Could/should be capped for your country
+23
WELL-PAST-IT
LondonTiger
madmaccas
BamBam
Luckless Pedestrian
blackcanelion
Notch
ChequeredJersey
InjuredYetAgain
funnyExiledScot
bluestonevedder
Cumbrian
Geordie
beshocked
Jenifer McLadyboy
maestegmafia
Taylorman
welshy824 (new)
George Carlin
Scrumdown
The Saint
bedfordwelsh
Looseheaded
27 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Could/should be capped for your country
To allow an insight into other players other than your own country's ones, I thought it might be interesting to name mostly uncapped players from your club/province/region (though forgotten capped players like Tom Prydie are fine if needs must) who you think could/should gain international recognition this coming season. It doesn't have to be purely your own team's players (particularly if you have no particular affinity to a "club" team), but it might be interesting to look back in a little while and see if players like Marland Yarde or Christian Leali'ifano are predicted.
So for the Dragons
Could
Seniors
Lewis Evans
Nic Cudd
U20's
Ieuan Jones
Jack Dixon
Should
Jon Evans
Dan Evans
So from Dragons, Lewis Evans has been there or thereabouts. Nic Cudd was one of the form Welsh 7s in the league (especially in a misfiring team) and the two young guys are highly thought of at the minute. For the shoulds, I think Jon Evans deserved to tour Japan this summer and Dan Evans probably would've gained more caps if he wasn't forced to play 10 a few games (when he's much more accomplished at 15). Dan could/should've been the Welsh fullback in Japan (with Sanjay wing over Prydie or especially Howells).
So for the Dragons
Could
Seniors
Lewis Evans
Nic Cudd
U20's
Ieuan Jones
Jack Dixon
Should
Jon Evans
Dan Evans
So from Dragons, Lewis Evans has been there or thereabouts. Nic Cudd was one of the form Welsh 7s in the league (especially in a misfiring team) and the two young guys are highly thought of at the minute. For the shoulds, I think Jon Evans deserved to tour Japan this summer and Dan Evans probably would've gained more caps if he wasn't forced to play 10 a few games (when he's much more accomplished at 15). Dan could/should've been the Welsh fullback in Japan (with Sanjay wing over Prydie or especially Howells).
Guest- Guest
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
JSD for England
that's it, i get pretty angry when remembering how poor his international career has been
that's it, i get pretty angry when remembering how poor his international career has been
Looseheaded- Posts : 1030
Join date : 2011-05-10
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Rev,
Agree with all and thought Evans would have had more involvement of late, also I still think Adam Hughes could cope at that level but seems to have slipped down the order considerably
Agree with all and thought Evans would have had more involvement of late, also I still think Adam Hughes could cope at that level but seems to have slipped down the order considerably
bedfordwelsh- Moderator
- Posts : 9962
Join date : 2011-05-11
Age : 56
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Could:
Adam Hughes
Jason Tovey (years ago)
Dan Evans
Should:
Lewis Evans
Jonny Evans
It's a travesty watching Shanks put in all the hard work and then get over looked for players playing crap like Pretorious, Turnbull and McCusker. and Dan Baker (what was that selection all about?) I hope Japan was an eye-opener. I also agree it would have been wise to take a capped player who can cover a few positions like Dan Evans over an absurd pick like Howells.
For the Scarlets I think their scrum-half Gareth Davies is a should. He is overlooked not only by the Wales selectors, but the Scarlet ones too. Their incumbents Knoyle and the 18 years old Aled Davies were particularly unimpressive; a binary opposite to the form of GD.
Owen Williams, another Scarlet was a should for the Japan tour. He would have been a good back-up to Biggar.
Adam Hughes
Jason Tovey (years ago)
Dan Evans
Should:
Lewis Evans
Jonny Evans
It's a travesty watching Shanks put in all the hard work and then get over looked for players playing crap like Pretorious, Turnbull and McCusker. and Dan Baker (what was that selection all about?) I hope Japan was an eye-opener. I also agree it would have been wise to take a capped player who can cover a few positions like Dan Evans over an absurd pick like Howells.
For the Scarlets I think their scrum-half Gareth Davies is a should. He is overlooked not only by the Wales selectors, but the Scarlet ones too. Their incumbents Knoyle and the 18 years old Aled Davies were particularly unimpressive; a binary opposite to the form of GD.
Owen Williams, another Scarlet was a should for the Japan tour. He would have been a good back-up to Biggar.
The Saint- Posts : 6046
Join date : 2013-05-04
Age : 35
Location : South-East Region
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Rhys Patchell (cardiff blues) should be capped as soon as possible in readiness for being Wales 10 at the next World Cup.
Rhodri Williams (scarlets) is the next great welsh scrum half and again should be pushed forward in readiness for 2015.
Samson Lee (Scarlets) is the long term successor to Adam Jones and should therefore be pushed forward to the welsh bench in the autumn series.
Any one of Corry Allen (blues), Eli Walker (ospreys) and jordan Williams (scarlets) to add a spark to the welsh backline.
Rhodri Williams (scarlets) is the next great welsh scrum half and again should be pushed forward in readiness for 2015.
Samson Lee (Scarlets) is the long term successor to Adam Jones and should therefore be pushed forward to the welsh bench in the autumn series.
Any one of Corry Allen (blues), Eli Walker (ospreys) and jordan Williams (scarlets) to add a spark to the welsh backline.
Scrumdown- Posts : 455
Join date : 2012-05-07
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Patchell was capped in Japan but agree with him and Lee being involved in the AIs
bedfordwelsh- Moderator
- Posts : 9962
Join date : 2011-05-11
Age : 56
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
If you'd asked me in May (before the Quadrangular tournament) Risca I would have been able to give you loads of names. However, we capped 11 players throughout that tournament - including some guys who had been waiting for a while. Not too many young players that still need to be capped - young Jonny Gray (brother of Richie and almost the same size) looks a real prospect but he's still a nipper, Sean Kennedy at Edinburgh is Scotland's future 9, but not yet.
Best young players (which is what you're asking, I think) who have handful of caps only are:
Alex Dunbar- Glasgow Warriors centre - quick, agile and can offload beautifully - he and Matt Scott are the future Scotland 12/13 combo.
Peter Horne - again, Warriors centre - poor bugger tore his ACL and is now out for 9 months.
Duncan Taylor - our young Saracen, looks like a solid, confident midfielder, nice to have blooded him internationally now.
Pat MacArthur - young Warriors hooker, should have been capped ages ago - Ross Ford didn't come close to his consistency last season.
Tim Swinson - Geordie Falcon's secret weapon, Swinson looks like he is finally the answer to 'whom to partner Richie Gray. Jim Hamilton with a better engine and a lower penalty count, Al Kellock but with the sheer aggression turned up to '11' rather than stuck at '3'. Expect Swinson and Gray to be the Scottish boiler room in the 6N.
Best young players (which is what you're asking, I think) who have handful of caps only are:
Alex Dunbar- Glasgow Warriors centre - quick, agile and can offload beautifully - he and Matt Scott are the future Scotland 12/13 combo.
Peter Horne - again, Warriors centre - poor bugger tore his ACL and is now out for 9 months.
Duncan Taylor - our young Saracen, looks like a solid, confident midfielder, nice to have blooded him internationally now.
Pat MacArthur - young Warriors hooker, should have been capped ages ago - Ross Ford didn't come close to his consistency last season.
Tim Swinson - Geordie Falcon's secret weapon, Swinson looks like he is finally the answer to 'whom to partner Richie Gray. Jim Hamilton with a better engine and a lower penalty count, Al Kellock but with the sheer aggression turned up to '11' rather than stuck at '3'. Expect Swinson and Gray to be the Scottish boiler room in the 6N.
George Carlin- Admin
- Posts : 15780
Join date : 2011-06-23
Location : KSA
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
for wales
eli walker
Samson lee
Jordan Williams
Owen Williams
Corey Allen
Gareth Davies
Rhodri Williams
Ieaun Jones
and the young dragon fullback who's name has escaped me
one for the future is rhys Williams, currently at the Leicester tigers academy, he is such a naturally gifted player.
eli walker
Samson lee
Jordan Williams
Owen Williams
Corey Allen
Gareth Davies
Rhodri Williams
Ieaun Jones
and the young dragon fullback who's name has escaped me
one for the future is rhys Williams, currently at the Leicester tigers academy, he is such a naturally gifted player.
welshy824 (new)- Posts : 162
Join date : 2012-02-01
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Scrumdown wrote:Rhys Patchell (cardiff blues) Rhodri Williams (scarlets) is the next great welsh scrum half and again should be pushed forward in readiness for 2015.
Samson Lee (Scarlets) is the long term successor to Adam Jones and should therefore be pushed forward to the welsh bench in the autumn series.
Whilst I agree with both of these points, though I'd be hesitant to label Rhodri as a future 'great', I think with props you have to accept that many won't be international standard until they are over 25, especially on the tight. Samson has time, and I'd say Craig Mitchell and, latterly off the bench, Scott Andrews have proven adequate deputies to the best tighthead in the world. I'd say Samson's time is post-'15, he's been comprehensively bested a few times in the Rabo and still has an awful lot of learning to do to add to natural ability and attitude he has. Hopefully with the same humility as Adam Jones he'll become a quality international 3, but I think we're still 4-5 years away from that.
Agree with everything about Gareth Davies about, a more talented 9 than Tavis and definitely Aled Davies, should be Phillips' replacement. Also agree with Alex Dunbar, admittedly haven't seen loads of him but what I have has been very positive. That Nick deLuca has the number of caps he has is baffling.
Guest- Guest
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Yes that tournament will benefit Scotland greatly George.
Yes I suppose it is mostly youngsters who will get brought up, but also players like Dan Evans from us who have been capped previously, aren't that young and should gain further caps.
Yes I suppose it is mostly youngsters who will get brought up, but also players like Dan Evans from us who have been capped previously, aren't that young and should gain further caps.
Guest- Guest
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Dan Evans, like Andy Fenby, Richard Fussell, Adam Hughes etc. is a decent footballer with good skills which he can showcase to good effect in the Rabo, but who is simply not good enough to play regular international rugby.
I'd say in Wales the main selection issue is, instead of picking good reserve players like Lewis Evans, who may be needed come the World Cup if there is an injury crisis, the management has decided to bypass these players due to age and take a punt with youngsters, like Kristian Phillips and Tom Prydie in 2010. It's the wrong tactic in my opinion, did Howells really deserve his cap over Fussell or Hughes as a 3/4? Obviously not, if he's good enough he'll be playing for Wales in 2-3 years time on merit. That's what the regional system is there for, surely?
I'd say in Wales the main selection issue is, instead of picking good reserve players like Lewis Evans, who may be needed come the World Cup if there is an injury crisis, the management has decided to bypass these players due to age and take a punt with youngsters, like Kristian Phillips and Tom Prydie in 2010. It's the wrong tactic in my opinion, did Howells really deserve his cap over Fussell or Hughes as a 3/4? Obviously not, if he's good enough he'll be playing for Wales in 2-3 years time on merit. That's what the regional system is there for, surely?
Guest- Guest
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Should...Blues player of the year and future 7's extraordinaire...Luke Braid
Should...but won't...Craig Clarke...inspirational winning captain of the sxv's Chiefs side.
Should...but won't...Craig Clarke...inspirational winning captain of the sxv's Chiefs side.
Taylorman- Posts : 12343
Join date : 2011-02-02
Location : Wellington NZ
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
miaow wrote:Dan Evans, like Andy Fenby, Richard Fussell, Adam Hughes etc. is a decent footballer with good skills which he can showcase to good effect in the Rabo, but who is simply not good enough to play regular international rugby.
I'd say in Wales the main selection issue is, instead of picking good reserve players like Lewis Evans, who may be needed come the World Cup if there is an injury crisis, the management has decided to bypass these players due to age and take a punt with youngsters, like Kristian Phillips and Tom Prydie in 2010. It's the wrong tactic in my opinion, did Howells really deserve his cap over Fussell or Hughes as a 3/4? Obviously not, if he's good enough he'll be playing for Wales in 2-3 years time on merit. That's what the regional system is there for, surely?
I agree in part but I can see their logic too. Being part of the squad involves a great deal more than just playing rugby. For a young player to be part of that set up will benefit their progress.
I think Prydie was great last season finally shock off his awful injury. I can see him and Ross Jones battling hard for the Wales fullback shirt over the next few years.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
You never know. He could well play for Ireland. He will only be 32 at the end of his contract with Connacht, by which time he will be IQ (unless he has played some game for NZ 7s or somethin g that I don't know about)Taylorman wrote:
Should...but won't...Craig Clarke...inspirational winning captain of the sxv's Chiefs side.
Nathan White shod see some gametime fo us too, as we are focked for THs, and he qualifies at the end of this coming season.
Jenifer McLadyboy- Posts : 4764
Join date : 2011-06-30
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Saracens
Should be
Will Fraser
George Kruis
Joel Tomkins
Bolter could be someone like
Ben Ransom, Jamie George or Ben Spencer - fortune with injuries would be needed.
Should be
Will Fraser
George Kruis
Joel Tomkins
Bolter could be someone like
Ben Ransom, Jamie George or Ben Spencer - fortune with injuries would be needed.
beshocked- Posts : 14849
Join date : 2011-03-08
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Tim Swinson - Geordie Falcon's secret weapon,
Crackin player...was a big fans favorite
Geordie- Posts : 28849
Join date : 2011-03-31
Location : Newcastle
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
GeordieFalcon wrote:Tim Swinson - Geordie Falcon's secret weapon,
Crackin player...was a big fans favorite
Was he not capped in SA vs the Boks and Italy...?
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
As a Newcastle fan:
Should:
Grant Shiells, I am not sure of Scotland's loose head stocks, but I think he will be a stalwart of your front row for many years to come. Excellent young player.
Bolters:
Will Welch, back row is becoming a really competitive area for England and I reckon he will probably be one of those players like James Scaysbrook and we look back and think 'how didn't he get a shot''?
Kieran Brookes: You will probably call me mad, but he plays in a position that we are weak in (tight head) and he seems to get called up at every opportunity for the Saxons. He is still only 22, a baby in prop terms and it is easy to forget just how good he was becoming before he went to Tigers and got injured. If Deano can get him fit and firing I really reckon he has a shot for England.
Dom Barrow, it very much depends upon how he progresses when he gets his opportunities though.
That's about it I'm afraid.
Should:
Grant Shiells, I am not sure of Scotland's loose head stocks, but I think he will be a stalwart of your front row for many years to come. Excellent young player.
Bolters:
Will Welch, back row is becoming a really competitive area for England and I reckon he will probably be one of those players like James Scaysbrook and we look back and think 'how didn't he get a shot''?
Kieran Brookes: You will probably call me mad, but he plays in a position that we are weak in (tight head) and he seems to get called up at every opportunity for the Saxons. He is still only 22, a baby in prop terms and it is easy to forget just how good he was becoming before he went to Tigers and got injured. If Deano can get him fit and firing I really reckon he has a shot for England.
Dom Barrow, it very much depends upon how he progresses when he gets his opportunities though.
That's about it I'm afraid.
Cumbrian- Posts : 5605
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 41
Location : Bath
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Actually Dom Barrow and David Sisi look like they have a good future, both big lads too. Along with Jack Clifford (unless he does an Alex Gray).
The Saint- Posts : 6046
Join date : 2013-05-04
Age : 35
Location : South-East Region
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
maestegmafia wrote:GeordieFalcon wrote:Tim Swinson - Geordie Falcon's secret weapon,
Crackin player...was a big fans favorite
Was he not capped in SA vs the Boks and Italy...?
I thought he was too. From what I remember, he put a HELL of a shift in that game. Tackling everyone behind the line. Him and Richie in the AIs for Scotland I think.
bluestonevedder- Posts : 3952
Join date : 2011-08-22
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
I'm not sure about Sisi, because of his bulk he has always had things pretty much his own way in the U20's. I would like to see him properly scrutinised at first team level before I make up my mind.
Clifford is a little different, he is more squat and powerful than Alex Gray ever was. Gray had the skill, he just never had the frame. Clifford is an excellent rugby player, without being a beanpole. I still reckon he'll end up moving to openside to back up Wallace at Quins (with Robshaw moving to 6) though.
Clifford is a little different, he is more squat and powerful than Alex Gray ever was. Gray had the skill, he just never had the frame. Clifford is an excellent rugby player, without being a beanpole. I still reckon he'll end up moving to openside to back up Wallace at Quins (with Robshaw moving to 6) though.
Cumbrian- Posts : 5605
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 41
Location : Bath
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
bluestonevedder wrote:maestegmafia wrote:GeordieFalcon wrote:Tim Swinson - Geordie Falcon's secret weapon,
Crackin player...was a big fans favorite
Was he not capped in SA vs the Boks and Italy...?
I thought he was too. From what I remember, he put a HELL of a shift in that game. Tackling everyone behind the line. Him and Richie in the AIs for Scotland I think.
I agree, looks a real talent and could compliment Gray well.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Yep, Big Tim now has 2 caps - the first against the Boks where he was MoM for me (hence I said the people that needed capped a month ago now have been). He may well be the missing piece in our tight game. If you look at a tight five of 1. Grant 2. MacArthur 3. Murray 4. Swinson and 5.Gray with Kelly Brown, Johnny Beattie and a (now fit after 2 years) Ross Rennie behind them, that could be a cohesive thing of beauty come the Six Nations.bluestonevedder wrote:maestegmafia wrote:GeordieFalcon wrote:Tim Swinson - Geordie Falcon's secret weapon,
Crackin player...was a big fans favorite
Was he not capped in SA vs the Boks and Italy...?
I thought he was too. From what I remember, he put a HELL of a shift in that game. Tackling everyone behind the line. Him and Richie in the AIs for Scotland I think.
George Carlin- Admin
- Posts : 15780
Join date : 2011-06-23
Location : KSA
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Can't see any uncapped players at Edinburgh earning a 1st cap this season.
There's an uncapped outside centre at Glasgow who can apparently play a bit, and he may be getting his first cap at some point this season.
There's an uncapped outside centre at Glasgow who can apparently play a bit, and he may be getting his first cap at some point this season.
funnyExiledScot- Posts : 17072
Join date : 2011-05-31
Age : 43
Location : Edinburgh
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Honestly. YOU trying spotting the difference:funnyExiledScot wrote:Can't see any uncapped players at Edinburgh earning a 1st cap this season.
There's an uncapped outside centre at Glasgow who can apparently play a bit, and he may be getting his first cap at some point this season.
1. A Messiah
2. A Very Naughty Boy
George Carlin- Admin
- Posts : 15780
Join date : 2011-06-23
Location : KSA
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
To be brutally honest, I don't think there are that many SQ but uncapped players at either Edinburgh or Glasgow.
Great things were expected of Stuart McInally when he left school and signed for Edinburgh but he doesn't seem to have delivered his early promise. We aren't exactly tripping over back row forwards who are fit so he may get a call to arms in the AI series
Great things were expected of Stuart McInally when he left school and signed for Edinburgh but he doesn't seem to have delivered his early promise. We aren't exactly tripping over back row forwards who are fit so he may get a call to arms in the AI series
InjuredYetAgain- Posts : 1317
Join date : 2011-06-02
Age : 58
Location : Edinburgh
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Quins:
Should/could be capped- Lowe (though his time has gone), Wallace, Guest (see Lowe), Gray -- in the more distant future - maybe Chisholm, Walker, Matthews, Buchanan, Botica if he picks UK, Clifford, Sinckler
Should/could be capped- Lowe (though his time has gone), Wallace, Guest (see Lowe), Gray -- in the more distant future - maybe Chisholm, Walker, Matthews, Buchanan, Botica if he picks UK, Clifford, Sinckler
ChequeredJersey- Posts : 18707
Join date : 2011-12-23
Age : 35
Location : London, UK
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
maestegmafia wrote:
I think Prydie was great last season finally shock off his awful injury. I can see him and Ross Jones battling hard for the Wales fullback shirt over the next few years.
Halfpenny's only 24, so I can't see anyone getting a serious look in for a while yet. But then I'd say Liam Williams is certainly second in line, offering pretty much the antithesis to Halfpenny. Prydie looks a decent player who, with another good season with the Dragons, might get in the squad for his back up kicking ability alone. Can't say I've seen enough of Ross Jones to comment.
Guest- Guest
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
miaow wrote:maestegmafia wrote:
I think Prydie was great last season finally shock off his awful injury. I can see him and Ross Jones battling hard for the Wales fullback shirt over the next few years.
Halfpenny's only 24, so I can't see anyone getting a serious look in for a while yet. But then I'd say Liam Williams is certainly second in line, offering pretty much the antithesis to Halfpenny. Prydie looks a decent player who, with another good season with the Dragons, might get in the squad for his back up kicking ability alone. Can't say I've seen enough of Ross Jones to comment.
unfrtunately the selection of Fussell ahead of Jones is the reason for that... Fussell is a more natural winger than Fullback. Jones was exceptional in last years U20s, with Prydie on the wing. Both good lads.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Look we've had so many quality young players come through at Ulster and they've mainly all got capped- even if they won't be involved in the squad next year because they only got caps during the Lions. Like Olding- we didn't even expect him to get gametime last year for Ulster and now he has an Ireland cap. He's barely turned 20. Gilroy, Jackson, Luke Marshall, Paul Marshall, Olding, Henderson all got first caps last year. Some of those players will form the backbone of the Ireland team for a generation.
I believe that Peter Nelson can be an international in the future, Paddy McAllister definitely will be if his injury rehab goes ok. Jared Payne could be once he qualifies on residency.
I believe that Peter Nelson can be an international in the future, Paddy McAllister definitely will be if his injury rehab goes ok. Jared Payne could be once he qualifies on residency.
Notch- Moderator
- Posts : 25635
Join date : 2011-02-10
Age : 36
Location : Belfast
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Notch wrote:Look we've had so many quality young players come through at Ulster and they've mainly all got capped- even if they won't be involved in the squad next year because they only got caps during the Lions. Like Olding- we didn't even expect him to get gametime last year for Ulster and now he has an Ireland cap. He's barely turned 20. Gilroy, Jackson, Luke Marshall, Paul Marshall, Olding, Henderson all got first caps last year. Some of those players will form the backbone of the Ireland team for a generation.
I believe that Peter Nelson can be an international in the future, Paddy McAllister definitely will be if his injury rehab goes ok. Jared Payne could be once he qualifies on residency.
Ulster have made some successful and clever decisions for their future over the last few years.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Nelson Asofa-Solomona. A potential combination of John Eales, Bakkies Botha, Sony Bill Williams and Jonah Lomu. Unfortunately he's off to rugby league. I'd have put him in the training squad against the French to keep him in rugby, even if he is 16/17.
Was arguably the dominant schoolboy player last year at the age of 16. This year he's barely containable. At 17 he's about 2.02 m and 118 kg. He freakishly strong and quick. He can sidestep, offload a la SBW, and good kicking game. All in all he's a once in a generation talent. Many better punters than me think he's the best age group player they have seen. He potentially has another year left at school, but he's off to join a host of Wellington rugby union talent in the Melbourne storm rugby league club.
Was arguably the dominant schoolboy player last year at the age of 16. This year he's barely containable. At 17 he's about 2.02 m and 118 kg. He freakishly strong and quick. He can sidestep, offload a la SBW, and good kicking game. All in all he's a once in a generation talent. Many better punters than me think he's the best age group player they have seen. He potentially has another year left at school, but he's off to join a host of Wellington rugby union talent in the Melbourne storm rugby league club.
Last edited by blackcanelion on Tue 06 Aug 2013, 8:59 am; edited 1 time in total
blackcanelion- Posts : 1989
Join date : 2011-06-20
Location : Wellington
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
maestegmafia wrote:miaow wrote:maestegmafia wrote:
I think Prydie was great last season finally shock off his awful injury. I can see him and Ross Jones battling hard for the Wales fullback shirt over the next few years.
Halfpenny's only 24, so I can't see anyone getting a serious look in for a while yet. But then I'd say Liam Williams is certainly second in line, offering pretty much the antithesis to Halfpenny. Prydie looks a decent player who, with another good season with the Dragons, might get in the squad for his back up kicking ability alone. Can't say I've seen enough of Ross Jones to comment.
unfrtunately the selection of Fussell ahead of Jones is the reason for that... Fussell is a more natural winger than Fullback. Jones was exceptional in last years U20s, with Prydie on the wing. Both good lads.
I'm still not convinced by Tom Prydie. There were times last season when he looked like he couldn't be bothered.
Jon Evans should certainly be in the Wales frame at scrum half - it should be a fight between him and Gareth Davies of the Scarlets.
Mark Bennett at Glasgow is class, as is Stuart Olding at Ulster. Two proper footballing centres.
Luckless Pedestrian- Posts : 24898
Join date : 2011-02-01
Age : 45
Location : Newport
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Wholeheartedly agree about Olding but, despite ASBO's protestations to the contrary, I just haven't seen enough of Mark Bennett to say one way or another.
InjuredYetAgain- Posts : 1317
Join date : 2011-06-02
Age : 58
Location : Edinburgh
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
IYA - how long have you been in Al-Qaeda?InjuredYetAgain wrote:Wholeheartedly agree about Olding but, despite ASBO's protestations to the contrary, I just haven't seen enough of Mark Bennett to say one way or another.
George Carlin- Admin
- Posts : 15780
Join date : 2011-06-23
Location : KSA
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Hoi, have you been hacking my e-mails or something? Where are Wikileaks legal team when you need them?
All I meant was that Bennett hasn't had that much game time to form an un-ASBOesque neutral's opinion. His time will come but he still has to prove himself consistently for the Weeg first
All I meant was that Bennett hasn't had that much game time to form an un-ASBOesque neutral's opinion. His time will come but he still has to prove himself consistently for the Weeg first
InjuredYetAgain- Posts : 1317
Join date : 2011-06-02
Age : 58
Location : Edinburgh
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
IYA - the Bennett club is a cult. Do not question, just obey.
He is the Messiah. He will be a Lion in 2017. NZ will fear him.
Ignore all those missed tackles in U20 rugby and the fact that he can't get a run in the team at Glasgow. Let's be fair, not even BOD would get a game ahead of players like Byron McGuigan, Peter Horne, Peter Murchie (out of position), Sean Lamont (out of position) and Stuart Hogg (out of position). I think we should just take it as read that Bennett is an outstanding player, and that Vern Cotter and Clermont just didn't know what they were doing when they sent him away before his contract expired. What do they know?
He is the Messiah. He will be a Lion in 2017. NZ will fear him.
Ignore all those missed tackles in U20 rugby and the fact that he can't get a run in the team at Glasgow. Let's be fair, not even BOD would get a game ahead of players like Byron McGuigan, Peter Horne, Peter Murchie (out of position), Sean Lamont (out of position) and Stuart Hogg (out of position). I think we should just take it as read that Bennett is an outstanding player, and that Vern Cotter and Clermont just didn't know what they were doing when they sent him away before his contract expired. What do they know?
funnyExiledScot- Posts : 17072
Join date : 2011-05-31
Age : 43
Location : Edinburgh
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
blackcanelion wrote:Nelson Asofa-Solomona. A potential combination of John Eales, Bakkies Botha, Sony Bill Williams and Jonah Lomu. Unfortunately he's off to rugby league. I'd have put him in the training squad against the French to keep him in rugby, even if he is 16/17.
Was arguably the dominant schoolboy player last year at the age of 16. This year he's barely containable. At 17 he's about 2.02 m and 118 kg. He freakishly strong and quick. He can sidestep, offload a la SBW, and good kicking game. All in all he's a once in a generation talent. Many better punters than me think he's the best age group player they have seen. He potentially has another year left at school, but he's off to join a host of Wellington rugby union talent in the Melbourne storm rugby league club.
Goes off to google
BamBam- Posts : 17226
Join date : 2011-03-17
Age : 35
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Matt Garvey - England
Geordie- Posts : 28849
Join date : 2011-03-31
Location : Newcastle
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
BamBam wrote:blackcanelion wrote:Nelson Asofa-Solomona. A potential combination of John Eales, Bakkies Botha, Sony Bill Williams and Jonah Lomu. Unfortunately he's off to rugby league. I'd have put him in the training squad against the French to keep him in rugby, even if he is 16/17.
Was arguably the dominant schoolboy player last year at the age of 16. This year he's barely containable. At 17 he's about 2.02 m and 118 kg. He freakishly strong and quick. He can sidestep, offload a la SBW, and good kicking game. All in all he's a once in a generation talent. Many better punters than me think he's the best age group player they have seen. He potentially has another year left at school, but he's off to join a host of Wellington rugby union talent in the Melbourne storm rugby league club.
Goes off to google
Not sure if you'll find him easily. He's still at school (Wellington College). Here's a clip and report.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a68RR6KkfrI He's no 8. This was his worst game this year I think.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/sport/college-sport/7049574/Rising-star-creating-some-spectacular-havoc
He's potential plus. It's worth remembering these are good school teams and he's young. I know parents of a kid in age group rep side with him. He's something else.
blackcanelion- Posts : 1989
Join date : 2011-06-20
Location : Wellington
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
It's fine. League can hone his handling then Union can nick him back. Isn't that how this works?
ChequeredJersey- Posts : 18707
Join date : 2011-12-23
Age : 35
Location : London, UK
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
blackcanelion wrote:BamBam wrote:blackcanelion wrote:Nelson Asofa-Solomona. A potential combination of John Eales, Bakkies Botha, Sony Bill Williams and Jonah Lomu. Unfortunately he's off to rugby league. I'd have put him in the training squad against the French to keep him in rugby, even if he is 16/17.
Was arguably the dominant schoolboy player last year at the age of 16. This year he's barely containable. At 17 he's about 2.02 m and 118 kg. He freakishly strong and quick. He can sidestep, offload a la SBW, and good kicking game. All in all he's a once in a generation talent. Many better punters than me think he's the best age group player they have seen. He potentially has another year left at school, but he's off to join a host of Wellington rugby union talent in the Melbourne storm rugby league club.
Goes off to google
Not sure if you'll find him easily. He's still at school (Wellington College). Here's a clip and report.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a68RR6KkfrI He's no 8. This was his worst game this year I think.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/sport/college-sport/7049574/Rising-star-creating-some-spectacular-havoc
He's potential plus. It's worth remembering these are good school teams and he's young. I know parents of a kid in age group rep side with him. He's something else.
Reminds me of Gavin Henson at his best. Looks incredibly talented. Shame he is off to League, real shame.
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Yes, because Henson is the benchmark for a young NZ kid
Will be one to keep an eye on in league, definitely wouldn't be surprised to see him back in a few years time
Will be one to keep an eye on in league, definitely wouldn't be surprised to see him back in a few years time
BamBam- Posts : 17226
Join date : 2011-03-17
Age : 35
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
For those posters not in the know, we are fully expecting FES and Mark Bennett to have their Make Up Sex some time this season. In the meantime, if you see any reference on these boards to Mark Bennett being associated with nappies, rusks, onesies, umbilical cords or being overrated, you will get the sense now as to why.funnyExiledScot wrote:IYA - the Bennett club is a cult. Do not question, just obey.
He is the Messiah. He will be a Lion in 2017. NZ will fear him.
Ignore all those missed tackles in U20 rugby and the fact that he can't get a run in the team at Glasgow. Let's be fair, not even BOD would get a game ahead of players like Byron McGuigan, Peter Horne, Peter Murchie (out of position), Sean Lamont (out of position) and Stuart Hogg (out of position). I think we should just take it as read that Bennett is an outstanding player, and that Vern Cotter and Clermont just didn't know what they were doing when they sent him away before his contract expired. What do they know?
George Carlin- Admin
- Posts : 15780
Join date : 2011-06-23
Location : KSA
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
George Carlin wrote:For those posters not in the know, we are fully expecting FES and Mark Bennett to have their Make Up Sex some time this season. In the meantime, if you see any reference on these boards to Mark Bennett being associated with nappies, rusks, onesies, umbilical cords or being overrated, you will get the sense now as to why.funnyExiledScot wrote:IYA - the Bennett club is a cult. Do not question, just obey.
He is the Messiah. He will be a Lion in 2017. NZ will fear him.
Ignore all those missed tackles in U20 rugby and the fact that he can't get a run in the team at Glasgow. Let's be fair, not even BOD would get a game ahead of players like Byron McGuigan, Peter Horne, Peter Murchie (out of position), Sean Lamont (out of position) and Stuart Hogg (out of position). I think we should just take it as read that Bennett is an outstanding player, and that Vern Cotter and Clermont just didn't know what they were doing when they sent him away before his contract expired. What do they know?
Cheers for the heads up..!
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Looseheaded wrote:JSD for England
that's it, i get pretty angry when remembering how poor his international career has been
Pretty similar to Stave Hanley, I always thought he was treated terribly by Woodward. He was top try scorer in the Premiership for something silly like 5 years in a row yet was ignored after getting munched by Scott Quinnell in '99 (who didn't get muched by Scott Quinnell?!).
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
madmaccas wrote:Looseheaded wrote:JSD for England
that's it, i get pretty angry when remembering how poor his international career has been
Pretty similar to Stave Hanley, I always thought he was treated terribly by Woodward. He was top try scorer in the Premiership for something silly like 5 years in a row yet was ignored after getting munched by Scott Quinnell in '99 (who didn't get muched by Scott Quinnell?!).
I think it was Scotts rather tubby younger brother Craig...!
maestegmafia- Posts : 23145
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Glyncorrwg
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Hmm, I remember Hanley as being a bit of a lump. A bit like Matt Banahan mark one. I was never convinced he had the skillset of an international winger. In Luger, Cohen, Robinson and Lewsey there was pretty stiff competition for places back then.
I wouldn't say he was treated badly. Strike rate in club rugby isn't everything. By that measure Tim Visser is the best winger in the Rabo, and he clearly isn't.
I wouldn't say he was treated badly. Strike rate in club rugby isn't everything. By that measure Tim Visser is the best winger in the Rabo, and he clearly isn't.
funnyExiledScot- Posts : 17072
Join date : 2011-05-31
Age : 43
Location : Edinburgh
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
Ha one man's big lump is Banahan, anothers is George North. Lewsey was predominately a fullback and Dan Luger actually had a pretty poor try scoring record for Quins. I would say Hanley's main opposition were his teammates Robinson and Cueto, the 3 of whom formed the deadliest back 3 in the Premiership at that time. Which begs the question why that winning combination was never even tried for England. As a Scot I'm very glad it wasn't.funnyExiledScot wrote:Hmm, I remember Hanley as being a bit of a lump. A bit like Matt Banahan mark one. I was never convinced he had the skillset of an international winger. In Luger, Cohen, Robinson and Lewsey there was pretty stiff competition for places back then.
I wouldn't say he was treated badly. Strike rate in club rugby isn't everything. By that measure Tim Visser is the best winger in the Rabo, and he clearly isn't.
To cap a player at 19 (a game in which he scored a cracking try), then drop him after the loss and never to give him another shot despite repeatedly topping the try scoring charts, is pretty poor IMO. To then pick players like Mike Stephenson, Phil Christophers, Mark van Gisbergen and Lesley Vainikolo ahead of him is simply crazy. You can only assume the Woodward blamed him for the loss to Wales in '99.
Tim Visser is clearly not the best all round wing in the Rabo, he is however the best 'finisher', of that there is no doubt, the try tally speaks for itself. Would you pick Lee 'cant catch, wont catch' Jones for Scotland over him?
Re: Could/should be capped for your country
If we are talking about players getting first caps in the next 12 months, well not many that I think should be capped (as so many were capped in Argentina).
A lot of the names mentioned so far for England are still, imo, more than 12 months away from being ready.
From Tigers I would say Graham Kitchener has the best chance of gaining a first cap before RWC 2015.
A lot of the names mentioned so far for England are still, imo, more than 12 months away from being ready.
From Tigers I would say Graham Kitchener has the best chance of gaining a first cap before RWC 2015.
LondonTiger- Moderator
- Posts : 23485
Join date : 2011-02-10
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» Father and Sons who have both been capped...?
» Club before country or country before club - a simple question
» National Most Capped XVs
» Who will be the most capped player?
» Un-Capped Choices of the Home Nations?
» Club before country or country before club - a simple question
» National Most Capped XVs
» Who will be the most capped player?
» Un-Capped Choices of the Home Nations?
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|