The v2 Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

+12
coxy0001
Imperial Ghosty
paperbag_puncher
CJB
milkyboy
HumanWindmill
Atila
Sugar Boy Sweetie
Scottrf
sittingringside
Rowley
The genius of PBF
16 posters

Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by The genius of PBF Fri 22 Jul 2011, 8:48 am

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Muhammad Ali
3. Harry Greb
4. Henry Armstrong
5. Sugar Ray Leonard
6. Benny Leonard
7. Willie Pep
8. Tommy Hearns
9. Pernell Whitaker
10. Lennox Lewis
11. Joe Louis
12. Sam Langford
13. Gene Tunney
14. Ezzard Charles
15. Eder Jofre
16. Stanley Ketchel
17. Jack Johnson
18. Joe Gans
19. Bob Fitzsimmons
20. Roberto Duran
21. Marvin Hagler
22. Jimmy Wilde
23. Ricardo Lopez
24. Archie Moore
25. Barney Ross
26. Tony Canzoneri
27. Oscar De La Hoya
28. Alexis Arguello
29. Aaron Pryor
30. Mickey Walker
31. Sandy Saddler
32. Jake LaMotta
33. Carlos Monzon
34. Larry Holmes
35. George Foreman
36. Julio Cesar Chavez
37. Charley Burley
38. Jim Jeffries
39. Michael Spinks
40. Ted Lewis
41. Jack Dempsey
42. Salvador Sanchez
43. Pancho Villa
44. Jimmy McLarnin
45. Barbados Joe Walcott
46. Carlos Ortiz
47. Jimmy Bivins
48. Joe Frazier
49. Mike McCallum
50. Emile Griffith

I have excluded the current boxers and slightly altered my list.


Last edited by The genius of PBF on Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:53 am; edited 2 times in total

The genius of PBF

Posts : 1552
Join date : 2011-06-03
Age : 47
Location : Las Vegas

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Rowley Fri 22 Jul 2011, 8:53 am

Hearns it too high for me, terrific fighter but not a top ten guy and certainly does not warrant a place above Langford Fitz or Charles for me. I agree with excluding current fighters though, a career should only be assessed when it is over. However as I struggle to get past a top ten have to admire you for taking on such a task.

Rowley
Admin
Admin

Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by sittingringside Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:05 am

Lamotta ahead of Monzon is an interesting one, I think most people would tend to swap them. You have Julio Cesar Chavez in twice.

sittingringside

Posts : 475
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Scotland/Cornwall

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Scottrf Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:06 am

sittingringside wrote:Lamotta ahead of Monzon is an interesting one, I think most people would tend to swap them. You have Julio Cesar Chavez in twice.
More incorrect than interesting.

Scottrf

Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Rowley Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:07 am

Scottrf wrote:
sittingringside wrote:Lamotta ahead of Monzon is an interesting one, I think most people would tend to swap them. You have Julio Cesar Chavez in twice.
More incorrect than interesting.

Not sure Chavez is good enough to feature twice either

Rowley
Admin
Admin

Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Scottrf Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:08 am

rowley wrote:
Scottrf wrote:
sittingringside wrote:Lamotta ahead of Monzon is an interesting one, I think most people would tend to swap them. You have Julio Cesar Chavez in twice.
More incorrect than interesting.

Not sure Chavez is good enough to feature twice either
Disagree.

Scottrf

Posts : 14359
Join date : 2011-01-26

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by sittingringside Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:13 am

Maybe one of the mentions refers to his son, the pound 4 pound great Julio Cesar Chavez Jr?

sittingringside

Posts : 475
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Scotland/Cornwall

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by The genius of PBF Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:31 am

Scottrf wrote:
rowley wrote:
Scottrf wrote:
sittingringside wrote:Lamotta ahead of Monzon is an interesting one, I think most people would tend to swap them. You have Julio Cesar Chavez in twice.
More incorrect than interesting.

Not sure Chavez is good enough to feature twice either
Disagree.

Thought I forgot to include the great Chavez which is why I added him again when I was doing a revised list but thanks for pointing out the mistake any suggestions who should be in the top 50????

The genius of PBF

Posts : 1552
Join date : 2011-06-03
Age : 47
Location : Las Vegas

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Sugar Boy Sweetie Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:33 am

Hearns, Sweet Pea and Lennox all a bit too high for me, but horses for courses.
Sugar Boy Sweetie
Sugar Boy Sweetie

Posts : 1869
Join date : 2011-01-26

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by The genius of PBF Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:34 am

Sugar Boy Sweetie wrote:Hearns, Sweet Pea and Lennox all a bit too high for me, but horses for courses.

I rated all 3 higher than most people.

The genius of PBF

Posts : 1552
Join date : 2011-06-03
Age : 47
Location : Las Vegas

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Sugar Boy Sweetie Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:40 am

The genius of PBF wrote:
Sugar Boy Sweetie wrote:Hearns, Sweet Pea and Lennox all a bit too high for me, but horses for courses.

I rated all 3 higher than most people.

Like I say horses for courses. All great fighters - lennox one of my personal top 5 favourites of all time. Pernell might make my p4p top 20, hearns I think you're being generous to as he lost his 2 biggest fights plus a couple of others he shouldn't have such as Barkley, but your list is your list.
Sugar Boy Sweetie
Sugar Boy Sweetie

Posts : 1869
Join date : 2011-01-26

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by sittingringside Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:44 am

I think more people would debate the ordering rather than the names you've got in there, which look pretty solid.

sittingringside

Posts : 475
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Scotland/Cornwall

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Atila Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:49 am

Sugar Ray Leonard, Thomas Hearns and Lennox Lewis are rated too high for me. But all power to you for doing a list, I never can.

Atila

Posts : 1711
Join date : 2011-06-03

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by HumanWindmill Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:51 am

I'd find places for George Dixon, Packey McFarland and José Napoles. Maybe Terry McGovern and Emile Griffith, also.

HumanWindmill
VIP
VIP

Posts : 10945
Join date : 2011-02-18

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Guest Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:57 am

Emile Griffith is at 50 Windy.I would reverese Arguello and Pryor,and find a place for Joey Giardello.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by HumanWindmill Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:59 am

So he is, andy. Thanks for pointing it out, and my apologies to PBF.

HumanWindmill
VIP
VIP

Posts : 10945
Join date : 2011-02-18

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by milkyboy Fri 22 Jul 2011, 10:02 am

Atila wrote:Sugar Ray Leonard, Thomas Hearns and Lennox Lewis are rated too high for me. But all power to you for doing a list, I never can.

sugar ray too high atila? Surely not! Actually, I agree with you on all counts, especially the list compiling bit which is frankly way too much like hard work

milkyboy

Posts : 7762
Join date : 2011-05-22

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by The genius of PBF Fri 22 Jul 2011, 10:04 am

andygf wrote:Emile Griffith is at 50 Windy.I would reverese Arguello and Pryor,and find a place for Joey Giardello.

I edited the list when Windy mentioned Emile so I should have mentioned it on the thread...apologies to everybody for the misunderstanding.

The genius of PBF

Posts : 1552
Join date : 2011-06-03
Age : 47
Location : Las Vegas

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by HumanWindmill Fri 22 Jul 2011, 10:06 am

The genius of PBF wrote:
andygf wrote:Emile Griffith is at 50 Windy.I would reverese Arguello and Pryor,and find a place for Joey Giardello.

I edited the list when Windy mentioned Emile so I should have mentioned it on the thread...apologies to everybody for the misunderstanding.

No probs, mate.

You could have gotten away with it, though, since everybody knows I'm three parts senile. Very Happy

HumanWindmill
VIP
VIP

Posts : 10945
Join date : 2011-02-18

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by CJB Fri 22 Jul 2011, 10:22 am

Chavez an dDuran higher personally

CJB

Posts : 5762
Join date : 2011-04-24
Age : 30
Location : Croydon

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by paperbag_puncher Fri 22 Jul 2011, 10:26 am

How in gods name is La Motta ahead of Monzon? You have a man whos more famous for a movie than his actual career ahead of a top 3 MW? I also think Benny Leonards too far ahead of Duran, De la Hoyas way too high and there are others that are way too high. Lennox Lewis doesnt make it in to my top 10 heavys let alone top 10 P4P. Wouldnt like to see the original list if this is the revised one.

However, fair play for making a list. I'm way too lazy to compile one.

paperbag_puncher

Posts : 2516
Join date : 2011-02-25

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Imperial Ghosty Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:11 pm

Tunney, Charles, Jofre, Fitzsimmons, Arguello and Duran are far too low, in no shape or form should Hearns be higher than any of them

De La Hoya, LaMotta and Lewis shouldn't be in a top 50 at all

Other than that i'd be here years correcting it

Imperial Ghosty

Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by coxy0001 Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:16 pm

Whitaker above Tunney? As Ghosty has said there's quite a few glaringly illogical placements in the rankings and i haven't got all afternoon highlighting them.

I mean SRL above Pep? Nope.

coxy0001

Posts : 4250
Join date : 2011-01-28
Location : Tory country

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by 88Chris05 Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:36 pm

Interesting list, PBF. Would be here all day if I picked the bones out of all of it, but that's the nature of these lists, I suppose.

I don't see how Chavez can be outside of the top twenty, or at least out of the top twenty-five, much less out of the top thirty-five, as you have him. For instance, how can you justify having the likes of Wilde, De la Hoya and La Motta ahead of him? In terms of achievements he leaves those men eating his dust.

Would add Mike Spinks to the top twenty-five at least, too. Easily a top five man in (probably) boxing's strongest ever division and then being the first 175 lb champion to step up and win the Heavyweight title entitles him to a high placing, in my eyes. Lennox Lewis and Hearns are both far too high for me, but we've had this discussion before, so no point going over old ground I suppose!

Would add that Barney Ross should be higher, though. Borderline top ten for me, at the very least top fifteen.
88Chris05
88Chris05
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 9661
Join date : 2011-02-16
Age : 36
Location : Nottingham

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Rowley Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:41 pm

Chris have you read Douglas Century's book on Ross, only ask as I know you're a massive fan and I read it a couple of months ago.

Rowley
Admin
Admin

Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Imperial Ghosty Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:44 pm

I would say what I really think of this list but think i'd be joining Roley in the cage if I did

Imperial Ghosty

Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by 88Chris05 Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:45 pm

rowley wrote:Chris have you read Douglas Century's book on Ross, only ask as I know you're a massive fan and I read it a couple of months ago.

Not yet Jeff, sadly enough. Have been meaning to get myself a copy, will have to do a.s.a.p. Without giving away too much, is it a thumbs up or thumbs down from you?
88Chris05
88Chris05
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 9661
Join date : 2011-02-16
Age : 36
Location : Nottingham

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Rowley Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:49 pm

Generally down mate, is part of a series on prominent jews or some such and so there are points you will feel you are getting a Jewish history lesson, which is fascinating enough but not exactly what you read a boxing book for. The stuff about his upbringing and life after boxing are well done and pretty in dpeth but this means his career in the ring is zipped through way too quick and for me when you are talking about a guy who fought who Ross fought he deserves better. Is relatively cheap so is probably worth buying but there is a far better biography of Ross yet to be written.

Rowley
Admin
Admin

Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by d260005p Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:49 pm

Id have Floyd Mayweather and Pacman midway through the list. Why is DLH so high at 27?? He got beat by Mosley and knocked out by Hopkins. Speaking of Hopkins, where the hell is he in the list?

d260005p

Posts : 674
Join date : 2011-07-14
Age : 38
Location : Telford

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by bhb001 Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:50 pm

Back on my horse about how highly rated Lewis is. As far as pound for pound is concerned, Archie Moore has to be higher placed than Lewis. The man fought at middle weight, light heavy and heavy, often times moving between them with only a month to shed or add weight. Yet he had over 200 fights! An absolute one of a kind who should be rated higher.

bhb001

Posts : 2675
Join date : 2011-02-16

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by 88Chris05 Fri 22 Jul 2011, 12:58 pm

rowley wrote:Generally down mate, is part of a series on prominent jews or some such and so there are points you will feel you are getting a Jewish history lesson, which is fascinating enough but not exactly what you read a boxing book for. The stuff about his upbringing and life after boxing are well done and pretty in dpeth but this means his career in the ring is zipped through way too quick and for me when you are talking about a guy who fought who Ross fought he deserves better. Is relatively cheap so is probably worth buying but there is a far better biography of Ross yet to be written.

That's a shame, will probably still read it at some stage though, as I'm not aware of too many other publications based on Ross. Have read a shed load of article clippings and mini biographies about him, often centred on his Jewish heritage, how he was pushed to the forefront in order to project a more positive view of the religion, how he served in World War Two and also his drug addiction in later life, which was caused by his medication for his war wounds. Would have liked a quality biography to top it off, based on your review I may have to wait a little longer for that!
88Chris05
88Chris05
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 9661
Join date : 2011-02-16
Age : 36
Location : Nottingham

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by KO-KING Fri 22 Jul 2011, 6:48 pm

27. Oscar De La Hoya? to high 50-75
Lamotta even in top 100 - what has he acheived?

KO-KING

Posts : 1052
Join date : 2011-02-02

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by KO-KING Fri 22 Jul 2011, 6:52 pm

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Muhammad Ali
4. Roberto Duran
5. Harry Greb
6. Sugar Ray Leonard
7. Benny Leonard
8. Willie Pep
9. Pernell Whitaker
10. Ezzard Charles

KO-KING

Posts : 1052
Join date : 2011-02-02

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by sittingringside Fri 22 Jul 2011, 9:12 pm

I might find a spot for Carmen Basilio

sittingringside

Posts : 475
Join date : 2011-04-27
Location : Scotland/Cornwall

Back to top Go down

Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List Empty Re: Revised Top 50 ATG Pound for Pound List

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum