[solved]Mafia- The return of Bullsack Holmes

First topic message reminder :

Rules

1. Keep talk about the game in this unless it is specially allowed by your role to talk via PM.
2. You should never edit/delete posts.
3. Do not post when dead.
4. When you want to place a vote make it in bold. Example: Vote: Bull. Non bold votes don't count for anything.
5. Game in split into day and night phases. During the day phase everyone votes as a collective to lynch (or not). Majority vote wins. Game switches to night mode following the lynch (or no lynch).
6. During night mode, mafia and special role players carry out their roles via pm to me.
7. Whenever someone has received majority vote (example 6 with 11, 5 with 9 etc.) that player will be immediately lynched even if the hammer vote is changed before the lynching.
8. Mafia must tell me which member commits the murder each night (if more than 1 mafia member)
9. THE DOCTOR, 100%, NEVER EVER EVER EVER CAN SAVE THEMSELVES.
10. Viva cannot make anyone swear on their mums life. It's annoying and pointless. He will be lynched instantly if he asks anyone to do so.

The Game

1. You win as a team. You still win if your side wins, while you're dead.
2. Player roles were determined via random.org.
3. If you have any questions about your role or how the game works, send me a PM.
4. I will not lie to you.
5. You can say anything except quote any of my PMs.

Roles (Will probably be updated):
Mafia: Standard Mafia member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can nominate a player to kill.
Mafia Roleblocker: Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can nominate a player to kill, and can nominate 1 player and block their actions.

Town: Standard Town member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. No Night phase duties.
Doctor: Town member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can opt to save a player from dying, *players killed during the same night phase only* - Cannot save themselves
Cop: Town member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can investigate one player to get an innocent/guilty verdict
Watcher: Town member. Can vote to lynch during the day phase. During the night phase can nominate a player, and will be informed which players have carried out an action on that player, but not which action...

I won't be able to play next game.

TheSecondComing wrote:So either Nando or Trebs is lying...not sure who I can trust there.

Who cares, get 1 tonight, the other tomorrow. Either way the towns won.

Vote Change - Trebs

Your a lieing bastard Trebs, I investigated GSC was told by TSJ himself that he is innocent.

Or Trebs is the cop and he's sticking to his guns about staying secret.

The cop really needs to show himself for the good of the town

Well who did you investigate Trebs?

And the doctor would be able to help possibly. If he saved either Trebs or Nando he'd know who the cop was out of those two...because no-one died.

For whom the bell tolls...

1 of the 2 is lying and therefore mafia logically. We have 2 chances.

Trebs (4) - sodhat, GSC, Azzy, Nando

That's 4/6...

Nando didn't explicitly say he was the cop to start with, he just strongly implied it to try and lure the cop out. I was all for waiting another day with no lynch.

Soddy, your theory doesn't work because the mafia might not have killed anyone.

Intriguing.

Your a terrible liar Trebs    Welcome to death

Possibly, but a bold tactic if so.

Either way, all it takes is the doctor to reveal himself next round...although I may well be dead.

Trebs wrote:Alright, fine.

I'm the cop. I was going to nail Nando for sure tonight with an investigation. I wasn't sure if he was covering for me or was mafia trying to pretend to be the cop. That's why I was trying to say no lynch, to let me have the investigation to be 100% sure.

That makes no sense as the mafia could have lynched you and we'd have lost the information of who you investigated first night, plus also not get the benefit of who the cop investigates tonight.

Also Nando is definately innocent...

Trebs is invited by the town to tie a yellow ribbon round the old oak tree. Unfortunately for him, he is the yellow ribbon and mafia to boot.

TOWN WINS!!

Again?

You guys are playing some bizarre Travolta/Cage Face/Off madness, and I'm sat here not following any of it

As i keep saying i am the cop, I investigated GSC who is innocent. That's all i know i was going to go for Trebs/Sodhat but decided something didn't sit right with GSC so went in that direction in stead.

Again. Viva wants in.

2 mafia
1 cop
1 doc
3 townies

So who was the doc and who did he save?

Trebs played the only hand he had left at the end. Puts a bit of doubt out there all the same.

We got lucky with the doc saving Nando first round

Well played guys, I couldn't do a lot different to what I did to be honest

Afro was doc, Nando was cop. I figured early in the second round.

I can play again, I'm desk-bound

Exactly the same as the last game Trebs.

I had no clue and saved Nando in the first round, and it was bad luck on your part that he was who you tried to lynch AND the cop to boot

Gimme a list of who's in and I can run it.

Nando mentioned he had a 'role' before, so I knew he was one of the two which is why I executed him.

I'll play

Ill play.

I'm in.

Me.

Trebs
Nando
GSC
Azzy
soddy

Afro??

Sorry, not me.

Struggled to keep up with the last game because of work

Viva said he'd play. Where is he?

5 then.

3 townies, cop, mafia?

Think he said he couldn't play this one.

Let's get going TSJ

That should be everyone.

3 townies, 1 mafia, 1 cop.

I'm stuck in the god damn townie zone. I'm the Jorah Mormont of Mafia

Vote: GSC

Because Albion are after Gareth McCleary.

Albion can't afford a player of McCleary magnificence.

Vote: No lynch

Because I think it's the best way forward.

GSC (1) - Azzy
No lynch (1) - Trebs

No point no lynching with 5.

Vote Azzy

No reason, just because

Vote:Sodhat Been a while since he been mafioso.

GSC (2) - Trebs, Azzy
Azzy (1) - GSC
soddy (1) - Nando

Knew I'd missed something

What will sodhat do? No-one's giving anything away right now.

I'm back, sorry, meeting briefly.

I don't think that's a sound theory there nando...

It's the only theory i have since everyone else being quiet but nice return putting it back on me I Iz Innocent Iz Tellz Ya

Are you the police again?

Maybe TSJ has just done the same roles as last time. I'm watching Trebs in that case.

I'm a townie, but if you lynch me it's not a doc or a cop so I'll take one for the team.

I'm not the mafia this time. I assure you soddy.

Although, if I was mafia, I'd say the same thing anyway