Week 11 Results

Fussball v Shakhtar Senseless

Voter 1:

Voter 2:

Voter 3:

Result:

Ebbsfleet United v Cape-Coast Mysterious Dwarfs

Voter 1:

Voter 2:

Voter 3:

Result:

Fiorentina Turner v Kalamazoo Outrage

Voter 1:

Voter 2:

Voter 3:

Result:

SAS v Deportivo Wanka

Postponed.

Deportivo Moron v Olympique Marswag

Voter 1:

Voter 2:

Voter 3:

Result:

Cheers for the results. That Juanfran injury screwed me over with Marky doing the tactical reshuffle.

See my feedback below

Ebbsfleet vs Dwarfs - Dwarfs win

Ebbsfleet feedback -

- Playing David Silva DM is utter madness. He's one of the best in the world at getting between the lines and finding space as an CAM, why you'd want him to just sit deep I have no idea. Not using your other CMs as options when he had the ball was weird too imo
+ I like the attacking ethos of your team overall, which I think does cause Dwarfs issues, love Neres/Brandt on the wings personally.
+ Would look to improve your CBs next in your squad imo

Dwarfs feedback -

+ You've identified his weakness at FB due to injury well, and really counter their tactics perfectly. Callejon and Reus run absolute riot in this game with the space they have.

Not a huge deal else to say on this one for Dwarfs, you've got a really good squad and it's just making sure you continue to produce good tactics based on your opponent each week to continue climbing the table


Tina vs Outrage - Outrage win

Overall - think you've both cancelled each other out formation/tactic wise here personally, it's a bit of a turgid game with the middle being so crowded. I've gone for an outrage win because I prefer their CMs to Turner's and I think Werner/Asensio carry more of a threat than El Shawaary/Chiesa. Close game but just a Outrage win

Tina feedback -

+ Like your tactics in this one, you've really identified how to play agianst Hero imo.
+ The Van Dijk signing was just what your defence needed
- I'm not the hugest fan of you playing De Rossi and Marchisio together, I'd look to play one and use the other off the bench, with maybe two more CMs ahead of them with a bit more dynamism

Outrage feedback -

+ Like the role you've given Asensio here, I think it's his best one in that free role. Would look to use it more often if I were you.
+ Identified your opponents tactics well
- Would maybe look to improve the GK next if I were you

Thanks Miky, hard luck in our game

Olly feedback: Like the role you've given Asensio here, I think it's his best one in that free role. Would look to use it more often if I were you.

Nando feedback: also why Asensio up front and not Maxi Gomez? Utter f*cking noncery that.

So is he good there or not lol

Did you play him false 9 or something?

I read it as a free role starting from the centre .. maybe would have been clearer if you put him behind Werner like Tino did with Chiesa, but I saw the role as the same

This was his instructions:

Asensio with free role, look for knockdown, go into channels and take on players

Not that it was my game to vote on, but I'd say that doing in the formation


1) looks like an terrible formation, and 2) doesn't shout out free role, more a withdrawn role.

Whereas putting "Asensio with free role, look for knockdown, go into channels and take on players" is much clearer as to what he will be doing

Yea I agree .. just think thats why Nando the nonce got confused, otherwise he would have given Chiesa the same comment

So just write it off as Nando being a nonce?

I didn't play Silva as a DM, I said he was a deeper lying playmaker - I wanted to counter Afro marking him out the game and losing the one chance i might have of winning. Without the ball Goretzka and Dendoncker were set up to go behind Silva and flesh out the the three CBs.

I am just wondering whether if I had changed this:

------------------------Neto--------------------------
-----------Bartra-------Mina-----Martinez----------
-------------------------Silva---------------------------
Neres--------Goretzka------Dendoncker----Brandt
------------------Tosun-------Bakambu---------------

to this.....

------------------------Neto--------------------------
-----------Bartra-------Mina-----Martinez----------
Neres----Goretzka----Silva----Dendoncker----Brandt
------------------Tosun-------Bakambu---------------

But had the exact same tactics, it would have been viewed more favorably. Even though it is exactly the same unless you are basing results on the look of the formation only and not the tactics.

Just pondering, especially based on Afro's post about Asensio above

if i play 2 up top and tell one he can do what he wants but run the channels id still expect him to be considered a forward honestly just reads like when rashford plays up top but drifts left from time to time admittedly now due to jose he spends all his time there now.

A lot of people don't bother reading the tactics. I've noticed it before on several occasions and it's why I think it should be one person doing results.

I personally think there is one game this week which definitely should have ended in a draw. And I think playing David Silva DM was a very clever move

playing silva as a deep lying playmaker or a DM or whatever imo was stupid because 1. nobody has ever seen him do it in real life and 2. you've removed literally the best player in the league at the AM position from his best position

silva's game is clever movement, getting into pockets of space, playing clever little through balls - i get the idea of trying to stop Afro marking him out the game, but i think you just overthought it because id say Silva can out wit any DM in the league atm

Hero wrote:Olly feedback: Like the role you've given Asensio here, I think it's his best one in that free role. Would look to use it more often if I were you.

Nando feedback: also why Asensio up front and not Maxi Gomez? Utter f*cking noncery that.

So is he good there or not lol

Imo he is great there

That's it in a nutshell. It's all about opinions. I feel like I need to keep a log of what you guys say and then build my tactics around who is voting rather than who I'm playing

All fair comments though. I quite like being a maverick tactics wise even if it doesn't mean a win. I await Silva to grow a beard and be a regista

I'm with Olly on this. You took Silva away from what he is good at, and I just don't see him dictating play from deep.

Whilst I can see you trying to take him out of the clutches of a man marker, moving him deep effectively had the same impact.