Footballer or Footballer - this or that type

by hbk48942 Thu 29 Aug - 21:09

First topic message reminder :

I will start with

Darren Bent or Jermain Defoe?

you pick between them and suggest the next two

by Guest Mon 16 Sep - 19:46

Benteke. Technically superior & better finisher at this point in time, hence why Mourinho wants Romelu to develop even more and improve his game.

Michel Salgado or Lillian Thuram?

by Nakatomi Plaza Mon 16 Sep - 22:24

Thuram, in the top 3 Right backs of the last 20 years for me.

Paolo Maldini or Franco Baresi

by Guest Mon 16 Sep - 22:35

Maldini. Baresi was an outstanding centre back but Maldini is one of the best defenders ever to lace up a pair of boots.

Ronaldinho or Rivaldo?

by **Crimey** Mon 16 Sep - 23:50

Ronaldinho

Probably the best footballer to watch in my lifetime.

Luis Suarez or Edison Cavani?

by FIFA Diva Mon 16 Sep - 23:52

Ronaldinho, a pioneer changed Football for the better did things that you couldn't imagine. Made Football what it's all about having fun.

Van Den Sar or Schmeichel?

by Duty281 Mon 16 Sep - 23:57

Schmeichel. One of the three greatest keepers of all time without a doubt.

Paolo Maldini or Roberto Carlos?

by cherriesfna Tue 17 Sep - 0:32

Maldini

Steve Fletcher or Pele

by Guest Tue 17 Sep - 10:30

Pele

Jean-Alain Boumsong or Titus Bramble? I want there key strengths listed please in determining your decision.

by MIG Tue 17 Sep - 11:19

Jean-Alain Boumsong just about edges is. I would say they are on a par on the pitch but Bramble loses out due to being a bit rapey.

Kieron Dyer or Darren Anderton. Who's the best at getting injured?

by **Crimey** Tue 17 Sep - 15:39

Kieron Dyer

Samuel Eto'o or Didier Drogba (now not in prime)?

by Guest Tue 17 Sep - 17:41

Drogba. Chelsea's best ever signing for me. Real big game player.

Peter Shilton or David Seaman?

by Guest Wed 18 Sep - 10:08

Shilton is my choice. He would never get lobbed by a curly haired, big toothed Brazilian from the edge of the box.

Pavel Nedved or Gaizka Mendieta?

by **Kenny** Wed 18 Sep - 12:25

Pavel Nedved

John Wark or Graeme Souness ?

by Guest Wed 18 Sep - 17:40

Souness although Wark was awesome in Escape to Victory.

Vinnie Jones or Terry Hurlock? Very Happy

by Guest Wed 18 Sep - 19:29

Vinnie Jones. Hurlock's hairdo was shocking, just like Puyol's at Barca.

Paulo Wanchope or Tore Andre Flo? Laugh

by Guest Wed 18 Sep - 19:50

Flo. Only thing I can remember Wanchope doing was scoring that solo goal at Old Trafford for Derby.

David Ginola or Hatem Ben Arfa?

by **VDT** Wed 18 Sep - 21:59

Ginola - Pure Class

Michu or Tim Cahill

by FIFA Diva Wed 18 Sep - 22:15

Tim Cahill maybe not as classy or nice to watch as Michu but what a battler only 5'10 but knows how to jump.

Xavi or Pirlo?

by **Kenny** Wed 18 Sep - 22:50

Andrea Pirlo although i didn't like him in Harry Potter as Professor Snape

Ritchie Humphreys or Mark Robins ?

by Guest Thu 19 Sep - 6:55

Well there is this notion that Robins saved Fergies bacon in 1990 so humphreys for me!

Lee Dixon or Nigel Winterburn?

by MIG Thu 19 Sep - 12:42

Nigel Winterburn for me. Dixon had a few donkey moments and was probably the least reliable in a very solid back 4. I like Dixon as a pundit though.

Dean Saunders or Dalien Atkinson?

by **Kenny** Thu 19 Sep - 16:43

Dean Saunders better allround player , plus Dalien was a real nob in real life ( i worked in a sports shop around the time he was playing and him and his mates walked in messed around with all the stock then started saying do you know who i am and saying he could buy the whole shop if he wanted to .

Steve Lomas or Neil Lennon ?

by Nakatomi Plaza Thu 19 Sep - 16:47

Lennon, Lomas was bang average.

Alan Smith (ex Arsenal, Leicester and England), or Alan Smith (ex Leeds, Man Utd and England)

by Guest Thu 19 Sep - 16:49

Arsenal's Smithy. A real handful on his day.

