Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
+25
Happytravelling
catchweight
EdWoodjr
theanimal316
RanjitPatel
Rodney
Marlonz
.aveyard2.0
Rowley
Eyetoldyouso
Scottrf
longgame
Nico the gman
Coxy001
horizontalhero
hampo17
AlexHuckerby
Lance
TopHat24/7
88Chris05
Hammersmith harrier
kingraf
AdamT
irishbrads
TRUSSMAN66
29 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Boxing
Page 3 of 3
Page 3 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
First topic message reminder :
Manny
-------
Mike Tyson.....Bonecrusher Smith.....Miguel Cotto....Marvin Hagler......Oscar DelaHoya......Larry Holmes...Johnny Nelson....Nonito Donaire......Muhammad Ali ?? ......Ivan Robinson.....Timothy Bradley......
Mayweather
-------------
Ray Leonard...Keith Thurman.....Tony Bellew....Adrien Broner....Iran Barkley....Charles Brewer.....Tommy Hearns....Montell Griffin....Deontay Wilder....Ray Mancini.....Kell Brook.........JMM.......Chris Algieri...Amir Khan...Nigel Benn.......Wlad Klit...
Manny
-------
Mike Tyson.....Bonecrusher Smith.....Miguel Cotto....Marvin Hagler......Oscar DelaHoya......Larry Holmes...Johnny Nelson....Nonito Donaire......Muhammad Ali ?? ......Ivan Robinson.....Timothy Bradley......
Mayweather
-------------
Ray Leonard...Keith Thurman.....Tony Bellew....Adrien Broner....Iran Barkley....Charles Brewer.....Tommy Hearns....Montell Griffin....Deontay Wilder....Ray Mancini.....Kell Brook.........JMM.......Chris Algieri...Amir Khan...Nigel Benn.......Wlad Klit...
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40654
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
88Chris05 wrote:Hammersmith harrier wrote:At the end of the day Clements did absolutely nothing wrong in scoring that round 10-7 but it looks like the Pacquiao fans are getting their excuses ready already. Expect a full blown conspiracy of how Bayless and the judges were in Mayweathers back pocket to ensure he won despite recently being on the end of three fairly awful judging displays.
Or we're just having a bit of a debate about scoring a fight.
That isn't why it was initially brought up, it was brought up as a pre-emptive excuse by a Manny Pacquiao fan.
Hammersmith harrier- Posts : 12060
Join date : 2013-09-26
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Scottrf wrote:I think you'd need significant changes to the 10 point must system to justify any radical changes in the scoring of knockdowns.
It doesn't really make sense that it's encouraged to split level-ish rounds, and these are on par with fairly dominant rounds which aren't quite 10-8 worthy.
Unless there's more discretion used then I think scoring knockdowns as they are now is fairest.
In the old days all rounds counted as one....... Scotty................You think that's fairer...............It might be.....Walcott beat Charles 8-7 on two cards in there Heavy title fight...
Bruce Curry lost 6-4 to Wilfred Benitez when he decked him three times overall in various rounds...........With 10 point must he wins pretty comfortably.....
Maybe I prefer round by round ...............10-1-1 sounds good to me..
![Wink](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_wink.gif)
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40654
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
I'd like at least some analysis of the opposite, something like 10-10 even or insignificant win, 10-9 close but significant win, 10-8 clear, 10-7 dominant. I think it would give more indication of the flow of the fight and less influence to rounds which are awarded without clear reason.TRUSSMAN66 wrote:In the old days all rounds counted as one....... Scotty................You think that's fairer
Maybe that's too open to abuse though, I don't know, but I think more control is better.
Scottrf- Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Judges are the most important part of the puzzle.......Getting rid of the incompetent and bent ones.........
But as it won't happen all scoring systems will be flawed..
Remember the Mexican judge had Chavez up by two against Meldrick..........
They should be arrested..........
But as it won't happen all scoring systems will be flawed..
Remember the Mexican judge had Chavez up by two against Meldrick..........
They should be arrested..........
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40654
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
If boxing was only ever scored by rounds it'd become pretty turgid pretty quickly.
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Scottrf wrote:I'd like at least some analysis of the opposite, something like 10-10 even or insignificant win, 10-9 close but significant win, 10-8 clear, 10-7 dominant. I think it would give more indication of the flow of the fight and less influence to rounds which are awarded without clear reason.TRUSSMAN66 wrote:In the old days all rounds counted as one....... Scotty................You think that's fairer
Maybe that's too open to abuse though, I don't know, but I think more control is better.
I find myself largely in agreement with this, still don't think it addresses the issue of incompetence, but it seems ridiculous you can batter a guy from pillar to post and receive exactly the same as a round where you maybe land one or two punches more. I appreciate judges have the facility to do this currently, but how frequently do we really see a ten eight round without a knockdown? It is remarkably infrequently.
Rowley- Admin
- Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
The 2 main reasons I see a Pacman win in this fight is that I believe Floyd has declined further than Manny, and Freddie Roach.
If memory serves me right the 2 fights against Maidana are the most punches Floyd has received in any previous fight. A guy like Maidana wouldn't have got near the Floyd of the 00s. While Manny's power is not what it was, his volume and accuracy coming from a tricky southpaw stance should see Mayweather take more punishment than any fight to date, enough for a stoppage I believe.
Secondly, Roach seems obsessed with beating Mayweather. He is a decisive figure Roach but a coach I rate very highly. I am inclined to believe him that he believes he has the game plan for Manny to win.
If memory serves me right the 2 fights against Maidana are the most punches Floyd has received in any previous fight. A guy like Maidana wouldn't have got near the Floyd of the 00s. While Manny's power is not what it was, his volume and accuracy coming from a tricky southpaw stance should see Mayweather take more punishment than any fight to date, enough for a stoppage I believe.
Secondly, Roach seems obsessed with beating Mayweather. He is a decisive figure Roach but a coach I rate very highly. I am inclined to believe him that he believes he has the game plan for Manny to win.
theanimal316- Posts : 471
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 38
Location : Belfast
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Nazim Richardson said the same about Mosley but with the following caveat "It's ok having a battle plan but you need a soldier who can carry out those orders."theanimal316 wrote:The 2 main reasons I see a Pacman win in this fight is that I believe Floyd has declined further than Manny, and Freddie Roach.
If memory serves me right the 2 fights against Maidana are the most punches Floyd has received in any previous fight. A guy like Maidana wouldn't have got near the Floyd of the 00s. While Manny's power is not what it was, his volume and accuracy coming from a tricky southpaw stance should see Mayweather take more punishment than any fight to date, enough for a stoppage I believe.
Secondly, Roach seems obsessed with beating Mayweather. He is a decisive figure Roach but a coach I rate very highly. I am inclined to believe him that he believes he has the game plan for Manny to win.
Everyone "knows" how to beat Mayweather but no-one's been able to execute this pi$$ easy game plan to date. Maybe Manny can do it but he's giving away a lot of reach and I can't see him getting in and out without getting caught himself. If Mayweather lands a big shot early, it may deter Manny and put him off. Do we know if Roach has a plan B,C,D,E,F and so on cos Manny might just need it
Guest- Guest
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
18/1 for Mayweather 10-12 has to be worth a look.
EdWoodjr- Posts : 410
Join date : 2011-05-16
Age : 57
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Not sure how the fight will play out but unless there is a KO there is a good chance the cards will lend themselves towards getting mileage out of a rematch. Think of Mayweather against de la Hoya and Alvarez.
catchweight- Posts : 4339
Join date : 2013-09-18
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Well, Mike Tyson certainly isn't sitting on the fence:
http://www.boxingnews24.com/2015/04/mike-tyson-goes-off-on-mayweather-calls-him-dirt-delusional-and-a-small-scared-man/
What had Floyd done to him?
Anyone know why Tyson has such a dislike?
http://www.boxingnews24.com/2015/04/mike-tyson-goes-off-on-mayweather-calls-him-dirt-delusional-and-a-small-scared-man/
What had Floyd done to him?
Anyone know why Tyson has such a dislike?
Happytravelling- Posts : 889
Join date : 2011-07-23
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
“I try to stay as far away from dirt as possible,” Tyson told USA TODAY Sports, “I was always told by my mother that if you can’t say anything nice about someone, don’t say nothing.”
Umm....
Umm....
Scottrf- Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
See Mayweather failed to submit his gloves in time for the Nevada deadline, which probably means sod all as they'll do nowt about it (make him wear ones pre-picked from the commission)
Cheers, Rodders
Cheers, Rodders
Rodney- Posts : 1974
Join date : 2011-02-15
Age : 46
Location : Thirsk
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
The Ring polled 50 fighters, trainers, journos etc and the result was 42-6 in favour of Mayweather Jr and 2 undecided.
Floyd looks tired, bless him. Mean he may not pummel Manny quite as badly.
Floyd looks tired, bless him. Mean he may not pummel Manny quite as badly.
Coxy001- Posts : 1816
Join date : 2014-11-10
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Coxy001 wrote:The Ring polled 50 fighters, trainers, journos etc and the result was 42-6 in favour of Mayweather Jr and 2 undecided.
Floyd looks tired, bless him. Mean he may not pummel Manny quite as badly.
Has he ever pummeled anyone ? If Mayweather attacks which for the life of me can't understand why anyone would think this , he is going to get sparked out IMO. The safe bet is he'll move and outbox/potshot Manny.
Cheers, Rodders
Rodney- Posts : 1974
Join date : 2011-02-15
Age : 46
Location : Thirsk
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cW7oj7QosjARodney wrote:Has he ever pummeled anyone ?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5q57ZboGw0
You're welcome.
Scottrf- Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
You're welcome Rodders
JabMachineMK2- Posts : 2383
Join date : 2012-02-09
Age : 104
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
That was over 10 years ago.
Cheers, rodders
Cheers, rodders
Rodney- Posts : 1974
Join date : 2011-02-15
Age : 46
Location : Thirsk
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
What's your point.....
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40654
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Rodney wrote:That was over 10 years ago.
Cheers, rodders
You asked has he ever pummelled anyone? No you've been proven wrong, don't change your argument.
hampo17- Admin
- Posts : 9108
Join date : 2011-02-24
Age : 36
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Point is ill be very surprised if it's a pummelling as he hasn't pummelled anyone in recent times.
Cheers, rodders
Cheers, rodders
Rodney- Posts : 1974
Join date : 2011-02-15
Age : 46
Location : Thirsk
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Rodney wrote:Point is ill be very surprised if it's a pummelling as he hasn't pummelled anyone in recent times.
Cheers, rodders
Not like the old timers used to..
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40654
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
People do get awfully upset if you criticise a convicted wife beater on here.
Morals not very high.
Cheers, rodders
Morals not very high.
Cheers, rodders
Rodney- Posts : 1974
Join date : 2011-02-15
Age : 46
Location : Thirsk
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Rodney wrote:People do get awfully upset if you criticise a convicted wife beater on here.
Morals not very high.
Cheers, rodders
Very cheap Roddy...
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40654
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
TRUSSMAN66 wrote:Rodney wrote:People do get awfully upset if you criticise a convicted wife beater on here.
Morals not very high.
Cheers, rodders
Very cheap Roddy...
Rodders normally comes across as fairly level headed, but on this subject you'd swear Floyd had taken a big steaming dump over his christmas dinner.
hampo17- Admin
- Posts : 9108
Join date : 2011-02-24
Age : 36
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
After all what do the two Sugars know about wife beating.
Hammersmith harrier- Posts : 12060
Join date : 2013-09-26
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
EdWoodjr wrote:18/1 for Mayweather 10-12 has to be worth a look.
22/1 in ladbrokes for the same bet. 18/1 for rounds 7-9
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Hammersmith harrier wrote:After all what do the two Sugars know about wife beating.
They didn't avoid beating their wives hammy. They did it more frequently in those days... they only used the one belt too
milkyboy- Posts : 7761
Join date : 2011-05-22
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
milkyboy wrote:Hammersmith harrier wrote:After all what do the two Sugars know about wife beating.
They didn't avoid beating their wives hammy. They did it more frequently in those days... they only used the one belt too
Yes but they used to beat their Wives better in those days..
Kids of today haven't got a clue how to do it properly..
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40654
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Too many alphabet belts these days. floyd has around 10, suppose he needs to make use of them
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
All the best fellas and enjoy a once in a generation clash !!!
Only brightside is If Manny wins I won't have to watch it !!
Only brightside is If Manny wins I won't have to watch it !!
![Wink](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_wink.gif)
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40654
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Good luck Truss.
Manny is getting knocked out. The oracle has spoken
Manny is getting knocked out. The oracle has spoken
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
The partisanship towards Mayweather and the lengths some posters go to champion him is different to other fighters. Maybe D4 hardened peoples resolve when it came to defending Mayweather.
Floyd has been described as boring by some and this has been met with deep distain and accusations about not understanding the sweet science. Most of the posters I enjoy though seem to not like Mayweather.
Floyd has been described as boring by some and this has been met with deep distain and accusations about not understanding the sweet science. Most of the posters I enjoy though seem to not like Mayweather.
Strongback- Posts : 6529
Join date : 2011-07-01
Location : Matchroom Sports Head Office
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Morning Strongy
There's a difference between Mayweather the man and Mayweather the boxer.
Can't stand the man, but as a boxer there's no denying the talent, unfortunately boxing is/has and always will be filled with people of a certain nature due to the simple nature of the sport.
As fans we like boxers for different reasons, some enjoy the sweet science, others want to see someone KO'd every time and so on and so forth.
Super fans of anyone can be really annoying due to the inability to see any faults with the 'other side'
There's a difference between Mayweather the man and Mayweather the boxer.
Can't stand the man, but as a boxer there's no denying the talent, unfortunately boxing is/has and always will be filled with people of a certain nature due to the simple nature of the sport.
As fans we like boxers for different reasons, some enjoy the sweet science, others want to see someone KO'd every time and so on and so forth.
Super fans of anyone can be really annoying due to the inability to see any faults with the 'other side'
Derbymanc- Posts : 4008
Join date : 2013-10-14
Location : Manchester
Re: Boxers divided on - Mayweather vs Pacman ....
Good post Derby and agree. Don't care much for him as a person but think he is an amazing fighter.
I will give Pac his dues if he wins as long as there is no controversy. If Floyd wins with controversy, I will rightfully say Manny should of won.
I like banter and have my fav fighters, however a spade is a spade with me.
Hope it's a cracking fight.
I will give Pac his dues if he wins as long as there is no controversy. If Floyd wins with controversy, I will rightfully say Manny should of won.
I like banter and have my fav fighters, however a spade is a spade with me.
Hope it's a cracking fight.
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Page 3 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
![-](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif)
» Mayweather vs Pacman doesnt seem as exciting anymore?
» Divided loyalties
» Frampo v Quigg week - Experts divided !!
» WHY MAYWEATHER IS A TOP 10 ALLTIMER ALREADY!!
» Khan vs Pacman
» Divided loyalties
» Frampo v Quigg week - Experts divided !!
» WHY MAYWEATHER IS A TOP 10 ALLTIMER ALREADY!!
» Khan vs Pacman
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Boxing
Page 3 of 3
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|