Big games at the end of the season: who should ref?
3 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 1 of 1
Big games at the end of the season: who should ref?
Let's try and keep this respectful...
I'm interested to know who people think should referee the big knockout games at the end of the season.
I'd like to see something along the lines of:
Prem semi-final 1: Wayne Barnes with Greg Garner & Matt Carley
Prem semi-final 2: Luke Pearce with JP Doyle & Andrew Small
Prem final: JP Doyle with Wayne Barnes & Luke Pearce
Challenge Cup final: (assuming an English team is involved) Jérôme Garcès with Pascal Gauzère & another French AR
Champions Cup final: (I'll assume Clermont-Toulon) Nigel Owens with JP Doyle & Wayne Barnes
Pro 12 final: Nigel Owens with John Lacey & Marius Mitrea
I don't necessarily rate Owens as the #1, but I'd like to see the calls for him to ref everything possible answered once and for all so we can start to give games to some of the more preferable refs like Doyle, Pearce and Garcès.
I'm interested to know who people think should referee the big knockout games at the end of the season.
I'd like to see something along the lines of:
Prem semi-final 1: Wayne Barnes with Greg Garner & Matt Carley
Prem semi-final 2: Luke Pearce with JP Doyle & Andrew Small
Prem final: JP Doyle with Wayne Barnes & Luke Pearce
Challenge Cup final: (assuming an English team is involved) Jérôme Garcès with Pascal Gauzère & another French AR
Champions Cup final: (I'll assume Clermont-Toulon) Nigel Owens with JP Doyle & Wayne Barnes
Pro 12 final: Nigel Owens with John Lacey & Marius Mitrea
I don't necessarily rate Owens as the #1, but I'd like to see the calls for him to ref everything possible answered once and for all so we can start to give games to some of the more preferable refs like Doyle, Pearce and Garcès.
OMc- Posts : 81
Join date : 2014-03-15
Re: Big games at the end of the season: who should ref?
Steve Walsh.
Oh... hang on...
Oh... hang on...
Jimpy- Posts : 2823
Join date : 2012-08-02
Location : Not in a hot sandy place anymore
Re: Big games at the end of the season: who should ref?
There is no way JP Doyle should get the AP final after last season's debacle. The ref and TMO should not be the most important factors in a game.
Would want Nigel Owens - AP final with Wayne Barnes and Luke Pearce.
Agree with the rest.
Would want Nigel Owens - AP final with Wayne Barnes and Luke Pearce.
Agree with the rest.
beshocked- Posts : 14849
Join date : 2011-03-08
Re: Big games at the end of the season: who should ref?
beshocked wrote:There is no way JP Doyle should get the AP final after last season's debacle. The ref and TMO should not be the most important factors in a game.
Would want Nigel Owens - AP final with Wayne Barnes and Luke Pearce.
Agree with the rest.
Would the RFU bypass their own to bring in a Welshman though?
I'm sure if you asked a Saints fan they'd have something to say for the way Barnes reffed the final in 2013. In my mind JP is much better - the best of a pretty good lot.
OMc- Posts : 81
Join date : 2014-03-15
Similar topics
» Pre-season games
» Pre Season Games
» Final Games of the season
» Ulster announce Pre-Season Games
» Boxing Sheep Season 2 Games 9 & 10 Deadline Friday 20/07/12 @12.00pm
» Pre Season Games
» Final Games of the season
» Ulster announce Pre-Season Games
» Boxing Sheep Season 2 Games 9 & 10 Deadline Friday 20/07/12 @12.00pm
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum