From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
+30
BigTrevsbigmac
ChequeredJersey
Cowshot
RDSguru
Taylorman
fa0019
Armchairexpert
Bathman_in_London
kingelderfield
GloriousEmpire
yappysnap
Jhamer25
Rugby Fan
TJ
Hood83
Breadvan
englandglory4ever
bluestonevedder
broadlandboy
Geordie
doctor_grey
majesticimperialman
beshocked
Duty281
mystiroakey
Mr Bounce
leicestertinytiger
Exiledinborders
nathan
WELL-PAST-IT
34 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 3 of 4
Page 3 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
First topic message reminder :
Well, first and foremost why the ABs are No.1 and likely to stay there.
What we must aspire to, to join them at the top.
We have strength in depth at loosehead, Marler played well and he is our 3rd choice.
T. Youngs needs to stay at Tigers for a bit until his throwing is consistent enough to play at this level, perhaps they could stretch him a couple of inches s well. Webber must get his chance.
Lawes and Launchberry are the best pairing at lock we have, Lawes was world class today. Parling is not an impact sub, Attwood or an equivalent is needed
Billy Vunipolo and Morgan are both very good 8s
Dickson is the way forward if we want a fast paced game, bringing forwards and backs into the game at pace.
Farrell can attack as well as kick, but needs to stop these lateral runs that go nowhere, much better 2nd half, tried to take it straighter
36 may have the 12 shirt again next year, if he plays like today and not last week.
Tomkins is not close to this level, yet at least. there are a least three better backs out there now, not including Manu. A failed experiment that needs to be stopped.
Ashton, played better, but still few runs following the ball carrier, runs back against the flow when ball moving laterally.
Brown is top class
Foden can cover wing, but is a full back
We need more cover at 9, Youngs is not doing it anymore, he ha been found out I think.
Flood cannot hack it at this level.
We are getting there if we can keep up the intensity, but too many mistake and poor choice replacements.
Well, first and foremost why the ABs are No.1 and likely to stay there.
What we must aspire to, to join them at the top.
We have strength in depth at loosehead, Marler played well and he is our 3rd choice.
T. Youngs needs to stay at Tigers for a bit until his throwing is consistent enough to play at this level, perhaps they could stretch him a couple of inches s well. Webber must get his chance.
Lawes and Launchberry are the best pairing at lock we have, Lawes was world class today. Parling is not an impact sub, Attwood or an equivalent is needed
Billy Vunipolo and Morgan are both very good 8s
Dickson is the way forward if we want a fast paced game, bringing forwards and backs into the game at pace.
Farrell can attack as well as kick, but needs to stop these lateral runs that go nowhere, much better 2nd half, tried to take it straighter
36 may have the 12 shirt again next year, if he plays like today and not last week.
Tomkins is not close to this level, yet at least. there are a least three better backs out there now, not including Manu. A failed experiment that needs to be stopped.
Ashton, played better, but still few runs following the ball carrier, runs back against the flow when ball moving laterally.
Brown is top class
Foden can cover wing, but is a full back
We need more cover at 9, Youngs is not doing it anymore, he ha been found out I think.
Flood cannot hack it at this level.
We are getting there if we can keep up the intensity, but too many mistake and poor choice replacements.
WELL-PAST-IT- Posts : 3744
Join date : 2011-06-01
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
very silly in comparison to footballTaylorman wrote:So in either 100 years or the last 20 Spain has a better winning record in matches that matter? Care to share what the figures are for Spain then? Or is just your'opinion'mystiroakey wrote:so you think this AB's is better than Spain?
come on spit out why and how ?
Or what is your measure of the most successful sporting team is mere winning % isnt it (I mean...how silly is that...winning %-)
1. winning friendlies are meaningless in football due to the set up and the fact that most of the time clubs control the players and during the season, international friendlies play second fiddle to the major domestic leagues.
2. The scoring system.. draws are not a rarity in football. so comparing winning percentages doesn't tell the full story. no lose stats would be more relevant.
3. Spain have won the last 3 major tournies on the spin.
4. football is a truly global sport, Rugby isn't
5. surely(back to your original point) we are talking about this team or one particular team- not a sustained period which incorporates many different set ups(so 100 or 20 years is irrelevant)
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Mystri - here's a hint. Rather than trying to argue this rather silly and meritless angle... The answer is : the Australian rugby league team.
You see, that then forces your opponent to bring up the globalisation of the sport and THEN you swoop in with a football reference to Spain, Brazil, whomever.
You see, that then forces your opponent to bring up the globalisation of the sport and THEN you swoop in with a football reference to Spain, Brazil, whomever.
Last edited by GloriousEmpire on Sat Nov 16, 2013 11:58 pm; edited 1 time in total
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
ebop i meam...our latecomer...
Anyway, have a snooker final to play so outta here. Well done ABs...hard luck England. Look forward to the tour. Its certainly given Hansen something to talk about.
Anyway, have a snooker final to play so outta here. Well done ABs...hard luck England. Look forward to the tour. Its certainly given Hansen something to talk about.
Taylorman- Posts : 12343
Join date : 2011-02-02
Location : Wellington NZ
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Mysti.... are you John [sp] Inverdale?
RDSguru- Posts : 441
Join date : 2013-03-09
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Hint The kiwis have been talking about the best sporting team- not the best Rugby union team!!GloriousEmpire wrote:Mystri - here's a hint. Rather than trying to argue this rather silly and meritless angle... The answer is : the Australian rugby league team.
You see, that then forces your opponent to bring up the globalisation of the sport and THEN you swoop in with a football reference to Spain, Brazil, whomever.
the australian team has never been so good, maybe england back in 2003 though
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
I dont think he even knows what football is dude!RDSguru wrote:Mysti.... are you John [sp] Inverdale?
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
You can always tell England have been put back in their box when "fans" start mentioning that rugby isn't a real sport anyway.
Sigh.
Sigh.
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Rugby is a very real sport. I love it!
But this is strictly some objectivity for the nonsense talked by certain kiwis.
But this is strictly some objectivity for the nonsense talked by certain kiwis.
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Phewwww... He was on about Sanchez [sp] scoring 2 for Chile against England yesterday and the scoring 6 against Wales today.... ! you're OK palmystiroakey wrote:I dont think he even knows what football is dude!RDSguru wrote:Mysti.... are you John [sp] Inverdale?
RDSguru- Posts : 441
Join date : 2013-03-09
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
RDSguru wrote:Phewwww... He was on about Sanchez [sp] scoring 2 for Chile against England yesterday and the scoring 6 against Wales today.... ! you're OK palmystiroakey wrote:I dont think he even knows what football is dude!RDSguru wrote:Mysti.... are you John [sp] Inverdale?
Lol.
I dont listen to him dude!"
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
As pointed out. The "nonsense" was spoken by Lancaster, rowntree and a Brit journo and now the BBC.
So, Erm, any more points about football to bring up?
So, Erm, any more points about football to bring up?
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
over what period are they 100%. Your criteria is a little grey mysti.Have you personally decided that the measure of all sporting sides is to win 3 specific tournaments? How is that logoical or even remotely fair? Very selective reasoning methinks.mystiroakey wrote:Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
ABs are 100% this year and have every trophy they play for:
Bledisloe cup- since 2002
World Cup - never lost a match in 11'
Rugby Championship-never lost a match in two years
Dave Gal Cup
Freedom Cup
and now the Hillary Shld
And I'd suggest you cant go back in time find one. Surely the measure of a successful team is continuity, consistency over a long period- 100 years in fact- sure they werent no.1 every year but they have the highest winning % over a very long period.Surely that is the measure of greatness in sport?
Last edited by Taylorman on Sun Nov 17, 2013 12:09 am; edited 1 time in total
Taylorman- Posts : 12343
Join date : 2011-02-02
Location : Wellington NZ
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
The comments all originated from kiwis mouths dude..
they are just reporting on it, and even if they agree(which many do) they are still wrong.
I dont have to back up everything up to do with England dude. We can be wrong!
they are just reporting on it, and even if they agree(which many do) they are still wrong.
I dont have to back up everything up to do with England dude. We can be wrong!
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Hey! Don't forget the Women's and men's 7 world cups and the IRB 7's circuit. Spain actually play for those ones!
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Its an amazing record- but for the factors i mentioned i put spain above them.Taylorman wrote:over what period are they 100%. Your criteria is a little grey mysti.Have you personally decided that the measure of all sporting sides is to win 3 specific tournaments? How is that logoical or even remotely fair? Very selective reasoning methinks.mystiroakey wrote:Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
ABs are 100% this year and have every trophy they play for:
Bledisloe cup- since 2002
World Cup - never lost a match
Rugby Championship-never lost a match in two years
Dave Gal Cup
Freedom Cup
and now the Hillary Shld
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Listening and hearing are 2 different things....mystiroakey wrote:Lol.RDSguru wrote:Phewwww... He was on about Sanchez [sp] scoring 2 for Chile against England yesterday and the scoring 6 against Wales today.... ! you're OK palmystiroakey wrote:I dont think he even knows what football is dude!RDSguru wrote:Mysti.... are you John [sp] Inverdale?
I dont listen to him dude!"
RDSguru- Posts : 441
Join date : 2013-03-09
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Mystri, what kiwis are saying the ABs are the best sports team in the world ever? I don't think any of us are. I certainly wouldn't dream of saying that and I am under no illusions about where rugby sits in world sport.
Guest- Guest
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Well then, next time England valiantly lose at home to Spain, the bbc can copy & paste their article.mystiroakey wrote:Its an amazing record- but for the factors i mentioned i put spain above them.Taylorman wrote:over what period are they 100%. Your criteria is a little grey mysti.Have you personally decided that the measure of all sporting sides is to win 3 specific tournaments? How is that logoical or even remotely fair? Very selective reasoning methinks.mystiroakey wrote:Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
ABs are 100% this year and have every trophy they play for:
Bledisloe cup- since 2002
World Cup - never lost a match
Rugby Championship-never lost a match in two years
Dave Gal Cup
Freedom Cup
and now the Hillary Shld
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
On another note given the crowd thinking that drowning the ABs haka out with swing low shows they dont get the meaning of it...again. On that basis...glad the ABs had the final word- for that crowd at least.
Swinging low alright...
Swinging low alright...
Taylorman- Posts : 12343
Join date : 2011-02-02
Location : Wellington NZ
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
The story's have been rife recently Ebop..
GE that isnt the way our media operates for football! Its doom and gloom or we are the greatest- nothing measured is allowed!!
Taylor- boo the haka
GE that isnt the way our media operates for football! Its doom and gloom or we are the greatest- nothing measured is allowed!!
Taylor- boo the haka
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Trinder has been on better form, JJ's form has been v average...and he's still more of a threat, and finally, my nan is pulling up trees. So 3 solid options. Fair point on not playing people out of position. I hope Daly fixes on one because he looks class to me. I wouldn't play Burrell anywhere personally, his basic skills are still way off.GeordieFalcon wrote:Hood,
Ok I accept Tomkins wasn't great...however of your list :
JJ isn't near the form he showed when he came on the scene, wish suggests he isn't that good
Daly who should have been there is playing FB
Your nan...well ive never seen her play so cant comment.
There is no other 13's who are playing consistently well and playing at 13. Eastmond? How is he playing. Im disappointed Lowe never got a chance I rate him highly but hes out for the season.
What other EQ'd 13 are playing week in week out to the reuiqred standard.
And if we play Burrell at 13 then we are doing what we keep criticising Lancaster for doing...playing players out of position.
Hood83- Posts : 2751
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
The twickenham crowd can afford to be obnoxious, they're just lying in wait to celebrate the World Cup England will win there in 2015 right? Remembering that winning RWC's at home is so easy and meritless.
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Great point mateGloriousEmpire wrote:The twickenham crowd can afford to be obnoxious, they're just lying in wait to celebrate the World Cup England will win there in 2015 right? Remembering that winning RWC's at home is so easy and meritless.
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Isnt it amazing how every feckin thread on this site turns to utter drivel....
Geordie- Posts : 28896
Join date : 2011-03-31
Location : Newcastle
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Sorry , partially my bad GF
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
what factors..and its not the best sporting team- because that is subjective.mystiroakey wrote:Its an amazing record- but for the factors i mentioned i put spain above them.Taylorman wrote:over what period are they 100%. Your criteria is a little grey mysti.Have you personally decided that the measure of all sporting sides is to win 3 specific tournaments? How is that logoical or even remotely fair? Very selective reasoning methinks.mystiroakey wrote:Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
ABs are 100% this year and have every trophy they play for:
Bledisloe cup- since 2002
World Cup - never lost a match
Rugby Championship-never lost a match in two years
Dave Gal Cup
Freedom Cup
and now the Hillary Shld
It is the most successful sporting team. % of wins over time.
How do you not get that?
Taylorman- Posts : 12343
Join date : 2011-02-02
Location : Wellington NZ
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Par for the course I'm afraid.....GeordieFalcon wrote:Isnt it amazing how every feckin thread on this site turns to utter drivel....
RDSguru- Posts : 441
Join date : 2013-03-09
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Let's get it back on track.
Anyone else feel that the comparisons between lancaster's lot and the RWC winning England side of a decade ago were perhaps a bit premature?
Anyone else feel that the comparisons between lancaster's lot and the RWC winning England side of a decade ago were perhaps a bit premature?
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
no worries they did...and who's heads were swinging low on the way out..ha ha. 'clowns' was all i could think of when they lit up. And Savea sure shut them up in quick time...you guys are funny sometimes...bit like the underwood wink...except this time it was 70,000 winks.mystiroakey wrote:The story's have been rife recently Ebop..
GE that isnt the way our media operates for football! Its doom and gloom or we are the greatest- nothing measured is allowed!!
Taylor- boo the haka
only the english know exactly the wrong buttons to press...
Taylorman- Posts : 12343
Join date : 2011-02-02
Location : Wellington NZ
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
As pointed out 3 times, that's irrelevant - the scoring systems are very different in different sports,Taylorman wrote:what factors..and its not the best sporting team- because that is subjective.mystiroakey wrote:Its an amazing record- but for the factors i mentioned i put spain above them.Taylorman wrote:over what period are they 100%. Your criteria is a little grey mysti.Have you personally decided that the measure of all sporting sides is to win 3 specific tournaments? How is that logoical or even remotely fair? Very selective reasoning methinks.mystiroakey wrote:Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
ABs are 100% this year and have every trophy they play for:
Bledisloe cup- since 2002
World Cup - never lost a match
Rugby Championship-never lost a match in two years
Dave Gal Cup
Freedom Cup
and now the Hillary Shld
It is the most successful sporting team. % of wins over time.
How do you not get that?
close games in rugby would be draws in football, and there is such a thing as friendlies in football.
BUt yes I agree NZRU win record is the best- nothing to discuss there though as its a nonsense thing to talk about because it doesn't mean anything in comparison to other sports.
Not sure why you have such a hard time understanding that
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
What, who (by) and where were these comparisons made?GloriousEmpire wrote:Let's get it back on track.
Anyone else feel that the comparisons between lancaster's lot and the RWC winning England side of a decade ago were perhaps a bit premature?
RDSguru- Posts : 441
Join date : 2013-03-09
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
To be fair to the twickenham crowd. Half of them know so little about what's going on that they probably heard the best team in history was coming, and mistakenly thought they'd bought tickets to see Spain play football.
The group hysteria thing seems big in England for whatever reason. Every morning 8 million people in London decide to get up and all be terrible at their jobs in unison, for example. A few thousand sheep singing a vaguely racist song in a culturally inappropriate way is nothing to get steamed about.
The group hysteria thing seems big in England for whatever reason. Every morning 8 million people in London decide to get up and all be terrible at their jobs in unison, for example. A few thousand sheep singing a vaguely racist song in a culturally inappropriate way is nothing to get steamed about.
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
and you are better than these people dude?GloriousEmpire wrote:To be fair to the twickenham crowd. Half of them know so little about what's going on that they probably heard the best team in history was coming, and mistakenly thought they'd bought tickets to see Spain play football.
The group hysteria thing seems big in England for whatever reason. Every morning 8 million people in London decide to get up and all be terrible at their jobs in unison, for example. A few thousand sheep singing a vaguely racist song in a culturally inappropriate way is nothing to get steamed about.
[laugh]
pot kettle
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
no mysti its you clouding the question. Its simple. Which sporting team has the highest winning percentage over time. Now there isnt a sport that i can think of that doesnt have a win or loss result. Soccer, for example. If one side scores more goals than the other it is called a win.mystiroakey wrote:As pointed out 3 times, that's irrelevant - the scoring systems are very different in different sports,Taylorman wrote:what factors..and its not the best sporting team- because that is subjective.mystiroakey wrote:Its an amazing record- but for the factors i mentioned i put spain above them.Taylorman wrote:over what period are they 100%. Your criteria is a little grey mysti.Have you personally decided that the measure of all sporting sides is to win 3 specific tournaments? How is that logoical or even remotely fair? Very selective reasoning methinks.mystiroakey wrote:Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
ABs are 100% this year and have every trophy they play for:
Bledisloe cup- since 2002
World Cup - never lost a match
Rugby Championship-never lost a match in two years
Dave Gal Cup
Freedom Cup
and now the Hillary Shld
It is the most successful sporting team. % of wins over time.
How do you not get that?
close games in rugby would be draws in football, and there is such a thing as friendlies in football.
BUt yes I agree NZRU win record is the best- nothing to discuss there though as its a nonsense thing to talk about because it doesn't mean anything in comparison to other sports.
Not sure why you have such a hard time understanding that
If they dont, it is a draw or a loss.
So, what is Spains record on that very easy to understand basis?
Taylorman- Posts : 12343
Join date : 2011-02-02
Location : Wellington NZ
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
To be fair, 3.93 million of them headed out for Cardiff.GloriousEmpire wrote:To be fair to the twickenham crowd. Half of them know so little about what's going on that they probably heard the best team in history was coming, and mistakenly thought they'd bought tickets to see Spain play football.
Boy were they surprised to see that last minute goal by Finland
RDSguru- Posts : 441
Join date : 2013-03-09
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
nz do- but its irrelevant and means nothing in comparison to footballing teams and who is the better team.. If you want an intelligent debate you have to actually work out what matters. Win % own its own inst a valid comparison stat as mentioned so many times.Taylorman wrote:no mysti its you clouding the question. Its simple. Which sporting team has the highest winning percentage over time. Now there isnt a sport that i can think of that doesnt have a win or loss result. Soccer, for example. If one side scores more goals than the other it is called a win.mystiroakey wrote:As pointed out 3 times, that's irrelevant - the scoring systems are very different in different sports,Taylorman wrote:what factors..and its not the best sporting team- because that is subjective.mystiroakey wrote:Its an amazing record- but for the factors i mentioned i put spain above them.Taylorman wrote:over what period are they 100%. Your criteria is a little grey mysti.Have you personally decided that the measure of all sporting sides is to win 3 specific tournaments? How is that logoical or even remotely fair? Very selective reasoning methinks.mystiroakey wrote:Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
ABs are 100% this year and have every trophy they play for:
Bledisloe cup- since 2002
World Cup - never lost a match
Rugby Championship-never lost a match in two years
Dave Gal Cup
Freedom Cup
and now the Hillary Shld
It is the most successful sporting team. % of wins over time.
How do you not get that?
close games in rugby would be draws in football, and there is such a thing as friendlies in football.
BUt yes I agree NZRU win record is the best- nothing to discuss there though as its a nonsense thing to talk about because it doesn't mean anything in comparison to other sports.
Not sure why you have such a hard time understanding that
If they dont, it is a draw or a loss.
So, what is Spains record on that very easy to understand basis?
Can you not see that?
Honestly?
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Don't forget Mysti, that we don't know how they defined greatest team ever, but I'm sure it'll have been in a way that suits them.
Anyway, what I think we learned today and last year is that we can take on the All Blacks this summer as underdogs certainly but with hope definitely. We've got to get the backs sorted but Twelvetrees is finding his feet at this level and I think we've settled a few more positions than we had before the AIs. Launchbury, Marler, Lawes, Billy V., Brown all showed they'd got something at this level. 12trees made good progress and Farrell is still improving. Long way to go. still. but we're starting to have a solid group and it feels to me like there really is the potential for this side to do well.
Now, if we just discover that Manu and 12trees click together, Yarde and Wade set the world on fire and Farrell gets game reading specs and we'll really have something to talk about!
Anyway, what I think we learned today and last year is that we can take on the All Blacks this summer as underdogs certainly but with hope definitely. We've got to get the backs sorted but Twelvetrees is finding his feet at this level and I think we've settled a few more positions than we had before the AIs. Launchbury, Marler, Lawes, Billy V., Brown all showed they'd got something at this level. 12trees made good progress and Farrell is still improving. Long way to go. still. but we're starting to have a solid group and it feels to me like there really is the potential for this side to do well.
Now, if we just discover that Manu and 12trees click together, Yarde and Wade set the world on fire and Farrell gets game reading specs and we'll really have something to talk about!
Cowshot- Posts : 1513
Join date : 2011-02-14
Location : Kingston-upon-Thames
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Yes if all that happens you might nearly be as good as Spain.
GloriousEmpire- Posts : 4411
Join date : 2013-01-28
Age : 51
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
"Now, if we just discover that Manu and 12trees click together, Yarde and Wade set the world on fire and Farrell gets game reading specs and we'll really have something to talk about!"
I would crack open a heineken for that team
I would crack open a heineken for that team
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Thank you. Of course there are comparisons that cant be made. But some can- winning % is THE one common to all.mystiroakey wrote:nz do- but its irrelevant and means nothing in comparison to footballing teams and who is the better team.. If you want an intelligent debate you have to actually work out what matters. Win % own its own inst a valid comparison stat as mentioned so many times.Taylorman wrote:no mysti its you clouding the question. Its simple. Which sporting team has the highest winning percentage over time. Now there isnt a sport that i can think of that doesnt have a win or loss result. Soccer, for example. If one side scores more goals than the other it is called a win.mystiroakey wrote:As pointed out 3 times, that's irrelevant - the scoring systems are very different in different sports,Taylorman wrote:what factors..and its not the best sporting team- because that is subjective.mystiroakey wrote:Its an amazing record- but for the factors i mentioned i put spain above them.Taylorman wrote:over what period are they 100%. Your criteria is a little grey mysti.Have you personally decided that the measure of all sporting sides is to win 3 specific tournaments? How is that logoical or even remotely fair? Very selective reasoning methinks.mystiroakey wrote:Oh ebop they are 100% IMO - football has moved on so much and is so competitive- to win 3 major tournies in the spin is mind blowing.
Many other teams may stick in the mind as great(for example brazil back in peles day) but there were in eras that lacked professionalism, fitness and competition.
ABs are 100% this year and have every trophy they play for:
Bledisloe cup- since 2002
World Cup - never lost a match
Rugby Championship-never lost a match in two years
Dave Gal Cup
Freedom Cup
and now the Hillary Shld
It is the most successful sporting team. % of wins over time.
How do you not get that?
close games in rugby would be draws in football, and there is such a thing as friendlies in football.
BUt yes I agree NZRU win record is the best- nothing to discuss there though as its a nonsense thing to talk about because it doesn't mean anything in comparison to other sports.
Not sure why you have such a hard time understanding that
If they dont, it is a draw or a loss.
So, what is Spains record on that very easy to understand basis?
Can you not see that?
Honestly?
My original point was NZ are the most successful sporting team in history on that basis.
Thats all the point was. 'Best' cannot be measured. For the very confusing reasons you are giving. %win is crystal clear- across any sport.
Taylorman- Posts : 12343
Join date : 2011-02-02
Location : Wellington NZ
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Taylorman- we had a GOAT sportsman debate on here- and I am hoping we have a GOAT team one.
and this NZ team and this SPAIN team will be big favs for the title!!
and this NZ team and this SPAIN team will be big favs for the title!!
mystiroakey- Posts : 32472
Join date : 2011-03-06
Age : 47
Location : surrey
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Davies, Roberts, North, Cuthbert, Biggar..... better crack the Carlsberg Export IMHO....mystiroakey wrote:"Now, if we just discover that Manu and 12trees click together, Yarde and Wade set the world on fire and Farrell gets game reading specs and we'll really have something to talk about!"
I would crack open a heineken for that team
Last edited by RDSguru on Sun Nov 17, 2013 12:42 am; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : Embolden Export for effect.... Ha)
RDSguru- Posts : 441
Join date : 2013-03-09
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
And very fine they are too. Should be a good Six Nations. Wales have been the better side recently but we are young and improving and we're hard on your heels.RDSguru wrote:Davies, Roberts, North, Cuthbert, Biggar..... better crack the Carlsberg Export IMHO....mystiroakey wrote:"Now, if we just discover that Manu and 12trees click together, Yarde and Wade set the world on fire and Farrell gets game reading specs and we'll really have something to talk about!"
I would crack open a heineken for that team
Cowshot- Posts : 1513
Join date : 2011-02-14
Location : Kingston-upon-Thames
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
And they are young too... with a tad of experience.. and improving too... looking forward to 6n's and the cracking of Champagne.... Roberts should be able to get some Duty Free. North should be able to bring some Red Rosè over the bridge too.Cowshot wrote:And very fine they are too. Should be a good Six Nations. Wales have been the better side recently but we are young and improving and we're hard on your heels.RDSguru wrote:Davies, Roberts, North, Cuthbert, Biggar..... better crack the Carlsberg Export IMHO....mystiroakey wrote:"Now, if we just discover that Manu and 12trees click together, Yarde and Wade set the world on fire and Farrell gets game reading specs and we'll really have something to talk about!"
I would crack open a heineken for that team
RDSguru- Posts : 441
Join date : 2013-03-09
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
I can't go there with you mate.mystiroakey wrote:"Now, if we just discover that Manu and 12trees click together, Yarde and Wade set the world on fire and Farrell gets game reading specs and we'll really have something to talk about!"
I would crack open a heineken for that team
Reason?
I don't like Heineken. I might share a Boddingtons's, however.
But debating soccer, even to make a point on the Rugby forum, is verboten.
Auto-flagellate please.
which is better than auto-flatulate.
doctor_grey- Posts : 12354
Join date : 2011-04-30
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
I shall have some virtuous herbal tea as a nightcap and head to bed a much happier supporter than I expected to be after a loss. Hopefully mental pictures of autoflatulation don't keep me awake too long.
Oh, and Dickson seemed much more comfortable too. May have found someone there...
Oh, and Dickson seemed much more comfortable too. May have found someone there...
Cowshot- Posts : 1513
Join date : 2011-02-14
Location : Kingston-upon-Thames
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Kangaroos are the only team I know of with a better record- think it will be over 90% of all matches they have ever playedTaylorman wrote:Theres a challenge mysti...name one major, or other, sporting side who for over 100 years has the % winning rate of the ABs, which currently at 76.1%.mystiroakey wrote:The all blacks are the best team in sporting history by the kiwis.. This is not a uk story but a kiwi one. And no you are miles off being the best sporting team ever. But the kiwis literally have nothing else so it's understandable that they grab on to this Schtick.
Or, who in the years of pro rugby a record of 83%. (92% at home).
Who is this side they are miles off?
ChequeredJersey- Posts : 18707
Join date : 2011-12-23
Age : 35
Location : London, UK
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Hey! Some of them are bad at their jobs unintentinally!GloriousEmpire wrote:To be fair to the twickenham crowd. Half of them know so little about what's going on that they probably heard the best team in history was coming, and mistakenly thought they'd bought tickets to see Spain play football.
The group hysteria thing seems big in England for whatever reason. Every morning 8 million people in London decide to get up and all be terrible at their jobs in unison, for example. A few thousand sheep singing a vaguely racist song in a culturally inappropriate way is nothing to get steamed about.
Also, wouldn't you be included in that 8million? Or are you alone free from generalistic, offensive and incorrect abuse?
ChequeredJersey- Posts : 18707
Join date : 2011-12-23
Age : 35
Location : London, UK
Re: From an England Perspective - What Have We learned Today
Reflecting on England's progression in November, Lancaster noted how new combinations had been tested but admitted than an opportunity to replicate last year's surprise win over the All Blacks hadn't been taken.
"You have to look at some of the players we've got missing and some of the new combinations we had, Billy Twelvetrees and Joel Tomkins playing for the first time together in this series," said Lancaster.
"But the over-riding feeling in the dressing room is one of disappointment but that is just how far we've come as a team.
"Credit to New Zealand they are a champion side and they showed it in the end. If you went into the England dressing room, we are desperately disappointed to have lost to a team that has been unbeaten all season.
"Our belief in ourselves and the direction we are going is positive. The players have been great role models and they play with pride and character every time they pull on an England shirt.
"We talk about belief in building a team. when you are putting the jigsaw together of building a team we are definitely moving in the right direction.
"You've got pride in the shirt, a great coaching team and backroom staff and a Twickenham crowd 100 per cent behind the team.
"All those things help in piecing the jigsaw together to be the best you can be when the World Cup comes around.
"It's been about winning here and now but also building the team to win in 2015 and that is our aim.
"We were sixth in the world when we started, third in the world now, pushing second where I think we should be.
"That was the stated aim by the end of this season. We've got the Six Nations to go, a tour to New Zealand and if we keep progressing that should be achievable."
"You have to look at some of the players we've got missing and some of the new combinations we had, Billy Twelvetrees and Joel Tomkins playing for the first time together in this series," said Lancaster.
"But the over-riding feeling in the dressing room is one of disappointment but that is just how far we've come as a team.
"Credit to New Zealand they are a champion side and they showed it in the end. If you went into the England dressing room, we are desperately disappointed to have lost to a team that has been unbeaten all season.
"Our belief in ourselves and the direction we are going is positive. The players have been great role models and they play with pride and character every time they pull on an England shirt.
"We talk about belief in building a team. when you are putting the jigsaw together of building a team we are definitely moving in the right direction.
"You've got pride in the shirt, a great coaching team and backroom staff and a Twickenham crowd 100 per cent behind the team.
"All those things help in piecing the jigsaw together to be the best you can be when the World Cup comes around.
"It's been about winning here and now but also building the team to win in 2015 and that is our aim.
"We were sixth in the world when we started, third in the world now, pushing second where I think we should be.
"That was the stated aim by the end of this season. We've got the Six Nations to go, a tour to New Zealand and if we keep progressing that should be achievable."
BigTrevsbigmac- Posts : 3342
Join date : 2011-05-15
Page 3 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Similar topics
» England v. Wales today
» Regards England loss today, Did England turn up today.
» 6Nations Conclusion - England Perspective
» England summer tour - A South African perspective
» With regarding England today!!!
» Regards England loss today, Did England turn up today.
» 6Nations Conclusion - England Perspective
» England summer tour - A South African perspective
» With regarding England today!!!
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 3 of 4
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum