Fantasy match-up! Who wins?

First topic message reminder :

Pacquiao vs. Mayweather?

It's a war but for the life of me don't see how Chavez is stronger than a future middleweight world champion, Rosario hit hard but he didn't hit anywhere near as hard Duran, personally think Duran stands up better to Chavez's punches than the other way round. Horrible fight for me to predict as they along with Khaosai Galaxy are my favourite three fighters of all time.

135 for me was Chavez best weight......

Make your mind up gHosty he can't be stronger than a middleweight champion....and then Hearns beat up a lightweight..

Can't have it both ways mate!!!

Chavez for me was sturdier and had a better chin......Rosario was a natural lightweight and got out muscled.......See why ROberto would be any different..

Not the hardest logic to understand that Duran had the strength and ability to beat Barkley but did not have height or reach to get close to Hearns, Leonard was a natural Welterweight who got out muscled, see the difference now?

Barkley won by three rounds for me....and he was garbage...

Got out muscled?? Is that why it was a controversial decision.....

When did Leonard ever use his strength anyway..He was a boxer...

Can't see your Herol Graham outmuscling Duran for that matter he wasn't that kind of fighter..he was a natural middle..

Chavez for me was stronger at lightweight especially in the chin and durability departments..

Had more heart as well....

opinions are opinions and you might be right..

Only in your head are the Barkley and Leonard decisions controversial, they were close but the right man won both times, you make out as if they were a Whittaker/Ramirez situation. Leonard beat Hearns with pure boxing then did he or did he go all guns blazing in an attempt to blast him out?

Who would have thought though that the boxer Floyd Mayweather would have outmuscled the brawler Ricky Hatton who was famed for his strength.

I also have no comeback to the no heart remark as I don't wish to speak ill of Chavez who was a very fine boxer

Same old argument? Suppose Paul Williams beat up JMM.