Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
+10
ChequeredJersey
hawkeye
LuvSports!
Born Slippy
JuliusHMarx
Haddie-nuff
HM Murdock
novak143
kingraf
erictheblueuk
14 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Tennis
Page 2 of 2
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
The Best Forehand?
Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
First topic message reminder :
Here we are folks. The vote is here and get them in for what I think is the more insteresting of the categories.
Here we are folks. The vote is here and get them in for what I think is the more insteresting of the categories.
Guest- Guest
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Thought his H2H was pretty favourable against them too? Also, from what I've seen on this forum and IRL, I'm not sure your second paragraph is true in Manu respects at all.novak143 wrote:Serve: He is undoubtedly the best in holding his serve when facing Break Points. This is because, he does not have a killer first serve, which is a blessing in disguise, as he tries to start the point from a neutral position. That is, he does not make it easy for the returner, nor does he put himself in a advantageous position. In a way he is not worried that his first serve did not go in and has now only one chance left (i.e. 2nd serve). Other players try to ace the first serve, pull it long and while doing 2nd serve end up doing a double fault also, at times (At least Novak falls in this trap, while facing a BP many times).kingraf wrote:It never ceases to amaze me that in the eyes of many, Nadals only weapon seems to be willpower.
can't serve
Can't volley
His initial movement is all wrong
No backhand
Has an ineffective forehand
But boy can he fight!!
Volley: Agreed, he is hooked up to base line unless drawn forward by a short ball. But when he does come to the net, he wins the point mostly.
Backhand: It has come a long way from the initial days, when it was a liability. Now, his cross-court BH is a weapon.
Forehand: As others have pointed out, the mere RPM count makes it very difficult for players other than Fed/Novak, to keep it in play. That is why he has such an enviable H2H record against all other players.
Now consider this. If I were not a fan of Nadal or Novak, and am just a neutral fan of the game as such. And if we are watching their classic matches like Rome'09 SF, AO'11 and '12, FO 12' and '13, USO'11 and '13, or even the Montreal'13, whom do you think the neutral fan supports? The one who is attacking the defensive player and going for his shots for 60-70% of the match time. Or the one who is content to return every ball, and wait for the opponent to blink before himself. I know tennis is not about winners and it is all about percentages. This is where Nadal excels. But if you watch a match like Rome09, FO13 or even Cincy13, the loser wins the heart of the neutral fans for the sheer persistence and belief in the attacking play. The irony is that, against Nadal that is the only way to win, and unfortunately other than Novak and Roger not many in modern tennis have the guts/game to beat this spin monster.
ChequeredJersey- Posts : 18707
Join date : 2011-12-23
Age : 35
Location : London, UK
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Also why would we be Rafa fans if his tennis offered nothing to the neutral? People make the assumption that fans think players are good to watch because they are fans. Logically the reverse is true, we are fans because we think they are good to watch. Unless I were Spanish, what other reason would I have to support Rafa?
ChequeredJersey- Posts : 18707
Join date : 2011-12-23
Age : 35
Location : London, UK
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Oh dear I wasn´t suggesting for a minute you were anti nadal. I merely pointed out that Rafa has not had the need to perfect that shot that has been undeniably his for as long as I can remember. I too favour Fernando Gonzalez and if you noticed my comments on the No. 1. thread you regarding forehands you would see he was my second favourite.. I too like Verdasco (on a good day.. which are few and far between these days sadly) but his forehand can be lethal. Dont care for Soderling personally but each to his ownwhocares wrote:Haddie-nuff, I didnt say its a new shot but perhaps more a tad precise than before. as for the rest, I can agree but allow me to prefer more agressive forehands from the likes of Gonzo and Soderling.
ps : before I get put in some type of anti nadal faction, I want to stress that I like Nadal both the character and tennis player.
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I agree with that observation CJ I am a fan of Rafa´s because I love to watch him play... yes I live in Spain which may appear to make me biased but if Raonic were Spanish I still wouldn´t be a fan.. if any of that makes senseChequeredJersey wrote:Also why would we be Rafa fans if his tennis offered nothing to the neutral? People make the assumption that fans think players are good to watch because they are fans. Logically the reverse is true, we are fans because we think they are good to watch. Unless I were Spanish, what other reason would I have to support Rafa?
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
In most matches Rafa has less fh winners than his opponent, feds doesn't
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Well LS he must have something going for him then if its not his fh... because he keeps winning and Fed doesntLuvSports! wrote:In most matches Rafa has less fh winners than his opponent, feds doesn't
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Yes. His ridiculous defensive skills and insane fitness levels that win him more points than his offence.
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Ha ha! laverfan. You are mischievous sometimes. Why would you use a match from 2008 were Nadal said about his play that he didn't think he could play worse to demonstrate that his forehand now is better than back then. It would be like me comparing his Wimbledon match this year with his Wimbledon win in 2008 (or his FO demolition of Federer that year...) to demonstrate his superior forehand back then.laverfan wrote:In 2008, Nadal had 82-11 with 8 titles, while in 2013, he is 61-3 with 10 titles, so his FH (using a direct proportionality) is much better now, with changes in his racquet and many other factors.ChequeredJersey wrote:LF, not sure what that puts in perspective at all?!
hawkeye- Posts : 5427
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I would think its unlikely there are that many matches where Rafa's opponent hits more FH winners. I would need some convincing that was the case.
Born Slippy- Posts : 4464
Join date : 2012-05-05
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Does best FH only include attacking FHs not defensive ones and rallying ones anyway? That would seem a stupid measure of the quality of a FH
ChequeredJersey- Posts : 18707
Join date : 2011-12-23
Age : 35
Location : London, UK
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
BS well i have seen many matches with rafa and he has hit less fh winners.
But as that would require a lot of research over the years, i doubt either could prove their point (US open rafa hit more than anyone on fh winners but in his 3 matches in beijing he hit less than his opponent each time), unless laverfan does it for us.
Fair point. I just said feds fh is better offensively.
But as that would require a lot of research over the years, i doubt either could prove their point (US open rafa hit more than anyone on fh winners but in his 3 matches in beijing he hit less than his opponent each time), unless laverfan does it for us.
Fair point. I just said feds fh is better offensively.
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I found it quite funny how many fans in Beijing where waving Spanish flags this morning. I'm not sure that this had anything to do with a large Spanish population living there or indeed could be interpreted as being representative of a display of Chinese love of the Spanish culture as a whole.Haddie-nuff wrote:I agree with that observation CJ I am a fan of Rafa´s because I love to watch him play... yes I live in Spain which may appear to make me biased but if Raonic were Spanish I still wouldn´t be a fan.. if any of that makes senseChequeredJersey wrote:Also why would we be Rafa fans if his tennis offered nothing to the neutral? People make the assumption that fans think players are good to watch because they are fans. Logically the reverse is true, we are fans because we think they are good to watch. Unless I were Spanish, what other reason would I have to support Rafa?
novak143. I suppose you could divide tennis fans into "neutral tennis fans" and "Rafa fans". But in what category would you place a neutral tennis fan who was also a Rafa fan. Would you say that the two groups are mutually exclusive? If that's the case would you say that that a neutral tennis fan who said they also liked Rafa was in denial or lying? And that really they weren't neutral at all but just a "Rafa fan". I guess you are a neutral tennis fan?
hawkeye- Posts : 5427
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
legendkillarV2. In your series of best shots maybe it would be a good idea to conclude with an article on the best tactical player? This article on forehands has shown that many are biased towards the use of high risk hit or miss forehands. They have their place of course but a good forehand is a bit more than that. I would say that a player with a good forehand should be able to demonstrate control, aggression, defense, variation of spin and speed... but also know when to use a particular forehand. Without the right tactics even a great forehand wouldn't get results
hawkeye- Posts : 5427
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I am temped to change my vote but I can't...
ChequeredJersey- Posts : 18707
Join date : 2011-12-23
Age : 35
Location : London, UK
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Sorry are Federer, Djokovic and Murray fans are neutral fans?
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
hawkeye- Posts : 5427
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
LuvSports! wrote:Yes. His ridiculous defensive skills and insane fitness levels that win him more points than his offence.
Sorry one thing to say to that LS Bovine Fertilizer
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Seems we can't even decide what 'best forehand' means, let alone who has it
JuliusHMarx- julius
- Posts : 22615
Join date : 2011-07-01
Location : Paisley Park
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
How about if you could choose a FH to have, who's would you have?
Guest- Guest
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Sorry then but if you don;t think Nadal wins more because of his offence then defence, then you're naive. When will the smileys stop?Haddie-nuff wrote:Sorry one thing to say to that LS Bovine FertilizerLuvSports! wrote:Yes. His ridiculous defensive skills and insane fitness levels that win him more points than his offence.
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I'd have JMDPs 'cos I'd like to hit the ball flat and hard like that.
If I went for my favourite player, as most people seem to do, I'd have to go for Henman
If I went for my favourite player, as most people seem to do, I'd have to go for Henman
JuliusHMarx- julius
- Posts : 22615
Join date : 2011-07-01
Location : Paisley Park
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I'd like to have Davydenko's forehead. It has a lovely peak to it.
HM Murdock- Posts : 4749
Join date : 2011-06-10
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I would want the Soderling FH. I just love his technique and wallop give the ball a good hiding!
Guest- Guest
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I think Nadal wins by using the right balance between offense and defence... its called tactics. He appears to get the balance right or or ..... ..... .....LuvSports! wrote:Sorry then but if you don;t think Nadal wins more because of his offence then defence, then you're naive. :)When will the smileys stop?Haddie-nuff wrote:Sorry one thing to say to that LS Bovine FertilizerLuvSports! wrote:Yes. His ridiculous defensive skills and insane fitness levels that win him more points than his offence.
hawkeye- Posts : 5427
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
When you want them to stop if thats your attitudeLuvSports! wrote:Sorry then but if you don;t think Nadal wins more because of his offence then defence, then you're naive. :)When will the smileys stop?Haddie-nuff wrote:Sorry one thing to say to that LS Bovine FertilizerLuvSports! wrote:Yes. His ridiculous defensive skills and insane fitness levels that win him more points than his offence.
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
LuvSports! wrote:Sorry then but if you don;t think Nadal wins more because of his offence then defence, then you're naive. :)When will the smileys stop?Haddie-nuff wrote:Sorry one thing to say to that LS Bovine FertilizerLuvSports! wrote:Yes. His ridiculous defensive skills and insane fitness levels that win him more points than his offence.
Last edited by Haddie-nuff on Fri Oct 04, 2013 6:15 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : duplicated)
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Ok how about this. I think Rafa's fh is better in defence but Fed's in attack .
Everybody wins.
Everybody wins.
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
LuvSports! wrote:Ok how about this. I think Rafa's fh is better in defence but Fed's in attack .
Everybody wins.
O goodie goodie and all done with a
But I still dont agree with you and I know that makes me sooooooooo naive
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I can remember when Federer was asked what shot he would have of Nadal's he said his forehand. I took that to mean he would exchange his own for it. (Nadal was asked the same question and he said Federer's serve)
But of course that is just their opinion. What do they know....
But of course that is just their opinion. What do they know....
hawkeye- Posts : 5427
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I think Federers is the most beautiful, but Nadals has been more effective for some time now.
CAS- Posts : 1313
Join date : 2011-06-08
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I thought Fed said none - all of his shots were better than all of Nadal's. Or maybe it was PseudoFed who said that.hawkeye wrote:I can remember when Federer was asked what shot he would have of Nadal's he said his forehand. I took that to mean he would exchange his own for it. (Nadal was asked the same question and he said Federer's serve)
But of course that is just their opinion. What do they know....
Interestingly Fed would seem to think the difference between his own BH vs Rafa's BH is less than the difference between their FHs - which means he doesn't know that much
JuliusHMarx- julius
- Posts : 22615
Join date : 2011-07-01
Location : Paisley Park
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Nadal's has also been more effective than Sampras' for some timeCAS wrote:I think Federers is the most beautiful, but Nadals has been more effective for some time now.
JuliusHMarx- julius
- Posts : 22615
Join date : 2011-07-01
Location : Paisley Park
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
At least you admit it thoughHaddie-nuff wrote:O goodie goodie and all done with aLuvSports! wrote:Ok how about this. I think Rafa's fh is better in defence but Fed's in attack .
Everybody wins.
But I still dont agree with you and I know that makes me sooooooooo naive
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Believe me LS when you can reach my age and still be called naive ... its a complimentLuvSports! wrote:At least you admit it thoughHaddie-nuff wrote:O goodie goodie and all done with aLuvSports! wrote:Ok how about this. I think Rafa's fh is better in defence but Fed's in attack .
Everybody wins.
But I still dont agree with you and I know that makes me sooooooooo naive
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
There are many such instances, v Djokovic at USO, v Safin at AO, v Monfils at Paris. He has been called the Shanker or Federror by many. My point was to show the improvement in the FH.Born Slippy wrote:I don't agree with Laver's post. It seems to be suggesting that Rafa's forehand is more highly regarded than Fed's purely because he wins more now. That's just not a fair assessment. I would probably personally give Fed's forehand the narrow edge but the fact is that, even at his absolute best, it could cough up errors against the very best. Was it the Rome final in 06 where he sprayed it all over the place on match points?
If I had to choose, and the choice was a single FH shot, my choice would be different, and not necessarily Federer.Born Slippy wrote:The fact is that if I had to choose Rafa or Fed to make a forehand under severe pressure then I would choose Rafa.
BTW, Monfils has a tremendous FH, as does (did?) Soderling, and this thread is becoming a Fedal FH discussion, less so what the OP intended.
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Nadal is unique. There are many who have beaten him, not just Djokovic or Federer.novak143 wrote:The irony is that, against Nadal that is the only way to win, and unfortunately other than Novak and Roger not many in modern tennis have the guts/game to beat this spin monster.
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
Jim Courier, during on-court interviews. BTW, they responded with wanting each other's FH, not serve and FH, IIRC.hawkeye wrote:I can remember when Federer was asked what shot he would have of Nadal's he said his forehand. I took that to mean he would exchange his own for it. (Nadal was asked the same question and he said Federer's serve)
But of course that is just their opinion. What do they know....
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I remember the same interview as HE. I don't think it was on-court.
Rafa definitely said he would like Roger's serve. I seem to recall Roger ducked the question somewhat. I don't think he named a shot of Rafa's he would like but generally praised Rafa's game instead.
Rafa definitely said he would like Roger's serve. I seem to recall Roger ducked the question somewhat. I don't think he named a shot of Rafa's he would like but generally praised Rafa's game instead.
HM Murdock- Posts : 4749
Join date : 2011-06-10
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
there was actually two, one where they tell Federer that Rafa said if he could have one shot he would have his forehand, Federer then says "well Rafa has a great forehand as well so I would take his" Then in a different year Courier said Rafa said he would take Rogers serve, so Roger just compliments Rafas all-round game
CAS- Posts : 1313
Join date : 2011-06-08
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
@CAS... Both of the Courier interviews used to be on UTube, but I cannot find either. :(The FH swap interview is the more recent one, correct?
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
I can't find it either, I actually think the one where Rafa says he would take Federers serve was the more recent one
CAS- Posts : 1313
Join date : 2011-06-08
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
It was the same year and both were interviewed by Jim Courier and I am sure Fed said Rafa's forehand and Rafa said Feds serve. I have looked but haven't been able to find it yet. But mean while I did find this and it made me laugh. Especially the bit starting at 1.50 were Federer describes his fitness routine saying "It's all talent and that he just sits on the couch" Ha ha! It made me think of a certain ex 606v2 member...laverfan wrote:Jim Courier, during on-court interviews. BTW, they responded with wanting each other's FH, not serve and FH, IIRC.hawkeye wrote:I can remember when Federer was asked what shot he would have of Nadal's he said his forehand. I took that to mean he would exchange his own for it. (Nadal was asked the same question and he said Federer's serve)
But of course that is just their opinion. What do they know....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rh6IO_sZys
I've missed Federer. But hurray he's back in Shanghai.
hawkeye- Posts : 5427
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Building The Perfect Tennis Player - Part 2 - Best Forehand
The 24-diapers comment is funny. Good to see Federer back.hawkeye wrote:Especially the bit starting at 1.50 were Federer describes his fitness routine saying "It's all talent and that he just sits on the couch" Ha ha!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rh6IO_sZys
I've missed Federer. But hurray he's back in Shanghai.
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» Building The Perfect Tennis Player Part 2 - Best Forehand
» Building The Perfect Tennis Player Part 3 - The Backhand
» Building The Perfect Player (Part 1 - The Best Serve)
» Building the Perfect Tennis Player - Best Serve
» Which superpower would be most useful as a tennis player?
» Building The Perfect Tennis Player Part 3 - The Backhand
» Building The Perfect Player (Part 1 - The Best Serve)
» Building the Perfect Tennis Player - Best Serve
» Which superpower would be most useful as a tennis player?
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Tennis
Page 2 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum