Footballer or Footballer - this or that type

First topic message reminder :

I will start with

Darren Bent or Jermain Defoe?

you pick between them and suggest the next two

Roy Makaay knew his way to goal

Shay Given or Nigel Martin ?

Shay Given

Falcao or Cavani?

It's a close one to call but I personally prefer Falcao.

Lucas Moura or Bernard?

Lucas at the moment although Bernard may turn out better difficult to say playing at Shaktar could be next Willian and move for big money or Douglas Costa who is still there despite links on a yearly basis.

Nemanja Vidic or Vincent Kompany

Didn't take long to repeat ourselves lol.

Ive changed it  Probs should of looked through 1st.

Tbf we've done Falcao Cavani lol.

Vidic atm, Kompany needs to regain his form and fitness

Tevez or Llorente

Tevez , still think he is more likely to score

Wiltshire or Cleverly ?

Wilshere

Cleverley is awful, Championship level footballer.

Andrey Arshavin or Roman Pavlyuchenko?

Arshavin. Very good on his day. Just didn't see it often enough. Pav was average.

Edgar Davids or Clarence Seedorf?

Seedorf had a lot more elegance than Davids.

Bergkamp or Cantona?

Bergkamp a pure genius , Cantona was a flawed genius which is why i would go for Bergkamp

Raul or Van Basten ?

van Basten all day. I think he is a level above Raul in terms of greatness personally.

Messi or Maradona?

Lionel Messi for me. Maradona was a great but I think Messi's goals have taken him to another level at club level. Of course, everyone compares them on the international stage & their effect nationally but I'm sure Lionel Messi will produce for Argentina at some point in the future.

Shinji Kagawa or Hidetoshi Nakata?

Shinji, he just needs to be managed better at United. He could have become a star at Dortmund.

Giggs or Bale

Giggs for what he's achieved and won in the game. In his prime, he was exceptional. I think we've only seen a year and a half of brilliance from Bale and is still unproven on the Champions League stage.

Samuel Eto'o or Didier Drogba?

Eto'o, Drogba certainly a fantastic striker but Eto'o a step up in quality.

Thiago Silva or Mats Hummels

Thiago Silva

Just prefer him as a defender, think he's an excellent player. Like Hummels though.

Andy Cole or Dwight Yorke?

Andy Cole. Certainly when it comes to scoring goals anyway.

Bryan Robson or Glenn Hoddle?

Glenn Hoddle. Masterful passer of a football. Robson was a great player mind, just always seemed to be hampered by injuries and niggles.

John Fashanu or Lee Chapman?

Tough, but going on longevity I'd say Lee Chapman.

Phil Jagielka or Gary Cahill?

I'll go with Cahill because he is playing at a higher level, it would be a lot closer if Jagielka also made a move to a bigger side.

Law or Daglish?

Dalglish , had vision skill and an eye for goal


Scholes or Giggs ?

Scholes he was more consistent in his performance.

Moore or Beckenbauer?

Beckenbauer.

Greatest captain and defender England has ever seen but up against the greatest captain and defender the World has ever seen.

Zaha or Sterling?

Both young, inexperienced & inconsistant but Zaha for me. Achieved more and just looks like he has far more untapped potential than Sterling. I'm not a huge fan of Raheem really & he offers nothing, for me anyway, of a geniune goal threat or composure in the box.

Hernan Jorge Crespo or Gabriel Batistuta?

Batistuta all day long, Was a wonderful player to watch.

Lewandowski or Mandzukic?

Batigol all day long. Fantastic finisher and legend of the game for me.

Del Piero or Totti?

Lewandowski to answer Nando's, and del Piero to answer Freek's

Duncan Ferguson or Andy Carroll

Ferguson.

Mata or Isco?

Juan Mata

More complete game as of now, but obviously biased having seen a lot more of Mata.

Mezut Ozil or Gareth Bale?

Bale

Alan Shearer or Teddy Sheringham

Personally Sheringham, realistically Shearer.

Kondogbia or Capoue?

Capoue, he looks like a top quality signing for spurs.

Jenkinson or Sagna?

Sagna, looks like his form has recovered after a difficult couple of years. Jenkinson's a trier but is still a bit raw.

Diego Lopez or Iker Casillas?

Casillas. Can't believe he's not starting for Madrid still.

Geoff Hurst or Jimmy Greaves?

Hurst

Steve Bruce or Gary Pallister?

Bruce for me, how he never got an international cap beggars belief, a player of his quality would walk the England team nowadays.

Draxler or Mkhitaryan?

Mkhitarian, although Draxler has potential to become a greater player.

Wilshere or Cleverley?

Wilshere a million times over. Cleverley wouldn't sniff the England squad if he played for any other team.

Gotze or Isco?

I asked this one on the first page.

Going to plump for Isco but its a proper Sophie's choice.

Vidal or Moutinho?

Vidal - Gutted Utd didn't sign him in the summer

Gary Neville or Jamie Carragher

G Nev, both as a player and pundit

Schweinsteiger or Gerrard

Gerrard- all rounder compared to schweinsteiger

Javier Garrido or Aaron Cresswell?

Garrido has more experience at a higher level

Angel Di Maria or Eden Hazard.

Hazard, Di Maria hasn't really stepped up.

Glenn Murray or Charlie Austin?

I Liked Charlie Austin

Aaron Lennon or Theo Walcott

Theo Walcott

Similar players but Walcott is a great finisher.

Martin Skrtel or Kolo Toure?

Kolo Toure, don't rate Skrtel at all

Loic Remy or Rickie Lambert?

Lambert at the moment Remy has a lot to prove yet in PL but could work out well unless played on wing. 


Christian Benteke or Romelu Lukaku.