Floyd will fight Maidana
+31
Hammersmith harrier
kingraf
Atila
KC
Strongback
ONETWOFOREVER
Aveyard01
Gerry SA
horizontalhero
hazharrison
WHU_Champo_League_in_7Yrs
KingMonkey
superflyweight
Rodney
catchweight
BallchinianMuffwig
Diamond in the rough
lambertm100
TRUSSMAN66
hogey
88Chris05
Pedro147
Sam_London
TopHat24/7
Rowley
Cass1234
Valero's Conscience
milkyboy
adamk
jimdig
hampo17
35 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Boxing
Page 3 of 6
Page 3 of 6 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Floyd will fight Maidana
First topic message reminder :
It's now official. Not a fan of this fight as I don't see what Maidana can do that will cause him any problems, a better fight than Khan in my opinion though.
It's now official. Not a fan of this fight as I don't see what Maidana can do that will cause him any problems, a better fight than Khan in my opinion though.
hampo17- Admin
- Posts : 9108
Join date : 2011-02-24
Age : 36
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Maidana will bring it, no doubt, but I don't see him catching Floyd. In recent times it has only been a fresh Mosley who has done that and Maidana is no Sugar Shane in terms of speed. I see Maidana trying to rough Floyd up but, as so many have found, Mayweather is a superb inside fighter and he gets pummelled.
KingMonkey- Posts : 1067
Join date : 2011-09-23
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Good to see Maidana get a good payday........
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Aveyard01- Posts : 6
Join date : 2013-07-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Bradley
Garcia
Manny
Lara
??
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
I'd really like to see Floyd step outside of Vegas for once. A year from now and Khan could be far more viable, maybe Brook so I'd like to see him over here in a stadium fight. It'd be a genuine legacy enhancer and something we haven't seen him do for a long time. He won't though because it'd be too many things stacked against him and hes not going to take the risk.
KingMonkey- Posts : 1067
Join date : 2011-09-23
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TopHat24/7 wrote:Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Bradley
Garcia
Manny
Lara
??
Garcia is a LWW and Floyd would just be accused of beating up a smaller man.
Manny and Bradley are signed to fight each other, and we all know the issues surrounding the cross promotional bodies anyway.
Lara is a LMW would be a good fight however he likely gets outclassed and then people start calling him overrated like they do with Canelo.
hampo17- Admin
- Posts : 9108
Join date : 2011-02-24
Age : 36
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Nice piece my friend..
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
KingMonkey wrote:I'd really like to see Floyd step outside of Vegas for once. A year from now and Khan could be far more viable, maybe Brook so I'd like to see him over here in a stadium fight. It'd be a genuine legacy enhancer and something we haven't seen him do for a long time. He won't though because it'd be too many things stacked against him and hes not going to take the risk.
When you want to see the King you travel TO HIM.
Mayweather has earned the right to stay home. Unbeaten in more then 16 years, p4p champ.
Khan needs to stop complaining. He has played himself, not Floyd who played him.
ONETWOFOREVER- Posts : 5510
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Thanks TRUSSONETWOFOREVER wrote:KingMonkey wrote:I'd really like to see Floyd step outside of Vegas for once. A year from now and Khan could be far more viable, maybe Brook so I'd like to see him over here in a stadium fight. It'd be a genuine legacy enhancer and something we haven't seen him do for a long time. He won't though because it'd be too many things stacked against him and hes not going to take the risk.
When you want to see the King you travel TO HIM.
Mayweather has earned the right to stay home. Unbeaten in more then 16 years, p4p champ.
Khan needs to stop complaining. He has played himself, not Floyd who played him.
Guest- Guest
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
hampo171 wrote:TopHat24/7 wrote:Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Bradley
Garcia
Manny
Lara
??
Garcia is a LWW and Floyd would just be accused of beating up a smaller man.
Manny and Bradley are signed to fight each other, and we all know the issues surrounding the cross promotional bodies anyway.
Lara is a LMW would be a good fight however he likely gets outclassed and then people start calling him overrated like they do with Canelo.
No, Floyd walks around at 154, and comes in at 150 for LMW fights. His skills carry him at LMW but he's a WW fighter. Plus, he blew up at 135lber to fight at 144 (albeit turning up at 146) so no reason he can't fight Garcia similarly. Fights either side of 147 are do-able for Floyd, IF he cared to chase them.
Either Manny or Brad would ditch their fights for a PBF pay-day, so that's no defence.
Lara, don't care if/how Floyd beats him, he's still a better option than MM.
Last edited by TopHat24/7 on Tue 25 Feb - 16:53; edited 1 time in total
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
DAVE667 wrote:Thanks TRUSSONETWOFOREVER wrote:KingMonkey wrote:I'd really like to see Floyd step outside of Vegas for once. A year from now and Khan could be far more viable, maybe Brook so I'd like to see him over here in a stadium fight. It'd be a genuine legacy enhancer and something we haven't seen him do for a long time. He won't though because it'd be too many things stacked against him and hes not going to take the risk.
When you want to see the King you travel TO HIM.
Mayweather has earned the right to stay home. Unbeaten in more then 16 years, p4p champ.
Khan needs to stop complaining. He has played himself, not Floyd who played him.
ONETWO...I'm proud to have you as an alias !!
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
DAVE667 wrote:Thanks TRUSSONETWOFOREVER wrote:KingMonkey wrote:I'd really like to see Floyd step outside of Vegas for once. A year from now and Khan could be far more viable, maybe Brook so I'd like to see him over here in a stadium fight. It'd be a genuine legacy enhancer and something we haven't seen him do for a long time. He won't though because it'd be too many things stacked against him and hes not going to take the risk.
When you want to see the King you travel TO HIM.
Mayweather has earned the right to stay home. Unbeaten in more then 16 years, p4p champ.
Khan needs to stop complaining. He has played himself, not Floyd who played him.
Grow up ffs
children
ONETWOFOREVER- Posts : 5510
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TRUSSMAN66 wrote:Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Nice piece my friend..
Of course it is.......
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
ONETWOFOREVER wrote:KingMonkey wrote:I'd really like to see Floyd step outside of Vegas for once. A year from now and Khan could be far more viable, maybe Brook so I'd like to see him over here in a stadium fight. It'd be a genuine legacy enhancer and something we haven't seen him do for a long time. He won't though because it'd be too many things stacked against him and hes not going to take the risk.
When you want to see the King you travel TO HIM.
Mayweather has earned the right to stay home. Unbeaten in more then 16 years, p4p champ.
Khan needs to stop complaining. He has played himself, not Floyd who played him.
Yeah, I get that, but with the amount of worthwhile foes dwindling and fights to sell he'll need to find a 'hook' especially after cruching Maidana. He'll look more invincible than ever!
KingMonkey- Posts : 1067
Join date : 2011-09-23
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
How does anybody know what weight Floyd is at the moment and how does anybody know apart from Floyd himself what is do-able......
I mean come on..............Did you phone Floyd and ask him !!
I mean come on..............Did you phone Floyd and ask him !!
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
He could embark on a SRR, ALI style world tour but at his age I don't see that. Anyway the longer he is unbeaten the easier it is to sell fights.KingMonkey wrote:ONETWOFOREVER wrote:KingMonkey wrote:I'd really like to see Floyd step outside of Vegas for once. A year from now and Khan could be far more viable, maybe Brook so I'd like to see him over here in a stadium fight. It'd be a genuine legacy enhancer and something we haven't seen him do for a long time. He won't though because it'd be too many things stacked against him and hes not going to take the risk.
When you want to see the King you travel TO HIM.
Mayweather has earned the right to stay home. Unbeaten in more then 16 years, p4p champ.
Khan needs to stop complaining. He has played himself, not Floyd who played him.
Yeah, I get that, but with the amount of worthwhile foes dwindling and fights to sell he'll need to find a 'hook' especially after cruching Maidana. He'll look more invincible than ever!
That's the power of the O my friend
ONETWOFOREVER- Posts : 5510
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
All aboard the excuse train...... Choo! Choo!!
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TRUSSMAN66 wrote:How does anybody know what weight Floyd is at the moment and how does anybody know apart from Floyd himself what is do-able......
I mean come on..............Did you phone Floyd and ask him !!
Unbelievable some on here TRUSS
ONETWOFOREVER- Posts : 5510
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
ONETWOFOREVER wrote:He could embark on a SRR, ALI style world tour but at his age I don't see that. Anyway the longer he is unbeaten the easier it is to sell fights.KingMonkey wrote:ONETWOFOREVER wrote:KingMonkey wrote:I'd really like to see Floyd step outside of Vegas for once. A year from now and Khan could be far more viable, maybe Brook so I'd like to see him over here in a stadium fight. It'd be a genuine legacy enhancer and something we haven't seen him do for a long time. He won't though because it'd be too many things stacked against him and hes not going to take the risk.
When you want to see the King you travel TO HIM.
Mayweather has earned the right to stay home. Unbeaten in more then 16 years, p4p champ.
Khan needs to stop complaining. He has played himself, not Floyd who played him.
Yeah, I get that, but with the amount of worthwhile foes dwindling and fights to sell he'll need to find a 'hook' especially after cruching Maidana. He'll look more invincible than ever!
That's the power of the O my friend
I agree my friend...Just wish I had an open line to Floyd like some lucky souls on here........
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
ONETWOFOREVER wrote:TRUSSMAN66 wrote:How does anybody know what weight Floyd is at the moment and how does anybody know apart from Floyd himself what is do-able......
I mean come on..............Did you phone Floyd and ask him !!
Unbelievable some on here TRUSS
Get a room you two.....
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Gerry SA wrote:Molina is a lightweight. It would be like Wlad beating up a cruiser weight... Pointless.TRUSSMAN66 wrote:Molina was unbeaten and Diaz drew with Shawn porter in the fight before Khan...
You look stupid when you say they are mediocre....
Come on..
Diaz is long passed his peak. Yet he still bashed up Khan.
Khan is a joke. Mayweather doesn't do pity...
I was suggesting mediocre is a bit harsh ...................
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
You were suggesting I'm stupid by calling them mediocre but that's fine, I can handle that. I still think they're mediocre.
KingMonkey- Posts : 1067
Join date : 2011-09-23
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
I think an unbeaten fighter....... and one that draws with a soon to be world champion in the fight before can't be mediocre.........
You not agree ???................Mediocre is too strong...........Reserve it for journeymen..
BTW Floyd tells me he's 157 with his socks on today !!
You not agree ???................Mediocre is too strong...........Reserve it for journeymen..
BTW Floyd tells me he's 157 with his socks on today !!
Last edited by TRUSSMAN66 on Tue 25 Feb - 17:11; edited 2 times in total (Reason for editing : ..)
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
157.5 after dipping his socked feet in the pool
KingMonkey- Posts : 1067
Join date : 2011-09-23
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
157.7 after seeing his girlfriend naked while dipping his socked feet in pool...
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TRUSSMAN66 wrote:I think an unbeaten fighter....... and one that draws with a soon to be world champion in the fight before can't be mediocre.........
You not agree ???................Mediocre is too strong...........Reserve it for journeymen..
BTW Floyd tells me he's 157 with his socks on today !!
Yaawwwwnnn
Question is, how bad does a Floyd opponent have to get before you don't blow smoke up his/its backside?
How about getting MAB out of retirement for a 150lb catchweight fight??
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TRUSSMAN66 wrote:157.7 after seeing his girlfriend naked while dipping his socked feet in pool...
Why the extra .2? Because he picks up a blunt instrument to beat her with..??
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TRUSSMAN66 wrote:I think an unbeaten fighter....... and one that draws with a soon to be world champion in the fight before can't be mediocre.........
You not agree ???................Mediocre is too strong...........Reserve it for journeymen..
BTW Floyd tells me he's 157 with his socks on today !!
Haha that's just quality
class
ONETWOFOREVER- Posts : 5510
Join date : 2011-01-26
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
ONETWOFOREVER wrote:TRUSSMAN66 wrote:I think an unbeaten fighter....... and one that draws with a soon to be world champion in the fight before can't be mediocre.........
You not agree ???................Mediocre is too strong...........Reserve it for journeymen..
BTW Floyd tells me he's 157 with his socks on today !!
Haha that's just quality
class
I aim to please...
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Slurp....slurp......can almost here the salad tossing from here!
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TopHat24/7 wrote:Slurp....slurp......can almost here the salad tossing from here!
Fancy you talking about salad..
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Fancy you making a joke that a) was actually funny; and b) wasn't about worshipping Floyd.
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Still fairplay Mate...At least you've heard of salad...Unlike half of the fighters you comment on everyday here !!
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Amir's daddy had his eye on 150 houses for sale in Bradford. Only £12,000 each.
He's cussin' Floyd now.
He's cussin' Floyd now.
Strongback- Posts : 6529
Join date : 2011-07-01
Location : Matchroom Sports Head Office
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Why is it frankly ridiculous? He's a champion @ LMW therefore a fight with a champ from the weight above is a natural one to make. There have been plenty of examples in boxing history of fighters testing themselves by fighting outside of their natural weight division, Greb, SRR, SRL to name but a few. This is what made them great, the fact that they sought out challenges which enhanced their legacy, it's also what stops Mayweather from being in the top tier of ATGs [in my opinion].
Why bother having a poll if you're just going to ignore it when it doesn't yield the response you want?
Can hardly be seen to be "giving the public what they want" now, can he?
KC- Posts : 160
Join date : 2011-03-06
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
But Floyd has already moved up to fight heavier fighters above his weight class. Winning the title at 154lbs should be suffice. What you are saying is that you want him to move up two weight classes. If he moved up and beat Martinez then what? A fight with Andre Ward or Carl Froch?KC wrote:Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Why is it frankly ridiculous? He's a champion @ LMW therefore a fight with a champ from the weight above is a natural one to make. There have been plenty of examples in boxing history of fighters testing themselves by fighting outside of their natural weight division, Greb, SRR, SRL to name but a few. This is what made them great, the fact that they sought out challenges which enhanced their legacy, it's also what stops Mayweather from being in the top tier of ATGs [in my opinion].
Why bother having a poll if you're just going to ignore it when it doesn't yield the response you want?
Can hardly be seen to be "giving the public what they want" now, can he?
Atila- Posts : 1712
Join date : 2011-06-03
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
He could just ask Martinez to move down - a concession Martinez would gladly make.
kingraf- raf
- Posts : 16604
Join date : 2012-06-06
Age : 30
Location : To you I am there. To me I am here.... is it possible that I'm everywhere?
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Atila wrote:But Floyd has already moved up to fight heavier fighters above his weight class. Winning the title at 154lbs should be suffice. What you are saying is that you want him to move up two weight classes. If he moved up and beat Martinez then what? A fight with Andre Ward or Carl Froch?KC wrote:Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Why is it frankly ridiculous? He's a champion @ LMW therefore a fight with a champ from the weight above is a natural one to make. There have been plenty of examples in boxing history of fighters testing themselves by fighting outside of their natural weight division, Greb, SRR, SRL to name but a few. This is what made them great, the fact that they sought out challenges which enhanced their legacy, it's also what stops Mayweather from being in the top tier of ATGs [in my opinion].
Why bother having a poll if you're just going to ignore it when it doesn't yield the response you want?
Can hardly be seen to be "giving the public what they want" now, can he?
As kingraf rightly points out, it's well documented that Martinez has offered to fight @ LMW against Mayweather.
Greb often fought LHWs & HWs who outweighed him by 20, 30 or 40 pounds - bigger doesn't always mean better.
KC- Posts : 160
Join date : 2011-03-06
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
I didn't know that Martinez has offered to move down to 154lbs. Basically then, it's not really a fight with the champion at a weight above.KC wrote:Atila wrote:But Floyd has already moved up to fight heavier fighters above his weight class. Winning the title at 154lbs should be suffice. What you are saying is that you want him to move up two weight classes. If he moved up and beat Martinez then what? A fight with Andre Ward or Carl Froch?KC wrote:Aveyard01 wrote:Looking forward to this purely for the fact it will make floyd look good, and when that happens he looks unreal. Who else is there? I think the fact that opponents you would say have a chance all fight at higher weights (Bradley even mentioning WARD!) is it unfair to expect a 36/7 year old to fight above his natural weight and give up all the advantages that go with that? The calls for floyd to fight at mw given his build are frankly ridiculous. So then, to live ww's...available, and who bring something to the table. Maidana ticks those boxes ( I prefer khan after a ww fight or two) he has a strap, porter isnt a name, bradley unavailable. I was thinking about how perception plays a huge factor in boxing (eg froch groves, but thats another debate) A fighter i would love to see is paulie malignaggi in there
Why is it frankly ridiculous? He's a champion @ LMW therefore a fight with a champ from the weight above is a natural one to make. There have been plenty of examples in boxing history of fighters testing themselves by fighting outside of their natural weight division, Greb, SRR, SRL to name but a few. This is what made them great, the fact that they sought out challenges which enhanced their legacy, it's also what stops Mayweather from being in the top tier of ATGs [in my opinion].
Why bother having a poll if you're just going to ignore it when it doesn't yield the response you want?
Can hardly be seen to be "giving the public what they want" now, can he?
As kingraf rightly points out, it's well documented that Martinez has offered to fight @ LMW against Mayweather.
Greb often fought LHWs & HWs who outweighed him by 20, 30 or 40 pounds - bigger doesn't always mean better.
Atila- Posts : 1712
Join date : 2011-06-03
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Posted this on another thread about Floyd fighting GGG, as it still sums my views up as well as I can manage:
Was Golovkin a fully fledged monster and stone wall cert for being a top five at middleweight nobody would be calling for the fight. As you have alluded to he has looked good so far, but against reasonably second tier opposition. He is also relatively inexperienced at world level. As such those of us asking for the fight are not really asking Floyd to challenge King Kong. My own personal view is Floyd’s clear edges in experience and skill are adequate compensation for the physical advantages enjoyed by GGG and so the fight is a pick em at worst.
As others have said would not overly criticize Floyd as and when it does not happen but do get baffled by the position of some on here. Surely fans should want to see fights that get their juices flowing and where they can’t pick a winner. Do get the feeling sometimes that there are folk on here who are members of the Mayweather family or on a percentage of his future purses so desperate are they to see him take fights that will not trouble his 0.
As a post script to this over the festive period Boxing News did a top 20 of the fights they would love to see in 2014, Floyd vs GGG was top of the pile, so the idea of them fighting is not completely pie in the sky or the fiction of a bunch of internet people who just want to see him lose.
Was Golovkin a fully fledged monster and stone wall cert for being a top five at middleweight nobody would be calling for the fight. As you have alluded to he has looked good so far, but against reasonably second tier opposition. He is also relatively inexperienced at world level. As such those of us asking for the fight are not really asking Floyd to challenge King Kong. My own personal view is Floyd’s clear edges in experience and skill are adequate compensation for the physical advantages enjoyed by GGG and so the fight is a pick em at worst.
As others have said would not overly criticize Floyd as and when it does not happen but do get baffled by the position of some on here. Surely fans should want to see fights that get their juices flowing and where they can’t pick a winner. Do get the feeling sometimes that there are folk on here who are members of the Mayweather family or on a percentage of his future purses so desperate are they to see him take fights that will not trouble his 0.
As a post script to this over the festive period Boxing News did a top 20 of the fights they would love to see in 2014, Floyd vs GGG was top of the pile, so the idea of them fighting is not completely pie in the sky or the fiction of a bunch of internet people who just want to see him lose.
Rowley- Admin
- Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Agree with Jeff totally on this one, To call a fight that would be 50/50 on paper a ridiculous idea is ridiculous in itself, its a fight more than winnable for Mayweather, I wouldn't ever hold it against Mayweather for it not happening, but as Jeff says why would people NOT want this fight to happen.. I honestly think If Mayweather has an 09-11 Pacquiao, Paul Willliams and Martinez/GGG on his record he would have a very good shout to be number one p4p mose definitely top 3.. These fights could have all been made over the past 5 years that's the most frustrating thing for me when discussing Mayweather, that we discuss the merits of him being top 10 or not when It could of been an absolutely certainty in everyones eyes and so so much more!
Cass1234- Posts : 65
Join date : 2011-11-22
Age : 35
Location : Leicester
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
As much as I do bash Floyd sometimes, I personally feel 160 is pushing unreasonable also for a guy that started at, what, 130?
There are plenty of fights he's rightly slated for 'missing' (PW @ 154, Martinez @ 154, Cotto @ 147, Manny @ 140/147 etc) but I could not knock him for not fighting a 160lber (given that he gives up weight to 154lbers even).
There are plenty of fights he's rightly slated for 'missing' (PW @ 154, Martinez @ 154, Cotto @ 147, Manny @ 140/147 etc) but I could not knock him for not fighting a 160lber (given that he gives up weight to 154lbers even).
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Rowley wrote:Posted this on another thread about Floyd fighting GGG, as it still sums my views up as well as I can manage:
Was Golovkin a fully fledged monster and stone wall cert for being a top five at middleweight nobody would be calling for the fight. As you have alluded to he has looked good so far, but against reasonably second tier opposition. He is also relatively inexperienced at world level. As such those of us asking for the fight are not really asking Floyd to challenge King Kong. My own personal view is Floyd’s clear edges in experience and skill are adequate compensation for the physical advantages enjoyed by GGG and so the fight is a pick em at worst.
As others have said would not overly criticize Floyd as and when it does not happen but do get baffled by the position of some on here. Surely fans should want to see fights that get their juices flowing and where they can’t pick a winner. Do get the feeling sometimes that there are folk on here who are members of the Mayweather family or on a percentage of his future purses so desperate are they to see him take fights that will not trouble his 0.
As a post script to this over the festive period Boxing News did a top 20 of the fights they would love to see in 2014, Floyd vs GGG was top of the pile, so the idea of them fighting is not completely pie in the sky or the fiction of a bunch of internet people who just want to see him lose.
Spot on.
Sometimes get the impression that Mayweather's fanboys are even more obsessed with maintaining his 0 than he is
KC- Posts : 160
Join date : 2011-03-06
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
I'm not saying he has to fight a 160lb boxer but he can't lay claim to be top 10 ATG by staying @ WW & cherry picking his opponents, at least fight someone who will extend you - Pacquaio, Bradley.
And the Bob Arum dispute is just a convenient smokescreen!
And the Bob Arum dispute is just a convenient smokescreen!
KC- Posts : 160
Join date : 2011-03-06
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
But he's not 'staying at WW', he's moved throught the weights from 130 to 135 to 140 to 147 to 154 (ish), and won every time he's entered the ring.
The way you write about him it's as if he's only ever campaigned as a WW.
The way you write about him it's as if he's only ever campaigned as a WW.
TopHat24/7- Posts : 17008
Join date : 2011-07-01
Age : 40
Location : London
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Truss thinks we just want to see him lose, and cites how we critique him differently to others.
We do judge him differently, it's actually a compliment, he's so damn good he gets judged by different standards, and we want him to take the next step up to define his legacy. Some think he owes us this, most I think, like me, think he doesn't, but needs to if he wants to cement that place in the higher echelons of the goat debate.
As for wanting to see him lose I'll say this.
Let's say (for example) a ggg fight could be made. For me its the definitive no lose situation. A potentially competitive fight to look forward to, with doubt about the outcome. If floyd wins, we can marvel at his performance and the cementing of his legacy. If ggg wins, we can revel in the smug grin getting wiped off Floyd's face. Perfect.
(I know truss if floyd wins ggg was hype etc
We do judge him differently, it's actually a compliment, he's so damn good he gets judged by different standards, and we want him to take the next step up to define his legacy. Some think he owes us this, most I think, like me, think he doesn't, but needs to if he wants to cement that place in the higher echelons of the goat debate.
As for wanting to see him lose I'll say this.
Let's say (for example) a ggg fight could be made. For me its the definitive no lose situation. A potentially competitive fight to look forward to, with doubt about the outcome. If floyd wins, we can marvel at his performance and the cementing of his legacy. If ggg wins, we can revel in the smug grin getting wiped off Floyd's face. Perfect.
(I know truss if floyd wins ggg was hype etc
milkyboy- Posts : 7762
Join date : 2011-05-22
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TopHat24/7 wrote:But he's not 'staying at WW', he's moved throught the weights from 130 to 135 to 140 to 147 to 154 (ish), and won every time he's entered the ring.
The way you write about him it's as if he's only ever campaigned as a WW.
Have to agree with Toppy.....Ouch..
People forget he was a Jr light.............We are talking 30 pounds to middle.....24 to Jr midd............
I'm sure Rowley and KC wouldn't be slagging off Salvador sanchez for avoiding Mike Mccallum..
Funny how people lose perspective when talking about Mayweather.......
Sanchez v Mccallum....Ouch what a mismatch.
Last edited by TRUSSMAN66 on Wed 26 Feb - 9:30; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : ..)
TRUSSMAN66- Posts : 40690
Join date : 2011-02-02
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
TRUSSMAN66 wrote:
People forget he was a Jr light.............
Key word in there is was. I was 8lb six ounces once.
Rowley- Admin
- Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.
Re: Floyd will fight Maidana
Not really, does not matter what he was once, it matters what he is now. As a current belt holder at light middle are we really stretching reality to call him a light middle? As such those who would like to see him fight GGG are asking him to go up one division.
Can I ask you a genuine question Truss? Why do you not want to see the fight?
Can I ask you a genuine question Truss? Why do you not want to see the fight?
Rowley- Admin
- Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.
Page 3 of 6 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Similar topics
» Floyd-Maidana
» What next for Khan if Maidana v Floyd rematch?
» Why I believe Marcos Rene Maidana can beat Floyd Mayweather
» If The Floyd - Pac Fight Never Happens Who Will Come Out Looking Worse???
» Who do you think Floyd Mayweather Jnr will fight next?
» What next for Khan if Maidana v Floyd rematch?
» Why I believe Marcos Rene Maidana can beat Floyd Mayweather
» If The Floyd - Pac Fight Never Happens Who Will Come Out Looking Worse???
» Who do you think Floyd Mayweather Jnr will fight next?
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Boxing
Page 3 of 6
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum