[solved]Mafia- The return of Bullsack Holmes

First topic message reminder :

Rules

1. Keep talk about the game in this unless it is specially allowed by your role to talk via PM.
2. You should never edit/delete posts.
3. Do not post when dead.
4. When you want to place a vote make it in bold. Example: Vote: Bull. Non bold votes don't count for anything.
5. Game in split into day and night phases. During the day phase everyone votes as a collective to lynch (or not). Majority vote wins. Game switches to night mode following the lynch (or no lynch).
6. During night mode, mafia and special role players carry out their roles via pm to me.
7. Whenever someone has received majority vote (example 6 with 11, 5 with 9 etc.) that player will be immediately lynched even if the hammer vote is changed before the lynching.
8. Mafia must tell me which member commits the murder each night (if more than 1 mafia member)
9. THE DOCTOR, 100%, NEVER EVER EVER EVER CAN SAVE THEMSELVES.
10. Viva cannot make anyone swear on their mums life. It's annoying and pointless. He will be lynched instantly if he asks anyone to do so.

The Game

1. You win as a team. You still win if your side wins, while you're dead.
2. Player roles were determined via random.org.
3. If you have any questions about your role or how the game works, send me a PM.
4. I will not lie to you.
5. You can say anything except quote any of my PMs.

Roles (Will probably be updated):
Mafia: Standard Mafia member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can nominate a player to kill.
Mafia Roleblocker: Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can nominate a player to kill, and can nominate 1 player and block their actions.

Town: Standard Town member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. No Night phase duties.
Doctor: Town member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can opt to save a player from dying, *players killed during the same night phase only* - Cannot save themselves
Cop: Town member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can investigate one player to get an innocent/guilty verdict
Watcher: Town member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can nominate a player, and will be informed which players have carried out an action on that player, but not which action...

*tried to

I think the cop needs to reveal himself and who he investigated.

Cop stays secret and saves the cop at nighttime

Afro wrote:I think the cop needs to reveal himself and who he investigated.

Cop stays secret and saves the cop at nighttime

But if the cop is saving the cop, who saves the cop?

The cop should stay quiet surely? The mafia would then know who the doc will save and kill off everyone else?

Everyone else is expendable though

Trebs wrote:The cop should stay quiet surely? The mafia would then know who the doc will save and kill off everyone else?

Townies should always act for the good of the town, not for the good of just themselves   

And we can identify innocent players faster than the mafia can kill them

Cop reveal themselves and the person they investigated.

At the moment we have a 1/6 chance of getting the mafia. Cop revealing themselves potentially changes that to 1 in 4

Vote: No lynch

Because it's fun

And then no lynch will probably be the best vote again.

But it all depends on the cop

Afro wrote:

Trebs wrote:The cop should stay quiet surely? The mafia would then know who the doc will save and kill off everyone else?

Townies should always act for the good of the town, not for the good of just themselves   

Sorry Afro, I'll ensure I act in the town's best interests in the future. I just think it's better strategy for the cop to keep quiet to limit the Mafia's options.

No lynch (2) - Nando, Azzy

snoozefest

You didn't take this long to nail me, did you?  

The cop has to come forward now. They will be able to cross someone off the list for us, it's a necessary step.

The Special Juan wrote:You didn't take this long to nail me, did you?  

THAT'S WHAT SHE SAID

Trebs wrote:

Afro wrote:

Trebs wrote:The cop should stay quiet surely? The mafia would then know who the doc will save and kill off everyone else?

Townies should always act for the good of the town, not for the good of just themselves   

Sorry Afro, I'll ensure I act in the town's best interests in the future. I just think it's better strategy for the cop to keep quiet to limit the Mafia's options.

Well if the cop stays quiet, then we have no choice but to go no lynching then. But we risk losing the cop this time if the mafia gets them

If the cop outs himself, and the doctor, that means 3 people will be known innocent. The mafia will know the two who are townies, and so if they don't die, they're innocent. We can't lose if the doc and cop out themselves.

Why give the mafia another night time? They could pick someone off.

We need to cop to speak and then the doctor can act to save him, while also ticking off another non-mafia member overnight.

sodhat wrote:The cop has to come forward now. They will be able to cross someone off the list for us, it's a necessary step.

100% for the long term strategy. And it determines if we no lynch or not

sodhat wrote:

The Special Juan wrote:You didn't take this long to nail me, did you?  

THAT'S WHAT SHE SAID

I think that says a lot about your taste in women...

This is why 6 people games have to start at night. The mafia has very little chance of winning if there's a no lynch.

Show me a man that doesn't like a skank and I'll show you a man afraid of living.

And of syphillis.

If your a cop and you know it clap your hands   

I am a God-fearing townie.

TheSecondComing wrote:This is why 6 people games have to start at night. The mafia has very little chance of winning if there's a no lynch.

Starting at night is effectively skipping out the vote and going to a no lynch anyway.

I'd remove the doctor and add a watcher or something. Doctor makes it too easy. Also make the mafia member a roleblocker.

I'm not a cop either.

One of us has to be.

Removing the doctor is smart. Never fancied that roleblocker malarkey.

Vote: No lynch

This isn't going anywhere, there's a good chance a second investigation by the cop will reveal all in the next day.

If your a cop and you know it clap your hands   

The mafia must be kicking themselves here. Nothing they can do apart from hope the doc doesn't save the cop.

No lynch (3) - Nando, Azzy, Trebs

Fernando wrote:If your a cop and you know it clap your hands   

If you're the cop, who did you investigate?

sodhat wrote:

Fernando wrote:If your a cop and you know it clap your hands   

If you're the cop, who did you investigate?

GSC the Townie

Right.

Vote Trebs

If he isn't the cop, then he is mafia with his suspicious ways.

This game is dull in the extreme.

Want to start over?

No lynch (3) - Nando, Azzy, Trebs
Trebs (1) - sodhat

We can add a Watcher if you want.

Just vote for someone you wangs

Doctor needs to go in a 6 man game I think. Makes the game formulaic which isn't really fun for anyone.

sodhat wrote:Just vote for someone you wangs

Fine.

Vote: Sodhat

Because you've voted for me.

No lynch (1) - Azzy
Trebs (2) - sodhat, GSC
sodhat (2) - Nando, sodhat

I'm a townie.

If Azzy is also a townie as he claims, and GSC is proven a townie, that leaves Nando the cop and either Afro/Trebs as the doc. Afro wants the cop to reveal so the town wins, Trebs doesn't, thus my vote.

Could introduce the role of Gimp. Can nominate to visit someone's house and perform an action on someone but will not be informed of that action.

Hmph.

Vote change: Trebs

TheSecondComing wrote:This is why 6 people games have to start at night. The mafia has very little chance of winning if there's a no lynch.

Only if the town get lucky the doc sves the person the mafia was trying to lynch

Alright, fine.

I'm the cop. I was going to nail Nando for sure tonight with an investigation. I wasn't sure if he was covering for me or was mafia trying to pretend to be the cop. That's why I was trying to say no lynch, to let me have the investigation to be 100% sure.

So either Nando or Trebs is lying...not sure who I can trust there.

Trebs (3) - sodhat, GSC, Azzy
sodhat (2) - Nando, sodhat