Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23

First topic message reminder :




New name, bit of a rebrand…..but same old Dragons? Hopefully not!

Player movements:

Players In:

Bradley Roberts from Ireland Ulster
JJ Hanrahan from France Clermont
Rhodri Jones from Wales Ospreys
Sean Lonsdale from England Exeter Chiefs
Max Clark from England Bath
George Nott from England London Irish
Sio Tomkinson from New Zealand Highlanders
Angus O'Brien from Wales Scarlets
Lewis Jones from Wales Cardiff
Rob Evans from Wales Scarlets


Players Out:

Taylor Davies returned to Wales Scarlets
Dan Babos released
Mesake Doge released
Tom Griffiths released
Jordan Olowofela returned to England Leicester Tigers
Max Williams released
Josh Lewis to Wales Merthyr
Jonah Holmes to England Ealing Trailfinders
Dan Baker to Wales Aberavon
Owen Jenkins to Wales Wales Sevens
Will Talbot-Davies to England Coventry
Greg Bateman retired
Joe Maksymiw to France Agen
Evan Lloyd to Wales Ebbw Vale
Carrick McDonough to Wales Ebbw Vale
Adam Warren to Wales Llandovery
Harry Fry to England Hartpury University

Some decent signings there, on paper. And lots of players leaving who were not that good. But also losing a couple of decent ones in Doge and Holmes.

Fingers crossed for a few more wins this season

Welshmushroom wrote:Tafka - i dont agree with that but only because what is going on elsewhere.  Most Premiership sides have similar budgets, not to mention we are for the first time on comparable spends as the other 3 regions.  If Ospreys can put a team that can win half their games I dont accept our current loss ratio.  At the very least we should be winning more of our home games.

I understand the sentiment of shopping at the bottom, which is true, but having coaches who have no track records of shrewd signings is my point with this.  Booth is way ahead of the other 3 coaches in terms of building his teams with a combination of development and clever signings.  

I'd also point to Connacht as well.  They have for years managed to sign clever transfers and outperformed most of the regions with comparable spends.  

I refuse to believe this is anything other than a head coach issue.  If anything there probably hasn't been a better market in the last decade for picking up gems.  I will concede that would involve having to max out the overseas cap for the regions because currently there are no credible welsh options to be competitive next season.

I’m sorry but the English sides have only dipped down to the level of the regions in terms of budget for this year, and then we’re dipping down even lower next year and for at least 4 more years after that. Meanwhile England are going back up plus have the marquee signing budget too, so they can have 2 x £million players (I think) on top of their squad spend. Plus their squads seem to be bigger and there are more teams to spread the internationals around so, as Mikey says, the regions will be further hampered during the international window (and anything we play either side of it when Gatland has his extra time with the players).

I fully agree that most of the coaching tickets are not up to scratch. And I’ve said that before, i.e. we need to spend more there. However, I completely disagree that we have the same ability to attract the same players as English premiership teams. Absolutely no way. Which is why we end up with the off casts while English prem sides pick up the good ones.

Mikey makes a good point about the Ospreys - Booth has had a great squad to work with, partly due to him…… but he did not develop Smith, AWJ, North, etc. And he has not replaced them with similar quality. So he’s going to find it harder next year as the budget cuts really start to bite.

Dragons: Ewan Rosser; Rio Dyer, Joe Westwood, Aneurin Owen, Chris Hollis; Will Reed, Rhodri Williams (capt); Rhodri Jones, Brodie Coghlan, Chris Coleman, Ben Carter, Matthew Screech, Ryan Woodman, Taine Basham, Aaron Wainwright

Replacements: James Benjamin, Rodrigo Martinez, Dmitri Arhip, George Nott, Dan Lydiate, Che Hope, Steff Hughes, Sio Tomkinson


Could someone/anyone explain how Coleman is always in, and worse yet, usually always starting? That isn't the only selection I have issue with, but given it's always a given when Dai is picking the team, I don't think he is the right guy for the job.

Would it hurt to put Hollis at centre? Dai must think so.

TAFKA The Oracle wrote:

Welshmushroom wrote:Tafka - i dont agree with that but only because what is going on elsewhere.  Most Premiership sides have similar budgets, not to mention we are for the first time on comparable spends as the other 3 regions.  If Ospreys can put a team that can win half their games I dont accept our current loss ratio.  At the very least we should be winning more of our home games.

I understand the sentiment of shopping at the bottom, which is true, but having coaches who have no track records of shrewd signings is my point with this.  Booth is way ahead of the other 3 coaches in terms of building his teams with a combination of development and clever signings.  

I'd also point to Connacht as well.  They have for years managed to sign clever transfers and outperformed most of the regions with comparable spends.  

I refuse to believe this is anything other than a head coach issue.  If anything there probably hasn't been a better market in the last decade for picking up gems.  I will concede that would involve having to max out the overseas cap for the regions because currently there are no credible welsh options to be competitive next season.

I’m sorry but the English sides have only dipped down to the level of the regions in terms of budget for this year, and then we’re dipping down even lower next year and for at least 4 more years after that. Meanwhile England are going back up plus have the marquee signing budget too, so they can have 2 x £million players (I think) on top of their squad spend. Plus their squads seem to be bigger and there are more teams to spread the internationals around so, as Mikey says, the regions will be further hampered during the international window (and anything we play either side of it when Gatland has his extra time with the players).

Prem budget has been the same for a while now. Since COVID hit the finances. Most clubs aren't going to be spending up to the cap and then those that have previously said they will are going quiet on that promise after the drop in TV revenue.

There's certainly bargains out there but everyone is after them. Even if you do get them they'll be projects that'll need the right environment.

There are a lot of exceptions with the English salary cap though. Really helps matters. It’s more than I thought. Yeah the Welsh could do the same, just as we could negotiate tax relief like in Ireland, but we haven’t and we don’t so it’s another area where we’re behind:

“THE LEVEL OF THE SALARY CAP

The level of the Salary Cap is proportionate and aligned to the growth of the business and is linked directly to the central distributions to the Clubs from Premiership Rugby.

For the 2023-24 Salary Cap Year, the level of the Salary Cap is £5,000,000 with the following credits and exclusions, which means that Clubs can spend at least £6.4m plus an Excluded Player Salary:

Home Grown Player Credits totalling £600,000 (up to £50,000 per player) – designed to incentivise Clubs to retain home grown talent;
EPS/International Player Credits totalling £400,000 (up to £80,000 per player) – to cover player absence during international periods;
Injured Player Credits totalling £400,000 – to allow replacement players to cover for long term injuries;
One Excluded Player (unless the original Two Excluded Players have existing contracts from June 2020) – their entire salary is excluded from the Salary Cap;
Unlimited education fund for players.
For the 2024-25 Salary Cap Year, the level is returning to £6,400,000 with the same credits and only one Excluded Player”

https://www.premiershiprugby.com/salarycap

So the regions next year could be spending up to £2m less than their English counterparts. That’s around 30% less (although I appreciate that not all English clubs will spend that much).

mikey_dragon wrote:Dragons: Ewan Rosser; Rio Dyer, Joe Westwood, Aneurin Owen, Chris Hollis; Will Reed, Rhodri Williams (capt); Rhodri Jones, Brodie Coghlan, Chris Coleman, Ben Carter, Matthew Screech, Ryan Woodman, Taine Basham, Aaron Wainwright

Replacements: James Benjamin, Rodrigo Martinez, Dmitri Arhip, George Nott, Dan Lydiate, Che Hope, Steff Hughes, Sio Tomkinson


Could someone/anyone explain how Coleman is always in, and worse yet, usually always starting? That isn't the only selection I have issue with, but given it's always a given when Dai is picking the team, I don't think he is the right guy for the job.

Would it hurt to put Hollis at centre? Dai must think so.

That squad will do nothing for those that say the Dragons have too many semi pros stealing a living!

On the prospect of bargains the Rebels have officially gone under. Potential shopping to be done over in Australia this off season as the other franchises will no be looking to accommodate the now out of contract Wallabies.

TAFKA The Oracle wrote:

mikey_dragon wrote:Dragons: Ewan Rosser; Rio Dyer, Joe Westwood, Aneurin Owen, Chris Hollis; Will Reed, Rhodri Williams (capt); Rhodri Jones, Brodie Coghlan, Chris Coleman, Ben Carter, Matthew Screech, Ryan Woodman, Taine Basham, Aaron Wainwright

Replacements: James Benjamin, Rodrigo Martinez, Dmitri Arhip, George Nott, Dan Lydiate, Che Hope, Steff Hughes, Sio Tomkinson


Could someone/anyone explain how Coleman is always in, and worse yet, usually always starting? That isn't the only selection I have issue with, but given it's always a given when Dai is picking the team, I don't think he is the right guy for the job.

Would it hurt to put Hollis at centre? Dai must think so.

That squad will do nothing for those that say the Dragons have too many semi pros stealing a living!

There is at least 3 in the starting team. Somehow one of them (Rhodri Jones) finds himself a nominee for player of the year.

formerly known as Sam wrote:On the prospect of bargains the Rebels have officially gone under. Potential shopping to be done over in Australia this off season as the other franchises will no be looking to accommodate the now out of contract Wallabies.

I doubt the board is smart enough to realise this. I suppose the best will be mopped up by the other Aus franchises and Japanese clubs though anyway.

mikey_dragon wrote:

formerly known as Sam wrote:On the prospect of bargains the Rebels have officially gone under. Potential shopping to be done over in Australia this off season as the other franchises will no be looking to accommodate the now out of contract Wallabies.

I doubt the board is smart enough to realise this. I suppose the best will be mopped up by the other Aus franchises and Japanese clubs though anyway.

I suspect the Wallabies will be. A number of the good squad players might be available though. Japanese clubs have quotas on foreign players so it's not a free for all. Clever clubs will not be looking at the big names but the promising players who are club level stalwarts or those that are just breaking through/about to break through.

Quite frankly the Dragons couldn't afford the well known names anyway but should be bargain shopping for the aforementioned types of players or at least asking around for any that might be WQ. Tigers did quite well with a couple from the Shute Shield in Australia in Porter and Potter.

TAFKA The Oracle wrote:There are a lot of exceptions with the English salary cap though. Really helps matters. It’s more than I thought. Yeah the Welsh could do the same, just as we could negotiate tax relief like in Ireland, but we haven’t and we don’t so it’s another area where we’re behind:

“THE LEVEL OF THE SALARY CAP

The level of the Salary Cap is proportionate and aligned to the growth of the business and is linked directly to the central distributions to the Clubs from Premiership Rugby.

For the 2023-24 Salary Cap Year, the level of the Salary Cap is £5,000,000 with the following credits and exclusions, which means that Clubs can spend at least £6.4m plus an Excluded Player Salary:

Home Grown Player Credits totalling £600,000 (up to £50,000 per player) – designed to incentivise Clubs to retain home grown talent;
EPS/International Player Credits totalling £400,000 (up to £80,000 per player) – to cover player absence during international periods;
Injured Player Credits totalling £400,000 – to allow replacement players to cover for long term injuries;
One Excluded Player (unless the original Two Excluded Players have existing contracts from June 2020) – their entire salary is excluded from the Salary Cap;
Unlimited education fund for players.
For the 2024-25 Salary Cap Year, the level is returning to £6,400,000 with the same credits and only one Excluded Player”

https://www.premiershiprugby.com/salarycap

So the regions next year could be spending up to £2m less than their English counterparts. That’s around 30% less (although I appreciate that not all English clubs will spend that much).

I dont think that will be the case though. Talk in Wales is the 4.5 Cap actually wont come into effect next season with them all staying at 5 million + 1 marquee player on top of that.

Regarding the Prem, yes that may be the cap but almost all of the clubs (Bristol, Exeter, Leicester etc) have all come out and said they are not moving to the cap and staying around 5 million to recover. In fact its probably only Northampton, Bath & Saracens who may spend up to the cap although none of those have come out and said they will but the other 7 won't wont be. Bristol have the richest owner in the league and even they are being restricted to 5 million as per Lam to make them viable.

So the gap probably is a lot closer than you think. Probably evidenced by the fact that a lot of them are losing a lot of their star names in the off season. It's also why a lot of people in the Prem have come out and said England needs to keep the selection law in place or they will lose a lot more.

My question is if we are spending 5 million next season, does anyone think we are overpaying some players. Because on paper we have a couple of top draw players but everything under that looks a lot weaker than other teams around the same spending power.

We know we probably cant get superstars either but i still maintain there are plenty of quality talents out there that we should be able to offer first team chances to that are getting no top end gametime.

The major issue facing Cardiff, Dragons, Scarlets is the lack of development that took place has left virtually no welsh options available in most of the key positions. WRU & the regions may have to accept for the next 2-3 years that they have to get a good amount of overseas players to plug the gap until they can get the next crop through (assuming the pathways are actually sorted out - which given the whole EDL debacle is unlikely as I'm not sure the WRU will get the right plan in action).

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/rugby-union/articles/cmllk9470p4o

"We see his long-term future with us," said Dragons head coach Dai Flanagan.

Leon Brown and Dai Flanagan need to go.

Well that's not the news im hoping to hear.....Dai what are you doing to me.....

If he does resign I reckon its another tough season on the cards next year..... Guess on the plus side my I know I can take a holiday whenever I want next year

I think we’ll be okay versus scarlets now that I’ve seen their front row and fly-half. It’s just as bad if not worse than what we are putting out .

Funny side really.

I am happy with the likes of Coughlan, Westwood and Rosser getting opportunities, but agree on the TH issue. I don't really like most of our front row replacements either.

I don't see the value in Brown having any deal, nor do I for Lydiate which was mooted this week. We can't plead budget constraints and then offer players any form of wage, that don't represent value for money. I don't agree with Flanagan suggesting Lydiate should look for a defence coach opportunity either. It just seems to contradict our message that we are looking to strengthen our back room staff. If we are looking at developing backroom staff from Wales, then it shouldn't just be off an opinion that he's good with youngsters and is/was a good defender so would make a good coach.

The way I see it is we have a real chance to start developing some players early. Most URC sides will also have to develop at some stage and it would make sense to get a early start on the competition.

But the game is about fundamentals still and no matter what that is the area we really need to improve. I honestly think with our backline talent coming through we will score tries if we can sort our front 8 out.

Welshmushroom wrote:The way I see it is we have a real chance to start developing some players early.  Most URC sides will also have to develop at some stage and it would make sense to get a early start on the competition.  

But the game is about fundamentals still and no matter what that is the area we really need to improve.  I honestly think with our backline talent coming through we will score tries if we can sort our front 8 out.

Who is he developing early? Lydiate? Coleman? Coleman is semi-pro, another one. Let us just be honest about it so it can be more acceptable for some. Reed is the same, I don't have to say much about that because the evidence is available via playback for every one of our games, but there's still going to be people that think he's good. For all the criticism, I think I can at least credit Dai with reaching this realisation! Hence him mentioning buying another fly-half.

I also think we have some talent in the backline. I still think it's a good idea to trial Rio at 15. Now more than ever, we need 5 more new players in the front 5.

He's not at the moment. But im hoping guys like Westwood get a good run out next year and players like Morgan & Hope.

He has to know at this point most of his senior guys can't get the job done.

Then again it is Dai so who knows what he will do.....

Sam Hobbs announced as our new forwards coach. Steps up from academy head coach. Hmmmm.

Not a good signing, for me. I guess he's bargain basement though. It's advisable to also bring in a scrum coach, but it would need to be someone good.

Chris Hollis has left the Dragons and returned home. Only a short term contract apparently. What did he play, a game or two?! What a waste of time that was.

I wonder who's decision it was? Conbeer is also available and a decent player, surely it's just a coincidence though. I would have probably kept Hollis and put him at centre, but I'm someone who doesn't want to see Owen and Hughes there.

I would like to see us go for Conbeer. Good player.

I think maybe Owen is worth persevering with for a bit longer, given his age and potential (that others seem to see in him). Time to move on from Hughes for sure. He was a good pro but is at the end of his career and we need better.

Reading more about Hollis - it seems he was on a trial. I wasn’t aware of that. All the reports at the time seemed to be suggesting a coup for the Dragons in landing a Saffa, signing with immediate effect, etc. but nothing mentioned a trial. Sort of glad in a way that we’ve had the balls to let him go if he wasn’t right for us. Often we’ll sign them on a 2 or 3 years contact and they flop in the 1st season!

I hope we're not afraid to play Westwood and Ackerman next season. I don't think Steff Hughes's 'leadership' is sufficient to guarantee him a starting spot.

I don't think we should sign Conbeer. He'd be another Jordan Williams for us IMHO.

Luckless Pedestrian wrote:I hope we're not afraid to play Westwood and Ackerman next season. I don't think Steff Hughes's 'leadership' is sufficient to guarantee him a starting spot.

I don't think we should sign Conbeer. He'd be another Jordan Williams for us IMHO.

Forgot about Ackerman, but he might not be available for some months into the season. Westwood at centre seems to be going well, I'd play him at 12, Wilson 13. Conbeer is a good winger but I'm sceptical about signing him and he doesn't have an amazing injury record either.

TAFKA The Oracle wrote:I would like to see  us go for Conbeer. Good player.

I think maybe Owen is worth persevering with for a bit longer, given his age and potential (that others seem to see in him). Time to move on from Hughes for sure. He was a good pro but is at the end of his career and we need better.

Reading more about Hollis - it seems he was on a trial. I wasn’t aware of that. All the reports at the time seemed to be suggesting a coup for the Dragons in landing a Saffa, signing with immediate effect, etc. but nothing mentioned a trial. Sort of glad in a way that we’ve had the balls to let him go if he wasn’t right for us. Often we’ll sign them on a 2 or 3 years contact and they flop in the 1st season!

Kirwan before his holiday was suggesting he would get a full contract, so something happened there. Dai even mentioned how he could give us front foot and let Rio etc get space off him. I doubt he was just on about judgement day, which wasn’t the case.

Very strange. It was a temp contract always, but to announce him leaving out of the blue seems peculiar.

Unless they want to invest in Westwood as Mikey says. But it’s still strange timing.

I’m not too sad he’s not signed btw. I want to see more of Ewan Rosser, Westwood and even Huw Anderson at 15 or wing. But all the chat was he’s going to be permanent.

Ultimately it looks like a waste now, given we are on less budget. He still cost something to pay. We could’ve looked at others. Flanagan is apparently pro youngster too.

Marnus van der Merwe (hooker), Alec Hepburn (LH), Ellis Mee (15), Max Douglas (Lock), Henry Thomas (TH), Blair Murray (utility).

Scarlets are well ahead of us in the signings IMO, especially as Dai is desperate to keep Lydiate and Brown. I wonder what he took from the game against them on JD? Where they beat us up front... Sam Lousi is staying on too, not sure about Fifita but I thought they might be keen to get his wages off the books. Both were rumoured to be off.

I actually think those Scarlets signings are pretty naff.

I dont rate Thomas as a Tighthead.  Hepburn will also have a question mark on him given he couldnt get into the Exeter side for over a year.  Douglas I'm not sure has the physicality needed for this league.  Mee and Murray are totally untested at Pro level so who knows if they are good enough or not.  

van der Merwe is probably the only half descent signing in that bunch and even then he will be warming the bench so not even one of their critical positions.

If that is the extent of their signings they are going to have to get comfortable with the bottom of the league.

Mee and Murray are pro players, not sure where you got otherwise from. VDM has to start over Elias and the everlasting Shaun Evans, neither are good enough at throwing. Their signings/re-signings crucially, are within the front 5. I don't rate O'Connor or Mathias, amazing how they're in the Wales squad... Scarlets should be above Dragons and Cardiff as it stands. Cardiff aren't doing enough to bring in front 5 players, yet. I know they signed Southworth as another LH but he's probably average, and bizarrely is now being described as a TH. They're continuing to sign open-sides and average back-row hybrids, I don't think at this rate they will ever learn.

Hepburn has had some little injuries over the last two seasons. Much like Shickerling he was left out of match day squads after it was announced he was off. Baxter has been trying to build up the squad to move forward and has mainly been playing players who are going to be there for the future.

Mee was Nottingham's fullback for last season, won supporters player of the season and was shortlisted for the Championship team of the season. Not sure he's a certain starter but he's potentially a young talent that could flourish over the next couple of years. He's still only 20, at 6ft4 he could fill out a bit more yet as well.

We need to look at Jordan Morris and perhaps get him some senior rugby, the guy is a beast. The only thing to concern me is that he’d have to learn to scrum with us, which we are not good at.

Deon Slabbert is back with the Puma’s for the Currie cup, after he had signed with Bulls - i imagine Dai’s obsession put him off anyway. It’s also more proof that Jake White has an ego, buying up a lot of players and not using them. His excuse previously was that he didn’t have enough players as they were all overseas. I wonder what the excuse is now.

Scarlets are keeping Fifita by the look of it, as well as Alex Craig and Johnny Williams. Their squad is much better than ours for next season, IMO. I do wonder how they are affording it though. Dragons haven't made enough signings. I'm not sure why more people don't mention it. They're bigging up the pre-season photos but it was mostly full of the usual average players. As much as I'm pleased with Steve Cummins, he was mostly a squad player at Scarlets and then Brive. Also pleased with Lloyd Evans incoming, especially with AOB getting injured often, but it all helps keep Reed out of the team.

What are peoples thoughts on our best 23?

Scarlets seem to have a smaller squad than us. I think they are at 38 and 10 of those are very young guys with very little to no experience of URC matches so they probably are on crap money. So I would assume the majority of their spend has been on just 28 guys. That's fairly thread bare and if they get injuries to senior guys they could have their season totally de-railed. We seem to have 43 on our roster. Of those 5 are youngsters but the other 38 all have a lot more experience at pro level - granted even if they have not performed the best. Dragons probably will cope better under injuries than what Peel has done.

In terms of our best 23 I think it would look like this:-

1. R. Jones
2. Dee
3. Brown (if we can ever keep him fit)
4. Carter
5. Cummings
6. Wainwright
7. Basham
8. Funaki
9. Blacker
10. O'Brien (I suspect Dai will probably go with Evans though)
11. Jared Rosser
12. Wilson
13. Westwood (Again Dai will probably pick Hughes though)
14. Dyer
15. Ewan Rosser (Dai's pick will be Evans though I bet)

16. Martinez
17. Arhip
18. Coghlan
19. Nott
20. Lewis-Hughes
21. R. Williams
22. L. Evans
23. Owen

I doubt though Dai will select this 23 though.

Wilson and Westwood probably be the other way around, won’t they?

Part of the previous points I’ve made, the squad isn’t good enough to climb up from the bottom of the table. It needs more additions. Rh Jones too soft, Brown too injured. It doesn’t seem like we’re making more signings either. The social media loves to post about us having the new signings, some of which are just squad players, when we need at least another 5 starters.

I think you’re right about Hughes as well, but it just shows the limitations with Dai.

Just looking at Wilson I think his history is at 12. He is versatile though and has played 13 and 15 as well. Westwood as a former wing has the pace and power for a 13. I know 13 is a difficult defensive position but I'd rather him play there and learn the position in the next couple of seasons. For him personally 13 is a position he could see international honors as well given Wales have issues there. There's plenty of good strong 12's in Wales or elsewhere. The issue Wales has is we don't actually have many good outside centres anymore.

Knowing Dai though he probably will have them in reverse but I think in the long term that will be a mistake.

I also think Wilson at 12 will have a hard time.  Almost every URC team has a monster heavyweight at 12.  Wilson will really struggle to contain them and even Westwood is not big enough really to hold them out defensively.

It's why I would have actually like to see Hollis at 12 as he was a big man and clearly was never a wing to begin with.  But Dai had different ideas on that one.

Our backline will have pace at least but I question if we will be sound in defending.  But going into this season our biggest issue is can we actually gain parity in the front 5.  I really think Dai needed to go another direction in the off season and given we are basically going in with the same props next year, I'm not holding out much hope in getting more wins this year.  

It's probably pointing out I expect all the URC teams to be a lot better again over the coarse of the season given the World Cup did hinder some sides in the early rounds.  South Africa will still struggle in the opening 4 rounds though as they will have a lot of players with the national side and some of those guys may not even be available before Dec.  

That at least will be good news for us as we do have 2 home games against SA teams in R3 & R4.

It is a bit annoying because almost every Dragons coach since inception was always behind the other 3 welsh sides in terms of funding.  This will be the first season were that isnt the case and if other Welsh sides are winning more we can no longer blame it on a disparity on budget.  I do think Dai made some mistakes in the transfer market this summer and he could have been really bold and taken some chances.  He went a little safe in the end.  

Granted I may have to eat my words if the new recruits pay off and the team does well but in that scenario I will be happy to accept I was wrong.  I just have my doubts is all.

I think Wilson will be okay at 12. I see your logic. I don’t often see Dai’s logic though. I’m still not sold on Carter and Screech unless one of them can play blindside, but we still appear to be pretty short of personnel at lock. Going by the pre-season photos, Davies and Coleman are still on the books. Bizarre. Why don’t we give Yendle a proper go?

Wyn Jones signed up elsewhere, I wonder what will become of Conbeer? Would be good for Ospreys imo.

No news on Bradley Roberts?

I think Carter has a way to go. Screech was one of those I simply would not have kept.

I do wish we would simply use the Challenge Cup to help development. Yendle could start all of those and see some action off the bench or away games we know we cant win. No doubt though Dai will feel the need to start frontline players in this competition which again will be a mistake. I'd rather us totally prioritize the URC because even if we did get to later games in the Challenge Cup we are not equipped to win it.

Davies simply does not have the power in that considerable frame he has. But every time he plays he just seems so passive. Since the Saffers have joined there are no hiding places in the forwards. Not if the goal is to win. The way the last 3 seasons in the URC have gone most teams have ball carrying/scrummaging locks. 6 seems to be that lighter lineout option for a lot of teams. Its something we cant do if for example we have Wainwright and Funaki starting. But it wont matter cause we dont have the timber at 4 & 5 in any case.

I dont think Arhip was that impressive either, Fairbrother is no world beater either. Coleman is getting chances but even I'm starting to doubt he is good enough at this level. And Brown, well he's just never fit for us. Personally I would have let all of those go and get 2 durable 3's in. Sordoni for example hasnt been picked up and he would have been one of the ones I would have got. I probably would have looked at some of the Zebre tightheads as well. Nocera, Neculai and Hasa all seem able to hold their own at set piece and are 20st + Props and I'm sure we would have been able to get one of those from them.

But we are where we are. To me on paper, there are some serious weaknesses in our side already and most of the better sides in the URC know they can target those and win games. It's a shame really because I actually think we have some very good backs that with the right attacking game could do some damage. Only the Ospreys in the Welsh regions have worked out they can sacrifice quality in the backline if they have a dominant pack to win at least a bulk of their games. I know it's not pretty but forwards win games.

It's just that we get to the point where we're desperate for wins, and they are more available in the Challenge Cup. This coming season is definitely one where we probably should focus on the league though.

Agree on Davies, but can't see what you saw in Coleman, been useless for 4 years now. Benjamin too. We also have this habit of keeping players on the books when they rarely feature, some like Josh Reynolds. We probably need to start with the props we haven't seen a lot of, because it is the same old story with Rh Jones and Brown. I mentioned a while back about Dai being keen to keep Lydiate and Brown, he's completely lost it with those calls. Agree on the other props though. If we didn't try and pick up Sordoni I would have at least liked him to go to another region.

Oh well, thought I'd have a go. Mine will be different, but we need a bigger back-row and players who don't break after 20 minutes of rugby.

1. Martinez
2. Dee
3. Fairbrother
4. Nott
5. Cummins
6. Carter
7. Wainwright
8. Funaki
9. Blacker
10. O'Brien
11. Jared Rosser
12. Wilson
13. Westwood
14. Dyer
15. Lloyd Evans

16. Coghlan/Roberts
17. Rh Jones
18. Arhip
19. Lewis-Hughes
20. Basham
21. R. Williams
22. Owen
23. E Rosser

mikey_dragon wrote:Oh well, thought I'd have a go. Mine will be different, but we need a bigger back-row and players who don't break after 20 minutes of rugby.

1. Martinez
2. Dee
3. Fairbrother
4. Nott
5. Cummins
6. Carter
7. Wainwright
8. Funaki
9. Blacker
10. O'Brien
11. Jared Rosser
12. Wilson
13. Westwood
14. Dyer
15. Lloyd Evans

16. Coghlan/Roberts
17. Rh Jones
18. Arhip
19. Lewis-Hughes
20. Basham
21. R. Williams
22. Owen
23. E Rosser

Not a bad side on paper. I do think Nott has actually been really good for us since joining. I thought when Martinez joined he would be really good as Argentinians usually are good at scrum time. I dont want to judge him yet given I had serious questions on the coaching last season. Tiatia should at least help the forwards this year I reckon so hopefully any potential Martinez comes out. The only one there I'm a bit iffy on is at 15 as I'm not sure he has the pace for a 15 I would like to see there. Its why I thought the younger Rosser would be a good shout there. Is a heavyweight pack though so maybe Evans boot at the back would allow them to play a set piece based game.

I also want to retract my earlier statement. Looks like Scarlets are on the verge of signing Holz after all. I'd imagine within a few games he will oust Thomas at 3. With him in their starting 15, their pack is shaping up nicely. Still dont rate Hepburn or Kemsley that much though. Is going to be strange as they probably will only have 3 welsh players in their pack.

That said because regional rugby did such a crap job bringing front 5 players through academies or development this was always going to have to happen. Hopefully while these overseas guys are here they will at least work on trying to replace them with Welsh Qualified options in the coming years.....

Think Burrows will feature on the bench at least, seeing as he’s probably our biggest hooker and Flanagan seems to want more size in the pack.

Yes I did just see that Scarlets are going to sign Holz now, after it was said they wouldn't due to medical reasons. It's been their worst season ever but they went out to rectify it by buying more front 5 forwards, Dragons are still sitting on their hands. Hepburn and Thomas can scrum, that much we know. Hopefully Mathias starts to come good, he went backwards this season - and kept getting picked for Wales ahead of Smith and Carre. HOC is their worst prop, reminds me of Coleman.

I think what makes me sad about the situation is I think we could have had a chance at a mid table season had Dai gone really bold with clear outs. Granted it would have meant getting a greater number of overseas guys in to do it but that would have been better in the short term - and then look at the next generation of forwards to bring through.

There would have been some Argy's, Georgians & Italians I would have targeted and at the very least we would have had a solid set piece and probably full availability for next season. I would have put together a fairly heavyweight team which would have faired better between Sept till Feb until the weather breaks. That at least would have allowed us a strong start to the season.

I'm trying to stay positive and it should be good to see how Wilson, Funaki, Cummings and some of the younger academy players that are coming through.

Some shocking re-signing news today. I bet Brown and Lydiate are to be confirmed next.

And like magic, a new contract for Leon Brown appears.