Alan Thompson or Steve Guppy?

by **VDT** Thu 19 Sep - 16:50

Alan Thompson

Tim Sherwood or David Batty

by **Kenny** Thu 19 Sep - 16:55

David Batty , always like his commitment plus anyone who wants to smack Graeme Saux gets my vote

Neville Southall or Peter Schmiechel ?

by **Hero** Thu 19 Sep - 17:41

Schmeichel

Bakkali or Fischer?

by **VDT** Fri 20 Sep - 13:33

Bakkali looks like he be amazing in the future

Cole & Yorke or Sheringham & Solskjær

by Holymiky Fri 20 Sep - 14:08

Cole & Yorke - Sheringham & Solskjær are great too.

David Seaman or Joe Hart?

by Nakatomi Plaza Fri 20 Sep - 16:27

Seaman edges it, because of longevity.

Nwankwo Kanu or Yakubu Aiyegbeni

by **VDT** Fri 20 Sep - 16:31

Yakubu - The Yak will score, Kanu will somehow hit over the bar from half a yard out!

Duncan Ferguson or Ricky Lambert

by FIFA Diva Fri 20 Sep - 16:44

Duncan Ferguson proper old school CF.

Cafu or Carlos?

by Guest Fri 20 Sep - 17:35

Cafu. Steady and reliable. Roberto Carlos hit a few good free kicks and fluffed a few hundred more.

Steve Bull or Shaun Goater?

by Fernando Fri 20 Sep - 19:03

Steve Bull

Paolo Di Canio or Mario Balotelli - Battle of nutcases

by **Hero** Fri 20 Sep - 19:11

Balotelli, whilst Di Canio was a cult hero for most of the clubs he played for and scored some quality goals he never really took it to the top level, Balotelli has already done it at the top level.

Reus or Muller?

by Nakatomi Plaza Fri 20 Sep - 20:04

Reus,

Muller more effective at the minute, but I think Reus could end up being the best of a fine line of German attacking midfielders.

Paul McGrath or Ledley King?

by **Kenny** Sat 21 Sep - 12:45

Ledley King , could of been one of the best centre halfs in the world but for injury

Alan Hansen or Gary Pallister ?

by Guest Sat 21 Sep - 12:59

Hansen all day long.

Craig Johnson or Harry Kewell?

by **Kenny** Sat 21 Sep - 13:22

Craig Johnson wasn't the best but seemed to get himself in the right place more often then not , Kewell had all the skill but not the attitude to fullfil it

Lee Dixon or Kenny Samson ?

by Guest Sat 21 Sep - 15:33

Samson for me. Dixon was part of an outstanding defensive unit whereas Samson was a better individual, so to speak.

Matt le Tissier or Stan Bowles?

by **Kenny** Sat 21 Sep - 16:03

le Tiss , saw him play live a few times and he had such awareness and time on the ball though i was a bit disappointed he never went to a top side .

Frank McAvenie or Charlie Nicholas ?

by Nakatomi Plaza Sun 22 Sep - 18:54

Champagne Charlie, mainly because he scored twice in the first cup final I ever saw.

Juan Mata or Oscar?

by **Kenny** Sun 22 Sep - 23:37

Juan Mata , but i am not the manager of Chelsea

George Weah or Fillipo Inzaghi ?

by MIG Mon 23 Sep - 10:50

Filipo Inzghi. Great goal record.

Barkley or Wilshere?

by Guest Mon 23 Sep - 11:25

Jack Wilshere, because he is better than Paul Scholes.

Fabio Cannavaro or Laurent Blanc?

by FIFA Diva Mon 23 Sep - 11:39

Cannavaro, he made defending an art again. Loved the fact he was a small man but could deal with anyone because of his intelligence.

Lahm or Cole?

by Guest Mon 23 Sep - 11:58

Lahm. Better going forward, and can play both FB positions.

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer or Andy Cole?

by Il Gialloblu Mon 23 Sep - 12:50

Surprised myself a little maybe after thinking about it, but Andy Cole. More ridiculed, but just seemed to achieve more. In a one off game? I might prefer to have OGS, but I think Cole had the better career.

Denis Bergkamp or Davor Suker?

by Guest Mon 23 Sep - 13:23

Bergkamp. Suker was a fine player - that goal against Denmark will live long in the memory - but Bergkamp was capable of such sublime skill that no-one else could ever dream of. That goal against Newcastle, the one against Argentina, the one against Leicester. Just three of dozens of out-of-this-world goals. Not to mention the impact he had for Arsenal. A true legend of the game.

Patrick Kluivert or Ruud van Nistelrooy?

by Nakatomi Plaza Mon 23 Sep - 17:30

Van Nistelrooy

Kluivert was more talented, but I tend to think he wasted a lot of his ability. Van Nistelrooy was an absolute predator, and did really well to come back from a serious knee injury to be such a great goalscorer in England, Spain and Germany.

Dion Dublin or Les Ferdinand?

by Sponsored content