PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
+16
TM2K
Plunky
BlueCoverman
ralphjohn69
navyblueshorts
JAS
robopz
pedro
I'm never wrong
Davie
GPB
Shotrock
McLaren
super_realist
beninho
kwinigolfer
20 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Golf
Page 16 of 20
Page 16 of 20 • 1 ... 9 ... 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20
PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
First topic message reminder :
1).Well done to Tyrrell Hatton, great win at Bay Hill which continued the run of non-American winners - Day, Leishman, McIlroy, Molinari, Hatton.
This was also an Open Championship qualifier and Keith Mitchell (for the second year running), Danny Lee and Dahmen get to battle the traffic at Royal St.George's in July.
2).For the second week running, the course set-up seemed to make scoring unnecessarily tricky given the prevailing weather conditions. A war of attrition, but not necessarily the most attractive golf for the TV viewer to enjoy.
Hopefully the set-up at TPC Sawgrass will enable the world's best to play their shots.
3).Scott Piercy made news for all the wrong reasons last week and now Tour Commish Monahan has expressed disappointment "in the lack of judgment used" and "that it has been addressed with Scott directly". Good thing Monahan didn't say "he knows better" because Piercy clearly doesn't. But his sponsors do, thankfully, tho' any Tour punishment will be kept unpublished - unless he starts missing tournaments, from which we might draw our own conclusions.
Personally, I'd like to have seen his "invitation" to Bay Hill revoked, but no such disapproval reported from the API.
4).Interesting graph from princedrac's twitter account this week showing the top ten owgr points-getters at The Players:
Four Americans: Woods, DLIII, Furyk, Couples
Three Aussies: Elk, Scott, Shark
Nick Price
Sergio & Langer
A good week, of which there haven't been many recently, will see Garcia can jump from 2nd to 1st, ahead of Tiger.
5).That's reflective of an international honours board with eight of the last twelve winners being "overseas" players.
And first-timers at TPC have a tough time too - after Jerry Pate won on the course's debut in 1982, only Hal Sutton and Craig Perks have won trophy on their first trip. Leading "rookie" last year was Eddie Pepperell who stormed home in 3rd place - but he's busy trying to figure out how you get dq'd three times in less than 2 years.
6).This week looks like the exact halfway point of the pre-Play-Off PGA Tour season, the 23rd event out of a total of 46. About 50 pros have already won enough FedEx Points to assure them a tee-time at the Northern Trust, Round 1 of the FedEx Cup Play-Offs.
Not many are Europeans: McIlroy, Hatton, Rahm, Hovland.
7).And only Fleetwood among other Europeans is comfortably placed, for now.
Those who have struggled this season so far, but are exempt at least through next year, include McDowell (79th), Casey (93rd), Lowry (140th), Molinari (168th), Donald (assuming he takes another earnings exemption - 172nd), Garcia (179th), Willett (181st), Stenson (197th), Wallace (202nd), Rose (205th),
While this lot, all not yet exempt for 2020/21 have it all to do: Straka (82nd), Norlander (84th), Knox (90th), Fitzpatrick (100th), Noren (107th), Rafa C-B (120th), Poulter (128th), Cappelen (130th), Laird (158th), Ventura (175th), Power (201st), Bjerregard (224th), Lewis (227th), plus 3 or 4 others on more tenuous status.
8).But one or two American "faces" are also struggling, with these three less than half-way to a Play-Off goal about 400 pts:
110th: Spieth
111th: D.Johnson
213th: Koepka
9).The Florida "Swing" has a musical chairs of dates next year, starting with Bay Hill, then The Players, followed by "Honda". No word yet on how Valspar fits in, but hopefully retains its fourth slot in Florida.
10).Finally, the Top 64 in the owgr's after The Players will qualify for the WGC-MatchPlay in Austin in a fortnight's time.
Any Valspar Notes will be added here next week.
1).Well done to Tyrrell Hatton, great win at Bay Hill which continued the run of non-American winners - Day, Leishman, McIlroy, Molinari, Hatton.
This was also an Open Championship qualifier and Keith Mitchell (for the second year running), Danny Lee and Dahmen get to battle the traffic at Royal St.George's in July.
2).For the second week running, the course set-up seemed to make scoring unnecessarily tricky given the prevailing weather conditions. A war of attrition, but not necessarily the most attractive golf for the TV viewer to enjoy.
Hopefully the set-up at TPC Sawgrass will enable the world's best to play their shots.
3).Scott Piercy made news for all the wrong reasons last week and now Tour Commish Monahan has expressed disappointment "in the lack of judgment used" and "that it has been addressed with Scott directly". Good thing Monahan didn't say "he knows better" because Piercy clearly doesn't. But his sponsors do, thankfully, tho' any Tour punishment will be kept unpublished - unless he starts missing tournaments, from which we might draw our own conclusions.
Personally, I'd like to have seen his "invitation" to Bay Hill revoked, but no such disapproval reported from the API.
4).Interesting graph from princedrac's twitter account this week showing the top ten owgr points-getters at The Players:
Four Americans: Woods, DLIII, Furyk, Couples
Three Aussies: Elk, Scott, Shark
Nick Price
Sergio & Langer
A good week, of which there haven't been many recently, will see Garcia can jump from 2nd to 1st, ahead of Tiger.
5).That's reflective of an international honours board with eight of the last twelve winners being "overseas" players.
And first-timers at TPC have a tough time too - after Jerry Pate won on the course's debut in 1982, only Hal Sutton and Craig Perks have won trophy on their first trip. Leading "rookie" last year was Eddie Pepperell who stormed home in 3rd place - but he's busy trying to figure out how you get dq'd three times in less than 2 years.
6).This week looks like the exact halfway point of the pre-Play-Off PGA Tour season, the 23rd event out of a total of 46. About 50 pros have already won enough FedEx Points to assure them a tee-time at the Northern Trust, Round 1 of the FedEx Cup Play-Offs.
Not many are Europeans: McIlroy, Hatton, Rahm, Hovland.
7).And only Fleetwood among other Europeans is comfortably placed, for now.
Those who have struggled this season so far, but are exempt at least through next year, include McDowell (79th), Casey (93rd), Lowry (140th), Molinari (168th), Donald (assuming he takes another earnings exemption - 172nd), Garcia (179th), Willett (181st), Stenson (197th), Wallace (202nd), Rose (205th),
While this lot, all not yet exempt for 2020/21 have it all to do: Straka (82nd), Norlander (84th), Knox (90th), Fitzpatrick (100th), Noren (107th), Rafa C-B (120th), Poulter (128th), Cappelen (130th), Laird (158th), Ventura (175th), Power (201st), Bjerregard (224th), Lewis (227th), plus 3 or 4 others on more tenuous status.
8).But one or two American "faces" are also struggling, with these three less than half-way to a Play-Off goal about 400 pts:
110th: Spieth
111th: D.Johnson
213th: Koepka
9).The Florida "Swing" has a musical chairs of dates next year, starting with Bay Hill, then The Players, followed by "Honda". No word yet on how Valspar fits in, but hopefully retains its fourth slot in Florida.
10).Finally, the Top 64 in the owgr's after The Players will qualify for the WGC-MatchPlay in Austin in a fortnight's time.
Any Valspar Notes will be added here next week.
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
They will be fussed when they can't get into WGC's and Majors and then the PGAT becomes an even more dominant closed shop.
McLaren- Posts : 17630
Join date : 2011-01-27
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
OWGR is gonna be massively screwed up (in some regards) due to this Covid-19 thing for probably up to 2 years. Best we just understand that and move forward. The was NO RIGHT ANSWER for everyone in unequally time restarts.
1) The TOP of the rankings aren't gonna be much of a problem... most the top players are PGAT members anyway and even those that aren't playing immediately will be soon, and often enough. OK... maybe a Fleetwood, Molinari or Adam Scott might lose some spots, but so what? They're not #1 contenders anyway, so it hardly matters. It's not like they're gonna miss out on any event they want to play.
2) The issues are gonna show up more at those big event qualification benchmarks of 50, 60, 100... But it's NOT an unequally time restart that's gonna cause most the issue... it's the way the ET schedule is being totally revamped. Bottom line is once they do restart, they're gonna have even more minimum or sub minimum fields than normal for quite a while. And that includes their bigger events later in the year, which are all but guaranteed to be generally weaker. That's gonna have a cascading effect on ET player rankings for years.
NEAR term FIX... All the majors have members on both the OWGR technical committee and Governing Board. They are well aware of the issue of an unequal restart and are supposedly pledged to mitigate that somewhat. If they do, that takes care of that (Masters field is already set as well). WGC qualies are yet to be discussed... but my guess is Memphis will bias more towards PGAT, but China is likely to more bias towards ET... so maybe it's a wash?
But MID term into next year... IMO ET spots in majors and big events are gonna be affected for WGC's and majors because of the ET schedule issues.
BUT... The OWGR has for decades biased towards the ET and the smaller tours via the Home Points and Inflated event minimums causing "over allocation of points" anyway. So in REAL terms... those biases will remain (and maybe even be stronger for the ET in the near/mid term). That will somewhat mitigate the rankings issues.
EDIT: PS... but the s**t is really gonna hit the fan in the next 3 weeks when everyone realizes all 3 of the first PGAT events in the restart are all in the 70-ish (or even 70+) range... that's gonna be a buttload of points given out..
1) The TOP of the rankings aren't gonna be much of a problem... most the top players are PGAT members anyway and even those that aren't playing immediately will be soon, and often enough. OK... maybe a Fleetwood, Molinari or Adam Scott might lose some spots, but so what? They're not #1 contenders anyway, so it hardly matters. It's not like they're gonna miss out on any event they want to play.
2) The issues are gonna show up more at those big event qualification benchmarks of 50, 60, 100... But it's NOT an unequally time restart that's gonna cause most the issue... it's the way the ET schedule is being totally revamped. Bottom line is once they do restart, they're gonna have even more minimum or sub minimum fields than normal for quite a while. And that includes their bigger events later in the year, which are all but guaranteed to be generally weaker. That's gonna have a cascading effect on ET player rankings for years.
NEAR term FIX... All the majors have members on both the OWGR technical committee and Governing Board. They are well aware of the issue of an unequal restart and are supposedly pledged to mitigate that somewhat. If they do, that takes care of that (Masters field is already set as well). WGC qualies are yet to be discussed... but my guess is Memphis will bias more towards PGAT, but China is likely to more bias towards ET... so maybe it's a wash?
But MID term into next year... IMO ET spots in majors and big events are gonna be affected for WGC's and majors because of the ET schedule issues.
BUT... The OWGR has for decades biased towards the ET and the smaller tours via the Home Points and Inflated event minimums causing "over allocation of points" anyway. So in REAL terms... those biases will remain (and maybe even be stronger for the ET in the near/mid term). That will somewhat mitigate the rankings issues.
EDIT: PS... but the s**t is really gonna hit the fan in the next 3 weeks when everyone realizes all 3 of the first PGAT events in the restart are all in the 70-ish (or even 70+) range... that's gonna be a buttload of points given out..
robopz- Posts : 3604
Join date : 2012-04-23
Location : Texas
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
At least a couple EuroT golfer (Matty Fitz, Mike Lorenzo-Vera) have tweeted their displeasure about the rankings
https://twitter.com/MattFitz94/status/1268212835387138050
https://twitter.com/MikeMlv/status/1268188133302075393
But as I have opined several times, the OWGR has always had an anti PGATour bias. the short and sweet explanation is all the subsidized events on the European Tour, The academic explanation is this paper
https://mba.tuck.dartmouth.edu/pages/faculty/richard.rendleman/docs/owgr_20130226a.pdf
https://twitter.com/MattFitz94/status/1268212835387138050
https://twitter.com/MikeMlv/status/1268188133302075393
But as I have opined several times, the OWGR has always had an anti PGATour bias. the short and sweet explanation is all the subsidized events on the European Tour, The academic explanation is this paper
https://mba.tuck.dartmouth.edu/pages/faculty/richard.rendleman/docs/owgr_20130226a.pdf
- Spoiler:
- And please, don't cite the tired Ryder Cup argument. this is a PGATour vs EuroTour argument, not America vs Europe argument. Most of the Euro Ryder Cup team are members of the PGATour and play more uncosanctioned PGATournaments than play uncosanctioned European Tour tournaments.
Last edited by GPB on Thu 04 Jun 2020, 7:17 pm; edited 1 time in total
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
robopz wrote:OWGR is gonna be massively screwed up (in some regards) due to this Covid-19 thing for probably up to 2 years. Best we just understand that and move forward. The was NO RIGHT ANSWER for everyone in unequally time restarts.
1) The TOP of the rankings aren't gonna be much of a problem... most the top players are PGAT members anyway and even those that aren't playing immediately will be soon, and often enough. OK... maybe a Fleetwood, Molinari or Adam Scott might lose some spots, but so what? They're not #1 contenders anyway, so it hardly matters. It's not like they're gonna miss out on any event they want to play.
2) The issues are gonna show up more at those big event qualification benchmarks of 50, 60, 100... But it's NOT an unequally time restart that's gonna cause most the issue... it's the way the ET schedule is being totally revamped. Bottom line is once they do restart, they're gonna have even more minimum or sub minimum fields than normal for quite a while. And that includes their bigger events later in the year, which are all but guaranteed to be generally weaker. That's gonna have a cascading effect on ET player rankings for years.
NEAR term FIX... All the majors have members on both the OWGR technical committee and Governing Board. They are well aware of the issue of an unequal restart and are supposedly pledged to mitigate that somewhat. If they do, that takes care of that (Masters field is already set as well). WGC qualies are yet to be discussed... but my guess is Memphis will bias more towards PGAT, but China is likely to more bias towards ET... so maybe it's a wash?
But MID term into next year... IMO ET spots in majors and big events are gonna be affected for WGC's and majors because of the ET schedule issues.
Don't agree with some of robo's preconceptions (or GPB's mantra for that matter) but overall agree with the conclusions and don't see it as necessarily being a bad thing.
Too many ET members gravitate to the PGA Tour before they're ready, often don't manage their schedules wisely, wake up at season's end without a card for the next year, slumped in the rankings and off back to Europe with tail between legs having lost a year, maybe more.
ET success is in their own hands, Admin, Sponsors, TV, Players - a setback now might be just the thing to re-set the future.
And they could certainly start, as said earlier, by reinforcing their fields "for their bigger events". Not suggesting blind altruism, but having a few of the ET's top players playing an extra event or two would help a lot.
Just wish there could be a bloodless coup with Pelley stampeding back to Calgary and someone like Bjorn taking the helm.
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Robo
I agree that the ET has had a favorable situation regarding the event minimums but what was never clear to me was, were the original seeds of the OWGR fair? Was the initial assumption that a PGAT player being better than a ET player sound.
From the moment of inception it was decided the PGAT was superior which then becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Now of course it is stronger but only because better OWGR means more top players and more money.
If in season one of the OWGR (or the McCormack thing) they had biased towards Europe and the top 10 was de facto ET players how different would things have turned out.
I appreciate this has nothing to do with the current situation it is just something I have always wondered about.
I agree that the ET has had a favorable situation regarding the event minimums but what was never clear to me was, were the original seeds of the OWGR fair? Was the initial assumption that a PGAT player being better than a ET player sound.
From the moment of inception it was decided the PGAT was superior which then becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Now of course it is stronger but only because better OWGR means more top players and more money.
If in season one of the OWGR (or the McCormack thing) they had biased towards Europe and the top 10 was de facto ET players how different would things have turned out.
I appreciate this has nothing to do with the current situation it is just something I have always wondered about.
McLaren- Posts : 17630
Join date : 2011-01-27
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Mac... with all due respect you got the origins of the rankings wrong. From DAY 1 it had incredibly strong biases towards smaller tours, even MUCH stronger than today.McLaren wrote:Robo
I agree that the ET has had a favorable situation regarding the event minimums but what was never clear to me was, were the original seeds of the OWGR fair? Was the initial assumption that a PGAT player being better than a ET player sound.
From the moment of inception it was decided the PGAT was superior which then becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Now of course it is stronger but only because better OWGR means more top players and more money.
If in season one of the OWGR (or the McCormack thing) they had biased towards Europe and the top 10 was de facto ET players how different would things have turned out.
I appreciate this has nothing to do with the current situation it is just something I have always wondered about.
IMO the problem with the rankings today is that they EVOLVED from a simple system they could do on the back of an envelope or a simple adding machine. It was simple compilations. Plus the initial calculations were based on many false assumptions on "assumed" overall strength of various tours. Then as they became "official" world rankings, WAAAY more politics and territory protecting came into play. And as time has gone along, they added "fixes" that had the unintended consequences of convoluting them more.
IMO the REAL fix is an entirely new system based on REAL results, irrespective of any Tour on which events are played. We have the computing power on any laptop to compile and process all the data world wide we would ever need.. in which probably 99% of the politics and "turf protecting" can be removed. AND we have enough of the worlds better players getting access to the same common premium events now... we can extrapolate REAL strengths of tours in comparison to each other. There's always some subjectivity in setting any formula (like how much bonus should a major get due to it's prestige and how much should a 2nd or 3rd be worth compared to a win)... but once those formulas are set... they apply the SAME to everyone without regard to protecting some tour's "turf".
robopz- Posts : 3604
Join date : 2012-04-23
Location : Texas
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
robopz wrote:Mac... with all due respect you got the origins of the rankings wrong. From DAY 1 it had incredibly strong biases towards smaller tours, even MUCH stronger than today.McLaren wrote:Robo
I agree that the ET has had a favorable situation regarding the event minimums but what was never clear to me was, were the original seeds of the OWGR fair? Was the initial assumption that a PGAT player being better than a ET player sound.
From the moment of inception it was decided the PGAT was superior which then becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Now of course it is stronger but only because better OWGR means more top players and more money.
If in season one of the OWGR (or the McCormack thing) they had biased towards Europe and the top 10 was de facto ET players how different would things have turned out.
I appreciate this has nothing to do with the current situation it is just something I have always wondered about.
IMO the problem with the rankings today is that they EVOLVED from a simple system they could do on the back of an envelope or a simple adding machine. It was simple compilations. Plus the initial calculations were based on many false assumptions on "assumed" overall strength of various tours. Then as they became "official" world rankings, WAAAY more politics and territory protecting came into play. And as time has gone along, they added "fixes" that had the unintended consequences of convoluting them more.
IMO the REAL fix is an entirely new system based on REAL results, irrespective of any Tour on which events are played. We have the computing power on any laptop to compile and process all the data world wide we would ever need.. in which probably 99% of the politics and "turf protecting" can be removed. AND we have enough of the worlds better players getting access to the same common premium events now... we can extrapolate REAL strengths of tours in comparison to each other. There's always some subjectivity in setting any formula (like how much bonus should a major get due to it's prestige and how much should a 2nd or 3rd be worth compared to a win)... but once those formulas are set... they apply the SAME to everyone without regard to protecting some tour's "turf".
Forgive GPB & robo for conveniently forgetting all those PGA Tour events which are subsidised by non-American golfers, especially at times European Tour members.
There are certainly some situations where an ET event has a winner's point haul that is too high, but I seriously doubt it makes a wildly significant difference these days.
I reckon if robo's suggestion had its way the PGA Tour would circle the wagons and subliminally (to give the PAC the benefit of the doubt) change the qualification system to make it even harder for overseas golfers to secure membership. MAGA
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Kwini... that's EXACTLY where all these discussions get off track. You're trying to make it an AMERICAN thing, but it's not... it's a TOUR thing.kwinigolfer wrote:Forgive GPB & robo for conveniently forgetting all those PGA Tour events which are subsidised by non-American golfers, especially at times European Tour members.
There are certainly some situations where an ET event has a winner's point haul that is too high, but I seriously doubt it makes a wildly significant difference these days.
I reckon if robo's suggestion had its way the PGA Tour would circle the wagons and subliminally (to give the PAC the benefit of the doubt) change the qualification system to make it even harder for overseas golfers to secure membership. MAGA
The strength of the PGA Tour is NOT just American's... it's because it attracts most of the best of WORLD to play on it as well. PGAT is NOT strong just because of Brooks and DJ and Tiger et al... it's strong because it's also got Rory & Rahm & Scott & Rose & Fleetwood & Molinari... etc. playing here as well (most of them more here than there). Meanwhile... you have very few of the top American's playing even the minimum on the ET or anywhere else.
IMO if all the non-American worlds best congregated on some other than the PGA Tour, then IT would be at least the equal to the PGA Tour, maybe even better But that's simply not the case. If you would get it out of your mind that this is some "American thing" (with me at least), we might be able to have some good conversation.
And I also believe you are wrong that these "subsidies" don't make much difference... It's not that the subsidy for any one event does it, it's that a bunch of them do with a little drip here... and then another drip there... and before you know it, the compounding effect of all can fill up a bathtub. I DON'T think it has much effect at the very top of the rankings. Rory and Rahm have earned their #1-2 because their rankings are NOT based on those subsides.
But where you see the effect is with the 4-8 spots being propped up into those #50-60 rankings that qualify for Majors and other top events in any given year. It's even more at the #100 level for the PGA... And it's not just ET players... it's Japan Tour players as well into the top-50...
robopz- Posts : 3604
Join date : 2012-04-23
Location : Texas
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
>>>> NERD ALERT <<<<
Robo:
IMO, Home Tour subsidies benefits the PGATour more than ANY other tour and it mitigates the Minimum Tour subsidies of the other.
By my research:
In 2019, 17 EuroTour events (Not co-sanctioned with PGATour, but co-sanctioned with other tours) were bumped 63 OWGR levels by Home Tour subsidies
In 2019, 29 PGATour events (Not co-sanctioned with EuroTour) were bumped 74 OWGR levels by the Home Tour Subsidy.
On the other semi major tours (ASA, AFR, AUS, JPN, SUN, KFT, CHA), the Home Tour subsidy seldom impacts the OWGR rating)
Robo:
IMO, Home Tour subsidies benefits the PGATour more than ANY other tour and it mitigates the Minimum Tour subsidies of the other.
By my research:
In 2019, 17 EuroTour events (Not co-sanctioned with PGATour, but co-sanctioned with other tours) were bumped 63 OWGR levels by Home Tour subsidies
In 2019, 29 PGATour events (Not co-sanctioned with EuroTour) were bumped 74 OWGR levels by the Home Tour Subsidy.
On the other semi major tours (ASA, AFR, AUS, JPN, SUN, KFT, CHA), the Home Tour subsidy seldom impacts the OWGR rating)
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Kwini... that's EXACTLY where all these discussions get off track. You're trying to make it an AMERICAN thing, but it's not... it's a TOUR thing.
Exactly. That is what I said in post above (in the spoiler box)
Its not America vs Europe. Its PGATour vs European Tour.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
kwinigolfer wrote:
Forgive GPB & robo for conveniently forgetting all those PGA Tour events which are subsidised by non-American golfers, especially at times European Tour members.
Do you honestly think Robo and I forgot that? If so, you ought to get on twitter because you would fit in with all the bat sh!t crazy wackos who take everything out of context blame everything on whatever scapegoat of their choice.
I even said in my post above
Most of the Euro Ryder Cup team are members of the PGATour and play more uncosanctioned PGATournaments than play uncosanctioned European Tour tournaments.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Happy to agree to differ on much of the above.
And easy for PGA Tour-orientation to say "the strength of the PGA Tour is not just Americans" - you want your cake and to eat it too (a phrase I've always thought a bit nonsensical).
Following that argument, you'd re-regulate all the points those International players earned on non-PGA Tour tours and say, "Look, those are subsidised so they don't count".
"Sorry Keith Mitchell, that Honda win is only worth 32 points not the 40 or 50, whatever it was", and he'd likely be royally p1ssed off. And rightly so.
Swings and roundabouts and I doubt it'll ever be much fairer and more equitable than it is. And I completely accept the owgr had no realistic option but to restart its engines next Thursday.
And that's without hypothesising what the PGA Tour would say if the Aussies said, look I know it's winter, but our courses are in pretty good nick, we can create a bubble and some tournaments, come on down.
PGA Tour players would be frothing at the mouth if they thought others were getting off to an earlier owgr start.
And easy for PGA Tour-orientation to say "the strength of the PGA Tour is not just Americans" - you want your cake and to eat it too (a phrase I've always thought a bit nonsensical).
Following that argument, you'd re-regulate all the points those International players earned on non-PGA Tour tours and say, "Look, those are subsidised so they don't count".
"Sorry Keith Mitchell, that Honda win is only worth 32 points not the 40 or 50, whatever it was", and he'd likely be royally p1ssed off. And rightly so.
Swings and roundabouts and I doubt it'll ever be much fairer and more equitable than it is. And I completely accept the owgr had no realistic option but to restart its engines next Thursday.
And that's without hypothesising what the PGA Tour would say if the Aussies said, look I know it's winter, but our courses are in pretty good nick, we can create a bubble and some tournaments, come on down.
PGA Tour players would be frothing at the mouth if they thought others were getting off to an earlier owgr start.
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
And easy for PGA Tour-orientation to say "the strength of the PGA Tour is not just Americans"
Easy to say, because it is true.
We realize that the best international players play more on the PGATour than their home tour.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
GPB wrote:And easy for PGA Tour-orientation to say "the strength of the PGA Tour is not just Americans"
Easy to say, because it is true.
We realize that the best international players play more on the PGATour than their home tour.
You have an uncanny knack of picking part of a sentence apart without bothering to try and understand the context - all I'm saying is that those very same International players bring to every Tour event their Home Tour points which are claimed to be unfairly subsidised. Perhaps they should check them at the door?
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
kwinigolfer wrote:
You have an uncanny knack of picking part of a sentence apart without bothering to try and understand the context -
well aint the pot calling the kettle black.
kwinigolfer wrote: all I'm saying is that those very same International players bring to every Tour event their Home Tour points which are claimed to be unfairly subsidised. Perhaps they should check them at the door?
Do you think those points only have a one way ticket to the PGATour. FWIW, a couple of hours ago, I just gave a detailed reason to Robo why I think Home Tour Points are more beneficial to the PGATour than any other tour. Did you read that?
I think you are talking about the Subsidized Minimums (which is different than HT). The 24 point minimum that all non-co-santioned EuroTour gets. Like the 2019 Magical Kenyan Open gets 24 points, when it has an OWGR rating of 17 EVR when a 24 pt event require 91 EVR. And the BMW PGA which typically gets rated in the low 50's yet gets an OWGR subsidized rating of 64.
Yes some of the PGATour gets subsidies. Puerto Rico, Reno, Punta Cana, Barbasol, and Players, but nearly as many.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
It's not the pot calling the kettle black, it's just me disagreeing with you as I believe it's a two-way street.
As for "Kenya", I completely agree with you, ridiculous - but I've always advocated for those to be reduced, no argument there. Should really be a Challenge Tour event which ET Members may enter.
As for "Kenya", I completely agree with you, ridiculous - but I've always advocated for those to be reduced, no argument there. Should really be a Challenge Tour event which ET Members may enter.
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Good point on the Home point subsidies GPB. If the home points aren't pushing an event above the minimum anyway, then they are not a factor. The minimum floor is.
robopz- Posts : 3604
Join date : 2012-04-23
Location : Texas
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Kwini... Totally lost me on the "have your cake and eat it too" comment. Deane Beman figured out long ago (with a little help from a kick in the nads from Seve), PGA tour needed to attract the world's best, not just be an American tour. And it's been growing with it's international players ever since, and it's way better & stronger because of it. We get that over here. We embrace it.
But that's getting far afield of the topic. There was no "fair to everyone" restart point for the OWGR, so I think we agree now is as good a time as any. And certainly PGA Tour will have an advantage because of that for a short time. But ET and other world tours have enjoyed biases in the OWGR for decades, so I don't care.
But that's getting far afield of the topic. There was no "fair to everyone" restart point for the OWGR, so I think we agree now is as good a time as any. And certainly PGA Tour will have an advantage because of that for a short time. But ET and other world tours have enjoyed biases in the OWGR for decades, so I don't care.
robopz- Posts : 3604
Join date : 2012-04-23
Location : Texas
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
robo,
Don't think we disagree on that much of this.
But my point was that ET players come over to the PGA Tour with, what you'd consider to be, an inflated owgr rating, yet that same rating benefits the PGA Tour Members.
Not quite sure where you get "totally lost" on this.
Don't think we disagree on that much of this.
But my point was that ET players come over to the PGA Tour with, what you'd consider to be, an inflated owgr rating, yet that same rating benefits the PGA Tour Members.
Not quite sure where you get "totally lost" on this.
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
In general, I DO believe a lot of ET players initially come over to the PGAT with inflated OWGR rankings. But those that are don't last long enough here to "inflate" PGAT field strengths much. And most of those that stay here play most of their events here, and when they play on the ET its in more of the premium events... so it equals out pretty quick.kwinigolfer wrote:robo,
Don't think we disagree on that much of this.
But my point was that ET players come over to the PGA Tour with, what you'd consider to be, an inflated owgr rating, yet that same rating benefits the PGA Tour Members.
Not quite sure where you get "totally lost" on this.
You and I have discussed this before... but it's getting soooo much harder to do what Fleetwood does... play a lot both here and at home. It takes a real ironman schedule to do it, and with all the travel involved, it's just too much for most. I think that's why most who dual tour here know they're probably committing most their play here and playing nearer the minimum at home. Tough choice to make unless they relocate their family or something.
robopz- Posts : 3604
Join date : 2012-04-23
Location : Texas
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
robopz wrote:kwinigolfer wrote:robo,
Don't think we disagree on that much of this.
But my point was that ET players come over to the PGA Tour with, what you'd consider to be, an inflated owgr rating, yet that same rating benefits the PGA Tour Members.
Not quite sure where you get "totally lost" on this.
You and I have discussed this before... but it's getting soooo much harder to do what Fleetwood does... play a lot both here and at home. It takes a real ironman schedule to do it, and with all the travel involved, it's just too much for most. I think that's why most who dual tour here know they're probably committing most their play here and playing nearer the minimum at home. Tough choice to make unless they relocate their family or something.
Not only is it "getting soooo much harder to do what Fleetwood does", there's no real evidence that it pays dividends for Tommy. I think perhaps a player may dedicate a year to playing heavy schedules on both Tours but they'll soon burn out, as Franny Molinari seems to have done. But I think there's still room for a Jon Rahm-type schedule and hope the top Europeans are brought to the table to discuss upcoming schedules if and when some sense of normality reappears for 2021 and 2022.
And burn-out especially likely if every week was played in mid-90 degree (or higher) sun and heat as seems to be on the menu for Colonial, Cristobal be damned (though imagine you might see a glancing blow or more)? Imagine Harbour Town will be toasty also.
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Wouldn't it be nice if the Tour published next week's runners & riders early, just to whet our appetite?
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Spectators at the Memorial
I'm never wrong- Posts : 2949
Join date : 2011-05-26
Location : Just up the road, and turn right at the lights.
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
kwinigolfer wrote:Wouldn't it be nice if the Tour published next week's runners & riders early, just to whet our appetite?
Here you go
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EZx2Y5NXQAA3ysK?format=jpg
Prince Dracula apparently has the inside track to viewing the field. Apparently Snedeker WD sometime yesterday or this morning. One of his followers speculated that Snedeker might have CV19.
Bo Hoag looks like he is the first man out. Not sure where he stands on the reshuffle list as I can't find the link.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Featured pairings this week
Rahm-Rory-Brooks
Fowler-Thomas-Spieth
Mickelson-Na-Woodland
Reed-DJohnson-Rose
Rahm-Rory-Brooks
Fowler-Thomas-Spieth
Mickelson-Na-Woodland
Reed-DJohnson-Rose
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Strange they don't include the most recent Major Champion in those groupings . . . . . . . . they missed the boat there.
GPB, I'm thinking Cristobal is sliding just East of you . . . . . . ?
GPB, I'm thinking Cristobal is sliding just East of you . . . . . . ?
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Path is projected just West of Chez GPB.
Lowry is not going to get into many featured groupings on PGATour.
Lowry is not going to get into many featured groupings on PGATour.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
GPB wrote:Path is projected just West of Chez GPB.
Lowry is not going to get into many featured groupings on PGATour.
Why not?
That's ridiculous. Very discriminatory.
But bl00dy typical.
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
kwinigolfer wrote:GPB wrote:Path is projected just West of Chez GPB.
Lowry is not going to get into many featured groupings on PGATour.
Why not?
That's ridiculous. Very discriminatory.
But bl00dy typical.
Maybe you should start protesting, rioting and looting
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
No GPB,
I'll leave that to the US, you're pretty good at it.
Why ever wouldn't the Tour respect a Major winner, or are thery taking the next step in trying to diminish the status of Majors in favour of, what?, the Phoenix Open? (Sorry Rickie)
I'll leave that to the US, you're pretty good at it.
Why ever wouldn't the Tour respect a Major winner, or are thery taking the next step in trying to diminish the status of Majors in favour of, what?, the Phoenix Open? (Sorry Rickie)
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
What is it about popularity that you don't understand?
Lowry is not a popular player and he has done very little to support the PGATour. He is the one that decided to not exploit his major championship win by WDing at the 11th from WGC FEDEX last summer. (Brown Bottle Flu).
IMO, he would have most certainly been in a featured pairing in Memphis.
You reap what you sow.
Lowry is not a popular player and he has done very little to support the PGATour. He is the one that decided to not exploit his major championship win by WDing at the 11th from WGC FEDEX last summer. (Brown Bottle Flu).
IMO, he would have most certainly been in a featured pairing in Memphis.
You reap what you sow.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
GPB wrote:What is it about popularity that you don't understand?
Lowry is not a popular player and he has done very little to support the PGATour. He is the one that decided to not exploit his major championship win by WDing at the 11th from WGC FEDEX last summer. (Brown Bottle Flu).
IMO, he would have most certainly been in a featured pairing in Memphis.
You reap what you sow.
Against which, you could say that almost none of the PGA Tour's Americans have done anything to support the ET yet they receive tee-times and media attention regardless.
If I was Shane and got dissed like this I'd be w/d'ing as well.
A Koepka / Woodland / Lowry grouping would have been far more appropriate, all things considered.
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
OHHHHHHHHHH!
You're making this a Europe vs America thing.
Surprise Surprise Surprise.
The object is of the featured pairings is to make money!
Shane Lowry is not going to make many rush out and subscribe to PGATour live.
You're making this a Europe vs America thing.
Surprise Surprise Surprise.
The object is of the featured pairings is to make money!
Shane Lowry is not going to make many rush out and subscribe to PGATour live.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
GPB wrote:OHHHHHHHHHH!
You're making this a Europe vs America thing.
Surprise Surprise Surprise.
The object is of the featured pairings is to make money!
Shane Lowry is not going to make many rush out and subscribe to PGATour live.
Whereas Patrick Reed will? Just to see if he's pulling another fast one??
GPB,
The Tour disses all but the most (theoretically) mediagenic overseas golfers all the time - no-one should be surprised that the most recent Major winner is ignored just because he's from "abroad".
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Mediagenic ? WTH does that mean.
FWIW, Reed has won a tournament in the last 4 events and a top 10 golfer.
Other than a very weak Hong Kong Open, Lowry has not been relevant in any event in 11 months let alone a PGATournament.
Webb Simpson is a Top 10 player, and he is not in the featured groupings either. I just don't see why you are so butthurt about this alleged snubbing. It just appears that you want to get offended by something.
Q-Score is very important, and Lowry doesn't have it here. Rory, Rahm, and to a marginal degree, Rose, have some Q-Rating. And that is why they are in the featured groupings.
FWIW, Reed has won a tournament in the last 4 events and a top 10 golfer.
Other than a very weak Hong Kong Open, Lowry has not been relevant in any event in 11 months let alone a PGATournament.
Webb Simpson is a Top 10 player, and he is not in the featured groupings either. I just don't see why you are so butthurt about this alleged snubbing. It just appears that you want to get offended by something.
Q-Score is very important, and Lowry doesn't have it here. Rory, Rahm, and to a marginal degree, Rose, have some Q-Rating. And that is why they are in the featured groupings.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
. . . . . . . . . .
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Shane WAS the "Champion Golfer of the Year" after all, an Englishman (or was it a Scot?) in a blue jacket said so. There you have it and that should but him in the feature groups henceforth. Harupmh, harumph.
But that was 2019 ...
Shotrock- Posts : 3924
Join date : 2011-05-10
Location : Philadelphia
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Shane should get some slack. He’s both fat and Irish so he could pass for an American.
pedro- Posts : 7353
Join date : 2011-01-27
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
No, his ruddy complexion and ill-fitting clothes make him all English, I mean GB and I.
Shotrock- Posts : 3924
Join date : 2011-05-10
Location : Philadelphia
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Sr,
Did you know that pro who was so tragically killed last week?
Did you know that pro who was so tragically killed last week?
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
I do Kwin ... he worked at AGC a number of years ago. Really tragic.
I also found out that he was bringing back some carts to a cart barn when the weather turned extremely nasty. A massive tree came down onto the building as he was putting carts away. They found him 3 hours after the storm and one can hope he did not suffer long at all. He and his mate are due to have their first child this week and he also lost a brother a number of years ago in a motorcycle accident.
I also found out that he was bringing back some carts to a cart barn when the weather turned extremely nasty. A massive tree came down onto the building as he was putting carts away. They found him 3 hours after the storm and one can hope he did not suffer long at all. He and his mate are due to have their first child this week and he also lost a brother a number of years ago in a motorcycle accident.
Shotrock- Posts : 3924
Join date : 2011-05-10
Location : Philadelphia
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
I didn't realize the PGA Tour Media Guide was online as a PDF file.
https://www.pgatourmediaguide.com/
https://www.pgatourmediaguide.com/
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
There you go: Shane Lowry, Champ & Herman.
Way to go PGA Tour: Discrimination alive and well. Surprised he didn't get Keith Clearwater & JJ Henry . . . . . . .
Way to go PGA Tour: Discrimination alive and well. Surprised he didn't get Keith Clearwater & JJ Henry . . . . . . .
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
I might of mentioned this before, but didn't I predict double dipping was going to become almost impossible quite a few years ago now?
Some people on here still feel hostile towards me for saying it.
Not that it bothered me.
Some people on here still feel hostile towards me for saying it.
Not that it bothered me.
McLaren- Posts : 17630
Join date : 2011-01-27
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
McLaren wrote:I might of mentioned this before, but didn't I predict double dipping was going to become almost impossible quite a few years ago now?
Some people on here still feel hostile towards me for saying it.
Not that it bothered me.
That was before the Tour gerrymandered its schedule!
This year will be especially difficult, but it's still possible. But only for those playing well - strugglers face a long road ahead.
Who's hostile? Not towards you Mac, surely??!!
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
hmm, no Thanks GPB for the link to the media guide.
And FWIW, Like Lowry, Herman and Champ have won on the PGATour within the last year.
At least they didn't do the USGA thing and pair Lowry with Colt Knost and Kevin Stadler.
Got a tip for you Kwini. Soak those Knickers in Soapy water. They will be easier to unknot.
And FWIW, Like Lowry, Herman and Champ have won on the PGATour within the last year.
At least they didn't do the USGA thing and pair Lowry with Colt Knost and Kevin Stadler.
Got a tip for you Kwini. Soak those Knickers in Soapy water. They will be easier to unknot.
Last edited by GPB on Tue 09 Jun 2020, 11:34 pm; edited 1 time in total
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Kevin Na has played 408 events in his PGATour Career
He is 36 yrs old.
For some perspective, Dustin Johnson is 35 yrs old he has played 264 events.
He is 36 yrs old.
For some perspective, Dustin Johnson is 35 yrs old he has played 264 events.
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
[quote="GPB"]hmm, no Thanks GPB for the link to the media guide.
And FWIW, Like Lowry, Herman and Champ have won on the PGATour within the last year.
At least they didn't do the USGA thing and pair Lowry with Colt Knost and Kevin Stadler.
Got a tip for you Kwini. Soak those Knickers in Soapy water. They will be easier to unknot.[/quo
GPB,
Forwhatever it's worth, you never make a post without me concluding that you must be a total cucking funt.
Goodbye
And FWIW, Like Lowry, Herman and Champ have won on the PGATour within the last year.
At least they didn't do the USGA thing and pair Lowry with Colt Knost and Kevin Stadler.
Got a tip for you Kwini. Soak those Knickers in Soapy water. They will be easier to unknot.[/quo
GPB,
Forwhatever it's worth, you never make a post without me concluding that you must be a total cucking funt.
Goodbye
kwinigolfer- Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Never? Exaggerate much?
Just trying to give you helpful hint.
You took this Shane Lowry thingy way over the top. Sorry that you cannot face the fact that Lowry is not very popular here. I like him, but I am also pragmatic about him. He is not going to bring any extra eyeballs to the the telecast.
Its absurd to think he is entitled to be in the featured groups.
Why can't you see that?
Just trying to give you helpful hint.
You took this Shane Lowry thingy way over the top. Sorry that you cannot face the fact that Lowry is not very popular here. I like him, but I am also pragmatic about him. He is not going to bring any extra eyeballs to the the telecast.
Its absurd to think he is entitled to be in the featured groups.
Why can't you see that?
GPB- Posts : 7283
Join date : 2012-02-10
Location : Midwest, USA
Re: PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
Questions for the upcoming weekend:
1 - Will the play be faster? (I'm guessing marginally so given the need to not react to or work around the crowds.)
2 - Will players mistakenly "high five"? (I would bet on it.)
3 - Will the TV ratings be strong? (Very strong I'm thinking since so many other major sports are on hold and even marginal golf fans will want some live play.)
4 - Who will surprise? (I'm hearing lots about Jordan Spieth getting out of his slump, but I would be surprised if he did. Just a hunch.)
5 - Who will win? (Rahm would be my guess.)
1 - Will the play be faster? (I'm guessing marginally so given the need to not react to or work around the crowds.)
2 - Will players mistakenly "high five"? (I would bet on it.)
3 - Will the TV ratings be strong? (Very strong I'm thinking since so many other major sports are on hold and even marginal golf fans will want some live play.)
4 - Who will surprise? (I'm hearing lots about Jordan Spieth getting out of his slump, but I would be surprised if he did. Just a hunch.)
5 - Who will win? (Rahm would be my guess.)
Last edited by Shotrock on Wed 10 Jun 2020, 2:15 pm; edited 1 time in total
Shotrock- Posts : 3924
Join date : 2011-05-10
Location : Philadelphia
Page 16 of 20 • 1 ... 9 ... 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20
Similar topics
» PGA Tour: The Players: Notes from the Ballwasher
» PGA Tour: THE PLAYERS Championship: Notes from the Ballwasher
» PGA Tour: The Players Championship: Notes from the Ballwasher
» PGA Tour: The Players Championship: Notes from the Ballwasher
» PGA Tour: The Players. Fifth Major? No! But Who Cares?: Notes from the Ballwasher
» PGA Tour: THE PLAYERS Championship: Notes from the Ballwasher
» PGA Tour: The Players Championship: Notes from the Ballwasher
» PGA Tour: The Players Championship: Notes from the Ballwasher
» PGA Tour: The Players. Fifth Major? No! But Who Cares?: Notes from the Ballwasher
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Golf
Page 16 of 20
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum