The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
+10
Standulstermen
Notch
SecretFly
Pot Hale
2ndtimeround
Rory_Gallagher
LeinsterFan4life
cakeordeath
ScarletSpiderman
PenfroPete
14 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 1 of 1
The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
BBC2 Northern Ireland !!
PenfroPete- Posts : 3415
Join date : 2011-05-13
Age : 63
Location : Pentre'r Eglwys, Cymru
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Ooohhh you can't say things like that. Anyway, to be fair it's BBC NI so it should be a bit one eyed, the same as S4C should, if not BBC NI should be more one eyed as their target audience are Ulster fans and potential Ulster fans.
ScarletSpiderman- Posts : 9944
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 40
Location : Pembs
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
It couldn't have been any worse than what I heard of the commentary for the Ireland vs England U20 game
cakeordeath- Posts : 1945
Join date : 2012-11-25
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Have you ever watched a CC game on BT?
LeinsterFan4life- Posts : 6174
Join date : 2012-03-13
Age : 34
Location : Meath
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
To be fair there were a few dubious decisions that went against Ulster in that game, and I don't think Neilly was too impressed with them.
ScarletsSpiderman - you are coming across as extremely bitter towards Ulster/Ireland these days. Quite a change in character, I must say. I hope you can get over it, you are a good poster usually.
ScarletsSpiderman - you are coming across as extremely bitter towards Ulster/Ireland these days. Quite a change in character, I must say. I hope you can get over it, you are a good poster usually.
Rory_Gallagher- Posts : 11324
Join date : 2011-09-18
Age : 32
Location : Belfast
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Was a bit one sided but at least they talked about the teams that where actually playing unlike the English commentary on S4C where they spend most the game talking sh1t about anything other than the game.
2ndtimeround- Posts : 595
Join date : 2011-01-30
Location : Wales
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Rory_Gallagher wrote:
ScarletsSpiderman - you are coming across as extremely bitter towards Ulster/Ireland these days. Quite a change in character, I must say. I hope you can get over it, you are a good poster usually.
I thought his observation about BBC NI commentary being somewhat biased towards the home team was spot on - it is. Understandably. As is RTE. As is BBC Wales, S4C, BBC alba, BT sport, etc, etc.
Pot Hale- Posts : 7781
Join date : 2011-06-05
Age : 62
Location : North East
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Rory_Gallagher wrote:To be fair there were a few dubious decisions that went against Ulster in that game, and I don't think Neilly was too impressed with them.
ScarletsSpiderman - you are coming across as extremely bitter towards Ulster/Ireland these days. Quite a change in character, I must say. I hope you can get over it, you are a good poster usually.
I don't think his post on this page is bitter really. It just says that all regional coverage is a bit biased.
Guest- Guest
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
The lack of understanding of the laws was incredible. Yess, the Nick Williams 'clear out' has not been penalised a lot, but by laws it was illegal. Credit to the IRFU assistant and to Ben Whitehouse for reviewing
PenfroPete- Posts : 3415
Join date : 2011-05-13
Age : 63
Location : Pentre'r Eglwys, Cymru
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Rory, not sure what I said wrong. I defended the commentary team, and even explained that if anything they should be bias. I expect a bit of bias towards the target audience, hence I expect BBCNI to be bias towards Ulster as I wxpect S4C to be bias to the Welsh.
I'm not sure what I said wrong, but hey-ho if you wish take it as a slur then feel free.
I'm not sure what I said wrong, but hey-ho if you wish take it as a slur then feel free.
ScarletSpiderman- Posts : 9944
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 40
Location : Pembs
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
I know it's all fun and games, and admittedly most of it keeps this place alive.........................just about........................ but sometimes even I begin to want to tear my hair out of my head.
Will you guys ever just watch the f**king rugby please!!!!
If it's not the Ref making biased decisions,
it's a TMO giving judgements on things he shouldn't be allowed give judgements on,
it's fans booing too much,
or being smarmy bastards for pretending they don't boo (oh we know yous do you Irish eejits!! Yes, it's you we mean!!)
or commentators having no 'Nollidge' and Pundits having too few details or too much blonde bimbo hair or............................
Just watch the game, for Christ's sake.... and then have a quiet beer of happiness or a miserable one of total grief.
Will you guys ever just watch the f**king rugby please!!!!
If it's not the Ref making biased decisions,
it's a TMO giving judgements on things he shouldn't be allowed give judgements on,
it's fans booing too much,
or being smarmy bastards for pretending they don't boo (oh we know yous do you Irish eejits!! Yes, it's you we mean!!)
or commentators having no 'Nollidge' and Pundits having too few details or too much blonde bimbo hair or............................
Just watch the game, for Christ's sake.... and then have a quiet beer of happiness or a miserable one of total grief.
SecretFly- Posts : 31800
Join date : 2011-12-12
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
BBC NI are biased. But I like Jim Neilly- it's that eejit Ryan Constable who is the worst of it. Neilly may be biased towards Ulster a bit but he's fair in that he will criticise bad play from Ulster and applaud good play from the opposition. He's a gentleman.
Constable though, he's ridiculous. He's the agent of half the Ulster players for goodness sake. Impartial observer? No chance. Never criticises Ulster even when they are at their most wretched. Doesn't even mention the opposition. Just uses the 80 mins to talk up the players he represents. Complete BS the BBC pay him to commentate when there is such a big conflict of interest.
Constable though, he's ridiculous. He's the agent of half the Ulster players for goodness sake. Impartial observer? No chance. Never criticises Ulster even when they are at their most wretched. Doesn't even mention the opposition. Just uses the 80 mins to talk up the players he represents. Complete BS the BBC pay him to commentate when there is such a big conflict of interest.
Notch- Moderator
- Posts : 25635
Join date : 2011-02-10
Age : 36
Location : Belfast
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Yep, love big Jim. He's an institution. Constable can do one.
Standulstermen- Posts : 5451
Join date : 2011-02-16
Age : 41
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
He gets a bit of stick for getting names wrong and stuff. Well he constantly gets the names of Ulster players wrong too.
Notch- Moderator
- Posts : 25635
Join date : 2011-02-10
Age : 36
Location : Belfast
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Newsflash all commentators are biased depending on where they are from etc etc even if they don't want to admit it.
I like Jim as a commentator yes he's biased, yes he gets names wrong and stuff but it's kinda part of the charm lol Constable's an idiot though as Notch says he reps half the team don't know why he's even there, maybe he's cheap?
I like Jim as a commentator yes he's biased, yes he gets names wrong and stuff but it's kinda part of the charm lol Constable's an idiot though as Notch says he reps half the team don't know why he's even there, maybe he's cheap?
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Paddy Wallace has started an agency hasn't he? Is he still punditing?
Standulstermen- Posts : 5451
Join date : 2011-02-16
Age : 41
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Paddy still pundits here and there for SKY and BBC the problem I have with constable is that he is not just a pundit but on the commentary team most of the time and it's always on Ulster and there is no reason he couldn't do both but Constable is so biased it's a joke
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
ScarletSpiderman wrote:Rory, not sure what I said wrong. I defended the commentary team, and even explained that if anything they should be bias. I expect a bit of bias towards the target audience, hence I expect BBCNI to be bias towards Ulster as I wxpect S4C to be bias to the Welsh.
I'm not sure what I said wrong, but hey-ho if you wish take it as a slur then feel free.
You didn't say anything wrong, it was just an observation over the past few days. I thought it was a continuation with the "you can't say that" comment, it just all seemed a bit out of character. Anyway, what I said was intended to be a light hearted and not taken seriously, but indeed I have failed miserably (with my comment reported, bizarrely). Apologies.
Rory_Gallagher- Posts : 11324
Join date : 2011-09-18
Age : 32
Location : Belfast
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
PenfroPete wrote:The lack of understanding of the laws was incredible. Yess, the Nick Williams 'clear out' has not been penalised a lot, but by laws it was illegal. Credit to the IRFU assistant and to Ben Whitehouse for reviewing
Yeah, Neilly was wrong to be upset with that penalty (a yellow would have been very harsh though) but the same thing happened later on in the game to Clive Ross (possibly in the last passage of play leading up to the Scarlets try).
Rory_Gallagher- Posts : 11324
Join date : 2011-09-18
Age : 32
Location : Belfast
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
All local tv broadcasters are naturally biased - Gusher is one of the lesser biased ones. I often watch a game live on one channel and record it on another to watch later to get both sets of commentaries. My litmus test for biased commentary is how many times they question the referee, which is mostly done by the pundit rather than the main commentator. Gusher normally tries to praise the ref if he can.
The Scots esp. John Beattie is probably top of the one-eyed poll, but Stuart Davies and Gwyn Jones aren't far behind. Jiffy is well down the list and is less biased covering Tests than the regions. I agree with Notch about Constable, but I'd still rather have him than McWhirter or Field.
The Scots esp. John Beattie is probably top of the one-eyed poll, but Stuart Davies and Gwyn Jones aren't far behind. Jiffy is well down the list and is less biased covering Tests than the regions. I agree with Notch about Constable, but I'd still rather have him than McWhirter or Field.
The Great Aukster- Posts : 5246
Join date : 2011-06-09
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
The good news is I had a word with the production staff so the next time we get Ulster on Sky we won't have McCormish said constantly when there is no R in his name lol Mind you I hope the next time we see Ulster on Sky we don't hear McCormish or McComish being mentioned
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Keeping the Worst theme going, BBC write up on the game said Kevin Phillips scored the final try of the game.
ScarletSpiderman- Posts : 9944
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 40
Location : Pembs
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
ScarletSpiderman wrote:Keeping the Worst theme going, BBC write up on the game said Kevin Phillips scored the final try of the game.
Notch- Moderator
- Posts : 25635
Join date : 2011-02-10
Age : 36
Location : Belfast
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
ScarletSpiderman wrote:Keeping the Worst theme going, BBC write up on the game said Kevin Phillips scored the final try of the game.
You know I was watching last night and I didn't see that mate, I mean I'm not the most observant of people but I think I would have noticed if Kevin Phillips had of scored that final try, that's not something you would tend to miss lol but hey if the BBC said it's true then I won't question it lol
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Notch wrote:BBC NI are biased. But I like Jim Neilly- it's that eejit Ryan Constable who is the worst of it. Neilly may be biased towards Ulster a bit but he's fair in that he will criticise bad play from Ulster and applaud good play from the opposition. He's a gentleman.
Constable though, he's ridiculous. He's the agent of half the Ulster players for goodness sake. Impartial observer? No chance. Never criticises Ulster even when they are at their most wretched. Doesn't even mention the opposition. Just uses the 80 mins to talk up the players he represents. Complete BS the BBC pay him to commentate when there is such a big conflict of interest.
Could not agree more. Neilly can actually be quite comical and I see him as the Ulsters Brian Moore. Constable has no place commenting, the guy is a complete and utter *&^%$.
Nachos Jones- Posts : 2232
Join date : 2013-11-15
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
No Brian Moore is the kind of guy you'd hate to be stuck in an elevator with, whereas Neilly would be a great guy to go and get a pint with.
Notch- Moderator
- Posts : 25635
Join date : 2011-02-10
Age : 36
Location : Belfast
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
I don't know, I really like Brian Moore (hated him at first but really like him now) and think he would also be a good guy to have a pint with.
As for being stuck in an elevator. One of my worst fears, hate the damn things.
As for being stuck in an elevator. One of my worst fears, hate the damn things.
Nachos Jones- Posts : 2232
Join date : 2013-11-15
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
Can't see why anyone would have a problem with local commentators being fans and supporters of the local teams. I prefer it, whether I am with 'em or again 'em. Almost all Rugby fans, commentators and civilians like us, all have our favourite teams. To me, it's always better to be open about that. Why not?The Great Aukster wrote:All local tv broadcasters are naturally biased - Gusher is one of the lesser biased ones. I often watch a game live on one channel and record it on another to watch later to get both sets of commentaries. My litmus test for biased commentary is how many times they question the referee, which is mostly done by the pundit rather than the main commentator. Gusher normally tries to praise the ref if he can.
The Scots esp. John Beattie is probably top of the one-eyed poll, but Stuart Davies and Gwyn Jones aren't far behind. Jiffy is well down the list and is less biased covering Tests than the regions. I agree with Notch about Constable, but I'd still rather have him than McWhirter or Field.
doctor_grey- Posts : 12279
Join date : 2011-04-30
Re: The 'JIFFY' award for totally biased commentary goes to.....
The problem for me Dr G is that if the commentators question the referee it legitimises witch hunts by fans. In the Pro12 this is accentuated because the referees are chosen by nationality and that naturally gives ammunition to the conspiracy theorists. I don't think the Pro12 referees are any worse that those in the AP for example but the fact that a ref is from another country (or a specific one) is just another prejudiced excuse to lose objectivity on their actual performance with the whistle.
The Great Aukster- Posts : 5246
Join date : 2011-06-09
Similar topics
» HBO's Commentary - Biased?
» Biased British Commentary - Is it getting worse ???
» Springboks may have a totally new look loose trio.
» A tribute to Jiffy
» Jiffy poll
» Biased British Commentary - Is it getting worse ???
» Springboks may have a totally new look loose trio.
» A tribute to Jiffy
» Jiffy poll
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum