Premiership Semi-Finals 2024

by doctor_grey Fri May 31, 2024 9:11 pm

Big weekend boys and girls. We have worked through difficulties and yet are in a position to win.
Reminds me of a song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2X0Gf9jfz8

Northampton Saints v Saracens
Franklins Gardens, Friday 31st May 2024; 19:45
TNT 1/TNT Ultimate/Discovery +
Officials:
Referee: Christophe Ridley
Assistant Referees: Anthony Woodthorpe and Andrew Jackson
No.4: Dan Jones
TMO: Ian Tempest

GOOD		EVIL
George Furbank	15	Elliot Daly
Tommy Freeman	14	Alex Lewington
Burger Odendaal	13	Lucio Cinti
Fraser Dingwall	12	Nick Tompkins
Ollie Sleightholme	11	Tom Parton
Fin Smith	10	Owen Farrell (c)
Alex Mitchell	9	Ivan van Zyl

Alex Waller	1	Mako Vunipola
Curtis Langdon	2	Jamie George
Trevor Davison	3	Marco Riccioni
Alex Moon	4	Maro Itoje
Alex Coles	5	Nick Isiekwe
Courtney Lawes (c)	6	Juan Martin Gonzalez
Tom Pearson	7	Ben Earl
Juarno Augustus	8	Billy Vunipola

Replacements:
Sam Matavesi	16	Theo Dan
Emmanuel Iyogun	17	Eroni Mawi
Elliot Millar Mills	18	Ollie Hoskins
Temo Mayanavanua	19	Hugh Tizard
Sam Graham	20	Theo McFarland
Lewis Ludlam	21	Tom Willis
Tom James	22	Aled Davies
George Hendy	23	Alex Lozowski

by formerly known as Sam Fri May 31, 2024 9:26 pm

Both sides expecting an attritional game and have gone for the 6-2 bench split. Sarries seemingly wanting to go after or at least try to disrupt the Saints lineout (maybe worried about first phase and Saints getting attacking momentum) so have gone for the extra jumping skills of Isekwe, he's more mobile than Tizard as well. Both benches have some fire power as well.

by WELL-PAST-IT Fri May 31, 2024 9:32 pm

You just beat me to it, I have the teams copied and ready to paste.

I am not sure about Odendaal at 13, he in my opinion is a weak link in the speed and fluidity of the back line. I would much prefer Freeman at 13 and Hendy 14.

Going to be an interesting clash of back rows, some real class acts out there.

George (the incumbent) vs Langdon (the Challenger) should be a very good battle. Pearson might get a bit of a roasting from Earl, but he has to learn. I suspect he will be an early change with Graham and Ludlam coming on for Lawes at about 50 minutes, poor old boy struggles with 80 these days.

by doctor_grey Fri May 31, 2024 9:53 pm

In their last games at the Gardens, I think Alex Waller (who has been playing great recently), Lewis Ludlum, and Courtney Lawes will have terrific games. Just need to avoid that little bit of extra nerves....

by WELL-PAST-IT Sat Jun 01, 2024 12:17 am

doctor_grey wrote:In their last games at the Gardens, I think Alex Waller (who has been playing great recently), Lewis Ludlum, and Courtney Lawes will have terrific games. Just need to avoid that little bit of extra nerves....

Don't forget Alex Moon, his last game as well

by Poorfour Sat Jun 01, 2024 1:08 am

What are we going to label the other semi? Sturm vs Drang? Flash Gordon vs Ming the Merciless?

by mountain man Sat Jun 01, 2024 1:25 am

Poorfour wrote:What are we going to label the other semi? Sturm vs Drang? Flash Gordon vs Ming the Merciless?

Bath v Sale will do.

No hype required.

by doctor_grey Sat Jun 01, 2024 1:53 am

WELL-PAST-IT wrote:
doctor_grey wrote:In their last games at the Gardens, I think Alex Waller (who has been playing great recently), Lewis Ludlum, and Courtney Lawes will have terrific games. Just need to avoid that little bit of extra nerves....

Don't forget Alex Moon, his last game as well

Truly!

by doctor_grey Sat Jun 01, 2024 1:54 am

mountain man wrote:
Poorfour wrote:What are we going to label the other semi? Sturm vs Drang? Flash Gordon vs Ming the Merciless?

Bath v Sale will do.

No hype required.

Why not call it the battle to lose to Saints next weekend...... Run

by Cumbrian Sat Jun 01, 2024 6:34 am

Really entertaining first half. Important bit of daylight for Saints, but both look dangerous in attack. Saracens are on the edge a little bit because of the 6-2 bench and losing Parton early. An early injury in the backs could be disastrous for them, especially with how dangerous Northampton are from long range.

by Geordie Sat Jun 01, 2024 6:46 am

Langdon needs to travel this summer.

by Cumbrian Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:02 am

Saracens' bench has made a huge impact, Saints really need to respond.

by Geordie Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:12 am

Mitchell is outstanding mind...England's no 1 9 now...
Lots of England contenders in this...and some of the old guard not standing up....the young pretenders making the plays.

by Geordie Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:22 am

Everyone questioned Eddie Jones initially for Furbank but hey...he knew what he saw......a classy player!!

by formerly known as Sam Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:22 am

Think Saints should have gone for the 5m scrum instead of the kick for the 9 point lead. Could have put the game to bed there.

by formerly known as Sam Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:23 am

Geordie wrote:Everyone questioned Eddie Jones initially for Firbank but hey...he knew what he saw......a classy player!!

He's got all the skills, except under the high ball where he's looked weak. The little extra kick of acceleration as he arrives onto the ball has caused problems for Sarries defence.

by Geordie Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:24 am

formerly known as Sam wrote:Think Saints should have gone for the 5m scrum instead of the kick for the 9 point lead. Could have put the game to bed there.

It's already to he'd Sam...the old guard have been seen off.

It's actually quite a moment this game....so many huge names on their last game....

by Geordie Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:26 am

formerly known as Sam wrote:
Geordie wrote:Everyone questioned Eddie Jones initially for Firbank but hey...he knew what he saw......a classy player!!

He's got all the skills, except under the high ball where he's looked weak. The little extra kick of acceleration as he arrives onto the ball has caused problems for Sarries defence.

Don't think he's weak Sam...just not the brick wall that Steward is. Which few are. Bit he offers so much more in other areas (in my opinion) and I'm a fan of Steward

by formerly known as Sam Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:40 am

Geordie wrote:
formerly known as Sam wrote:
Geordie wrote:Everyone questioned Eddie Jones initially for Firbank but hey...he knew what he saw......a classy player!!

He's got all the skills, except under the high ball where he's looked weak. The little extra kick of acceleration as he arrives onto the ball has caused problems for Sarries defence.

Don't think he's weak Sam...just not the brick wall that Steward is. Which few are. Bit he offers so much more in other areas (in my opinion) and I'm a fan of Steward

Just meant tonight not in general. Think he came for two or three and got nowhere near any of them. Normally he's more composed than that.

by Geordie Sat Jun 01, 2024 7:50 am

Ah gotcha!

Courtney's interview...wow brutal. What a player. Bring it on.

by doctor_grey Sat Jun 01, 2024 10:26 pm

So Saints scrum took control of a match against Sarries. And, not to hurt myself too severely patting myself on the back, but I really expected Alex Waller to have a great game, and he did. Along with Courtney Lawes both seem to be playing some of their best Rugby now.

Not too bad, not too bad at all.

by Geordie Sun Jun 02, 2024 2:58 am

Decent game Bath v Sale...

by Welshmushroom Sun Jun 02, 2024 3:10 am

doctor_grey wrote:So Saints scrum took control of a match against Sarries. And, not to hurt myself too severely patting myself on the back, but I really expected Alex Waller to have a great game, and he did. Along with Courtney Lawes both seem to be playing some of their best Rugby now.

Not too bad, not too bad at all.

Losing a lot of players as well are Northampton so going to be interesting how they recruit in the summer and go next year. Some of their best players in the pack are going so that may impact them next year.

by Geordie Sun Jun 02, 2024 4:17 am

Who are Saints losing....Lawes, Ludlam, Waller x 2, Moon

Lawes is pretty much irreplaceable, whilst Ludlum and Waller will the tough to replace..but not impossible. Their academy is churning out some top players at the moment aswell...

by WELL-PAST-IT Sun Jun 02, 2024 5:15 am

I think they are losing those plus Hill and letting go a lot more, I think it is something like 13 overall. Lawes is the irreplaceable one as you say, they have got Graham, Pearson, Scott-young, Augustus, plus Irvine and Pollock to bring through. If lock resources allow Coles can also play the Lawes game quite well. They have Munga and Mayanavanua at lock to go with Coles, then it gets a bit thin, Locket is just too lightweight, needs to put on 10kg to be premiership weight, 17.5 stone does not do it these days. If he can't put the weight on properly, perhaps 6 is a better option.

We are well equiped at LH, but TH needs some attention, we have two established Tight Heads then rookies.

by Mr Bounce Sun Jun 02, 2024 5:40 am

From a team point of view, I am not sure why Sarries played Farrell when he was crocked? I appreciate that it was potentially his last game etc and he wanted to do his bit for the fans and the club, but was a half-broken Owen genuinely better than their next best 10? It's an odd one.

If he wasn't leaving, he probably would have been rested I guess.

Anyway, well played Saints and Bath - here's hoping that the final will be a cracker.

by Welshmushroom Sun Jun 02, 2024 5:49 am

Geordie wrote:Who are Saints losing....Lawes, Ludlam, Waller x 2, Moon

Lawes is pretty much irreplaceable, whilst Ludlum and Waller will the tough to replace..but not impossible. Their academy is churning out some top players at the moment aswell...

They are producing some great players but there are some pretty big losses in there that are not easily replaced. If they go with youth you would imagine it may take those players a couple of seasons before they get to those players level.

They have great coaches there though so no doubt will still be a force next season.

by formerly known as Sam Sun Jun 02, 2024 6:56 am

Welshmushroom wrote:
Geordie wrote:Who are Saints losing....Lawes, Ludlam, Waller x 2, Moon

Lawes is pretty much irreplaceable, whilst Ludlum and Waller will the tough to replace..but not impossible. Their academy is churning out some top players at the moment aswell...

They are producing some great players but there are some pretty big losses in there that are not easily replaced. If they go with youth you would imagine it may take those players a couple of seasons before they get to those players level.

They have great coaches there though so no doubt will still be a force next season.

Waller is being replaced by West. That's an upgrade. There's Ioygen and Haffar coming through as well, they are huge prospects meaning Waller the Younger wasn't really required.

Lawes is nigh on impossible to replace but Josh Kemeny from the Rebels is inbound to try and do the job. Ludlam and Moon haven't had any replacements announced yet but they'll need them. Moon is a big lump in the row and Ludlam covers the whole backrow. Pollock the England under 20s wonder kid is likely to get more game time next season so Pearson could start to cover more of the backrow but it's a step down. I'd expect a couple more signings to be incoming.

by doctor_grey Sun Jun 02, 2024 12:00 pm

Very interesting that the Bath 23 that defeated Sale today was the same as the 23 that defeated Saints more-or-less seconds. Only exception to the XVs being the same was Barbeary, who was on the bench against Saints and started against Bath.

by **Rugby Fan** Sun Jun 02, 2024 2:23 pm

Jonny Hill had an altercation with a Bath supporter after the match.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/rugby-union/2024/06/01/jonny-hill-bath-supporter-headlock-premiership/

An incident involving Jonny Hill will now be investigated by Sale Sharks after the England and Lions lock was accused of grabbing a Bath supporter in a headlock that left them with a cut above their right eye during ugly scenes after Bath’s semi-final victory at The Rec.

Hill, who is 6ft 7in, was not playing in the match and was dressed in casual clothes sat in the friends and family section of the West Stand, with the incident seen by multiple eyewitnesses.

The 28-year-old fan, who did not want to be named and was understood to have engaged in some banter with Hill at the end of the game, said afterwards: “I was sat there, and he came down the stairs, grabbed me around the throat, snapped my sunglasses and cut the top of my eye. He was like saying to me, ‘don’t ever do that again’.

“To be honest, all I want is a new pair of sunglasses. It is not football. I was sat with my partner and all her family (Bath fans). We were Worcester fans. I don’t want to make a big thing.”

Sale said in a statement: “Sale Sharks are aware of an incident involving a player and Bath Rugby fan at the final whistle of today’s semi-final. The club will work with Bath Rugby to complete an investigation into the incident and will provide no further comment at this time.”

Alex Sanderson, the club’s director of rugby, revealed afterwards that he had not seen the incident while also defending Hill’s character.

“It is news to me, Jonny is not the aggressive type and I will answer those questions when I know,” Sanderson said. “I can vouch for Jonny’s character, he is not an overly aggressive or spiteful person.”

Paul Deacon, the Sale assistant coach, could be overheard speaking to the supporter afterwards offering his apologies, while adding that he had not seen what happened...

by **RiscaGame** Sun Jun 02, 2024 5:12 pm

I had heard about that. I also heard of a Sale fan being punched in the head by a Bath fan on X too. Sounds a bit feisty there.

by Geordie Sun Jun 02, 2024 6:00 pm

formerly known as Sam wrote:
Welshmushroom wrote:
Geordie wrote:Who are Saints losing....Lawes, Ludlam, Waller x 2, Moon

Lawes is pretty much irreplaceable, whilst Ludlum and Waller will the tough to replace..but not impossible. Their academy is churning out some top players at the moment aswell...

They are producing some great players but there are some pretty big losses in there that are not easily replaced. If they go with youth you would imagine it may take those players a couple of seasons before they get to those players level.

They have great coaches there though so no doubt will still be a force next season.

Waller is being replaced by West. That's an upgrade. There's Ioygen and Haffar coming through as well, they are huge prospects meaning Waller the Younger wasn't really required.

Lawes is nigh on impossible to replace but Josh Kemeny from the Rebels is inbound to try and do the job. Ludlam and Moon haven't had any replacements announced yet but they'll need them. Moon is a big lump in the row and Ludlam covers the whole backrow. Pollock the England under 20s wonder kid is likely to get more game time next season so Pearson could start to cover more of the backrow but it's a step down. I'd expect a couple more signings to be incoming.

Didn't know they'd signed West...Good signing...and yes Iyogun and Haffar are two outstanding prospects.
Walkers consistency was his strength...just played every game. Players like that are priceless.

Pearson still a one to watch for me ...and as you say Pollock will play more next season.
If they get locks in Coles could very well play at 6 more...but I like how he's going at lock so would leave him there.

by WELL-PAST-IT Sun Jun 02, 2024 8:25 pm

formerly known as Sam wrote:
Welshmushroom wrote:
Geordie wrote:Who are Saints losing....Lawes, Ludlam, Waller x 2, Moon

Lawes is pretty much irreplaceable, whilst Ludlum and Waller will the tough to replace..but not impossible. Their academy is churning out some top players at the moment aswell...

They are producing some great players but there are some pretty big losses in there that are not easily replaced. If they go with youth you would imagine it may take those players a couple of seasons before they get to those players level.

They have great coaches there though so no doubt will still be a force next season.

Waller is being replaced by West. That's an upgrade. There's Ioygen and Haffar coming through as well, they are huge prospects meaning Waller the Younger wasn't really required.

Lawes is nigh on impossible to replace but Josh Kemeny from the Rebels is inbound to try and do the job. Ludlam and Moon haven't had any replacements announced yet but they'll need them. Moon is a big lump in the row and Ludlam covers the whole backrow. Pollock the England under 20s wonder kid is likely to get more game time next season so Pearson could start to cover more of the backrow but it's a step down. I'd expect a couple more signings to be incoming.

I would respectfully disagree with your comment about West being an upgrade to Waller (A), he struggles to make first choice with Sarries, two props ahead of him ahead. Waller has made 377 appearances in the Prem, way ahead of anybody else in his position, you don't do that by being a weak scrummager. He is still first choice at Saints in a pack that has being dominant against most Prem teams for the last two seasons. I suspect that Iyogun and Haffar will be on a level or better next year. I am not sure what West's ball play is like but Waller like most Saints forwards has very good hands and happily plays 1st receiver, he is also a lot quicker than he looks.

West has had only 5 starts this season (3 of them in the Rugby Cup), 2 Premiership starts both games Sarries lost and ironically one of them against Saints where Sarries were second best in the scrum; overall 13 appearances averaging 35 minutes per game

by doctor_grey Sun Jun 02, 2024 9:59 pm

Mate, I think West is a good addition. But Waller has been really playing out of his skin for most of this season. Really reminds me when he was young and still earning his stripes.

Saints had the best of the scrum for most of the game, and when Millar-Mills, Iyogun, and Matavesi came on the scrum went from being strong and better than Saracens to dominating. Almost started to bring back memories of Tiny, Dylan, and Mooj.

by formerly known as Sam Mon Jun 03, 2024 6:49 am

WELL-PAST-IT wrote:
formerly known as Sam wrote:
Welshmushroom wrote:
Geordie wrote:Who are Saints losing....Lawes, Ludlam, Waller x 2, Moon

Lawes is pretty much irreplaceable, whilst Ludlum and Waller will the tough to replace..but not impossible. Their academy is churning out some top players at the moment aswell...

They are producing some great players but there are some pretty big losses in there that are not easily replaced. If they go with youth you would imagine it may take those players a couple of seasons before they get to those players level.

They have great coaches there though so no doubt will still be a force next season.

Waller is being replaced by West. That's an upgrade. There's Ioygen and Haffar coming through as well, they are huge prospects meaning Waller the Younger wasn't really required.

Lawes is nigh on impossible to replace but Josh Kemeny from the Rebels is inbound to try and do the job. Ludlam and Moon haven't had any replacements announced yet but they'll need them. Moon is a big lump in the row and Ludlam covers the whole backrow. Pollock the England under 20s wonder kid is likely to get more game time next season so Pearson could start to cover more of the backrow but it's a step down. I'd expect a couple more signings to be incoming.

I would respectfully disagree with your comment about West being an upgrade to Waller (A), he struggles to make first choice with Sarries, two props ahead of him ahead. Waller has made 377 appearances in the Prem, way ahead of anybody else in his position, you don't do that by being a weak scrummager. He is still first choice at Saints in a pack that has being dominant against most Prem teams for the last two seasons. I suspect that Iyogun and Haffar will be on a level or better next year. I am not sure what West's ball play is like but Waller like most Saints forwards has very good hands and happily plays 1st receiver, he is also a lot quicker than he looks.

West has had only 5 starts this season (3 of them in the Rugby Cup), 2 Premiership starts both games Sarries lost and ironically one of them against Saints where Sarries were second best in the scrum; overall 13 appearances averaging 35 minutes per game

West has struggled at Sarries but the season before he spent half the season as Tigers go to option at loosehead being a significant part of the post Borthwick turnaround where Tigers went from free fall to making the playoffs and narrowly losing to Sale.

Alex Waller is leaving rugby in the form of his life, for most of his career he's been an average club level prop. West is more than that. Injuries and short term contracts haven't helped but I think he'll thrive for Saints next season. He's a better scrummaging prop than Waller (even the improved version) and can at least match what he offers in the loose. I'm annoyed as I'd have happily replaced Cronin with West every day of the week for next season.

by carpet baboon Mon Jun 03, 2024 7:20 am

Quick question.

Of the 4 teams playing yesterday which had the most players from there academy.

My gut says Northampton have the most and Bath the least.

by doctor_grey Mon Jun 03, 2024 8:40 am

carpet baboon wrote:Quick question.

Of the 4 teams playing yesterday which had the most players from there academy.

My gut says Northampton have the most and Bath the least.

That's a good question. I would think Saints as well.

by formerly known as Sam Mon Jun 03, 2024 5:12 pm

Sale might have been close with;

15. Joe Carpenter, 14. Tom Roebuck, 13. Sam James, 9. Gus Warr, 1. Bevan Rodd, 2. Tommy Taylor, 3. James Harper, 6. Ben Curry

, 7. Sam Dugdale,

Replacements:  

17. Si McIntyre, 21. Raffi Quirke, 22. Luke James, 23. Tom Curry.

13 of the 23.

by mountain man Mon Jun 03, 2024 5:54 pm

As a matter of interest, what's the feeling on having play offs? Good idea as exciting for fans, rugby usually played in better weather and gives opportunity for any of top 4 to win title.

Or is it a cynical money spinner when teams should be resting players and whoever finishes top at end of season should be declared winner?

My personal opinion is whoever finishes top should be winners, so this year it's Saints.
As a fan I love watching the play offs, but let's say Saracens who finished 4th had won their SF and then went on to win final. Would that be right outcome?

Yes all teams know from outset what the situation is but I cant help thinking the best team over whole season should be winner. This season Bath and Saints been close, both ending on 60 points but its not always the case.

Anyway, just wondering what others think about it.

by mountain man Tue Jun 04, 2024 1:54 am

As a matter of interest what's everyones opinion on having playoffs?

Good idea as fans get to see some great rugby in in better weather/conditions, a chance for any of top 4 to win title, clubs get money as almost guaranteed sellout crowds?

Or is it a cynical money spinner when players should be rested for summer and that whoever ends season top should be winner anyway?

My thinking is whoever ends season top is winner. For this season it's Saints. As a fan the matches are brilliant of course but let's say Saracens who ended up 4th had won their SF and then went on to win final. Would that be right? This season Bath and Saints ended up on 60 points so a close run affair but in past margin been fair bit more.
Obviously all teams know situation at start of year so it is what it is but I was wondering how everyone thinks about it.

by WELL-PAST-IT Tue Jun 04, 2024 3:55 am

I don't mind the playoffs, but there should be a reward for winning the Premiership and then another reward for winning another two games.

If I remember correctly, the playoffs were introduced to make it fair to those clubs that had been hit by international call ups, the effect of that has been muted now, so either get rid of them or make it a cup for winning the league and another for winning the top four final.

by doctor_grey Tue Jun 04, 2024 10:11 am

Yeah, but....
The playoffs were always about the money. Or, well, money and growing the sport. The rest were simple little obfuscations which helped rationalise the process. Which is fine because they are not really untrue, just not the main motivator. And I am firmly in the camp of the winner of the playoffs (a little good fortune Saturday, please) is the winner of the season. Most sport globally does it that way and everyone wins.

Ultimately, as Phil Dowson recently said: "No one remembers who came top of the table. They remember who hoisted the cup".

by Poorfour Tue Jun 04, 2024 9:11 pm

doctor_grey wrote:Yeah, but....
The playoffs were always about the money. Or, well, money and growing the sport. The rest were simple little obfuscations which helped rationalise the process. Which is fine because they are not really untrue, just not the main motivator. And I am firmly in the camp of the winner of the playoffs (a little good fortune Saturday, please) is the winner of the season. Most sport globally does it that way and everyone wins.

Ultimately, as Phil Dowson recently said: "No one remembers who came top of the table. They remember who hoisted the cup".

As a Quins fan who went to Ashton Gate 3 years ago, I endorse this position.

by Sponsored content