence by the Irish fans in the crowd and media run up to the game.
This tubby Welshman is the center of a lot of controversy. And is it time to give him the pension and move on with younger fitter referees who can keep up with the rules and the match?
Last edited by anotherworldofpain on Mon 18 Jun 2012, 6:13 am; edited 1 time in total
anotherworldofpain- Posts : 2803
Join date : 2012-04-06
Age : 45
Location : St John's Wood, London
Re: Nigel Owens and Ireland and the Ruck Monkey
thebluesmancometh wrote:This tubby Welshman is the center of a lot of controversy. And is it time to give him the pension and move on with younger fitter referees who can keep up with the rules and the match?
Suddenly decent English.
Also this 'tubby' welshman you speak of is actually an ex body builder, a bit of a fitness fenatic I hear and has recently recorded a Yo Yo test result that would trump a huge amount of international players.
Is that really a good indication of being a good referee?
Being able to...https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDiioSreoPc
MrsP- Posts : 9207
Join date : 2011-09-13
thebluesmancometh- Posts : 8358
Join date : 2011-05-05
Page 3 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
Similar topics
» Well done Nigel Owens! But...please stop pinging the dynamic attacking ruck.
» Did Nigel Owens show us a new way to reff games Ireland v Italy 8/3/14
» Nigel Owens
» Nigel Owens abuse
» The Nigel Owens incident
» Did Nigel Owens show us a new way to reff games Ireland v Italy 8/3/14
» Nigel Owens
» Nigel Owens abuse
» The Nigel Owens incident
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 3 of 3
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum