606v2 Super Featherweight Rankings

These seem to be dying a death now so will just get the rest out of the way so I can post the results

1. Arguello
2. Mayweather
3. Saddler
4. Elorde
5. Nelson
6. Chavez
7. Mitchell
8. Dundee
9. Chocolate
10. Pacquiao
11. Marquez
12. Barrera
13. Morales
14. Chacon
15. Kobayashi

Bah! Let's give it a go - 1) Arguello 2) Mayweather 3) Chavez 4) Nelson 5) Elorde 6) Saddler 7) Camacho 8) Mitchell 9) Pacquiao 10) Barrera 11) Kid Chocolate 12) Chacon 13) Dundee 14) Marquez 15) Freitas

Escalera, Limon, Morales, Boza and one or two others miss out narrowly.

Captain's list is much more in line with how I see it...

Castillo, Limon, Chacon, escalera and nine defences odd give Alexis the honor...though I see Mayweather beating him if they fought...

Mayweather 2nd and Chavez third..nine defences unbeaten is much better than tenth????

1) Alexis Arguello
2) Julio Cesar Chavez
3) Floyd Mayweather Jr
4) Azumah Nelson
5) Gabriel 'Flash' Elorde
6) Brian Mitchell
7) Sandy Saddler
8) Kid Chocolate
9) Alfredo Escalera
10) Todd Morgan
11) Marco Antonio Barrera
12) Johnny Dundee
13) Bobby Chacon
14) Benny Bass
15) Hector Camacho

Superb division, I'm glad it's getting it's own billing. The top four are absolutely set in stone, for me, although you could quibble about the order of numbers two, three and four.

I have to change my opinion of Pacquiao, having revisited his career. He fought far more at 130 than I'd thought, with mostly excellent results and he deserves to be quite high in the lists, in fact. I shall make the necessary amendment to my rankings.

Was going to say Captain it's probably Pacmans best weight for me, wins over Marquez, Barrera, Morales, Solis and Larios are with the exception of Cotto and Hatton the best of his career.

Arguello
Chavez
Mayweather Jr
Nelson
Elorde
Chocolate
Saddler
Mitchell
Barrera
Camacho
Pacquiao
Frietas
Morales
Chacon
Marquez

Upon further reflection have decided to amend my list with Chavez moving up a few places

Mayweather Jnr
Arguello
Saddler
Nelson
Chavez
Pacquiao
Mitchell
Elorde
Chocolate
Dundee
Escalera
Barrera
Chacon
Morales
J.M Marquez

I place Pacquiao so high as I think this was his best weight.

1. Arguello
2. Chavez
3. Mayweather
4. Nelson
5. Mitchell
6. Elorde
7. Pacquaio
8. Chocolate
9. Saddler
10. Barrera
11. Escalera
12. Morales
13. Chacon
14. Camacho
15. Morgan

1. Arguello
2. Mayweather
3. Elorde
4. Nelson
5. Mitchell
6. Chavez
7. Saddler
8. Chocolate
9. Morgan
10. Pacquiao
11. Hernandez
12. Escalera
13. Freitas
14. Villaflor
15. Kobayashi

1. Arguello
2. Nelson
3. Mayweather
4. Saddler
5. Chavez
6. Elorde
7. Chocolate
8. Pacquiao
9. Mitchell
10. Dundee
11. Barrera
12. Escarela
13. Marquez
14. Morales
15. Camacho

1. Arguello
2. Chavez
3. Nelson
4. Mayweather
5. Pacquiao
6. Elorde
7. Saddler
8. Chocolate
9. Camacho
10 Barrera
11. Mitchell
12. Dundee
13. Escarela
14. Morgan
15. Freitas

Surprised to see Pacquaio feature so low on these lists in general. Hes miles ahead of the likes of Mitchell and Camacho at the weight in my view and I tend to view his achievements there as not too far behind Mayweather.

1. Arguello
2. Saddler
3. Elorde
4. Chavez
5. Mayweather
6. Nelson
7. Pacquiao
8. Chocolate
9. Mitchell
10. Barrera
11. Marquez
12. Dundee
13. Morales
14. Chacon
15. Kobayashi

Along with Truss, I found captaincarrantuohil's list very difficult to argue with, my one deviation being that I give Mitchell the tiniest of edges over Camacho.

1. Arguello
2. Mayweather
3. Chavez
4. Nelson
5. Elorde
6. Saddler
7. Mitchell
8. Camacho
9. Pacquiao
10.Barrera
11.Chocolate
12.Chacon
13.Dundee
14.Marquez
15.Freitas

1. Alexis Arguello
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Sandy Saddler
4. Julio Cesar Chavez
5. Azumah Nelson
6. Gabriel Elorde
7. Brian Mitchell
8. Kid Chocolate
9. Manny Pacquiao
10. Johnny Dundee
11. Marco Antonio Barrera
12. Eric Morales
13. Juan Manuel Marquez
14. Bobby Chacon
15. Hiroshi Kobayashi