Mick Newell replaces Ashley Giles as selector
4 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Cricket
Page 1 of 1
Mick Newell replaces Ashley Giles as selector
Should help more county players get in under Moores like last time
GSC- Posts : 43487
Join date : 2011-03-28
Age : 32
Location : Leicester
Re: Mick Newell replaces Ashley Giles as selector
They haven't said he's replaced Giles, but they have said, he will be a selector whilst also remaining with Notts..
however Newell was my choice to become England head coach, so im happy with the decision to make him a selector
however Newell was my choice to become England head coach, so im happy with the decision to make him a selector
Guest- Guest
Re: Mick Newell replaces Ashley Giles as selector
Giles stepped down so putting 2 and 2 together
GSC- Posts : 43487
Join date : 2011-03-28
Age : 32
Location : Leicester
Re: Mick Newell replaces Ashley Giles as selector
Yeah happy Newell has taken over from Giles.
Just hope he isn't biast towards Nottinghamshire players.
Just hope he isn't biast towards Nottinghamshire players.
NickisBHAFC- Posts : 11670
Join date : 2011-04-24
Location : Sussex
Re: Mick Newell replaces Ashley Giles as selector
Not a particularly big fan of Newell if I'm honest.
If anything he'll be reluctant to pick Notts players as he's still involved with them, see his new Limited Overs skipper JWA Taylor. Doubt he's getting a call up now.
If anything he'll be reluctant to pick Notts players as he's still involved with them, see his new Limited Overs skipper JWA Taylor. Doubt he's getting a call up now.
JDizzle- Posts : 6926
Join date : 2011-03-11
Re: Mick Newell replaces Ashley Giles as selector
I'm not sure the idea that county selectors will always be partisan and pick their own players actually holds. I can imagine Angus Fraser having the opposite effect actually - urging caution with regard to Middx players. Of course, there may be cases when having worked with a player allows the selector to feel more confident in picking somebody too. Perhaps this will be most true of Moores and Kerrigan, and perhaps Newell and Taylor.
I'm a little surprised that they've gone for another selector attached to a county. It means that the panel now consists, alongside the National Selector, of somebody who was a county Head Coach until a few days ago, a county Head Coach and a county Director of Cricket. However, it probably makes economic sense to do this. Apart from attending meetings the main thing that selectors do is sit at county grounds, mostly in press boxes, making notes on various players. In some ways it makes sense for somebody who is already travelling around the county circuit to take this on rather that somebody different. Whitaker or even Moores can always be dispatched if somebody particularly needs looked at it in a certain week.
There might also have been an issue in finding another suitable candidate. When Fraser was appointed (to replace Flower) a few months ago the position was advertised and, if there had been another outstanding contender from outside the county game, I'm sure they'd have been looked at.
I'm a little surprised that they've gone for another selector attached to a county. It means that the panel now consists, alongside the National Selector, of somebody who was a county Head Coach until a few days ago, a county Head Coach and a county Director of Cricket. However, it probably makes economic sense to do this. Apart from attending meetings the main thing that selectors do is sit at county grounds, mostly in press boxes, making notes on various players. In some ways it makes sense for somebody who is already travelling around the county circuit to take this on rather that somebody different. Whitaker or even Moores can always be dispatched if somebody particularly needs looked at it in a certain week.
There might also have been an issue in finding another suitable candidate. When Fraser was appointed (to replace Flower) a few months ago the position was advertised and, if there had been another outstanding contender from outside the county game, I'm sure they'd have been looked at.
Shelsey93- Posts : 3134
Join date : 2011-12-14
Age : 31
Re: Mick Newell replaces Ashley Giles as selector
I suppose the upside is there's very few coaches more up to date with CC than Newell.
Tbh outside of Taylor there's not really many he could bring in. Hales was awful in 4 day cricket last season, Lumbs already in the t20 team. Patels got the talent but burned his bridges I imagine.
Tbh outside of Taylor there's not really many he could bring in. Hales was awful in 4 day cricket last season, Lumbs already in the t20 team. Patels got the talent but burned his bridges I imagine.
GSC- Posts : 43487
Join date : 2011-03-28
Age : 32
Location : Leicester
Similar topics
» Ashley Giles Named ODI and T20 Coach for England
» If I was a England selector...
» It looks like Grant Fox will become a Selector for the All Blacks...
» Keelan Giles to start against Scotland if George North is injured?
» Bopara replaces Trott for England
» If I was a England selector...
» It looks like Grant Fox will become a Selector for the All Blacks...
» Keelan Giles to start against Scotland if George North is injured?
» Bopara replaces Trott for England
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Cricket
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum