The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
+5
RanjitPatel
Adam D
hazharrison
AdamT
TRUSSMAN66
9 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Boxing
Page 1 of 1
The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
In my humble opinion.....
1. FRAZIER vs Ali
2. ALI vs Foreman
3. SCHMELLING vs Louis
4. FOREMAN vs Frazier
5. DOUGLAS vs Tyson
6. BOWE vs Holyfield
7. FITZSIMMONS vs Corbett
8. SPINKS vs Holmes
9. TUNNEY vs Dempsey
10. ALI vs Liston
11. LANGFORD vs Wills
12. WILLARD vs Johnson
13. BRADDOCK vs Baer
14. SANDERS vs Klitscho
15. HOLMES vs Norton
16. HOLYFIELD vs Tyson
17. CORBETT vs Sullivan
18. LEWIS vs Holyfield
19. COETZEE vs Dokes
20. BURNS vs Hart
1. FRAZIER vs Ali
2. ALI vs Foreman
3. SCHMELLING vs Louis
4. FOREMAN vs Frazier
5. DOUGLAS vs Tyson
6. BOWE vs Holyfield
7. FITZSIMMONS vs Corbett
8. SPINKS vs Holmes
9. TUNNEY vs Dempsey
10. ALI vs Liston
11. LANGFORD vs Wills
12. WILLARD vs Johnson
13. BRADDOCK vs Baer
14. SANDERS vs Klitscho
15. HOLMES vs Norton
16. HOLYFIELD vs Tyson
17. CORBETT vs Sullivan
18. LEWIS vs Holyfield
19. COETZEE vs Dokes
20. BURNS vs Hart
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40685
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Louis vs Schmelling 2
Marciano vs Walcott (that punch)
Johnson vs Burns (first black champ)
Tyson vs Spinks
Good list Truss, not saying these should be top 20, but a few more that could be considered.
Marciano vs Walcott (that punch)
Johnson vs Burns (first black champ)
Tyson vs Spinks
Good list Truss, not saying these should be top 20, but a few more that could be considered.
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
I'd have Bowe over Holyfield higher: Schmeling over Louis and Douglas over Tyson are wins that come with caveats (Louis had only been a pro two years and Tyson was a mess).
I'd have Langford over Wills higher; Holyfield over Bowe should figure and Louis over Schmeling looks a glaring omission. Marciano over Charles was a great win as was Walcott over Ezzard and how about Foreman over Moorer? Liston over Patterson? Patterson over Johansson?
I'd have Langford over Wills higher; Holyfield over Bowe should figure and Louis over Schmeling looks a glaring omission. Marciano over Charles was a great win as was Walcott over Ezzard and how about Foreman over Moorer? Liston over Patterson? Patterson over Johansson?
hazharrison- Posts : 7540
Join date : 2011-03-26
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Tyson vs Spinks is a great call.
hazharrison- Posts : 7540
Join date : 2011-03-26
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Spinks vs Ali?
Ali was past it but Spinks was a novice.
Ali was past it but Spinks was a novice.
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Should have been more specific..............Tried to base it on quality of the champion, overall performance and historical impact....
Schmelling had lost to Sharkey coming in to Louis...
Marciano was being outboxed....
Burns was a midget...
Spinks... well......
I see where you are coming though mate....Appreciate the contribution..
Schmelling had lost to Sharkey coming in to Louis...
Marciano was being outboxed....
Burns was a midget...
Spinks... well......
I see where you are coming though mate....Appreciate the contribution..
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40685
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
I would have Ali vs Liston right up there with Foreman
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
I think you have a point there...
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40685
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
I think the third Ali vs Frazier fight should be considered too.
Great list.
Great list.
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Adam D wrote:I think the third Ali vs Frazier fight should be considered too.
Great list.
It was considered mate....Maybe it belongs I don't know...probably...I have Baer-Braddock on there and whilst Braddy was the second biggest underdog in history....Baer did clown it away.....It does get weak at the end of the list with Coetzee - Dokes on there etc..
Certainly the greatest heavy fight of alltime..
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40685
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
What about Johnson v Jeffries?
Jeffries coming back after a 6 year retirement to try to take the title back for the white man and failing. The fight of the century and the racial hatred at the time gives this fight huge historical significance.
Jeffries coming back after a 6 year retirement to try to take the title back for the white man and failing. The fight of the century and the racial hatred at the time gives this fight huge historical significance.
RanjitPatel- Posts : 692
Join date : 2013-02-26
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
RanjitPatel wrote:What about Johnson v Jeffries?
Jeffries coming back after a 6 year retirement to try to take the title back for the white man and failing. The fight of the century and the racial hatred at the time gives this fight huge historical significance.
Another cracker (the pick not Jeffries).
hazharrison- Posts : 7540
Join date : 2011-03-26
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Yeah Johnson vs Jeffries is a great shout.
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
hazharrison wrote:RanjitPatel wrote:What about Johnson v Jeffries?
Jeffries coming back after a 6 year retirement to try to take the title back for the white man and failing. The fight of the century and the racial hatred at the time gives this fight huge historical significance.
Another cracker (the pick not Jeffries).
Not really sure what was great about beating Jeffries...at that time..
It's not an article about the twenty most historic wins...
It's about challengers beating quality champions or vice versa...........Jeffries was old and fat....
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40685
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
In that case a Baer who hadn't trained should be nowhere near the list. It's an underdog story, not that great a win otherwise.
Either Rahman or McCall's wins against Lewis are better.
Either Rahman or McCall's wins against Lewis are better.
Scottrf- Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Or Lewis against Vitali.
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Quality of champion, performance and historical impact are the criteria you said. Historical impact of the fight makes us for the performance of Jeffries which couldn't be helped.
Louis v Schmelling is bigger and Johnson v Burns, maybe, but not much else for the impact it had, in my opinion. Huge at the time.
Louis v Schmelling is bigger and Johnson v Burns, maybe, but not much else for the impact it had, in my opinion. Huge at the time.
RanjitPatel- Posts : 692
Join date : 2013-02-26
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
RanjitPatel wrote:Quality of champion, performance and historical impact are the criteria you said. Historical impact of the fight makes us for the performance of Jeffries which couldn't be helped.
Louis v Schmelling is bigger and Johnson v Burns, maybe, but not much else for the impact it had, in my opinion. Huge at the time.
Schmelling was beaten by Sharkey.....and was pretty ordinary anyway...
All the other guys beaten in the list....Beat decent champions......
Just the way i say it.....Quality of champion/challenger at the time is my number 1 criteria..
Last edited by TRUSSMAN66 on Wed Jul 08, 2015 12:30 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : ..)
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40685
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Johnson -Burns is the most historically significant fight of all. Louis and Ali were significant figures of their day, by they were a product of their times whereas Johnson shaped his times- the fight against Burns impacted upon race relations in the US as much as Rosa Parks not giving up her seat on the bus- it affected the course of race -relations. The results started a ripple of riots and violence that spread right across America. Other fights had higher quality participants, were better fights, made more money but nothing comes close in how important is was.
horizontalhero- Posts : 938
Join date : 2011-05-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
David Haye vs Audley Harrison
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Martin Rogan v Matt Skelton
shenglong2015- Posts : 513
Join date : 2015-07-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Big Skelton would throw the head in him.
I was at the first Frampton vs Martinez fight.
Big Rogie fought a four rounder against some guy that looks like he was pulled from the bar. He was a big lump.
I was at the first Frampton vs Martinez fight.
Big Rogie fought a four rounder against some guy that looks like he was pulled from the bar. He was a big lump.
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
I wrote it as tongue in cheek Adam, but the Rogan v Skelton fight was an absolute barnstormer, and when big Rogie sent the Bedford Bear across the ring in the 11th round and stopped him, well it was jubilation! We had a heavy that potnetially could do something, alas the Sexton debacles and everything that followed thereafter, the fallout with John Breen/Magee and so on......
Talk of Rogie fighting Big Sexy Sean Turner for the Irish Heavyweight Title - have you see Sean Turner fight yet? (Talk about big lumps lol)....hes one hell of a character!
Talk of Rogie fighting Big Sexy Sean Turner for the Irish Heavyweight Title - have you see Sean Turner fight yet? (Talk about big lumps lol)....hes one hell of a character!
shenglong2015- Posts : 513
Join date : 2015-07-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Awh man if only you seen the guy he was fighting that night. He looked like some big lump you would see bouncing at the local sh.thole and would have no bother throwing the head in you.
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
shenglong2015 wrote:I wrote it as tongue in cheek Adam, but the Rogan v Skelton fight was an absolute barnstormer, and when big Rogie sent the Bedford Bear across the ring in the 11th round and stopped him, well it was jubilation! We had a heavy that potnetially could do something, alas the Sexton debacles and everything that followed thereafter, the fallout with John Breen/Magee and so on......
Talk of Rogie fighting Big Sexy Sean Turner for the Irish Heavyweight Title - have you see Sean Turner fight yet? (Talk about big lumps lol)....hes one hell of a character!
Not interested in Irish garbage..
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40685
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Don't be racist Truss!
AdamT- Posts : 6651
Join date : 2014-03-27
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Jim Jefferies v Tom Sharkey 2.
One of the greatest fights in heavyweight history between two of the best of their day over 25 bruising rounds. Some debatable judging to add to the pot.
One of the greatest fights in heavyweight history between two of the best of their day over 25 bruising rounds. Some debatable judging to add to the pot.
Strongback- Posts : 6529
Join date : 2011-07-01
Location : Matchroom Sports Head Office
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Why is Truss allowed to be racist, and never banned from this forum? I have been reading for over 2 years now, and he seems to have the freedom to write what he likes, irrespective of who it offends? Seems odd.
shenglong2015- Posts : 513
Join date : 2015-07-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
He was being xenophobic not racist.
Scottrf- Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Not as If I don't get "American this and that" chucked at me at least ten times a day on here...
I blame the parents..
I blame the parents..
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40685
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Scottrf wrote:He was being xenophobic not racist.
Why does he not like The Warrior Princess?
shenglong2015- Posts : 513
Join date : 2015-07-02
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
Scottrf wrote:He was being xenophobic not racist.
The difference between xenophobia and racism can be quite fine.
Racism is not always about colour.
Strongback- Posts : 6529
Join date : 2011-07-01
Location : Matchroom Sports Head Office
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
He does seem to be having a meltdown today. Hope he's OK.
Scottrf- Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: The Twenty Greatest Wins In Heavyweight History...
I see Sheng's now referring to himself in the third personshenglong2015 wrote:Scottrf wrote:He was being xenophobic not racist.
Why does he not like The Warrior Princess?
Guest- Guest
shenglong2015- Posts : 513
Join date : 2015-07-02
Similar topics
» Whats the 3 greatest wins in the Heavyweight History ?
» The Greatest Heavyweight. My All Time Top Twenty
» The greatest heavyweight.....
» Who Had The Hottest Heavyweight Run In History?
» Best streetfighters in Heavyweight history!!!
» The Greatest Heavyweight. My All Time Top Twenty
» The greatest heavyweight.....
» Who Had The Hottest Heavyweight Run In History?
» Best streetfighters in Heavyweight history!!!
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Boxing
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum